Bentley Motors
#1
1000 jobs to go from Bentley. I live near Crewe, bit of a white ghetto (not as bad as Stockport, but in the same vein). Strong industrial heritage with Bentley (former Rolls Royce Motors) and Bombardier (former British Rail Engineering) - but both of these employers have cut jobs over the decades. Big Polish community, which seems to be a divisive thing locally.

Bentley is owned by VW. Components and materials cross borders several times in the production of a typical luxury car. Manufacturing cars in Crewe and selling them all over the world will not be feasible if we find ourselves trading on WTO rules. So I wonder did these white, highly-skilled, well-paid workers think this through when they voted for Brexit, ousted an excellent "Remainer" MP (Edward Timpson) in favour of an opportunist "I will deliver Brexit even though I didn't vote for it" Labour nutter (Laura Smith) and finally elected a cardboard cut-out opportunist Tory (Dr Mullan, both a frontline NHS worker and a volunteer cop if you believe his publicity). Will they reflect on the notion of "cause and effect" as they see their houses and cars re-possessed? Will they expect the hard-pressed Cheshire East council to "do more" for them in their hour of need?

When the shit truly hits the fan (middle of next year I guess), will saying "told you so, you twat" to every Brexiteer be labelled a hate crime? Or will Brexit voters become as scarce as Tory voters did around 1980, until the Falklands War re-ignited their joi-de-vivre?
Reply
#2
(06-05-2020, 02:23 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote: Sadly the decline in the UK car industry (and manufacturing in general) has happened over a long period since the 60s including whilst in the EU - I used to live near Cofton Park and remember all the meetings there with Red Robbo, though I was just a kid. A Brexit no deal won't help of course but I'm not sure every bad or good economic outcome in the near or long term future will be related to it, not fully anyway, though that won't stop every one being attributed to it. Would love to see a UK car industry take off again in the long term future, remembering Longbridge as it used to be. Not sure if that is ever likely, or if it would be more or less likely in or out of the EU.

The UK automotive industry has expanded massively since the 1980s and was extremely successful and secure as a sector until 2016.
Reply
#3
The biggest growth industry will be the Brexiteer Bucket. You can wear it on your head and it can completely block out reality and when that becomes impossible it offers you a pot to piss in.
Reply
#4
Not sure why the manufacturers being British owned is important on a practical basis; everything on the practical side of things (the production lines, designers and engineers, assembly workers, distributors, suppliers etc) are still based in Britain. A lot of the suppliers reliant on the British automotive industry are also British companies.

If you look at SMMT vehicle data or Statista you will see the output has declined since 2016, before that there was a small dip after the 2008 crash but output was stable between 2003 and 2016. If you then look at ONS between 1990 and 2003 and the decade production stats from 1970 to 1980 you will see the huge drop of between the 1970s and 1980s but then you will notice that by 1996 the annual production exceeded the cumulative production between 1970 and 1979. 2009 aside, it kept at a similar level up until 2016. 2020 data is accounted for but given the closures previously scheduled and the Covid-19 crisis that will likely tank even further.

Regarding the decline, joining the EEC had a massive initial impact as it was easier to buy French and German cars but the reason why they were better was down to serious mismanagement at BMC caused by a lack of coherent strategy within divisions due to rapid expansion which (thanks to Tony Benn being a colossal idiot) bled over to the previously efficient Leyland Motors through British Leyland before the situation worsened as more competing cars were launched before British Leyland ultimately were bailed out as they were seen to be "too big to fail". A lot of the favoured marques in British Leyland were split off and in the 1990s started making good cars again, Japanese automotive expansion in the European markets favoured Britain as a base of operations in the 90s and early 2000s and even the demise of MG and Rover wasn't able to harm production output.
Reply
#5
The dip in 2009 was not experienced in 2008 and there was a quick bounceback in 2010. And the 2009 production was still equal to about half of the 1970s cumulative output so to say it was at 1980s levels is a bit disingenuous. As I said, annual production between 1996 and 2016, 2009 aside, was in line with the cumulative output of the whole decade of the 1970s.

I don't think the government should get involved with the automotive industry quite frankly, the last time they did they made things worse. If they had just let BMC go under and let the profitable marques like Austin and Jaguar spin out then the 1980s wouldn't have happened and I'm pretty confident our domestic automotive industry would be rivalling Germany's big three.
Reply
#6
(06-05-2020, 02:23 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote: Sadly the decline in the UK car industry (and manufacturing in general) has happened over a long period since the 60s including whilst in the EU - I used to live near Cofton Park and remember all the meetings there with Red Robbo, though I was just a kid. A Brexit no deal won't help of course but I'm not sure every bad or good economic outcome in the near or long term future will be related to it, not fully anyway, though that won't stop every one being attributed to it. Would love to see a UK car industry take off again in the long term future, remembering Longbridge as it used to be. Not sure if that is ever likely, or if it would be more or less likely in or out of the EU.

Longbridge as it used to be, you mean a appallingly mismanaged Union ruined shambles of the 70's that produce unbelievably poor quality vehicles that were the butt of jokes the world over, happy days  Rolleyes
Reply
#7
(06-05-2020, 05:15 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(06-05-2020, 04:48 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: The dip in 2009 was not experienced in 2008 and there was a quick bounceback in 2010. And the 2009 production was still equal to about half of the 1970s cumulative output so to say it was at 1980s levels is a bit disingenuous. As I said, annual production between 1996 and 2016, 2009 aside, was in line with the cumulative output of the whole decade of the 1970s.

I don't think the government should get involved with the automotive industry quite frankly, the last time they did they made things worse. If they had just let BMC go under and let the profitable marques like Austin and Jaguar spin out then the 1980s wouldn't have happened and I'm pretty confident our domestic automotive industry would be rivalling Germany's big three.

Certainly not being disingenuous - I am just looking at the stats and assuming they are accurate, the dip in 2009 took production to well below 1980 level, and the bounce back was not quick in 2010 - went up to 1393 thousand units, still not hugely better than the 1980 figure of 1312 - and didn't get back to 2008 levels until 2015. Then a big jump 2015-2016 for some reason. It is as you say half the 70s figure in 1980 and 2009, but that's still a big drop - I'm guessing more than half down in terms of employment as well with more automation in production. So I'm not completely agreeing with your analysis in that regard, though you may well be right about UK government involvement - it would have to be in a different way to before.

2009 was a short dip as a result of a lot of shutdowns as a result of the crash, it's a massive outlier. There was a big jump up in 2010 and another jump in 2012. The 2015-16 jump was as a result of Mini, Toyota, Jaguar and Honda productions going up predominantly caused by a surge in demand in continental Europe and Ireland, if I remember correctly it was something like 11% which is huge given the EU27 is our largest automotive export market.

There's been a lot more automation in the automotive industry but cars are also a lot more complex so the design and engineering side of things is a lot bigger than it was, extrapolating employment would be difficult. Shop floors are definitely down but the more skilled side of things are probably up.

(06-05-2020, 04:52 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(06-05-2020, 02:23 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote: Sadly the decline in the UK car industry (and manufacturing in general) has happened over a long period since the 60s including whilst in the EU - I used to live near Cofton Park and remember all the meetings there with Red Robbo, though I was just a kid. A Brexit no deal won't help of course but I'm not sure every bad or good economic outcome in the near or long term future will be related to it, not fully anyway, though that won't stop every one being attributed to it. Would love to see a UK car industry take off again in the long term future, remembering Longbridge as it used to be. Not sure if that is ever likely, or if it would be more or less likely in or out of the EU.

Longbridge as it used to be, you mean a appallingly mismanaged Union ruined shambles of the 70's that produce unbelievably poor quality vehicles that were the butt of jokes the world over, happy days  Rolleyes

BL was in a shambles long before the unions got involved, and the poor vehicle quality was due to long term mismanagement at the top and Tony Benn being an idiot in meddling in BMC instead of letting BMC die as the market was trying to dictate.
Reply
#8
(06-05-2020, 05:17 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(06-05-2020, 04:52 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(06-05-2020, 02:23 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote: Sadly the decline in the UK car industry (and manufacturing in general) has happened over a long period since the 60s including whilst in the EU - I used to live near Cofton Park and remember all the meetings there with Red Robbo, though I was just a kid. A Brexit no deal won't help of course but I'm not sure every bad or good economic outcome in the near or long term future will be related to it, not fully anyway, though that won't stop every one being attributed to it. Would love to see a UK car industry take off again in the long term future, remembering Longbridge as it used to be. Not sure if that is ever likely, or if it would be more or less likely in or out of the EU.

Longbridge as it used to be, you mean a appallingly mismanaged Union ruined shambles of the 70's that produce unbelievably poor quality vehicles that were the butt of jokes the world over, happy days  Rolleyes

Union issues aside, I have fond memories of cars such as the Morris Minor and Maxi and the Mini, which of course is still going strong, and of all the employment at Longbridge. So I say 'Pah' to ypou.

It was meant more tongue in cheek actually Pickle I to have lots of memories of BL cars and as you said provided thousands of valuable jobs not just at Longbridge but the supply chain and local businesses, but be honest the build quality was God awful and even into the 80's they were using 30+year old tech on their cars, marinas using lever arms, on front suspension when the competition were using macpherson struts just as  an example, the maestro and montego were poor upgrades tbh but the rover models were still decent cars but still suffered from poor build and coupled with lack of investment in design just couldn't compete with the influx of foreign models even when BMW took over they were still rehashing old models it was only ever going to end one way unfortunately, that said I had a Rover 214 8v 1999 model which I brought 2nd hand and had for around 6yrs it still rates as one of my best allround cars in terms of drivabilty unfortunately it just became to expensive to keep repairing.
Reply
#9
There are two separate issues here. One is Britain's place in the modern car manufacturing industry. We have several car plants which are acknowledged to be amongst the world's most efficient, but our place in what is now an international industry is entirely dependent on tariff-free trading. Most manufacturers work in partnerships, sharing technology and components across countries without technical or trade barriers. By crashing out of Europe without any arrangements in place, we place ourselves at an immediate disadvantage. The 4 years (and counting) of uncertainty since the referendum has simply eroded away the confidence of the big car companies, and they have planned to cut us loose if they need to. As Boris famously said "Fuck Business".

Foreign vs UK ownership. It's always seemed to me that if profit is to be made, it's best kept at home, not sent abroad. But after 40 years of "let the market decide" economics and politics in Britain, we have completely lost the will and the ability to keep hold of things. So our energy and transport infrastructures, our major industries, even defence-related ones, are all foreign owned and operated. I don't believe any other country in the developed world has stepped so far back from managing its own affairs. Try suggesting to a Texan (one of our new trade buddies, so we're told) that a Mexican or Canadian company would supply him with electricity. But here we have life-long Sun and Express readers happily (or more likely unknowingly) using French and German gas and electricity, shopping in French and German supermarkets and gleefully waving Union Jacks every time Bozza say "Let's get Brexit done".
Reply
#10
(06-06-2020, 08:58 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: But after 40 years of "let the market decide"

If only.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: