Nissan
#21
Can you imagine if was the other way round you would be like a peacock strutting saying I told you so .....brexit blah blah blah

I'm sure a few on here were praying for them to close down so they could do
I told you so and turkeys voted for xmas .....
Reply
#22
(05-29-2020, 01:10 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(05-29-2020, 12:45 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-29-2020, 09:59 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You will have to ask the person who is quoted.

Or you could use the evidence presented to you.

It's great news. Do we know what promises the government have made? Do we know how much it's going to cost us?

What's happening with the Ford plants? The Vauxhall plants? The toyota plant? The honda plant? (oops that one's already gone!)

It makes sense we'll still have a car industry - especially in the short term whilst the infra-structure is still here - as we do have a large car market.

But can it sustain ALL these manufacturers?

Maybe, if our productive is high enough to soak up the export duties and profitable enough to overcome the political pressure from the EU and the home countries of the car manufacturers.  

Surely, though, that's a big ask?

It's interesting that the only manufacturer so far to make a substantial commitment neither has a home base in the EC and has by far it's biggest sales market in the UK - not the EC.

Let's see what all of the rest do  before we celebrate too hard and claim victory.

Bear in mind this industry will need to replace probably 90% of all existing stock with electric variations in the next couple of decades or so. That's a lot of cars to make.
Reply
#23
(05-29-2020, 03:17 PM)The liquidator Wrote: Can you imagine if was the other way round you would be like a peacock strutting saying I told you so .....brexit blah  blah  blah

I'm sure a few on here were praying for them to close down so they could do
I told you so and turkeys voted for xmas .....

For someone who keeps asking for facts, you really don't like facts
Reply
#24
(05-29-2020, 03:26 PM)Fido Wrote: Bear in mind this industry will need to replace probably 90% of all existing stock with electric variations in the next couple of decades or so. That's a lot of cars to make.

All the existing stock would have to be replaced long before 20 years, regardless of electric variations! It won't make much difference to the volume of the global car industry except for more co-operation and consolidation between them to pay for research. Which would squeeze regional car companies out even more.
Reply
#25
We haven't left the EU yet. Let's see what gets negotiated, eh?
Reply
#26
(05-29-2020, 04:38 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: We haven't left the EU yet. Let's see what gets negotiated, eh?

That's a good point. You never know...

As an aside, the big problem with the car industry is that it always seems to be a national flag industry. Government wishes take priority over commercial decisions. You've got to wonder how profitable any of them would be if you took out all the visible and invisible subsidies.
Reply
#27
(05-29-2020, 03:37 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(05-29-2020, 03:17 PM)The liquidator Wrote: Can you imagine if was the other way round you would be like a peacock strutting saying I told you so .....brexit blah  blah  blah

I'm sure a few on here were praying for them to close down so they could do
I told you so and turkeys voted for xmas .....

For someone who keeps asking for facts, you really don't like facts

Turkey's voted for xmas  

Blah blah blah
Reply
#28
(05-30-2020, 07:04 AM)The liquidator Wrote:
(05-29-2020, 03:37 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(05-29-2020, 03:17 PM)The liquidator Wrote: Can you imagine if was the other way round you would be like a peacock strutting saying I told you so .....brexit blah  blah  blah

I'm sure a few on here were praying for them to close down so they could do
I told you so and turkeys voted for xmas .....

For someone who keeps asking for facts, you really don't like facts

Turkey's voted for xmas  

Blah blah blah

Keep ignoring the facts. Two big UK car plants are closing over the next 13 months, two more are moving production from their UK bases to Germany and another is sounding a complete closure for 2023.

And, to get it back to my point on Sunderland, no new investment is being made as all that is happening is that they're moving production of CMF-CD (Kadjar) and CMF-B (Captur) Renault models to a factory already producing cars on those frameworks for Nissan (Qashqai, Juke) meaning no new workers need to be hired or trained and no new tooling needs to be fitted, and as production of two models were moved to Japan last year there is space in the two lines there meaning no money needs to be put into a new production line.

This is a complete nothing story, the only interesting thing is that Renault and Nissan are being forced to work closely together despite trying their best not to since the alliance was signed in order to stave off the threat of going under. Until new models are actually being built in Sunderland there will be no new investment there.
Reply
#29
Shock horror - Liq believes government propaganda. Fight them on the beaches mate
Reply
#30
(05-30-2020, 01:40 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(05-30-2020, 07:04 AM)The liquidator Wrote: Turkey's voted for xmas  

Blah blah blah

Keep ignoring the facts. Two big UK car plants are closing over the next 13 months, two more are moving production from their UK bases to Germany and another is sounding a complete closure for 2023.

And, to get it back to my point on Sunderland, no new investment is being made as all that is happening is that they're moving production of CMF-CD (Kadjar) and CMF-B (Captur) Renault models to a factory already producing cars on those frameworks for Nissan (Qashqai, Juke) meaning no new workers need to be hired or trained and no new tooling needs to be fitted, and as production of two models were moved to Japan last year there is space in the two lines there meaning no money needs to be put into a new production line.

This is a complete nothing story, the only interesting thing is that Renault and Nissan are being forced to work closely together despite trying their best not to since the alliance was signed in order to stave off the threat of going under. Until new models are actually being built in Sunderland there will be no new investment there.

I think the motivation for some of the posts on this thread is the fact that, for over four years, we have had it insisted to us that leaving the EU would be the death nell to the British automotive industry. 


Admittedly only a quick bit of research but I’m struggling to find any catastrophic disaster that your first paragraph might infer.
Nissan are actually suggesting they could pull out of manufacturing in Europe and “ramp up” production in the U.K. following Brexit.
Honda are closing Swindon (it’s only plant in Europe) due to “Global changes” and “Nothing to do with Brexit”.
Ford are closing an engine plant in Wales and denied “Brexit was a factor”. Adding “We are committed to the U.K.”.
They also closed a car plant in France and cut jobs in Germany. and 3 other plants Europe wide. Also 7000 office jobs worldwide.
Toyota have stated there are no plans for changes to their U.K. operations at present but could consider closing it’s U.K. plant, scaling back or even more investment. So, the expression “sounding complete closure” is a bit of hyperbole.
Vauxhall’s Ellesmere Port plant is slowly turning around from crippling inefficiency but Luton, according to the FT. is fairly safe. Especially following a £100 mil investment in 2018.
Again we have the threatening ‘could’ move Mini production and “may need to consider” moving. Those comments made by Peter Schwarzenbauer who has since been replaced as director responsible for the Mini. Some production of engines bound for South African built cars has moved abroad.
Thanks to a trade deal between the EU and Japan, cars can be imported direct from Japan into Europe without tariffs. So again closures of Japanese plants would have been on the cards with or without Brexit.

Here is an article from one of Dekka’s fave papers, The FT, so I’m sure he’ll like it (well, perhaps he won’t!). He must have missed it otherwise he’d have shared it, surely. Here is a snippet; 

‘Every year, more than 1m brand new cars leave Britain, bound for Europe and the rest of the world. ...for each one that departs, two arrive, a testament to the UK’s deep reliance on overseas car plants to keep its forecourts stocked.
The prospect of new tariffs after Brexit is prompting some carmakers to consider tearing up this decades-old arrangement by making more of their locally-sold vehicles in Britain.
“It’s always a good thing to manufacture the cars close to the market where you sell them, generally speaking,” said Carlos Tavares, chief executive of Vauxhall owner PSA. “So I would love to manufacture many Vauxhall cars in the UK for the UK market . . . that’s what’s at stake with the Brexit outcome.”

https://www.ft.com/content/97fef2b8-4915...5839e06441

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-47287386

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-48533790

https://www.theguardian.com/business/202...ard-brexit
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)