Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
05-13-2020, 06:09 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-13-2020, 06:12 PM by fuzzbox.)
(05-13-2020, 06:04 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: [quote pid='173508' dateline='1589392497']
So when it was known that the predictions were wrong, what steps were taken to track or test? Especially amongst the most vulnerable if not the general populous? They made adjustments to the strains targeted to the jab and increased production to try and stop that same strain from doing it again the next year. With regards to the most vulnerable, they're given free jabs.
[/quote]
My point is still the same. When it became clear they got it wrong, which I'm assuming is always a risk, and 20k+ died, did they do any tracking, tracing and testing amongst the most vulnerable to protect them in the current season? I'm guessing not or it was ineffective if 28k died.
Thanks to you, I've just 'wasted' 20 minutes reading about the history and treatment of smallpox!
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
They do tests to determine what specific strains are prevalent so they can prep the next jab to counter it. Strain prevelence is published in the weekly flu reports from Public Health England if you want to read. I'm not sure they do any tracking outside of standard reporting in GPs and hospitals. I know the University of Birmingham were tracking a flu outbreak in France last year and preparing a vaccine to stop that strain from killing people here.
Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
05-13-2020, 06:35 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-13-2020, 06:50 PM by fuzzbox.)
(05-13-2020, 06:26 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: They do tests to determine what specific strains are prevalent so they can prep the next jab to counter it. Strain prevelence is published in the weekly flu reports from Public Health England if you want to read. I'm not sure they do any tracking outside of standard reporting in GPs and hospitals. I know the University of Birmingham were tracking a flu outbreak in France last year and preparing a vaccine to stop that strain from killing people here.
That was my point. There are teams in place to track a virus to prepare a vaccine, but there was nothing in place or developed once it became clear there was a problem in the current season. Or if there was, it failed if 28k died. Was there a lesson to be learnt? If there was, could it have applied to our current problems?
UPDATE: thanks for the weekly flu report info (PHE National Influenza Report? Is that the right one?), just having a browse through (this is why I don't get any work done!). It seems mostly related to COVID - not surprising. Unless i'm misreading it, there doesn't seem much testing for flu done? I'm not making a point, I'm just surprised or am I misreading it?
Posts: 4,217
Threads: 169
Joined: Jan 2019
(05-13-2020, 04:41 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: (05-13-2020, 03:45 PM)Ossian Wrote: (05-13-2020, 01:05 PM)billybassett Wrote: By the way be careful out there now you can go out more. Way way more likely to die on the roads/rail and footpaths of britain than that pesky covid
Not the railways; it would never get anywhere near that point.
More than half a dozen fatalities in any one year and The Mail and Express would be screaming for the network to be shut down. Number of railway fatalities - excluding suicides - in the last 10 years: 4 (2 Network Rail employees/2 members of the public).
See, why Railtrack failed and why Network Rail is part of the public sector.
Hatfield crash happened, Railtrack were scrutinised by the public on their failure to maintain track that wasn't as commercially viable and then they started a massive repair and maintenance programme that caused them to go into administration and liquidation.
im not sure if it was that crash or the potters bar crash you know what caused one of them something simple as not tightning the bolts on the plate that holds 2 separate pieces of rail together .
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
05-13-2020, 07:35 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-13-2020, 07:43 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(05-13-2020, 06:58 PM)The liquidator Wrote: (05-13-2020, 04:41 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: (05-13-2020, 03:45 PM)Ossian Wrote: (05-13-2020, 01:05 PM)billybassett Wrote: By the way be careful out there now you can go out more. Way way more likely to die on the roads/rail and footpaths of britain than that pesky covid
Not the railways; it would never get anywhere near that point.
More than half a dozen fatalities in any one year and The Mail and Express would be screaming for the network to be shut down. Number of railway fatalities - excluding suicides - in the last 10 years: 4 (2 Network Rail employees/2 members of the public).
See, why Railtrack failed and why Network Rail is part of the public sector.
Hatfield crash happened, Railtrack were scrutinised by the public on their failure to maintain track that wasn't as commercially viable and then they started a massive repair and maintenance programme that caused them to go into administration and liquidation.
im not sure if it was that crash or the potters bar crash you know what caused one of them something simple as not tightning the bolts on the plate that holds 2 separate pieces of rail together .
That was Potters Bar. Railtrack negligence caused that accident but the die had been cast at that point as they were in the process of being liquidated and their responsibilities transferred to Network Rail.
Hatfield was caused by track fatigue and the cracks that had accrued caused it to fail. Railtrack inspected the offending stretch the year before, identified the problem and reported track fatigue but decided not to fix it as it wasn't economically viable for them to fix all fatigued track.
(05-13-2020, 06:35 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: (05-13-2020, 06:26 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: They do tests to determine what specific strains are prevalent so they can prep the next jab to counter it. Strain prevelence is published in the weekly flu reports from Public Health England if you want to read. I'm not sure they do any tracking outside of standard reporting in GPs and hospitals. I know the University of Birmingham were tracking a flu outbreak in France last year and preparing a vaccine to stop that strain from killing people here.
That was my point. There are teams in place to track a virus to prepare a vaccine, but there was nothing in place or developed once it became clear there was a problem in the current season. Or if there was, it failed if 28k died. Was there a lesson to be learnt? If there was, could it have applied to our current problems?
UPDATE: thanks for the weekly flu report info (PHE National Influenza Report? Is that the right one?), just having a browse through (this is why I don't get any work done!). It seems mostly related to COVID - not surprising. Unless i'm misreading it, there doesn't seem much testing for flu done? I'm not making a point, I'm just surprised or am I misreading it?
The issue is that once they've identified the strain they have to develop the new jab composition and scale up manufacturing which isn't helpful in the middle of an outbreak. Often what happens is they go through WHO data and infer what strains are prevalent in other parts of the world to plan accordingly.
RE the influenza report, that's the correct one. It will talk about all respiratory diseases but the surveillance figures pertain solely to influenza strains.
Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
05-14-2020, 10:15 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-14-2020, 10:39 AM by fuzzbox.)
(05-13-2020, 07:35 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: The issue is that once they've identified the strain they have to develop the new jab composition and scale up manufacturing which isn't helpful in the middle of an outbreak. Often what happens is they go through WHO data and infer what strains are prevalent in other parts of the world to plan accordingly.
RE the influenza report, that's the correct one. It will talk about all respiratory diseases but the surveillance figures pertain solely to influenza strains.
It's all interesting stuff. There seems to be a lot done to prevent the deaths by forecasting, but from what I've read, once that defence was breached, almost nothing was in place to stop flu ripping through the vulnerable. In fact, their were a lot of people calling for testing and tracking of the virus at a local level so they could isolate the vulnerable in carehomes etc. but ultimately the investment was never made and it never got done. Of course, it's easier to say in retrospect, but it does seem people died that needn't have and lessons that could have been learnt weren't. The similarities are striking.
What also came up was that I wrongly assumed we regularly tested for the flu virus. You're right to use the word 'surveillance'. I thought that would give us some lab capacity that could somehow (not easily or efficiently, but possible) be repurposed for corona. Turns out we don't do any large scale testing of flu, even in times of crisis (see previous paragraph) so there was no capacity that we could use.
I suppose there was a reluctance to have a potentially unused expensive facility on the books. If we didn't learn that after the deaths of 28k in 2014, I'm guessing that will change now. It would be a perfect initiative to share between a group of funding member states...
Posts: 3,733
Threads: 116
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(05-14-2020, 10:15 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: (05-13-2020, 07:35 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: The issue is that once they've identified the strain they have to develop the new jab composition and scale up manufacturing which isn't helpful in the middle of an outbreak. Often what happens is they go through WHO data and infer what strains are prevalent in other parts of the world to plan accordingly.
RE the influenza report, that's the correct one. It will talk about all respiratory diseases but the surveillance figures pertain solely to influenza strains.
It's all interesting stuff. There seems to be a lot done to prevent the deaths by forecasting, but from what I've read, once that defence was breached, almost nothing was in place to stop flu ripping through the vulnerable. In fact, their were a lot of people calling for testing and tracking of the virus at a local level so they could isolate the vulnerable in carehomes etc. but ultimately the investment was never made and it never got done. Of course, it's easier to say in retrospect, but it does seem people died that needn't have and lessons that could have been learnt weren't. The similarities are striking.
What also came up was that I wrongly assumed we regularly tested for the flu virus. You're right to use the word 'surveillance'. I thought that would give us some lab capacity that could somehow (not easily or efficiently, but possible) be repurposed for corona. Turns out we don't do any large scale testing of flu, even in times of crisis (see previous paragraph) so there was no capacity that we could use.
I suppose there was a reluctance to have a potentially unused expensive facility on the books. If we didn't learn that after the deaths of 28k in 2014, I'm guessing that will change now. It would be a perfect initiative to share between a group of funding member states...
Not surprisingly, the EU has these in place (quick google revealed the Early Warning and Response System and European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control ).
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(05-14-2020, 11:02 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (05-14-2020, 10:15 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: (05-13-2020, 07:35 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: The issue is that once they've identified the strain they have to develop the new jab composition and scale up manufacturing which isn't helpful in the middle of an outbreak. Often what happens is they go through WHO data and infer what strains are prevalent in other parts of the world to plan accordingly.
RE the influenza report, that's the correct one. It will talk about all respiratory diseases but the surveillance figures pertain solely to influenza strains.
It's all interesting stuff. There seems to be a lot done to prevent the deaths by forecasting, but from what I've read, once that defence was breached, almost nothing was in place to stop flu ripping through the vulnerable. In fact, their were a lot of people calling for testing and tracking of the virus at a local level so they could isolate the vulnerable in carehomes etc. but ultimately the investment was never made and it never got done. Of course, it's easier to say in retrospect, but it does seem people died that needn't have and lessons that could have been learnt weren't. The similarities are striking.
What also came up was that I wrongly assumed we regularly tested for the flu virus. You're right to use the word 'surveillance'. I thought that would give us some lab capacity that could somehow (not easily or efficiently, but possible) be repurposed for corona. Turns out we don't do any large scale testing of flu, even in times of crisis (see previous paragraph) so there was no capacity that we could use.
I suppose there was a reluctance to have a potentially unused expensive facility on the books. If we didn't learn that after the deaths of 28k in 2014, I'm guessing that will change now. It would be a perfect initiative to share between a group of funding member states...
Not surprisingly, the EU has these in place (quick google revealed the Early Warning and Response System and European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control ).
The EU offered to let us stay in it (covers non-members) and the DHSC and NHS asked the government to take them up on that a few months ago but the government are suddenly allergic to the word European.
Posts: 4,217
Threads: 169
Joined: Jan 2019
(05-14-2020, 11:02 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (05-14-2020, 10:15 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: (05-13-2020, 07:35 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: The issue is that once they've identified the strain they have to develop the new jab composition and scale up manufacturing which isn't helpful in the middle of an outbreak. Often what happens is they go through WHO data and infer what strains are prevalent in other parts of the world to plan accordingly.
RE the influenza report, that's the correct one. It will talk about all respiratory diseases but the surveillance figures pertain solely to influenza strains.
It's all interesting stuff. There seems to be a lot done to prevent the deaths by forecasting, but from what I've read, once that defence was breached, almost nothing was in place to stop flu ripping through the vulnerable. In fact, their were a lot of people calling for testing and tracking of the virus at a local level so they could isolate the vulnerable in carehomes etc. but ultimately the investment was never made and it never got done. Of course, it's easier to say in retrospect, but it does seem people died that needn't have and lessons that could have been learnt weren't. The similarities are striking.
What also came up was that I wrongly assumed we regularly tested for the flu virus. You're right to use the word 'surveillance'. I thought that would give us some lab capacity that could somehow (not easily or efficiently, but possible) be repurposed for corona. Turns out we don't do any large scale testing of flu, even in times of crisis (see previous paragraph) so there was no capacity that we could use.
I suppose there was a reluctance to have a potentially unused expensive facility on the books. If we didn't learn that after the deaths of 28k in 2014, I'm guessing that will change now. It would be a perfect initiative to share between a group of funding member states...
Not surprisingly, the EU has these in place (quick google revealed the Early Warning and Response System and European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control ).
Am I being nieve somehow why was spain and italy and Belgium a total car crash then ?
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(05-14-2020, 01:34 PM)The liquidator Wrote: (05-14-2020, 11:02 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (05-14-2020, 10:15 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: (05-13-2020, 07:35 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: The issue is that once they've identified the strain they have to develop the new jab composition and scale up manufacturing which isn't helpful in the middle of an outbreak. Often what happens is they go through WHO data and infer what strains are prevalent in other parts of the world to plan accordingly.
RE the influenza report, that's the correct one. It will talk about all respiratory diseases but the surveillance figures pertain solely to influenza strains.
It's all interesting stuff. There seems to be a lot done to prevent the deaths by forecasting, but from what I've read, once that defence was breached, almost nothing was in place to stop flu ripping through the vulnerable. In fact, their were a lot of people calling for testing and tracking of the virus at a local level so they could isolate the vulnerable in carehomes etc. but ultimately the investment was never made and it never got done. Of course, it's easier to say in retrospect, but it does seem people died that needn't have and lessons that could have been learnt weren't. The similarities are striking.
What also came up was that I wrongly assumed we regularly tested for the flu virus. You're right to use the word 'surveillance'. I thought that would give us some lab capacity that could somehow (not easily or efficiently, but possible) be repurposed for corona. Turns out we don't do any large scale testing of flu, even in times of crisis (see previous paragraph) so there was no capacity that we could use.
I suppose there was a reluctance to have a potentially unused expensive facility on the books. If we didn't learn that after the deaths of 28k in 2014, I'm guessing that will change now. It would be a perfect initiative to share between a group of funding member states...
Not surprisingly, the EU has these in place (quick google revealed the Early Warning and Response System and European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control ).
Am I being nieve somehow why was spain and italy and Belgium a total car crash then ?
We're on about flu strains?
|