Our media
#11
(05-03-2020, 10:13 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(05-03-2020, 09:56 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The media is a very broad church some like Reuter’s present the news imo in a balanced well researched way. Others like the Sun are just moth pieces for government.

That said anyone who is paying attention to the news over the last four years will have seen the government simply tell blatant lies, refuse to apologise for mistakes and deflect. Hardly surprising the press ask the same questions as frustrating as that may be given they are rarely afforded a straight answer.

Can you give examples of these blatant lies?

I think it's fair to say they have. What's new is that the lies are blatant with no effort to even cover them up. Whether that's the governments contempt for the electorate or the electorates low opinion of politicians that they expect to be lied to, I've no idea.

Having said that, Blair's lying re. the Gulf war tops anything this government has lied about. Doesn't make this government right, but it puts them into perspective.
Reply
#12
(05-03-2020, 10:39 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(05-03-2020, 10:13 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(05-03-2020, 09:56 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The media is a very broad church some like Reuter’s present the news imo in a balanced well researched way. Others like the Sun are just moth pieces for government.

That said anyone who is paying attention to the news over the last four years will have seen the government simply tell blatant lies, refuse to apologise for mistakes and deflect. Hardly surprising the press ask the same questions as frustrating as that may be given they are rarely afforded a straight answer.

Can you give examples of these blatant lies?

I think it's fair to say they have. What's new is that the lies are blatant with no effort to even cover them up. Whether that's the governments contempt for the electorate or the electorates low opinion of politicians that they expect to be lied to, I've no idea.

Having said that, Blair's lying re. the Gulf war tops anything this government has lied about. Doesn't make this government right, but it puts them into perspective.
Still angers me now. Caused a huge divide in Brum.
Sadly it seems the norm now to lie.
Reply
#13
I think they have been shown to be even more incompetent than I thought possible. With the exception of a few respected experts like Hugh Pym and Fergus Walsh they have shown themselves to be embarrassingly unintelligent.
They ask questions that were answered weeks ago proving they don't listen and then as a pack get their teeth into a point that is soon discredited and without apology or reflection move on to the next piece of ignorant tosh.
If they want to talk about hindsight they need to reflect on the fact that not one of them had the brains to see what was coming down the line with this situation when it was as obvious as the nose on their faces.
As for the laughable impartiality of the BBC, the day that Newsnight employed that wanker Lewis Goodhall , a known political activist, that is the sort of lie that needs to be pointed at.
Reply
#14
(05-03-2020, 11:15 AM)Swagbaggie Wrote: I think they have been shown to be even more incompetent than I thought possible. With the exception of a few respected experts like Hugh Pym and Fergus Walsh they have shown themselves to be embarrassingly unintelligent.
They ask questions that were answered weeks ago proving they don't listen and then as a pack get their teeth into a point that is soon discredited and without apology or reflection move on to the next piece of ignorant tosh.
If they want to talk about hindsight they need to reflect on the fact that not one of them had the brains to see what was coming down the line with this situation when it was as obvious as the nose on their faces.
As for the laughable impartiality of the BBC, the day that Newsnight employed that wanker Lewis Goodhall , a known political activist, that is the sort of lie that needs to be pointed at.

They also employ Andrew Neil on 'This week' who actually worked for the conservative party AND Rupert Murdoch! Can you get much further right than that? Despite personally being on the left side of politics, I still thought it was the best current affairs programme on TV. 

The BBC doesn't have to be impartial all the time, but it does have to be 'balanced'.
Reply
#15
Examples 1

Examples 2

Example 3


The press are guilty of the opposite of what some are trying to spin
Reply
#16
(05-03-2020, 11:23 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(05-03-2020, 11:15 AM)Swagbaggie Wrote: I think they have been shown to be even more incompetent than I thought possible. With the exception of a few respected experts like Hugh Pym and Fergus Walsh they have shown themselves to be embarrassingly unintelligent.
They ask questions that were answered weeks ago proving they don't listen and then as a pack get their teeth into a point that is soon discredited and without apology or reflection move on to the next piece of ignorant tosh.
If they want to talk about hindsight they need to reflect on the fact that not one of them had the brains to see what was coming down the line with this situation when it was as obvious as the nose on their faces.
As for the laughable impartiality of the BBC, the day that Newsnight employed that wanker Lewis Goodhall , a known political activist, that is the sort of lie that needs to be pointed at.

They also employ Andrew Neil on 'This week' who actually worked for the conservative party AND Rupert Murdoch! Can you get much further right than that? Despite personally being on the left side of politics, I still thought it was the best current affairs programme on TV. 

The BBC doesn't have to be impartial all the time, but it does have to be 'balanced'.
I don't agree. I didn't say what party Goodhall worked for because it is irrelevant to my point. Impartiality as well as balance in a publicly funded body is an imperative and if they can't do that they should be sacked let alone employed. 
I am apolitical by the way I think they are all self serving wankers.
Reply
#17
(05-03-2020, 10:52 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(05-03-2020, 10:39 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(05-03-2020, 10:13 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(05-03-2020, 09:56 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The media is a very broad church some like Reuter’s present the news imo in a balanced well researched way. Others like the Sun are just moth pieces for government.

That said anyone who is paying attention to the news over the last four years will have seen the government simply tell blatant lies, refuse to apologise for mistakes and deflect. Hardly surprising the press ask the same questions as frustrating as that may be given they are rarely afforded a straight answer.

Can you give examples of these blatant lies?

I think it's fair to say they have. What's new is that the lies are blatant with no effort to even cover them up. Whether that's the governments contempt for the electorate or the electorates low opinion of politicians that they expect to be lied to, I've no idea.

Having said that, Blair's lying re. the Gulf war tops anything this government has lied about. Doesn't make this government right, but it puts them into perspective.
Still angers me now. Caused a huge divide in Brum.
Sadly it seems the norm now to lie.

Blairs government in 97 were the real founders of postmodern spin. And Labour still pays for it today.
Reply
#18
(05-03-2020, 11:39 AM)HeathAyIt Wrote:
(05-03-2020, 10:52 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(05-03-2020, 10:39 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(05-03-2020, 10:13 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(05-03-2020, 09:56 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The media is a very broad church some like Reuter’s present the news imo in a balanced well researched way. Others like the Sun are just moth pieces for government.

That said anyone who is paying attention to the news over the last four years will have seen the government simply tell blatant lies, refuse to apologise for mistakes and deflect. Hardly surprising the press ask the same questions as frustrating as that may be given they are rarely afforded a straight answer.

Can you give examples of these blatant lies?

I think it's fair to say they have. What's new is that the lies are blatant with no effort to even cover them up. Whether that's the governments contempt for the electorate or the electorates low opinion of politicians that they expect to be lied to, I've no idea.

Having said that, Blair's lying re. the Gulf war tops anything this government has lied about. Doesn't make this government right, but it puts them into perspective.
Still angers me now. Caused a huge divide in Brum.
Sadly it seems the norm now to lie.

Blairs government in 97 were the real founders of postmodern spin. And Labour still pays for it today.
And yet we still get Campbell pitching up offering his tripe on every channel, Blair spouting his hypocritical unsolicited unwanted commentary and that wanker Peston engaging  human rights solicitor Cherie Booth like we wouldn't recognise that letterbox gob of hers and his failure to highlight who she was. I think they were filming her from one of their 70 houses they own in Bristol alone.
Reply
#19
(05-03-2020, 11:33 AM)Swagbaggie Wrote: I don't agree. I didn't say what party Goodhall worked for because it is irrelevant to my point. Impartiality as well as balance in a publicly funded body is an imperative and if they can't do that they should be sacked let alone employed. 
I am apolitical by the way I think they are all self serving wankers.

 I wasn't suggesting you had an agenda - you think they should be impartial, I can understand your point of view. That's fine by me.

But you also said 'balance' which is why i gave the party he worked for and mentioned Andrew Neil - to demonstrate balance. That's why I thought it was relevant to your point.

Personally, I like to hear other people opinions, especially if they're not mine. I think it's important to try and understand where someone is coming from and so FOR ME, there is a use in the BBC in providing them - as long as they're balanced and all opinion is disclosed. 

I would rather that than get all my information from sources where I don't know who's financing what and what their motivations are. 

I'm not sure they're 'all' self-serving - but I take your point!
Reply
#20
(05-03-2020, 11:50 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(05-03-2020, 11:33 AM)Swagbaggie Wrote: I don't agree. I didn't say what party Goodhall worked for because it is irrelevant to my point. Impartiality as well as balance in a publicly funded body is an imperative and if they can't do that they should be sacked let alone employed. 
I am apolitical by the way I think they are all self serving wankers.

 I wasn't suggesting you had an agenda - you think they should be impartial, I can understand your point of view. That's fine by me.

But you also said 'balance' which is why i gave the party he worked for and mentioned Andrew Neil - to demonstrate balance. That's why I thought it was relevant.

Personally, I like to hear other people opinions, especially if they're not mine. I think it's important to try and understand where someone is coming from and so FOR ME, there is a use in the BBC in providing them - as long as they're balanced and all opinion is disclosed. 

I would rather that than get all my information from sources where I don't know who's financing what and what their motivations are. 

I'm not sure they're 'all' self-serving - but I take your point!

I agree FB. I too like to hear all points of view in the manner you state but the BBC and in particular Newsnight don't do that. They present selective investigation and in some cases ideology as fact and they embarrass themselves with their reluctance to own up to mistakes. 
They never present themselves as left leaning. 
The biggest travesty was Paul Mason who for years presented his economic forecasts in the supposed balanced way we would like to recieve only for him to get the push and then pitch up as a press advisor for Labour, then a momentum supporter before becoming anti momentum when he realised the damage they were doing but still a fervent Corbynite. 
He never declared any of his agenda when he was presenting his crap.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: