Posts: 1,236
Threads: 71
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
3
Posts: 3,903
Threads: 18
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(04-30-2020, 05:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-30-2020, 01:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm asking for a debate, not a one-sided lowest common denominator protect-everything-at-all-costs scarefest with no end in sight. From some of the responses it's clear that a few folk would've been happy living in East Berlin before the wall came down.
Proth you only ever see one side of a debate, your entire belief system is based on the accumulation of wealth above most other things, it’s how you validate someone’s opinion is the correct one or not. So what you’re really hoping for is the economy is put before people’s lives at the earliest opportunity but only some people’s lives, the ones that cost money rather than make. Unless you are advocating they are protected properly and logically that would include them and their families, finances were secured until such time as the risk was minimal. Forgive me if that seems harsh but your postings for years have rarely if ever as far as I can recall ever deviated from the most purest and ideological form of capitalism.
A way out would be for testing to be available across the UK so you can identify, trace and lock down areas where the virus shows an outbreak. Proactive measures not reactive which we have seen all through this crisis from the government. That way people would be able to go back to work at a relatively low risk over a managed time and the vulnerable wouldn’t be prisoners in their own homes. The only balancing act for this would be how low the risk would need to be, until hopefully at some point a vaccine is found or better medicines are found to aid recovery.
The fact is we can’t currently do that is because austerity left the country completely unprepared for such a way of operating. We are now trying to play catch-up and how much more has this cost in lives and economically in the long term than curbing the worst instincts of austerity to cut and cut again until we are scrabbling around for wafer thin plastic sheeting to protect frontline staff as an example?
What would your solution be? Just lift the lockdown and see what happens? Let's put this another way,, who on here would be prepared to sacrifice their life in order to save the economy for the benefit of others!!!!!
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(04-30-2020, 04:30 PM)billybassett Wrote: (04-30-2020, 03:27 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (04-30-2020, 11:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-30-2020, 09:10 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Stop revolving your life around opportunity costs for people's livelihoods FFS, there's no point running a business if all of the customers have died.
But that's the point isn't it? In the greater scheme of things very few people are going to die. Whereas hundreds of thousands (if not millions) of livelihoods are going to be ruined.
I'm fortunate that I've put enough away for a rainy day, which has finally arrived. The vast majority of people in this country live from paycheck to paycheck and don't have that luxury - just as they didn't in 2008.
Well there's 2 way of looking at this.
In the long term we are all going to die, In the short term if unchecked covid 19 has the potential to take 200 -400 k uk citizens, that's not an insubstantial amount.
Another made up death number. I'll make one up as well. If we don't start getting back to something like normal soon then the indirect deaths of covid over the next 10 years, due to a multitude of factors such s quiet health, mental health, poverty, blah blah will be circa 200,000
Not actually a made up number, but given the parameters I set 200k made up numbers and not really made up at all.
Based on the virus being allowed to spread unchecked, and 60% of the population getting it. That approximately would be 40 million, and a death rate of between 0.5 to 1 per 100 people who get the virus. These are not unreasonable assumptions given how contagious the virus is, and a death rate of 1 per 100 is again not unreasonable given the numbers of people who would get the virus, it would almost certainly mean that some people who could have been saved would be lost due to lack of medical resources (not a criticism, no health service could deal with those numbers)
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(04-30-2020, 05:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-30-2020, 01:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm asking for a debate, not a one-sided lowest common denominator protect-everything-at-all-costs scarefest with no end in sight. From some of the responses it's clear that a few folk would've been happy living in East Berlin before the wall came down.
Proth you only ever see one side of a debate, your entire belief system is based on the accumulation of wealth above most other things, it’s how you validate someone’s opinion is the correct one or not. So what you’re really hoping for is the economy is put before people’s lives at the earliest opportunity but only some people’s lives, the ones that cost money rather than make. Unless you are advocating they are protected properly and logically that would include them and their families, finances were secured until such time as the risk was minimal. Forgive me if that seems harsh but your postings for years have rarely if ever as far as I can recall ever deviated from the most purest and ideological form of capitalism.
A way out would be for testing to be available across the UK so you can identify, trace and lock down areas where the virus shows an outbreak. Proactive measures not reactive which we have seen all through this crisis from the government. That way people would be able to go back to work at a relatively low risk over a managed time and the vulnerable wouldn’t be prisoners in their own homes. The only balancing act for this would be how low the risk would need to be, until hopefully at some point a vaccine is found or better medicines are found to aid recovery.
The fact is we can’t currently do that is because austerity left the country completely unprepared for such a way of operating. We are now trying to play catch-up and how much more has this cost in lives and economically in the long term than curbing the worst instincts of austerity to cut and cut again until we are scrabbling around for wafer thin plastic sheeting to protect frontline staff as an example?
What would your solution be? Just lift the lockdown and see what happens?
Hilarious coming from the the most one-eyed of the cyclops herd on here.
I'm asking for an adult debate about the opportunity cost of a Lockdown of this scale. For the record, my mother has had Stage 4 cancer for 8 years and is in isolation with my brother who moved in with her 8 weeks ago. I have two kids missing out on vital time at school. I have as much skin in the game as anyone on here.
Those seeking to protect every single life are at odds with reality. We can't live in stasis until there's a vaccine, "testing" is a panacea too.
Contrary to your point about austerity, it appears that the NHS is coping just fine with plenty of capacity.
As such the answer to your final question is - continued indefinite isolation for the most vulnerable and lift the the lockdown progressively for everyone else.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-01-2020, 08:43 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-30-2020, 05:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-30-2020, 01:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm asking for a debate, not a one-sided lowest common denominator protect-everything-at-all-costs scarefest with no end in sight. From some of the responses it's clear that a few folk would've been happy living in East Berlin before the wall came down.
Proth you only ever see one side of a debate, your entire belief system is based on the accumulation of wealth above most other things, it’s how you validate someone’s opinion is the correct one or not. So what you’re really hoping for is the economy is put before people’s lives at the earliest opportunity but only some people’s lives, the ones that cost money rather than make. Unless you are advocating they are protected properly and logically that would include them and their families, finances were secured until such time as the risk was minimal. Forgive me if that seems harsh but your postings for years have rarely if ever as far as I can recall ever deviated from the most purest and ideological form of capitalism.
A way out would be for testing to be available across the UK so you can identify, trace and lock down areas where the virus shows an outbreak. Proactive measures not reactive which we have seen all through this crisis from the government. That way people would be able to go back to work at a relatively low risk over a managed time and the vulnerable wouldn’t be prisoners in their own homes. The only balancing act for this would be how low the risk would need to be, until hopefully at some point a vaccine is found or better medicines are found to aid recovery.
The fact is we can’t currently do that is because austerity left the country completely unprepared for such a way of operating. We are now trying to play catch-up and how much more has this cost in lives and economically in the long term than curbing the worst instincts of austerity to cut and cut again until we are scrabbling around for wafer thin plastic sheeting to protect frontline staff as an example?
What would your solution be? Just lift the lockdown and see what happens?
Hilarious coming from the the most one-eyed of the cyclops herd on here.
I'm asking for an adult debate about the opportunity cost of a Lockdown of this scale. For the record, my mother has had Stage 4 cancer for 8 years and is in isolation with my brother who moved in with her 8 weeks ago. I have two kids missing out on vital time at school. I have as much skin in the game as anyone on here.
Those seeking to protect every single life are at odds with reality. We can't live in stasis until there's a vaccine, "testing" is a panacea too.
Contrary to your point about austerity, it appears that the NHS is coping just fine with plenty of capacity.
As such the answer to your final question is - continued indefinite isolation for the most vulnerable and lift the the lockdown progressively for everyone else.
The NHS is a only coping because of the lockdown. Although those working in the NHS on the frontline who have lost relatives would I imagine disagree. As would those working in the Care industry.
We haven’t tested people enough because we didn’t have capacity to do so.
No one is proposing a lockdown for any longer than it is safe to do so. However the pressure being applied to the government by mostly right wing MPs and gobshite commentators isn’t helpful and not at all grown up. There is a difference between asking for a road map out of this and demanding we end lockdown ends ASAP. I don’t envy the governments position on this as we are in limbo until testing is at a capacity to actually assess in what areas we can ease lockdown. Currently I don’t think testing capacity is anywhere near that, it’s better but hardly on the scale of Germany or Singapore who did ‘test, test, test right from the outset.
Shielding for the vulnerable is the trickiest part in all this for both of us but if we are to do this then it’s important to support those groups economically, socially and look after their physical and mental health. Not everyone will be in the position to shield themselves or members of their family if they are told it’s not safe to come out of self isolation and that is where I believe the state may have to step in long after most are back in work.
In a nutshell we aren’t yet in a position to ease lockdown to a significant degree but when we are we have to do it in phases and actually look after not penalise the most vulnerable as we do so. If austerity taught us anything it should surely be to not put things in place that hurt the weak disproportionately.
Posts: 398
Threads: 13
Joined: Feb 2019
People in poorest areas are more than twice as likely to die from Covid 19 than those from better off places in the UK.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(05-01-2020, 09:17 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The NHS is a only coping because of the lockdown. Although those working in the NHS on the frontline who have lost relatives would I imagine disagree. As would those working in the Care industry.
We haven’t tested people enough because we didn’t have capacity to do so.
No one is proposing a lockdown for any longer than it is safe to do so. However the pressure being applied to the government by mostly right wing MPs and gobshite commentators isn’t helpful and not at all grown up. There is a difference between asking for a road map out of this and demanding we end lockdown ends ASAP. I don’t envy the governments position on this as we are in limbo until testing is at a capacity to actually assess in what areas we can ease lockdown. Currently I don’t think testing capacity is anywhere near that, it’s better but hardly on the scale of Germany or Singapore who did ‘test, test, test right from the outset.
Shielding for the vulnerable is the trickiest part in all this for both of us but if we are to do this then it’s important to support those groups economically, socially and look after their physical and mental health. Not everyone will be in the position to shield themselves or members of their family if they are told it’s not safe to come out of self isolation and that is where I believe the state may have to step in long after most are back in work.
In a nutshell we aren’t yet in a position to ease lockdown to a significant degree but when we are we have to do it in phases and actually look after not penalise the most vulnerable as we do so. If austerity taught us anything it should surely be to not put things in place that hurt the weak disproportionately.
I think we agree on both of those points.
Continued Lockdown will also hurt the poor disproportionately - as they're the ones working in the sectors most affected by it.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(05-01-2020, 08:43 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-30-2020, 05:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-30-2020, 01:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm asking for a debate, not a one-sided lowest common denominator protect-everything-at-all-costs scarefest with no end in sight. From some of the responses it's clear that a few folk would've been happy living in East Berlin before the wall came down.
Proth you only ever see one side of a debate, your entire belief system is based on the accumulation of wealth above most other things, it’s how you validate someone’s opinion is the correct one or not. So what you’re really hoping for is the economy is put before people’s lives at the earliest opportunity but only some people’s lives, the ones that cost money rather than make. Unless you are advocating they are protected properly and logically that would include them and their families, finances were secured until such time as the risk was minimal. Forgive me if that seems harsh but your postings for years have rarely if ever as far as I can recall ever deviated from the most purest and ideological form of capitalism.
A way out would be for testing to be available across the UK so you can identify, trace and lock down areas where the virus shows an outbreak. Proactive measures not reactive which we have seen all through this crisis from the government. That way people would be able to go back to work at a relatively low risk over a managed time and the vulnerable wouldn’t be prisoners in their own homes. The only balancing act for this would be how low the risk would need to be, until hopefully at some point a vaccine is found or better medicines are found to aid recovery.
The fact is we can’t currently do that is because austerity left the country completely unprepared for such a way of operating. We are now trying to play catch-up and how much more has this cost in lives and economically in the long term than curbing the worst instincts of austerity to cut and cut again until we are scrabbling around for wafer thin plastic sheeting to protect frontline staff as an example?
What would your solution be? Just lift the lockdown and see what happens?
Hilarious coming from the the most one-eyed of the cyclops herd on here.
I'm asking for an adult debate about the opportunity cost of a Lockdown of this scale. For the record, my mother has had Stage 4 cancer for 8 years and is in isolation with my brother who moved in with her 8 weeks ago. I have two kids missing out on vital time at school. I have as much skin in the game as anyone on here.
Those seeking to protect every single life are at odds with reality. We can't live in stasis until there's a vaccine, "testing" is a panacea too.
Contrary to your point about austerity, it appears that the NHS is coping just fine with plenty of capacity.
As such the answer to your final question is - continued indefinite isolation for the most vulnerable and lift the the lockdown progressively for everyone else.
In fairness Proth I think the vast majority of people do take into consideration the cost of lockdown both to the economy and the general health of the nation, they just may come to a different conclusion than the one you might reach.
There would be a cost to the economy if there had not been a lockdown. If the virus had been allowed to rip through the country with no measures taken, how many people would have wanted to go to Shopping centres, visit pubs, restaurants, cinemas etc. Those businesses would have still suffered even if there had been no lockdown, and perhaps without the govt assistance that came hand in hand with the lockdown measures.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(05-01-2020, 08:43 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-30-2020, 05:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-30-2020, 01:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm asking for a debate, not a one-sided lowest common denominator protect-everything-at-all-costs scarefest with no end in sight. From some of the responses it's clear that a few folk would've been happy living in East Berlin before the wall came down.
Proth you only ever see one side of a debate, your entire belief system is based on the accumulation of wealth above most other things, it’s how you validate someone’s opinion is the correct one or not. So what you’re really hoping for is the economy is put before people’s lives at the earliest opportunity but only some people’s lives, the ones that cost money rather than make. Unless you are advocating they are protected properly and logically that would include them and their families, finances were secured until such time as the risk was minimal. Forgive me if that seems harsh but your postings for years have rarely if ever as far as I can recall ever deviated from the most purest and ideological form of capitalism.
A way out would be for testing to be available across the UK so you can identify, trace and lock down areas where the virus shows an outbreak. Proactive measures not reactive which we have seen all through this crisis from the government. That way people would be able to go back to work at a relatively low risk over a managed time and the vulnerable wouldn’t be prisoners in their own homes. The only balancing act for this would be how low the risk would need to be, until hopefully at some point a vaccine is found or better medicines are found to aid recovery.
The fact is we can’t currently do that is because austerity left the country completely unprepared for such a way of operating. We are now trying to play catch-up and how much more has this cost in lives and economically in the long term than curbing the worst instincts of austerity to cut and cut again until we are scrabbling around for wafer thin plastic sheeting to protect frontline staff as an example?
What would your solution be? Just lift the lockdown and see what happens?
Hilarious coming from the the most one-eyed of the cyclops herd on here.
I'm asking for an adult debate about the opportunity cost of a Lockdown of this scale. For the record, my mother has had Stage 4 cancer for 8 years and is in isolation with my brother who moved in with her 8 weeks ago. I have two kids missing out on vital time at school. I have as much skin in the game as anyone on here.
Those seeking to protect every single life are at odds with reality. We can't live in stasis until there's a vaccine, "testing" is a panacea too.
Contrary to your point about austerity, it appears that the NHS is coping just fine with plenty of capacity.
As such the answer to your final question is - continued indefinite isolation for the most vulnerable and lift the the lockdown progressively for everyone else.
Despite coming at this from different points of view, I think this is what most are looking to do. It's definitely the approach I would take. As I mentioned in an earlier post Construction should be back now, they were given the green light weeks ago but it is the individual companies that are holding back; Manufacturing will follow soon in a reduced capacity taking into account some form of protection for the workers.
Office based workers should be able to continue with, where needed, companies improving their IT infrastructures to enable this. I work for a global company that has 50ish in our office all working from home to at least 90% capacity. We'll be at home until Q4 more than likely.
Retail will be the next big one but that will be at a very reduced capacity as sales will be restricted due to footfall. I see a complete realignment of shopping and retail rentals going forward, this was always coming but this has just accelerated the process.
Hospitality and Travel is the one that will take the biggest hit and will re-emerge a totally different beast.
I disagree about the NHS coping just fine, they are doctors not soldiers so anywhere there are reports of staff deaths means it is not fine. We sent them into work without the correct protective equipment because of decisions made not to spend money - that stems directly from austerity and government cuts.
And on a side note, I hope you and your family are staying fit especially your mom who by the sounds of it will need protecting for quite a while.
Posts: 8,846
Threads: 270
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(05-01-2020, 10:00 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (05-01-2020, 08:43 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-30-2020, 05:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-30-2020, 01:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm asking for a debate, not a one-sided lowest common denominator protect-everything-at-all-costs scarefest with no end in sight. From some of the responses it's clear that a few folk would've been happy living in East Berlin before the wall came down.
Proth you only ever see one side of a debate, your entire belief system is based on the accumulation of wealth above most other things, it’s how you validate someone’s opinion is the correct one or not. So what you’re really hoping for is the economy is put before people’s lives at the earliest opportunity but only some people’s lives, the ones that cost money rather than make. Unless you are advocating they are protected properly and logically that would include them and their families, finances were secured until such time as the risk was minimal. Forgive me if that seems harsh but your postings for years have rarely if ever as far as I can recall ever deviated from the most purest and ideological form of capitalism.
A way out would be for testing to be available across the UK so you can identify, trace and lock down areas where the virus shows an outbreak. Proactive measures not reactive which we have seen all through this crisis from the government. That way people would be able to go back to work at a relatively low risk over a managed time and the vulnerable wouldn’t be prisoners in their own homes. The only balancing act for this would be how low the risk would need to be, until hopefully at some point a vaccine is found or better medicines are found to aid recovery.
The fact is we can’t currently do that is because austerity left the country completely unprepared for such a way of operating. We are now trying to play catch-up and how much more has this cost in lives and economically in the long term than curbing the worst instincts of austerity to cut and cut again until we are scrabbling around for wafer thin plastic sheeting to protect frontline staff as an example?
What would your solution be? Just lift the lockdown and see what happens?
Hilarious coming from the the most one-eyed of the cyclops herd on here.
I'm asking for an adult debate about the opportunity cost of a Lockdown of this scale. For the record, my mother has had Stage 4 cancer for 8 years and is in isolation with my brother who moved in with her 8 weeks ago. I have two kids missing out on vital time at school. I have as much skin in the game as anyone on here.
Those seeking to protect every single life are at odds with reality. We can't live in stasis until there's a vaccine, "testing" is a panacea too.
Contrary to your point about austerity, it appears that the NHS is coping just fine with plenty of capacity.
As such the answer to your final question is - continued indefinite isolation for the most vulnerable and lift the the lockdown progressively for everyone else.
In fairness Proth I think the vast majority of people do take into consideration the cost of lockdown both to the economy and the general health of the nation, they just may come to a different conclusion than the one you might reach.
There would be a cost to the economy if there had not been a lockdown. If the virus had been allowed to rip through the country with no measures taken, how many people would have wanted to go to Shopping centres, visit pubs, restaurants, cinemas etc. Those businesses would have still suffered even if there had been no lockdown, and perhaps without the govt assistance that came hand in hand with the lockdown measures.
Good point.
|