Pubs closing.....
#31
People seem to be assuming that the government is trying to STOP the spread of the virus. They aren't - and some would argue they can't - they are trying to slow it and stagger it.

Why else would schools still be open? Across the capitalist world - How else are people going be able to support their families if they can't work? 

If people still go to pubs or cafe's or the gym  - that's not them being 'selfish c's' or 'killing an old dear' , it's them doing exactly what the government wants, letting our life carry on whilst hopefully regulating the spread of the virus to manageable levels. Frankly, kids mixing at schools are more likely to be 'murdering the old dears' which makes responsible parents the 'selfish c's' rather than the bloke in the pub - to carry on the ridiculously hyperbolic narrative.

Italy has had to introduce more extreme measures because there health service can't cope anymore. We may reach that state soon and things will change, but at present, this is where we are.
Reply
#32
(03-18-2020, 12:11 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: People seem to be assuming that the government is trying to STOP the spread of the virus. They aren't - and some would argue they can't - they are trying to slow it and stagger it.

Why else would schools still be open? Across the capitalist world - How else are people going be able to support their families if they can't work? 

If people still go to pubs or cafe's or the gym  - that's not them being 'selfish c's' or 'killing an old dear' , it's them doing exactly what the government wants, letting our life carry on whilst hopefully regulating the spread of the virus to manageable levels. Frankly, school kids mixing at schools are more likely to be 'murdering the old dears' which makes responsible parents the 'selfish c's' rather than the bloke in the pub - to carry on the ridiculously hyperbolic narrative.

Maybe the approach will change, but at present, this is where we are.

Disagree with this and I don't think its hyperbole. I think the (UK) government's approach is totally wrong and that anyone still congregating in groups are just increasing the risk of making themselves vectors for a virus that will disproportionately affect the elderly and vulnerable. 

Every article I've read by someone who should (in theory) know what they are doing has poured scorn on the "herd immunity" approach. The ONLY good reason I can think of for the current approach is that they are in fact planning to follow other countries' approach soon but are concerned with behavioural fatigue kicking in just when the infections reach their peak. I also disagree with this but at least I can see where they're coming from.

They obviously know that social distancing is the strongest weapon we have in the fight which is why they've "advised" to avoid social venues and gatherings but because they are in the pocket of big business they prefer the workers and the small businesses to take the financial hit.
Reply
#33
(03-18-2020, 12:28 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Disagree with this and I don't think its hyperbole. I think the (UK) government's approach is totally wrong and that anyone still congregating in groups are just increasing the risk of making themselves vectors for a virus that will disproportionately affect the elderly and vulnerable. 

Every article I've read by someone who should (in theory) know what they are doing has poured scorn on the "herd immunity" approach. The ONLY good reason I can think of for the current approach is that they are in fact planning to follow other countries' approach soon but are concerned with behavioural fatigue kicking in just when the infections reach their peak. I also disagree with this but at least I can see where they're coming from.

They obviously know that social distancing is the strongest weapon we have in the fight which is why they've "advised" to avoid social venues and gatherings but because they are in the pocket of big business they prefer the workers and the small businesses to take the financial hit.

Fair enough. But then, why do you think they haven't closed the schools? 

You're right, plenty of experts have disagreed with 'herd' theory, but no means every 'expert'. 

China have been successful initially in reducing new registered infections, but they are now rising again. If that regime can't stop it spreading, how can a western government? (EDIT - there's been conflicting reports on this. Have they just stopped testing most cases - like they have in much of UK? Do we even know what is happening in this country - let alone China?)

For clarification, I don't think the virus is hyperbole (quite the opposite), I think calling people murderers and selfish c's is. I maintain, if you're right, letting your children going to school is far more damaging than going to an empty pub. Not that I do either!

People are expecting someone to solve it because that's what we are used to. For the first time in a number of generations, maybe this time they can't. At least until a vaccine comes out next year. I don't agree with linking this to climate change, but I do think it will make people realise that we shouldn't be too complacent and assume somebody will 'fix it' without us making any effort or sacrifice.
Reply
#34
Not sure why they haven't closed the schools - presumably because then it would be completely obvious that social distancing is what's needed and they'd then need to officially close businesses.

I haven't called anyone a murderer or a cunt but I do think someone unwittingly coughing in a pub is going to be the death of someone vulnerable. 100%. Need to contain it as much as possible (which might require multiple lockdowns, spaced apart) and roll on the vaccine.

Agree with your last point though, might make some people wake up. We've essentially had it cushty for the longest stretch in human history and have become complacent. If we can't fix it then ultimately life must go on and lots of people will die. We should try everything before allowing that though.
Reply
#35
(03-18-2020, 01:18 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Not sure why they haven't closed the schools - presumably because then it would be completely obvious that social distancing is what's needed and they'd then need to officially close businesses.

I haven't called anyone a murderer or a cunt but I do think someone unwittingly coughing in a pub is going to be the death of someone vulnerable. 100%. Need to contain it as much as possible (which might require multiple lockdowns, spaced apart) and roll on the vaccine.

Agree with your last point though, might make some people wake up. We've essentially had it cushty for the longest stretch in human history and have become complacent. If we can't fix it then ultimately life must go on and lots of people will die. We should try everything before allowing that though.

That's why i clarified my use of 'hyperbole'. It wasn't meant for you or the virus (slightly clumsy and possibly offensive linkage - but hopefully you get my point!) 

'but I do think someone unwittingly coughing in a pub is going to be the death of someone vulnerable.' Maybe, but ultimately very, very unlikely and certainly less likely than an unhygienic kid (as most of the young ones are!) mixing in a school and coming home afterwards. So are parents more selfish? Should they be particularly singled out?

But how likely is it anyway? We just don't know. Maybe that's the problem.

I take your point about 'trying everything'. But that 'might' be easier for you or me to do. But for others, it's either impossible or unworkable. Some people need to go out earn money or have a social obligation to provide a service.  Is it fair to let or make them take such a risk while we don't? Anyway, you can't take all risk out of society. People being people they might not want to. People still enjoy or want to drive, fly or go skiing. I suspect as this goes on a need for social interaction may become too much. My hope is that they do whatever they do fully understanding the risks. Which, at present, we don't.

You could be right and I could be completely wrong, though. The frightening thing is, nobody knows.

Whichever side of the argument someones on, maybe looking after our most vulnerable PROPERLY should be our priority. Should they go into isolation? If so, for how long? As it goes on, what about quality of life? I just don't know...
Reply
#36
(03-18-2020, 01:18 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Not sure why they haven't closed the schools - presumably because then it would be completely obvious that social distancing is what's needed and they'd then need to officially close businesses.

I haven't called anyone a murderer or a cunt but I do think someone unwittingly coughing in a pub is going to be the death of someone vulnerable. 100%. Need to contain it as much as possible (which might require multiple lockdowns, spaced apart) and roll on the vaccine.

Agree with your last point though, might make some people wake up. We've essentially had it cushty for the longest stretch in human history and have become complacent. If we can't fix it then ultimately life must go on and lots of people will die. We should try everything before allowing that though.

Geniune question bud and I've no axe to grind, but once the schools are shut who is going to replace all those front line health care workers, etc who will now have to stay at home to child mind, just at the time when to may be needed most?
Reply
#37
Wetherspoons staying open - despite Government recommendations!

Just about sums the bloke up eh?
Reply
#38
(03-18-2020, 05:13 PM)baggpuss Wrote: Wetherspoons staying open - despite Government recommendations!

Just about sums the bloke up eh?

All Bathams still open, Just about sums the bloke up?
Reply
#39
(03-18-2020, 03:33 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(03-18-2020, 01:18 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Not sure why they haven't closed the schools - presumably because then it would be completely obvious that social distancing is what's needed and they'd then need to officially close businesses.

I haven't called anyone a murderer or a cunt but I do think someone unwittingly coughing in a pub is going to be the death of someone vulnerable. 100%. Need to contain it as much as possible (which might require multiple lockdowns, spaced apart) and roll on the vaccine.

Agree with your last point though, might make some people wake up. We've essentially had it cushty for the longest stretch in human history and have become complacent. If we can't fix it then ultimately life must go on and lots of people will die. We should try everything before allowing that though.

Geniune question bud and I've no axe to grind, but once the schools are shut who is going to replace all those front line health care workers, etc who will now have to stay at home to child mind, just at the time when to may be needed most?
Hopefully no-one. Now that they have finally closed schools I'd like to think that the govt will provide support for childcare (thus killing a 2nd bird with the same stone of helping nurseries/creches/babysitters). If not, they work and partners/families etc look after kids. If not that then we lose them.
Reply
#40
Fleur-De-Lys in Lowsonford was very quiet when I drove past last night, but there were people in there.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)