Today
#11
(02-10-2020, 09:52 AM)Bloke who lives abroad Wrote: If only HRK could finish.

He played a blinder today, he really did. Dragged their defence all over the place and held the ball up nicely when we needed him to. Some very nice touches too.

But... but... he could've.... should've had at least one. Maybe 2 or even 3.  I reckon he must just tense up, that bit too much, which someone like Austin doesn't do.

Oh for a Hal Robson Austin!
Reply
#12
For all the stick HRK gets, he's actually our best striker in terms of his xG (expected goals) metric, which suggests he's finished far more difficult chances. Both he and Phillips are far above where they should be in terms of goals scored vs. quality of chances. Austin on the other hand is actually some way behind where he should be, suggesting his finishing may be over estimated. The rest of our players are roughly where they should be.

HRK's xG is 4.8 vs 7 league goals
Austin xG is 10.8 vs 8 league goals
Zohore xG is 3.4 vs 3 goals

Given the main criticism of the xG is that it assumes all players have equal finishing ability (ie: Aguero is predicted to convert chances with the same likelihood as Wesley), Austin's reputation as a natural finisher should see him massively exceed this. The fact he's also playing for a club at the top of the league also means he should have more chances created.

Fact is we seem to create more chances with Austin in the side than without, but he doesn't convert at as high a rate as HRK.

Maybe worth rethinking the narrative!
Reply
#13
(02-10-2020, 10:35 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: For all the stick HRK gets, he's actually our best striker in terms of his xG (expected goals) metric, which suggests he's finished far more difficult chances. Both he and Phillips are far above where they should be in terms of goals scored vs. quality of chances. Austin on the other hand is actually some way behind where he should be, suggesting his finishing may be over estimated. The rest of our players are roughly where they should be.

HRK's xG is 4.8 vs 7 league goals
Austin xG is 10.8 vs 8 league goals
Zohore xG is 3.4 vs 3 goals

Given the main criticism of the xG is that it assumes all players have equal finishing ability (ie: Aguero is predicted to convert chances with the same likelihood as Wesley), Austin's reputation as a natural finisher should see him massively exceed this. The fact he's also playing for a club at the top of the league also means he should have more chances created.

Fact is we seem to create more chances with Austin in the side than without, but he doesn't convert at as high a rate as HRK.

Maybe worth rethinking the narrative!

eh? 29 shots created at Millwall, without Austin kind of disproves the theory that we create more with him in than not. For me Austin's movement just doesn't fit as well as HRK's does, it just feels like Pereira knows that HRK will make a run whereas with Austin that understanding (or the run) just doesn't seem to be there... Which also sees more pressure on midfield and then on defence too...
Reply
#14
Miss of the day yesterday went to Pereira, with Bartley a close second!

(02-10-2020, 10:35 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Fact is we seem to create more chances with Austin in the side than without, but he doesn't convert at as high a rate as HRK.

Maybe worth rethinking the narrative!

In the Prem HRK had a massively superior conversion rate to Rondon, although maybe that's less impressive.
Reply
#15
What does surprise me is how we've all gone from making jokes about HRK to now actually thinking he might be OK really, with a following wind and some good players around him...sort of thing!
Reply
#16
(02-10-2020, 10:56 AM)MassDebater Wrote: What does surprise me is how we've all gone from making jokes about HRK to now actually thinking he might be OK really, with a following wind and some good players around him...sort of thing!

https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/showthread.php?tid=2359
Reply
#17
(02-10-2020, 10:52 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(02-10-2020, 10:35 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: For all the stick HRK gets, he's actually our best striker in terms of his xG (expected goals) metric, which suggests he's finished far more difficult chances. Both he and Phillips are far above where they should be in terms of goals scored vs. quality of chances. Austin on the other hand is actually some way behind where he should be, suggesting his finishing may be over estimated. The rest of our players are roughly where they should be.

HRK's xG is 4.8 vs 7 league goals
Austin xG is 10.8 vs 8 league goals
Zohore xG is 3.4 vs 3 goals

Given the main criticism of the xG is that it assumes all players have equal finishing ability (ie: Aguero is predicted to convert chances with the same likelihood as Wesley), Austin's reputation as a natural finisher should see him massively exceed this. The fact he's also playing for a club at the top of the league also means he should have more chances created.

Fact is we seem to create more chances with Austin in the side than without, but he doesn't convert at as high a rate as HRK.

Maybe worth rethinking the narrative!

eh? 29 shots created at Millwall, without Austin kind of disproves the theory that we create more with him in than not. For me Austin's movement just doesn't fit as well as HRK's does, it just feels like Pereira knows that HRK will make a run whereas with Austin that understanding (or the run) just doesn't seem to be there... Which also sees more pressure on midfield and then on defence too...

That's one game in 30...

And the stat suggests we create more high quality goal scoring opportunities for Austin than we do for HRK, not that we create more outright chances. It's not about creating loads and loads of chances, it's about creating good chances. I'd take 3 or 4 clear cut chances a game vs 30 average ones. Forest and Fulham are particularly good at this and it's why they are where they are. For much of the season Brentford were the opposite, creating tonnes of chances but very few clear ones. They've now addressed that, hence their recent form.

Compared to Leeds we create less xG chances - Bamford for example should have 7 or 8 additional goals this season - but HRK seems to be a better fit for our set up as whilst we create less obvious chances for him, he's a more reliable scorer. I'd imagine other players have a higher xG in games where HRK plays than Austin.
Reply
#18
(02-10-2020, 10:35 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: For all the stick HRK gets, he's actually our best striker in terms of his xG (expected goals) metric, which suggests he's finished far more difficult chances. Both he and Phillips are far above where they should be in terms of goals scored vs. quality of chances. Austin on the other hand is actually some way behind where he should be, suggesting his finishing may be over estimated. The rest of our players are roughly where they should be.

HRK's xG is 4.8 vs 7 league goals
Austin xG is 10.8 vs 8 league goals
Zohore xG is 3.4 vs 3 goals

Given the main criticism of the xG is that it assumes all players have equal finishing ability (ie: Aguero is predicted to convert chances with the same likelihood as Wesley), Austin's reputation as a natural finisher should see him massively exceed this. The fact he's also playing for a club at the top of the league also means he should have more chances created.

Fact is we seem to create more chances with Austin in the side than without, but he doesn't convert at as high a rate as HRK.

Maybe worth rethinking the narrative!

I do think Austin has been rather unlucky with some efforts where he's hit the woodwork or the keeper has made a brilliant save to deny him but on the other hand I guess we should possibly take into account how many of the goals of each were penalties.

We've had 6 penalties so far, Austin has scored 3, Zohore 2 and HRK the other.
Reply
#19
(02-10-2020, 12:02 PM)Lightnin Wrote:
(02-10-2020, 10:35 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: For all the stick HRK gets, he's actually our best striker in terms of his xG (expected goals) metric, which suggests he's finished far more difficult chances. Both he and Phillips are far above where they should be in terms of goals scored vs. quality of chances. Austin on the other hand is actually some way behind where he should be, suggesting his finishing may be over estimated. The rest of our players are roughly where they should be.

HRK's xG is 4.8 vs 7 league goals
Austin xG is 10.8 vs 8 league goals
Zohore xG is 3.4 vs 3 goals

Given the main criticism of the xG is that it assumes all players have equal finishing ability (ie: Aguero is predicted to convert chances with the same likelihood as Wesley), Austin's reputation as a natural finisher should see him massively exceed this. The fact he's also playing for a club at the top of the league also means he should have more chances created.

Fact is we seem to create more chances with Austin in the side than without, but he doesn't convert at as high a rate as HRK.

Maybe worth rethinking the narrative!

I do think Austin has been rather unlucky with some efforts where he's hit the woodwork or the keeper has made a brilliant save to deny him but on the other hand I guess we should possibly take into account how many of the goals of each were penalties.

I think the pens would inflate Austin's overall average, suggesting his open play score is even worse.

Pens are xG of about 0.93 in that they should pretty much always be scored, whereas Austin has a 100% conversion rate for us.

That means he's actually worse from open play than he should be.
Reply
#20
(02-10-2020, 12:05 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-10-2020, 12:02 PM)Lightnin Wrote:
(02-10-2020, 10:35 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: For all the stick HRK gets, he's actually our best striker in terms of his xG (expected goals) metric, which suggests he's finished far more difficult chances. Both he and Phillips are far above where they should be in terms of goals scored vs. quality of chances. Austin on the other hand is actually some way behind where he should be, suggesting his finishing may be over estimated. The rest of our players are roughly where they should be.

HRK's xG is 4.8 vs 7 league goals
Austin xG is 10.8 vs 8 league goals
Zohore xG is 3.4 vs 3 goals

Given the main criticism of the xG is that it assumes all players have equal finishing ability (ie: Aguero is predicted to convert chances with the same likelihood as Wesley), Austin's reputation as a natural finisher should see him massively exceed this. The fact he's also playing for a club at the top of the league also means he should have more chances created.

Fact is we seem to create more chances with Austin in the side than without, but he doesn't convert at as high a rate as HRK.

Maybe worth rethinking the narrative!

I do think Austin has been rather unlucky with some efforts where he's hit the woodwork or the keeper has made a brilliant save to deny him but on the other hand I guess we should possibly take into account how many of the goals of each were penalties.

I think the pens would inflate Austin's overall average, suggesting his open play score is even worse.

Pens are xG of about 0.93 in that they should pretty much always be scored, whereas Austin has a 100% conversion rate for us.

That means he's actually worse from open play than he should be.

Statistically yes but as I've said, he's been unlucky with some efforts. I think it's widely agreed that Zohore just hasn't shown enough desire as yet, we were told by Cardiff fans what we were getting and they've been pretty much bang on. HRK and Austin are both horses for courses, I think you either play HRK if going one up top and have Austin as the back up in case he has one of his poor games or you play them both as Austin doesn't seem to have the overall attributes to play up top on his own but we're never really going to do this. It's pretty clear Slav knows.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)