SB moaning
#31
(01-13-2020, 06:46 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-13-2020, 04:45 PM)billybassett Wrote: As I said on another thread:

This is what we're missing...


As a comparison:

Catches this season
Kiko Casilla (leeds) 25
David Martin (brentford) 25
Sam Johnstone 6

Punches this season
Kiko Casilla (leeds) 17
David Martin (brentford) 14
Sam Johnstone 10

If he's instructed not to claim high balls though... 

That is common with teams set up to zonal mark, the keepers area is the goal line.

If this is true then I simply don't understand why it should be sacrosanct.  As long as he's not being obstructed then given he has arms - Johnstone does have arms - he can obviously reach above any player and should make a decision to attempt to catch or punch the ball clear.  Occasionally keepers mess up and are beaten by headers as a result of miscuing their attempt to catch or clear but not that often and definitely not 11 times in the number of games we've conceded a goal it seems.  I can't see many keepers saving a header stuck on the line when it's from 6 yards or less away.
Reply
#32
How about we try not to allow so many crosses into the box and give away soft corners? We could do this by being more organised when out of possession and stopping the big gaps between our attack and defence as we over commit players going forward. It’s easy to blame the defence and the same comments were made when Mowbray was in charge about having better defenders, man marking, zonal etc but in the end it all boils down to the entire team defending not just the defence. Unfashionable as that may be.
Reply
#33
(01-14-2020, 09:01 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(01-13-2020, 06:46 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-13-2020, 04:45 PM)billybassett Wrote: As I said on another thread:

This is what we're missing...


As a comparison:

Catches this season
Kiko Casilla (leeds) 25
David Martin (brentford) 25
Sam Johnstone 6

Punches this season
Kiko Casilla (leeds) 17
David Martin (brentford) 14
Sam Johnstone 10

If he's instructed not to claim high balls though... 

That is common with teams set up to zonal mark, the keepers area is the goal line.

If this is true then I simply don't understand why it should be sacrosanct.  As long as he's not being obstructed then given he has arms - Johnstone does have arms - he can obviously reach above any player and should make a decision to attempt to catch or punch the ball clear.  Occasionally keepers mess up and are beaten by headers as a result of miscuing their attempt to catch or clear but not that often and definitely not 11 times in the number of games we've conceded a goal it seems.  I can't see many keepers saving a header stuck on the line when it's from 6 yards or less away.

Although the goal line is their 'zone'. doesn't the gk still have priority if (s)he is confident of getting to the ball? It's their job as leader to make that call - it's not meant to be rigid for the reasons said above. IF I'm right (and I might not be), then surely he should still come out for at least some of the crosses?
Reply
#34
It's a definite weakness, amongst his many strengths. The Brentford keeper was noticably better than any other that i've seen this season, he commanded his box unlike anyone I have seen for a fair while.
Reply
#35
(01-13-2020, 06:46 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-13-2020, 04:45 PM)billybassett Wrote: As I said on another thread:

This is what we're missing...


As a comparison:

Catches this season
Kiko Casilla (leeds) 25
David Martin (brentford) 25
Sam Johnstone 6

Punches this season
Kiko Casilla (leeds) 17
David Martin (brentford) 14
Sam Johnstone 10

If he's instructed not to claim high balls though... 

That is common with teams set up to zonal mark, the keepers area is the goal line.

Surely can't be.
What manager would instruct his keeper not to come for a ball they can easily punch or catch to take the pressure off their defence? Unless of course Bilic knows Johnstone can't catch for toffee or is incapable of judging a ball in flight - which would then beg the question why is he playing in the team at all.
Reply
#36
I'd definitely be starting Hegazi now. If only to shake the other two up a little.

October/November, when Bartley and Ajayi were at their peak, then no. Hegazi couldn't get in and rightly so. But since then? We've become sloppier in our own penalty area. Start Hegazi. For me, it's a must.

(And tell SJ to punch clear if he cant catch!!!)
Reply
#37
You could have Flint, Moore, McCauley in our backline and we would still concede from headers and corners simply because of the amount of unchallenged crosses and giveaway corners we allow.
Reply
#38
Thought this was another thread about saido
Reply
#39
It is a weakness of Johnstone, regardless of instructions, however if he's also had those instructions that's partly why the numbers are so low.

Kiely was the same. Carson was too, and wasn't even half the shot stopper Johnstone is.

We were spoiled for years with Foster, some of our fans need to see that he was the rarity, not the usual.
Reply
#40
Buy a good keeper who dominates his box. Take of the rose tinted glasses and recognize the fact that Johnstone ain't good enough.Be told!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)