Democracy
#11
So it's goodbye to Scotland and the north of Ireland.
Reply
#12
Yes, first past the post usually delivers governments with majorities. That on its own is a neutral thing, given the practice of voters to turf out governments once in a while, which tends to translate into stop-go politics. There's a lot to be said for coalition politics, as they can promote more policy stability.

It's quite hard to argue effectively that Britain's decisive govt. electoral system has granted the UK (or the US) better governance than most other developed ones, especially in terms of substantively democratic outcomes. Both countries grapple with lower than average turnout rates and massive and persistent inequality in terms of income, wealth, education, and social mobility. But that, apparently, is what the Brits want.
Reply
#13
(12-13-2019, 11:10 AM)Pneumann Wrote: Yes, first past the post usually delivers governments with majorities. That on its own is a neutral thing, given the practice of voters to turf out governments once in a while, which tends to translate into stop-go politics. There's a lot to be said for coalition politics, as they can promote more policy stability.

It's quite hard  to argue effectively that Britain's decisive govt. electoral system has granted the UK  (or the US) better governance than most other developed ones, especially in terms of substantively democratic outcomes. Both countries grapple with lower than average turnout rates and massive and persistent inequality in terms of income, wealth, education, and social mobility. But that, apparently, is what the Brits want.

I think it's what Labour and the Tories want as they're the only ones who are ever going to taste power.  Many Brits just get swept up with the idea of us inventing democracy and having the mother parliament etc.  We don't seem to accept that other countries may have found a better way to our archaic system.

I would also seriously consider compulsory voting, even if it resulted in cocks on paper winning an overall majority!
Reply
#14
Pity the poor souls at Change UK. They must've rightly judged that the Liberals were ripe to be replaced, set up their own party, suffered because of the freak EU election, fled to the Libs only to find their leader--Swinson--as tin eared as can be, and then defeated from parliament.
Reply
#15
A conservative member on Sky News this morning genuinely said "there's no mandate for indyref2 in Scotland as the SNP only got 45% of the vote"
Reply
#16
(12-13-2019, 12:10 PM)Sliced Wrote: A conservative member on Sky News this morning genuinely said "there's no mandate for indyref2 in Scotland as the SNP only got 45% of the vote"

In a way that is no different to baggy1's post above adding up all the votes to supposedly prove that remain would win another referendum

So a similar working of a multi party, multi issue vote transferred to a binary vote would be

SNP 45% + Greens 1% =46% in favour of independence - All other parties 54% in favour of staying in UK

But even Sturgeon has said she won't pretend that every SNP voter in the election would vote for independence and the opposite  applies for other parties.
You cannot correlate a single issue vote with a multi party, multi issue vote.
Reply
#17
(12-13-2019, 11:06 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(12-13-2019, 09:19 AM)Sotv Wrote: And of course you would have posted this if the result was reversed Big Grin

It cuts both ways, it's not a blue or red thing so wind your neck in a little.  Quite the opposite in fact, as an example the Lib Dems would have their share of votes much more reflected than they currently do.  The argument is against both Labour & Tory, which is probably why it will never happen.

And for the record I didn't vote for Corbyn, but I would have been happy with a hung parliament, which is what "one person, one vote" proper democracy would have given.  Plenty other countries manage to work alliances of power.

It’s all about winning for some. It doesn’t matter what they have won or even if they know what the prize is in reality. Really the slogan / mantra Get Brexit Done is their I want my prize. Let’s see what that prize actually is before celebrating. 

Our election system is completely flawed and encourages tribalism, this has a place in football but nit in grown up democracy.
Reply
#18
(12-13-2019, 12:43 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(12-13-2019, 11:25 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I would also seriously consider compulsory voting, even if it resulted in cocks on paper winning an overall majority!

If you start a Cocks On Ballot Paper party, one measure you could propose would be any cock drawing on any part of the ballot also counts as a vote for you, whether the cock is in the right box or not. This would only be applied of course if the Cocks got in.

They usually do
Reply
#19
(12-13-2019, 11:06 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(12-13-2019, 09:19 AM)Sotv Wrote: And of course you would have posted this if the result was reversed Big Grin

It cuts both ways, it's not a blue or red thing so wind your neck in a little.  Quite the opposite in fact, as an example the Lib Dems would have their share of votes much more reflected than they currently do.  The argument is against both Labour & Tory, which is probably why it will never happen.

And for the record I didn't vote for Corbyn, but I would have been happy with a hung parliament, which is what "one person, one vote" proper democracy would have given.  Plenty other countries manage to work alliances of power.
FWIW i don't like the FPP system as it makes many votes worthless in most elections. 

 Last nights results are from an election in very unusual circumstances where the old party loyalties have been broken, so it was an exception to that rule but generally it holds true that in traditional safe seats, most votes are "wasted". 

PR would be more democratic but would lead to far more coalitions. In the short term i think we would see the kind of debacle we have recently with parties just out to stymie each other,  but long term i would hope they would figure out how to work together.

One word of warning is that whilst we may see a truer representation of support support for the parties like the lib dems / greens, we would also see that for fringe parties and even extreme ones could gain seats.
Reply
#20
Using a PR basis on the results from yesterday would have given us something like this

Cons     283
Lab       209
SNP        25
LibD       75
DUP         5
SF           4
PC           3
SDLP       2
Green    18
All          3
Brexit    13
UUP        2
York        1

Hung Parliament - Lab, LibDems, SNP, Plaid and Greens (330) force a referendum against the Cons, DUP and Brexit Party (301)
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: