Stoke
#21
Great read that, some good articles The Athletic to be fair to them, didn’t anybody or can somebody copy the recent Kieran Gibbs one they did?

As for Sjoke, just don’t see Michael O’Neill being the answer, sure he’ll be in for Brunty in January

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#22
(12-07-2019, 11:29 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: Stoke is easily where we may have gone without a restructure and Darren Moore,, Shan & Bilic, after the 'Pards' and Williams fiascos. For all the falck aimed at Jenkins and initially Dowling, we seem to be getting it right (fingers crossed). We need to go back up, so Lai can sell on.

To be fair, we shouldn't have gone down with the squad we had, even though it was limited. A manager with nous would have kept us up comfortably. And for all the Pulis flack, some of his signings are close to the heart of what we are now doing as they are good players at this level and could do a job further up (Gibbs, Livermore,Phillips, Barry, Hegazi).

I'm not sure Stoke got that bit right, when you look at the signings they made from us. And that was by two separate managers. When you back then sack managers, and do not move enough players on, you end up with a squad of players unsuited to the tasks. They must have signings form 4/5 managers there. And 3 of them in the last 2 years. They are fast becoming the Birmingham of Terry Cooper then Barry Fry.

We've thrown good money after bad, over and over with each new manager since Hughes. Both Rowett and Jones were allowed to buy whole new teams while the subsequent dip in form and high wages of each previous manager’s players meant there was no way we were going to get rid of them. This has led to us having a ginormous and unhappy squad, liberally sprinkled with deadwood. Wimmer (£18m signing) and Imbula (£18m signing) are both on loan, and it’s believed we’re paying both players’ not insignificant wages.

In some respects while it can sound like an excuse, injuries did play a part in the start of our woes. Whatever anyone thinks of him, Shawcross was a massive player for us, but his back injury finished him as far as the level he used to perform at. Equally, Butland was out for a year and since his return he's not even 50% of the outstanding keeper he was. Bojan was outstanding, got injured and was never the same again  Odemwingie was as good for us as he was for you, got injured and was as good as finished. Glen Johnson was having a great season, got injured and he was done for. All these injuries happened during a two year period.

Then the stupid signings started in an attempt to rebuild, and we were left to rely on the brilliance of Arnie and the one in five genius of Shaqiri. Arnie wanted something better and that was it. The party was over. I'm too tired and peed off to carry on from there right now, but I'm sure you all get the picture.
Reply
#23
(12-07-2019, 11:37 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Great read that, some good articles The Athletic to be fair to them, didn’t anybody or can somebody copy the recent Kieran Gibbs one they did?

As for Sjoke, just don’t see Michael O’Neill being the answer, sure he’ll be in for Brunty in January

Cuzer

I also thought he'd be in for Brunty, but now I'm not so sure. Sounds like too much of a mess now for Brunty to be tempted.
Reply
#24
(12-08-2019, 12:49 AM)Squid Wrote:
(12-07-2019, 11:37 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Great read that, some good articles The Athletic to be fair to them, didn’t anybody or can somebody copy the recent Kieran Gibbs one they did?

As for Sjoke, just don’t see Michael O’Neill being the answer, sure he’ll be in for Brunty in January

Cuzer

I also thought he'd be in for Brunty, but now I'm not so sure. Sounds like too much of a mess now for Brunty to be tempted.

But once we’ve chucked more stupid money at him.....

This is not me casting any doubt or inference on Brunty’s character or motivations (I’m well aware of the respect Albion supporters have for him), just my weary view of the kind of blatant stupidity that I’m convinced will continue at our club until the ridiculous way its run is addressed and heads have rolled.
Reply
#25
(12-07-2019, 10:30 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote:
(12-07-2019, 08:23 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote:
(12-07-2019, 08:11 PM)Squid Wrote:
(12-07-2019, 07:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Can we have a summary Wink

Poor recruitment, poor managerial decisions, poor financial decisions. It's worth reading in full.

Decent read Squid. Esp the Nathan Jones stuff

It's a really fascinating read. I thought about posting it on here a couple of weeks ago but thought I might encounter some 'Is this a Stoke board FFS' style resistance.

Amongst lots of interesting snippets, the bombshell for us was that we could have sold Imbula for a profit a few months after we bought him. At the time that would have gone down like a lead balloon because he looked a really special player. Instead, he's hung around like the deadest of deadweights, helping to pull the club down to the depths we're now encountering.

SW4 - sorry I've not replied sooner. Been to Junior's dance show so couldn't spend time responding fully. The supporters’ view on the decision to allow O'Neill to continue with Northern Ireland was split 50/50 between people who thought it was right to allow it, and people who thought it was a shocking decision. Frankly, from what I can gather about today's performance it's probably best if he spends less time with the players.

It's beginning to dawn on supporters with each defeat that we're now on the wrong side of looking doomed. How we've reached this point is both blindingly obvious and head-scratchingly mystifying at the same time. 

My view is that we now need to accept we’re down, and carry out a complete clearout on the playing side, accepting whatever we can for players like Butland who we've previously held onto in the absence of a big offer. The only one worth demanding big money for is Etebo who the new manager already appears to have got on the wrong side of. There’s no point hoping a couple of good signings will help. These players have no fight and no pride. ‘Rip it up and start again’ should be the new club mantra.

This has to be accompanied by a ruthless cull of the dumbfucks off the pitch who've help cause the collapse of a club who ten years ago were held up as a model of how a smallish Premier League club should be run.

FWIW I don’t think O’Neill is the answer, he’s a manager who has a reputation of getting the best out of a group who are willing to embrace his ideas and work hard, 2 things that your squad have shown to have no interest in doing. 

What’s without a doubt is your need for a total clear out, fortunately you have owners who could afford to write off the £100m they’ve wasted and start over but it’s looking more and more likely that’ll be in League One
Reply
#26
It ain't that simple to have a clear out. These lazy bastards will be on good money and long contracts. Difficult to find new clubs to better these terms for under performing players. Bomb squad comes to mind. Wolves struggled with their relatively small one but Villa loaned out some of theirs or left them languishing with the stiffs taking a big financial hit. FFP I guess makes it harder to manage also
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: