Johnstone
#41
Scott Carson was fucking crap and beaten only in shitness stakes by Paul Crichton and Pascal Zuberbuhler.
Reply
#42
Yes, but far more successful than SJ at the same age.

You have to compare the playing level he was shite at.
The other two were worse than SJ.
Reply
#43
He played one competitive game for England and one match in the Champions League for Liverpool.

I think you must know this logic doesn't hold up, Johnstone's ability is far beyond Carson's ever was. Sitting on the bench in the Champions League and the personal opinion of Steve McClaren doesn't change that.
Reply
#44
(12-05-2019, 08:55 AM)Sliced Wrote: He played one competitive game for England and one match in the Champions League for Liverpool.

I think you must know this logic doesn't hold up, Johnstone's ability is far beyond Carson's ever was. Sitting on the bench in the Champions League and the personal opinion of Steve McClaren doesn't change that.

He played 4 times for England.

I agree totally that Carson was garbage, but played at a far higher level than SJ has so far, so I don't think you can compare them. SJ will be 27 in March, and has only ever played in The Chump. To say he is better than a keeper who had played for his country, won a top European medal, and played 145 games in The Prem (4 full seasons) at the same age is like comparing apples with bananas.
Reply
#45
(12-05-2019, 09:45 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-05-2019, 08:55 AM)Sliced Wrote: He played one competitive game for England and one match in the Champions League for Liverpool.

I think you must know this logic doesn't hold up, Johnstone's ability is far beyond Carson's ever was. Sitting on the bench in the Champions League and the personal opinion of Steve McClaren doesn't change that.

He played 4 times for England.

I agree totally that Carson was garbage, but played at a far higher level than SJ has so far, so I don't think you can compare them. SJ will be 27 in March, and has only ever played in The Chump. To say he is better than a keeper who had played for his country, won a top European medal, and played 145 games in The Prem (4 full seasons) at the same age is like comparing apples with bananas.

Phil Jones has played nearly 10 seasons of PL football, has a league title, domestic honours, a European cup and 20+ caps for his country. Ajayi meanwhile has never played above Champ level, but I know who I’d have in my team.

Carson had a couple of decent seasons and was signed by Liverpool as a player with potential... he received a call up to the England side at a time when we had injuries and every other option had failed... we ended up thinking Joe Hart was capable by comparison shortly after!
Reply
#46
(12-05-2019, 09:45 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-05-2019, 08:55 AM)Sliced Wrote: He played one competitive game for England and one match in the Champions League for Liverpool.

I think you must know this logic doesn't hold up, Johnstone's ability is far beyond Carson's ever was. Sitting on the bench in the Champions League and the personal opinion of Steve McClaren doesn't change that.

He played 4 times for England.

I agree totally that Carson was garbage, but played at a far higher level than SJ has so far, so I don't think you can compare them. SJ will be 27 in March, and has only ever played in The Chump. To say he is better than a keeper who had played for his country, won a top European medal, and played 145 games in The Prem (4 full seasons) at the same age is like comparing apples with bananas.

1 competitive game, 3 friendlies

You say you don't think you can compare them but a few posts ago also said:

"In the past 20 years Foster, Kirkland, Hoult, Alan Miller and even "crisp packet hands" were better English keepers in our team than him."

That's a comparison!
Reply
#47
(12-05-2019, 10:15 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-05-2019, 09:45 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-05-2019, 08:55 AM)Sliced Wrote: He played one competitive game for England and one match in the Champions League for Liverpool.

I think you must know this logic doesn't hold up, Johnstone's ability is far beyond Carson's ever was. Sitting on the bench in the Champions League and the personal opinion of Steve McClaren doesn't change that.

He played 4 times for England.

I agree totally that Carson was garbage, but played at a far higher level than SJ has so far, so I don't think you can compare them. SJ will be 27 in March, and has only ever played in The Chump. To say he is better than a keeper who had played for his country, won a top European medal, and played 145 games in The Prem (4 full seasons) at the same age is like comparing apples with bananas.

1 competitive game, 3 friendlies

You say you don't think you can compare them but a few posts ago also said:

"In the past 20 years Foster, Kirkland, Hoult, Alan Miller and even "crisp packet hands" were better English keepers in our team than him."

That's a comparison!

No Sliced, poor choice of words on my behalf!!

What i'm clumsily trying to say is that CPH was better, because of the higher level. In saying "you can't compare" I mean that a shit keeper in the Prem is better than an average/good one in The Chump (in my opinion).

I know what I mean, anyway  Big Grin Big Grin
Reply
#48
I don’t need stats to tell me that Scott Carson was anything other than a simple-looking, wonky handed waste of £3.5m. Fucking appalling keeper.
Reply
#49
I guess it's just a difference of opinion. I feel much less stressed when opposition players enter the final third now than I was when Carson was in net Big Grin
Reply
#50
(12-05-2019, 12:26 PM)Sliced Wrote: I guess it's just a difference of opinion. I feel much less stressed when opposition players enter the final third now than I was when Carson was in net Big Grin

I feel less stressed now when opposition players enter our half than I did when Carson had possession!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)