The disgusting truth about Hillsborough
#21
[quote pid='126494' dateline='1575128464']
[quote pid='126487' dateline='1575126477']

We know there were a number of issues with the ground and we know there was a late of arrival of fans.  The late arrival is fact, what caused this is open to debate - I would argue there was the usual late arrivals on top of the lateness caused by traffic issues.  This would have exacerbated the issue - were the police aware of the travel disruptions?

I'm also aware fans of previous clubs had had issues at the ground and there was the potential of a crush if the fans weren't filtered through properly and this was a big issue. 

The lies about Liverpool fans kicking the gate down etc. and the newspaper reports based on police lies needed exposing as did the suitability of the ground in general.  It was era of cover-ups and the police (with the support of the state i.e. Thatcher's Government) acted as if they were the law rather than merely implementing the law. I'm not sure we're quite there with the highlighted bit just yet.

I do though think it's wrong to say that the past behaviour of football fans, and Liverpool in particular, didn't have an affect on the decisions made at the time (remember this was only 3 years after Heysel when walls collapsed from crowd surges and pushing and 39 died).  The opening of the gate wouldn't allow more fans in than had tickets (unless we're accepting that fans were trying to jib in) but did result in letting in too many in too quickly.  Once in they should have been funnelled to the sides.  

Decisions were, now clearly incorrectly, made based on this and they decided it was better to let them in than have the chaos that was happening with crowds outside trying to get in for the kick off.  It's said that "On match day, radio and television advised fans without tickets not to attend. Rather than establishing crowd safety as the priority, clubs, local authorities and the police viewed their roles and responsibilities through the 'lens of hooliganism'". 

The 96 innocent died because of the police actions.  My point was that certain police actions on the day would have been mindful of the history of Liverpool fans past behaviour and therefore influence decisions.  

Would they have opened the gate for other fans?  I guess we'll never know.

Yes the police need to take responsibility, as do the FA and the board of Sheffield Wednesday who never did reduce capacity as advised (by the police). 

I suspect that most people who were the hawthorn's that day when the HT announcement was made that there had been crowd disturbances jumped to a conclusion of Liverpool fans causing trouble again.  I did and so did everyone around me.
[/quote]

Have you heard the panicked radio comms. requesting control room to open the gate?
[/quote]

Nope.  I’m aware that the Liverpool fans were climbing over and that the police on the ground were panicking about the crush outside.  

I’m not really sure what your point is.
Reply
#22
(11-30-2019, 12:29 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: The thread earlier about Duckenfield being found not guilty at Hillsborough has, as is synonymous on here, started plenty of anti Liverpool sentiment.
I personally don’t have the vitriol for Liverpool as a club, as all clubs have good and bad fans. They have more idiots than most, but even in the worst clubs the low life still make up a small percentage.
The rest are just normal people, who come from decent families and love their football.
I must admit though until tonight I didn’t know the full story of that day, but a 3 part podcast on the BBC has clarified it.
I’m embarrassed about the gaps in my knowledge.
Fact is the authorities are 100 per cent, indisputable, to blame!
At Hillsborough, Police opened a gate as they hadn’t manned the turnstiles properly which pushed thousands into a pen, where there was terracing spacing in pens on either side. Instead a surge of thousands pushed through the middle into one pen, called pen 3. No ticket less fans to blame, even a little bit, which I did earlier. There was a total lack of policing including only one who some met through the gate who admitted he couldn't do anything as he couldn't speak to anyone as he hadn't a radio.
It was just complete disorganisation.
The tales of normal people, one who said until then he had trusted authority but never again, is powerful as is the tales of dads who went there, with school children the age of mine now and saw their kids die in front of them.
Can you imagine taking your kids to the Albion and them dying in front of you? Please picture this and ask would you be angry and have got over it?
These are accounts from decent people from a different city, not the minority of scally feral scum, who some on here paint a picture of as everything to do with Liverpool FC.
It's worth adding, the vast majority of Liverpool fans have no reason to apologise for Heysel, any more than most on here need to apologise for England fans abroad running amok.
As I said in the earlier thread, I was in Leppings Lane at the 87 semi with the Leeds fans, as my mate got me a ticket to go with him.
That day was also terrifying, the most dangerous situation I've ever found myself in at a match due to the crush and it could have happened then.
In conclusion it was total ineptitude by several authorities, most notably the police, and plenty of lies and collusion leading all the way to government that is the whole story. 
Here's the first episode for those of you who want to listen. https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/p07wch5g 
I guarantee if you do and are any way right you’ll never call them candle lighters again!

Thanks for the link - I’ll take a look later.
Reply
#23
(11-30-2019, 02:41 PM)cornishbaggie Wrote:
(11-30-2019, 01:52 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(11-30-2019, 12:48 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Thatchers government were vile, nothing ridiculous about that. They treated the working class like rats. It was a regime totally lacking compassion or basic human decency.
I agree all clubs had scum fans, and still do, but hooligans, past reputation etc is utter bullshit in the story of Hillsborough.
Tragedies bring great change and 30 years on I believe grounds are far better places, but that’s no comfort to the families of the dead, who have had their lives ruined.

There was already legislation in place to control safety.

The Safety of Sports Grounds Act 1975, introduced under Harold Wilson,  brought about the introduction of the safety certificate.  Local Authorities are responsible for both issuing and enforcing a safety certificate in respect of sports grounds designated by the Secretary of State.   So the relevant local authority issued safety certificates for Hillsborough for 14 years prior to the disaster.

Given previous incidents at Leppings lane, the Local Authority are particularly culpable together with the Police and also the fans who turned up in numbers without tickets with the intent of getting in for nowt.

A myth which was dispelled as far back as 1990, by the Lord Justice Taylor report when he stated categorically that "fans' behaviour played no part in the disaster". And this myth was laid to rest 26 years later at the inquests, which the authorities tried so hard to prevent taking place, when the jury stated The behaviour of Liverpool supporters did not cause or contribute to the dangerous situation at the Leppings Lane turnstiles. And yet the myth persists.

It persists because it's not a myth.  So the thousands of fans outside who caused the crush and were eventually let in all had tickets and behaved impeccably?
Reply
#24
Hopalong I think Cornish’s response re the turnstiles and the inadequacy of the capability to get fans in demonstrate that it’s nothing to do with ticketless fans.
I, as I admit, thought the same as you until yesterday but the documentary proves I am wrong. I’d also like to thank Cornish as it’s his knowledge that put me on the road to finding the answers. I’m humble enough to admit I was wrong, but now know the relevant facts.
Fans in no way were responsible, even if some of them didn’t have tickets.
Small end for bigger club, as in 87, too few turnstiles in operation, failure to delay the match, all this added to the cocktail of this tragedy. The fans involvement didn’t stand up to scrutiny and I suggest you listen and you’ll think the same as me.
Reply
#25
(11-30-2019, 04:24 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: [quote pid='126494' dateline='1575128464']
[quote pid='126487' dateline='1575126477']

We know there were a number of issues with the ground and we know there was a late of arrival of fans.  The late arrival is fact, what caused this is open to debate - I would argue there was the usual late arrivals on top of the lateness caused by traffic issues.  This would have exacerbated the issue - were the police aware of the travel disruptions?

I'm also aware fans of previous clubs had had issues at the ground and there was the potential of a crush if the fans weren't filtered through properly and this was a big issue. 

The lies about Liverpool fans kicking the gate down etc. and the newspaper reports based on police lies needed exposing as did the suitability of the ground in general.  It was era of cover-ups and the police (with the support of the state i.e. Thatcher's Government) acted as if they were the law rather than merely implementing the law. I'm not sure we're quite there with the highlighted bit just yet.

I do though think it's wrong to say that the past behaviour of football fans, and Liverpool in particular, didn't have an affect on the decisions made at the time (remember this was only 3 years after Heysel when walls collapsed from crowd surges and pushing and 39 died).  The opening of the gate wouldn't allow more fans in than had tickets (unless we're accepting that fans were trying to jib in) but did result in letting in too many in too quickly.  Once in they should have been funnelled to the sides.  

Decisions were, now clearly incorrectly, made based on this and they decided it was better to let them in than have the chaos that was happening with crowds outside trying to get in for the kick off.  It's said that "On match day, radio and television advised fans without tickets not to attend. Rather than establishing crowd safety as the priority, clubs, local authorities and the police viewed their roles and responsibilities through the 'lens of hooliganism'". 

The 96 innocent died because of the police actions.  My point was that certain police actions on the day would have been mindful of the history of Liverpool fans past behaviour and therefore influence decisions.  

Would they have opened the gate for other fans?  I guess we'll never know.

Yes the police need to take responsibility, as do the FA and the board of Sheffield Wednesday who never did reduce capacity as advised (by the police). 

I suspect that most people who were the hawthorn's that day when the HT announcement was made that there had been crowd disturbances jumped to a conclusion of Liverpool fans causing trouble again.  I did and so did everyone around me.

Have you heard the panicked radio comms. requesting control room to open the gate?
[/quote]

Nope.  I’m aware that the Liverpool fans were climbing over and that the police on the ground were panicking about the crush outside.  

I’m not really sure what your point is.
[/quote]

You asked a question that i answered.

Due to the crush outside, they would have opened the gate regardless. 

Why was there a crush outside?  Depends on your agenda.  There's a lot of evidence pointing to how and why a bottle neck formed outside the turnstiles and very little to prove that Liverpool fans had no tickets (at this particular match).
Reply
#26
(11-30-2019, 05:59 PM)WWHO Wrote:
(11-30-2019, 04:24 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: [quote pid='126494' dateline='1575128464']
[quote pid='126487' dateline='1575126477']

We know there were a number of issues with the ground and we know there was a late of arrival of fans.  The late arrival is fact, what caused this is open to debate - I would argue there was the usual late arrivals on top of the lateness caused by traffic issues.  This would have exacerbated the issue - were the police aware of the travel disruptions?

I'm also aware fans of previous clubs had had issues at the ground and there was the potential of a crush if the fans weren't filtered through properly and this was a big issue. 

The lies about Liverpool fans kicking the gate down etc. and the newspaper reports based on police lies needed exposing as did the suitability of the ground in general.  It was era of cover-ups and the police (with the support of the state i.e. Thatcher's Government) acted as if they were the law rather than merely implementing the law. I'm not sure we're quite there with the highlighted bit just yet.

I do though think it's wrong to say that the past behaviour of football fans, and Liverpool in particular, didn't have an affect on the decisions made at the time (remember this was only 3 years after Heysel when walls collapsed from crowd surges and pushing and 39 died).  The opening of the gate wouldn't allow more fans in than had tickets (unless we're accepting that fans were trying to jib in) but did result in letting in too many in too quickly.  Once in they should have been funnelled to the sides.  

Decisions were, now clearly incorrectly, made based on this and they decided it was better to let them in than have the chaos that was happening with crowds outside trying to get in for the kick off.  It's said that "On match day, radio and television advised fans without tickets not to attend. Rather than establishing crowd safety as the priority, clubs, local authorities and the police viewed their roles and responsibilities through the 'lens of hooliganism'". 

The 96 innocent died because of the police actions.  My point was that certain police actions on the day would have been mindful of the history of Liverpool fans past behaviour and therefore influence decisions.  

Would they have opened the gate for other fans?  I guess we'll never know.

Yes the police need to take responsibility, as do the FA and the board of Sheffield Wednesday who never did reduce capacity as advised (by the police). 

I suspect that most people who were the hawthorn's that day when the HT announcement was made that there had been crowd disturbances jumped to a conclusion of Liverpool fans causing trouble again.  I did and so did everyone around me.

Have you heard the panicked radio comms. requesting control room to open the gate?

Nope.  I’m aware that the Liverpool fans were climbing over and that the police on the ground were panicking about the crush outside.  

I’m not really sure what your point is.
[/quote]

You asked a question that i answered.

Due to the crush outside, they would have opened the gate regardless. 

Why was there a crush outside?  Depends on your agenda.  There's a lot of evidence pointing to how and why a bottle neck formed outside the turnstiles and very little to prove that Liverpool fans had no tickets (at this particular match).
[/quote]

The crush had a number of factors - late arrival of fans (because of a number of factors), inadequate turnstiles, refusal to delay the kick off, impatient fans and fans climbing over wall into the ground.  It’s the job of the Health & Safety and Police to manage it and they failed, for Health & Safety I would blame Sheff Weds and the FA for not acting on past issues and then awarding the tie to this ground.

The police would have also been aware of what could happen if it kicked off and Liverpool fans had a history of doing so.  This may have been in the coppers mind at the time.

Would those reasons have been applicable to Albion? Not sure, although we all could name the fans of certain clubs that would be more likely to kick off than the Albion and so do the police.  This thought would be factored in when making snap decisions.

For the record I’ve never blamed the fans for what happened.  I also queued and left an Albion shirt at Anfield in the aftermath.  It’s just this picture of Liverpool fans being angels and that the police didn’t need to take into account how they may react that gets some people’s backs up.  The Taylor Report concluded that fan behaviour and drunkenness was secondary and not the reason for the disaster. This viewpoint was later changed in the later inquiries.
Reply
#27
On the sole question of whether the gates would have been opened for other fans, we played Barnsley in the same FA Cup year 1989 and the gates were opened for Barnsley fans when too many of them to cope with turned up at the Victoria Ground. 

The match was drawn and exactly the same thing happened with our fans at the replay. I was at the replay at Barnsley and took the decision to stand with the away fans because I couldn't see us getting in too much before half time. 

Whether at the replay the decision was taken to open the gates because our fans had a reputation, or whether it was just the done thing at the time to open the gates in such circumstances, I've no idea. I know with hindsight, many of our fans felt that we were close to a Hillsborough situation with the number of fans who were crammed into the away end that night.
Reply
#28
Although I sympathise with the OP, I'm afraid I can't agree that the disaster was 100% the fault of the police.
I'm no apologist for the police and I think they can take the lion's share of the blame, but there were other factors involved:
Some of the Liverpool supporters. I'm sorry, but having, on a number of occasions, witnessed the behaviour of Liverpool supporters first hand, I find it impossible to believe that there weren't a faction who came in late, with or without tickets and contributed to the tragedy.
Sheffield Wednesday football club for allowing the inadequate turnstile arrangements.
Every football hooligan in that era, because without those morons, there would be no fences, and without the fences, there would have been no tragedy.
The idiots who decided that immoveable fencing was the way forward.
The rest of us (this is going to be popular!). I remember feeling crushed as the Baggies scored down at the Dell, just after the fences came in and saying to my mate 'One day, people are going to get seriously hurt with this setup'. What did I do? Lobby my MP? Write to the papers? Set up a protest group? No, like everyone else, I meekly accepted that football supporters were seen as second class citizens and allowed myself to be escorted from the station to the ground as one of a group of criminals.
You can allocate the amount of blame wherever you think, but it's too simplistic just to blame the coppers, despite how poorly they reacted on the day.
Reply
#29
(11-30-2019, 08:48 PM)74bus Wrote: Although I sympathise with the OP, I'm afraid I can't agree that the disaster was 100% the fault of the police.
I'm no apologist for the police and I think they can take the lion's share of the blame, but there were other factors involved:
Some of the Liverpool supporters. I'm sorry, but having, on a number of occasions, witnessed the behaviour of Liverpool supporters first hand, I find it impossible to believe that there weren't a faction who came in late, with or without tickets and contributed to the tragedy.
Sheffield Wednesday football club for allowing the inadequate turnstile arrangements.
Every football hooligan in that era, because without those morons, there would be no fences, and without the fences, there would have been no tragedy.
The idiots who decided that immoveable fencing was the way forward.
The rest of us (this is going to be popular!). I remember feeling crushed as the Baggies scored down at the Dell, just after the fences came in and saying to my mate 'One day, people are going to get seriously hurt with this setup'. What did I do? Lobby my MP? Write to the papers? Set up a protest group? No, like everyone else, I meekly accepted that football supporters were seen as second class citizens and allowed myself to be escorted from the station to the ground as one of a group of criminals.
You can allocate the amount of blame wherever you think, but it's too simplistic just to blame the coppers, despite how poorly they reacted on the day.
For me, this sums it up.

Blame for a number of groups, including the Police, but no acknowledgment at all of the contributory negligence of others.

I mentioned in the other thread, the reaction at The Hawthorns that day. If Liverpool weren't to blame that day, there were many other days where the behaviour of their supporters had caused difficulties, and this kind of reputation can come back to haunt you.

The only innocents in my eyes were the people who turned up early, and 96 of these poor souls were crushed to death.
Reply
#30
(11-30-2019, 08:59 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-30-2019, 08:48 PM)74bus Wrote: Although I sympathise with the OP, I'm afraid I can't agree that the disaster was 100% the fault of the police.
I'm no apologist for the police and I think they can take the lion's share of the blame, but there were other factors involved:
Some of the Liverpool supporters. I'm sorry, but having, on a number of occasions, witnessed the behaviour of Liverpool supporters first hand, I find it impossible to believe that there weren't a faction who came in late, with or without tickets and contributed to the tragedy.
Sheffield Wednesday football club for allowing the inadequate turnstile arrangements.
Every football hooligan in that era, because without those morons, there would be no fences, and without the fences, there would have been no tragedy.
The idiots who decided that immoveable fencing was the way forward.
The rest of us (this is going to be popular!). I remember feeling crushed as the Baggies scored down at the Dell, just after the fences came in and saying to my mate 'One day, people are going to get seriously hurt with this setup'. What did I do? Lobby my MP? Write to the papers? Set up a protest group? No, like everyone else, I meekly accepted that football supporters were seen as second class citizens and allowed myself to be escorted from the station to the ground as one of a group of criminals.
You can allocate the amount of blame wherever you think, but it's too simplistic just to blame the coppers, despite how poorly they reacted on the day.
For me, this sums it up.

Blame for a number of groups, including the Police, but no acknowledgment at all of the contributory negligence of others.

I mentioned in the other thread, the reaction at The Hawthorns that day. If Liverpool weren't to blame that day, there were many other days where the behaviour of their supporters had caused difficulties, and this kind of reputation can come back to haunt you.

The only innocents in my eyes were the people who turned up early, and 96 of these poor souls were crushed to death.

And this is what Liverpool and/or their supporters should have acknowledged years ago
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: