11-08-2019, 08:30 PM
(11-08-2019, 08:00 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote:(11-08-2019, 07:40 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(11-08-2019, 11:06 AM)Dreamkiller Wrote:(11-08-2019, 10:56 AM)Mr vertical Wrote: I think the "Midlands" ends with the accent when you head up north DK. Somewhere between Cannock and Stafford - maybe in the Chetwynd Arms itself. They could just as easily lump you boys into Cheshire and nobody would notice
Jeez, Cheshire would never accept us! There are genuinely villages on the North Staffs/South Cheshire border with ST post codes who campaign to have their code changed to a Cheshire one - I presume it adds to their house values.
Overall, we probably like to think we're Northern rather than Midlands, but we're kind of defined by the fact we're covered by Central News and Midlands Today rather than their more northern counterparts.
My experience with Stoke is it doesn’t really know where it is or what it wants to be since the factories closed. I remember the fashion was distinctly Manc circa 1990s before the Oasis bandwagon when I lived there. I think Stokies think it’s more cool / trendy / sick whatever it is now to say they’re northern but Manchester couldn’t give a feck about Stoke and the neither can Brum. In some respects the Black Country is your closest contemporary.
I only mentioned it because of Mr V's comment. The topic of whether we're Northern or Midland crops up every 6 months or so on the Oatcake and dies a death after a couple of pages due to lack of interest. It's not something that vexes us or takes up much of our time thinking about.
As for Birmingham or Manchester giving a feck about us, I'm not really sure why this needed saying other than to get some unnecessary reaction. I'm not aware we've ever sought either of their approvals.
I wasn’t having a go at Stoke it is like the Black Country searching for a post industrial identity which is defined more by its past than present. Which is why I said despite the similar distance to Manchester and Brum (north, midlands) it seems it’s closest / most similar place is the Black Country.



