The Boris plan coming to fruition
#51
(10-30-2019, 07:57 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: EU nationals living here are net contributors to the economy
Thousands of them work in the NHS and Care sectors they aren’t stopping any British person from working in the NHS

Where are you getting your ‘facts’ from? UKIP, anonymous shite on Facebook, the bloke down the pub?
Well you say that.

BRITISH migrants sent £11bn back to foreign nations last year – the same amount as our entire Foreign Aid budget.

https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/585860...tries-year

Polish workers in Britain have sent home £23billion in the past seven years, an official report revealed last night.
The report by Poland’s statistics office revealed that last year migrant workers helped push up the total sent back home to some £3.7billion.
The study also revealed that of the 390,000 Poles thought to be living in the UK around one in five – some 70,000 – are thought to be unemployed.
It would mean British taxpayers are forking out some £4.5million a week in unemployment benefit for migrants.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article...efits.html

EU migrants claimed more than £4 billion in welfare payments in a year.

2018 Data from the Department for Work and Pensions, HMRC and Treasury shows EU workers received more than £2.2billion in tax credits and housing benefits, £1.1billion in out-of-work payments and £700million in child benefit.
Though there is a huge disparity between Western and Eastern European’s,
almost half the personal taxes paid by Eastern European migrants from Poland, Bulgaria, Romania etc. went straight back in tax credits and child benefit. This does not include JSA 
(DWP figures were not broken down by country)

Strangely, we were emphatically told by ministers,before the referendum, that these figures were not available 
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/5776790/eu-migrants-in-britain-claimed-more-than-4bn-of-handouts-in-a-year/

Remain supporters do point to an ‘independent’  2016 study carried out by the UCL which said EU migrants contributed £1.34 to the economy for every £1.00 claimed in benefits. There are grave reservations about the methodology used and even academics in that very institution have debunked the report.
http://civitas.org.uk/press/schoolboy-errors-in-ucl-immigration-report/
Reply
#52
(10-30-2019, 10:03 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-30-2019, 07:57 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: EU nationals living here are net contributors to the economy
Thousands of them work in the NHS and Care sectors they aren’t stopping any British person from working in the NHS

Where are you getting your ‘facts’ from? UKIP, anonymous shite on Facebook, the bloke down the pub?
Well you say that.

BRITISH migrants sent £11bn back to foreign nations last year – the same amount as our entire Foreign Aid budget.

https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/585860...tries-year

Polish workers in Britain have sent home £23billion in the past seven years, an official report revealed last night.
The report by Poland’s statistics office revealed that last year migrant workers helped push up the total sent back home to some £3.7billion.
The study also revealed that of the 390,000 Poles thought to be living in the UK around one in five – some 70,000 – are thought to be unemployed.
It would mean British taxpayers are forking out some £4.5million a week in unemployment benefit for migrants.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article...efits.html

EU migrants claimed more than £4 billion in welfare payments in a year.

2018 Data from the Department for Work and Pensions, HMRC and Treasury shows EU workers received more than £2.2billion in tax credits and housing benefits, £1.1billion in out-of-work payments and £700million in child benefit.
Though there is a huge disparity between Western and Eastern European’s,
almost half the personal taxes paid by Eastern European migrants from Poland, Bulgaria, Romania etc. went straight back in tax credits and child benefit. This does not include JSA 
(DWP figures were not broken down by country)

Strangely, we were emphatically told by ministers,before the referendum, that these figures were not available 
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/5776790/eu-migrants-in-britain-claimed-more-than-4bn-of-handouts-in-a-year/

Remain supporters do point to an ‘independent’  2016 study carried out by the UCL which said EU migrants contributed £1.34 to the economy for every £1.00 claimed in benefits. There are grave reservations about the methodology used and even academics in that very institution have debunked the report.
http://civitas.org.uk/press/schoolboy-errors-in-ucl-immigration-report/

Or...

Full Facts

FT


The Econmist


https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/the-fiscal-impact-of-immigration-in-the-uk/

The Kings Fund impact of migration on NHS

I think my links are a tad more balanced than the Sun, Mail and Express.
Reply
#53
You have linked to articles are dated 2011 and 2015 from the sun and mail ffs. Reading those rags won’t cure your xenophobia.

You don’t have to look far to find more balanced reading... https://www.ft.com/content/797f7b42-bb44...176fbf93f5
Reply
#54
(10-30-2019, 10:36 AM)boingingjim Wrote: I am a capitalist.  I believe in opportunity for all.  I was born in a working class family that saw my mother work two jobs and father on night shifts.  Thatcher and her Grammar school policies at the time enabled me to go and become something I could otherwise never have dreamed of.  I believe in working hard and paying taxes, I believe in people being more able to decided where to spend than Governments, I don't believe in state intervention at a massive scale.

You talk about me being blinded by soundbites and media portrayal, yet you paint Corbyn as being a work class lad from the estates of London. He's as stinking rich as most Tory MP's.  Abbott sends her kids to private school not the comprehensives of her constituency.  

I have no issue with anyone voting Labour, Tory or Libs or even Greens.  People vote for their own reasons, what I can't abide is someone calling me a racist bigot when that is not true.
You pay your tax and benefit from the Government investing in Defence, Police, NHS, Education, Roads, Infrastructure etc etc.   If you don't want the Government spending it for you where would you choose to spend it yourself ?
Reply
#55
(10-30-2019, 10:03 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-30-2019, 07:57 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: EU nationals living here are net contributors to the economy
Thousands of them work in the NHS and Care sectors they aren’t stopping any British person from working in the NHS

Where are you getting your ‘facts’ from? UKIP, anonymous shite on Facebook, the bloke down the pub?
Well you say that.

BRITISH migrants sent £11bn back to foreign nations last year – the same amount as our entire Foreign Aid budget.

https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/585860...tries-year

Polish workers in Britain have sent home £23billion in the past seven years, an official report revealed last night.
The report by Poland’s statistics office revealed that last year migrant workers helped push up the total sent back home to some £3.7billion.
The study also revealed that of the 390,000 Poles thought to be living in the UK around one in five – some 70,000 – are thought to be unemployed.
It would mean British taxpayers are forking out some £4.5million a week in unemployment benefit for migrants.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article...efits.html

EU migrants claimed more than £4 billion in welfare payments in a year.

2018 Data from the Department for Work and Pensions, HMRC and Treasury shows EU workers received more than £2.2billion in tax credits and housing benefits, £1.1billion in out-of-work payments and £700million in child benefit.
Though there is a huge disparity between Western and Eastern European’s,
almost half the personal taxes paid by Eastern European migrants from Poland, Bulgaria, Romania etc. went straight back in tax credits and child benefit. This does not include JSA 
(DWP figures were not broken down by country)

Strangely, we were emphatically told by ministers,before the referendum, that these figures were not available 
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/5776790/eu-migrants-in-britain-claimed-more-than-4bn-of-handouts-in-a-year/

Remain supporters do point to an ‘independent’  2016 study carried out by the UCL which said EU migrants contributed £1.34 to the economy for every £1.00 claimed in benefits. There are grave reservations about the methodology used and even academics in that very institution have debunked the report.
http://civitas.org.uk/press/schoolboy-errors-in-ucl-immigration-report/

Ever feel that you've been had JOK? I can understand your points on governance and concern over the future vision of the EU and can see why that would have an impact on your thought process, but choosing to link to rags that come with an agenda shows how dangerous the whole debate has been. You are an intelligent bloke; getting your information from those publications is beneath you.
Reply
#56
(10-29-2019, 10:21 PM)billybassett Wrote: No surprise with the lack of decent opposition that Boris's plan to grasp power in this country is finally on the glidepath.

When the bigots and the racists give him the majority he craves god help this country.

Or people who want brexit to be delivered
Reply
#57
(11-06-2019, 08:59 AM)Albionbaggie2019 Wrote:
(10-29-2019, 10:21 PM)billybassett Wrote: No surprise with the lack of decent opposition that Boris's plan to grasp power in this country is finally on the glidepath.

When the bigots and the racists give him the majority he craves god help this country.

Or people who want brexit to be delivered

This is the worrying thing about this coming GE - the electorate will be focusing on Brexit when really it's the party manifestos we should be scrutinising.  

We've suffered 9 years of austerity that has seen all services cut back. Social service cuts resulting in an increase in mental health problems, visibly noticeable rises in homeless on the streets and anti-social behaviour. Fire services cut, police services cut, armed forces ill-equipped, school budgets cut, Border Agency underresourced and roads poorly maintained. And then, of course, there's the NHS. Not sure how much more streamlined you want it, boingingjim, but I think travelling 30 minutes to my nearest A&E followed by a wait of heaven knows how many hours to get seen is streamlined enough, thanks.

I'm really concerned by the prospect of another 5 years of Tory government.
Reply
#58
You lot must have amnesia under labour I remember the hospitals filthy the way you lot are going on you think labour was handing out houses and cash like it was going out of fashion .....
These lot didnt get hold of the banks and let people borrow as much as they want without a care in the world and when it all went tits up the tories had to get it in hand with shit consequences that's what you get with out regulation .....they let the lunatics take over the asylum ......that's labour for you and I forgot about Brown selling off our gold reserves .....tories are shot labour are worse .
Reply
#59
The big step change in deregulation of the financial sector - the so-called 'Big Bang' - took place under Thatcher in 1986.

Here...

"The 2007-2012 global financial crisis was an unintended consequence of the 'Big Bang'" - Nigel Lawson, Chancellor of the Exchequer 1983-1989. 

You could possibly criticise Labour for not reversing some of that deregulation, but to suggest that it's all down to them is just nonsense.
Reply
#60
(11-06-2019, 04:52 PM)The liquidator Wrote: You lot must have amnesia under labour I remember the hospitals filthy the way you lot are going on you think labour was handing out houses and cash like it was going out of fashion .....
These lot didnt get hold of the banks and let people borrow as much as they want without a care in the world and when it all went tits up the tories had to get it in hand with shit consequences that's what you get with out regulation .....they let the lunatics take over the asylum ......that's labour for you and I forgot about Brown selling off our gold reserves .....tories are shot labour are worse .

The NHS had the highest approval ratings and shortest waiting times for many years. Things were not perfect, PFI was an awful scheme for example but they are better than they are now. 

The Tories lobbied for even less regulation on the financial sector. This is an inconvenient truth that some like to erase from memory. Do you really think a Conservative government would have stood on a manifesto of more regulation on the City?  

I think it’s your good self that is suffering from amnesia if you go to AE now you might just get seen by around 9-10pm tonight on average.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: