So where are we then
#31
(10-28-2019, 08:06 AM)strawman Wrote:
(10-27-2019, 07:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-27-2019, 07:33 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-27-2019, 07:14 PM)Ossian Wrote: Serious question: does anybody know exactly how our borders become more secure if we leave the EU? We're not part of Schengen; passports have to be shown on departure (even from another EU country) and again on arrival; under a reciprocal EU arrangement (one which will presumably disappear post-Brexit) we presently have a customs, immigration and border force presence in both Belgium and France.

What will the new arrangement be? And how will it be 'more secure'?

Surely it must depend on the terms. There's so much uncertainty still. I don't think anyone really knows what anything will look like.

Brexiteers know / knew what they were voting for! Believe!!!!

Actually those that voted leave did not vote for something, they voted against it – 

They voted against the possibility of an ever more centralised Europe where the UK becomes a state of the European federation.

The Lisbon treaty removed a number of UK vetoes and made changes to QMV without reference to the UK electorate. They voted against the push for the removal of even more vetoes which could once again happen without reference to the people.

They voted against the discriminatory FOM of a club (not a country) and in favour of equal opportunity by visa for the peoples of all the worlds countries.

They voted against “ever closer union” 

They voted against the principal of “supremacy of EU law”  (look it up) and for the supremacy of laws made by our own elected representatives.

They voted against an institution that has never had a non-white commissioner and where it's own politicians have said “If you want to see diversity in the EU look at the faces of the cleaners not the EU Parliament”.

And many voted against because of people like you patronising, bigoted, ageist and demeaning of those that disagree with you. You are the boards Trump.

Sometimes the unknown has less fear than remaining in a relationship that becomes increasingly resentful and uncooperative. But they will attempt to stay in some kind of relationship because of, at least, some shared values.

So it was the remainers that voted for something. So pray tell us what exactly you voted for, because if it was the status quo, there is none. Did you vote for the possibility of losing more vetoes, ever closer union, more countries joining for their vision a European Empire. 

Go on outline exactly what you voted for, because as you have no idea whet will happen to the EU in 5, 10 or 20 years, you too have voted for the unknown. Believe!

Of course 17.4m voted for those reasons. 

I voted to stay in because the E.U. had made it easier to travel across Europe 
It had made it easy to work with people across the EU which as our closest neighbours makes perfect sense.
I had / have no problem with being part of Europe politically, socially and economically rather than an island on the outskirts looking in. I have no problem with more integration with the E.U. because despite its problems it’s values are still better than most.
I have had no problems working, or living in the E.U. and sorry the unknowns of leaving on balance seem like we get the booby prize. 
I voted for the UK to actually be a driving force in the UK and add balance to the E.U. rather than take our ball back saying it’s not fair. 
I voted for my family to not suffer the adverse economic consequences of Brexit that even this government seems to have admitted will be a fact not project fear. 
I voted not to be on the same side of history as the EDL, the ERG, Leave.EU, UKIP, Farage, Johnson, Mogg, Gove, Raab, Patel, The Daily Mail, the Sun etc
I voted to stay in the EU as the biggest lies told were those that the UK didn’t have any sovereignty anymore and we were completely beholden to their laws when in fact the last three years has proved that to be complete bobbins.

I didn’t vote to make it more difficult to work in the E.U. 
I didn’t vote for something that may take up to 50yrs to see any tangible benefits of according to some leading Brexiteers like Mogg.
I didn’t vote because there are too many foreigners over here doing jobs I don’t and won’t do
I didn’t vote for a economically damaging hard Brexit 
I didn’t vote for a freedom of movement based entirely on someone’s worth only judged on earning potential. 
I didn’t vote leave in protest at the ‘elite’ the definition of which changes every day depending upon who this government and Brexiteers want to blame for their mess. 
I didn’t vote leave because of austerity cuts which many did

Call me all the names under the sun it’s all you have left, there are no sunlit uplands mentioned anymore. Also please link me to those bigoted views I have displayed on here... oh and saying the older generation (baby boom generation and of course not all) have let the younger generations down is not ageist just a fact given the lack of affordable housing, job uncertainty etc which has happened under there stewardship of the country.
Reply
#32
The notion of a member state - particularly one as vocal and powerful as the UK - being simply told to jump and responding with "Certainly, how high?" is one of the most over-used fallacies in this whole process; Leave's very own version of project fear. We have exercised plenty of opt-outs - The Euro, Schengen, Tax and Social Security harmonisation - there's three pretty substantial ones to be going on with. It's one of the reasons why members who are like-minded but lacking the clout are sorry to see us going.

Another fallacy is the idea that we - a post-industrial economy with a population heading for 70 million - can become some kind of deregulated, low tax haven - like an offshore Luxembourg, only bigger.

I voted remain because the balance of arguments for doing so easily trumped the hypotheticals being promoted by the leave campaign; many of which have already been dismantled. A list of things some people don't like at the moment, plus a supplementary worst-case list of other things which others might want to happen in the future, is nowhere near enough.

My life is actually pretty okay: if I'm going to vote for change the reasons would need to be absolutely compelling. They aren't.
Reply
#33
(10-28-2019, 09:41 AM)Ossian Wrote: The notion of a member state - particularly one as vocal and powerful as the UK - being simply told to jump and responding with "Certainly, how high?" is one of the most over-used fallacies in this whole process; Leave's very own version of project fear. We have exercised plenty of opt-outs - The Euro, Schengen, Tax and Social Security harmonisation - there's three pretty substantial ones to be going on with. It's one of the reasons why members who are like-minded but lacking the clout are sorry to see us going.

Another fallacy is the idea that we - a post-industrial economy with a population heading for 70 million - can become some kind of deregulated, low tax haven - like an offshore Luxembourg, only bigger.

I voted remain because the balance of arguments for doing so easily trumped the hypotheticals being promoted by the leave campaign; many of which have already been dismantled. A list of things some people don't like at the moment, plus a supplementary worst-case list of other things which others might want to happen in the future, is nowhere near enough.

My life is actually pretty okay: if I'm not going to vote for change the reasons would need to be absolutely compelling. They aren't.

Completely agree and slightly more eloquently put than my list Wink
Reply
#34
A lot of the more cogent arguments for Brexit seem to ride on the assumption that people share common values and interests by dint of having been born on the same island. I don't prescribe to this and barely regard the Johnson's and Rees-Mogg's of the world to be the same species as me. They certainly don't have my best interests at heart just because we both happen to be British.

I'm all for ever close union with our European neighbours as I regard myself as having more in common with French/German/Polish/Romanian workers than the Conservative government

I think the fact the we never had our republican revolution has led to something of a 'cap doffing' mentality amongst some of the working class even today, leading to Conservative governments looking out for the wealthy and the privileged alone. I think that although this is to their detriment, they accept it as it allows them to continue the idea of English (and it is mostly English) exceptionalism ie that England and it's citizens are somehow inherently superior to other European nations. When looked at practically and without emotion, closer union with Europe has only and can only benefit the working class of this country if they could see that Klaus the plumber and Claude the brickie are "their people", not Boris the banker and his ilk.
Reply
#35
Ah well another £7bn sacrificed: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/201...say-lords/

All worth it though m'lud...
Reply
#36
(10-28-2019, 12:22 PM)billybassett Wrote: Ah well another £7bn sacrificed: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/201...say-lords/

All worth it though m'lud...

You can add £100m on advertising we would definitely be leaving on the 31st of October...
Reply
#37
(10-28-2019, 12:22 PM)billybassett Wrote: Ah well another £7bn sacrificed: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/201...say-lords/

All worth it though m'lud...

Does this give us an indication of the trade deals we are likely to negotiate?
Reply
#38
(10-28-2019, 01:44 PM)sickParrot Wrote:
(10-28-2019, 12:22 PM)billybassett Wrote: Ah well another £7bn sacrificed: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/201...say-lords/

All worth it though m'lud...

Does this give us an indication of the trade deals we are likely to negotiate?

Well we've only rolled over deals for about 8% of our total trade so far...
Reply
#39
NHS nothing to see here...

In safe hands
Reply
#40
Project fear Dekka, and the wankers will keep saying that until it's too late. At that point they'll all just disappear (a la Cameron) for someone else to claen up the mess.

For the Brexiteers on here, do you genuinely believe that we are going to complete this great deal with the US pharmaceuticals that means we will pay less for our drugs?

The only benefit I can see to all of this is that I can spend the next decade continuing to be a miserable old cunt saying 'I TOLD YOU SO!!'
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)