Talksport
#11
(10-28-2019, 07:56 AM)Peachy Wrote: My understanding is that the permenant deal is only binding should promotion be achieved. Is this not right?

If not then I'd say get him signed up pronto. From what I've seen and comparing him to others he's a £25m player all day long.

Great bit of negotiating business by Dowling and co.

I understand the argument not to waste this season's budget on him if the deal is water tight but contracts and agreements in football have a habit of being a bit flaky. The way his seasons going he could easily get his head turned by a "big" club and at the least it could disrupt him with his agent getting a lob on and seeing cash signs.

Promotion doesn’t come into the agreement, even though it’s watertight, Pereira can still say no so I’d be inclined to get it done in Jan, his form isn’t going unnoticed by others

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#12
(10-28-2019, 08:02 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'd he plays x amount of games or we get promoted.

There is no way out, however a team can buy him straight from us if they want to.

Correct.  When two clubs agree an option to buy, the player has to concept to the terms of that option. That’s what other posters are missing.  Without the player being tied into the option deal the option between the clubs would be worthless as the player could torpedo it being exercised.  

A wage deal will already have been agreed with the player for when the option is exercised, one wage if we win promotion and another wage if we are still in the Championship next year (and in my view we’d be quite likely to sell him for around £25m to a PL club if we don’t go up).
Reply
#13
(10-28-2019, 09:18 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-28-2019, 08:02 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'd he plays x amount of games or we get promoted.

There is no way out, however a team can buy him straight from us if they want to.

Correct.  When two clubs agree an option to buy, the player has to concept to the terms of that option. That’s what other posters are missing.  Without the player being tied into the option deal the option between the clubs would be worthless as the player could torpedo it being exercised.  

A wage deal will already have been agreed with the player for when the option is exercised, one wage if we win promotion and another wage if we are still in the Championship next year (and in my view we’d be quite likely to sell him for around £25m to a PL club if we don’t go up).

Surely the agreement is with the club, not the player?

He almost certainly has agreed in principle, but I don't think he's signed anything because he can't - he's signed to another club.  I thought pre-contract agreements were only allowed in very specific circumstances to do with the time remaining on a contract? If he wants to play for someone else, he can. Until he signs a contract with us.

I take your point about the torpedo, though. Although I would say it's not completely worthless because it takes the selling club out of the equation and ensures the player was happy with the contract at the time of the loan agreement.

I could be wrong though, maybe making these type of pre-contract agreements are acceptable if the selling club consents to the player signing them.
Reply
#14
(10-28-2019, 09:41 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(10-28-2019, 09:18 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-28-2019, 08:02 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'd he plays x amount of games or we get promoted.

There is no way out, however a team can buy him straight from us if they want to.

Correct.  When two clubs agree an option to buy, the player has to concept to the terms of that option. That’s what other posters are missing.  Without the player being tied into the option deal the option between the clubs would be worthless as the player could torpedo it being exercised.  

A wage deal will already have been agreed with the player for when the option is exercised, one wage if we win promotion and another wage if we are still in the Championship next year (and in my view we’d be quite likely to sell him for around £25m to a PL club if we don’t go up).

Surely the agreement is with the club, not the player?

He almost certainly has agreed in principle, but I don't think he's signed anything because he can't - he's signed to another club.  I thought pre-contract agreements were only allowed in very specific circumstances to do with the time remaining on a contract? If he wants to play for someone else, he can. Until he signs a contract with us.

I take your point about the torpedo, though. Although I would say it's not completely worthless because it takes the selling club out of the equation and ensures the player was happy with the contract at the time of the loan agreement.

I could be wrong though, maybe making these type of pre-contract agreements are acceptable if the selling club consents to the player signing them.

The option agreement has to be with both club and player.  If it was solely with the clubs then it would be worthless as the player could block the move.  In that agreement the player would sign a conditional wage agreement - which only kicks in if the option agreement is exercised by us. He will only have signed a conditional wage agreement and that’s fine as it is ineffective until he becomes our player, and that is out of his control.  

That’s how these “option to buy” agreements work. In fact, it’s the only work that they can work in practice without agents scuppering them.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: