Posts: 1,906
Threads: 31
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(10-21-2019, 07:18 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (10-21-2019, 07:58 AM)Statto Wrote: (10-20-2019, 07:27 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Good saves yesterday, saw the brief highlights on Quest.
I would like to see him pushing the ball to safety more. He has a tendency to push the ball back into play, rather than safety, but that is nit picking.
Out of all your criticisms of Johnstone, this is literally your most ridiculous.
He is excellent at ensuring his saves go well out of the danger area. The only rebound I can recall being scored this season was the fumble against Blackburn. Numerous shots have been propelled well clear of danger.
Good to hear him getting his name sung to to the rafters at FT on Saturday.
0.30 and 1.36. They should have scored 2 goals there, after good saves.
One was hammered at him from about five yards away and the other was pushed wide of goal. Couldn't have done any more with either.
"Saves in Top 2 Tiers (2019/20)
41 - SAM JOHNSTONE
40 - Bartosz Bialkowski
36 - George Long
35 - Kelle Roos
34 - Berndt Leno, Freddy Woodman
33 - Brice Samba, Daniel Bentley
West Brom's Sam Johnstone has made the most saves of any keeper (Top 2 Leagues)"
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
10-23-2019, 01:52 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-23-2019, 02:03 AM by Kit Kat Chunky.)
He was great tonight.
Let one in on his near post, from an admittedly good header, when the defence should have protected him. Clawing at thin air.
Second one was a very good shot, but at a savable height, when he was positioned too far to his left. A full stretch save didn't cover his posts. I doubt a Chump keeper would have saved it, but a Prem Keeper would be closer at that height, and from that distance. It wasn't "top corner". A Chump goal. He had no right to save either, and no blame attaches, but his feet were in treacle. How about that mess when Barnsley hit the bar in the second half, when Woodrow should have completed his hat-trick? Was that good? Why was he flapping like a seal?
We played out from the back at times, and this was a good time to do it. Don't play out against a high press, do it when the opposition are sitting deep. I get it. Fuck me, he played the Centre Halves into trouble on more than one occasion, by giving them them the ball when they were facing him, with players on their back.
I fear if we don't get promoted then we are stuck with him. If we do get promoted, we should do like The Seals have done, and sign someone who is actually reliable and competent. Tom Heaton or Johnstone - who would you rather have? He is 27 in March, for FFS. Foster played for England when he was 24 last cap at 31. SJ isn't a young inexperienced keeper any more.
I don't blame him for the goals tonight, but as Clint Eastwood once said "A man has to know his limitations"; and Sam has plenty.
By contrast, Bradley Collins in the Barnsley goal is 22 years old. Yes he has limitations. He isn't a classy keeper, and didn't make any "worldies". He only conceded 2 goals tonight though, came through the Chelsea Academy, and cost Barnsley nothing.
Posts: 1,060
Threads: 13
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
So not blame attaches’ tonight, yet your post insinuates quite the opposite. If Johnstone had conceded the goals Collins did tonight, you would have slaughtered him.
Johnstone did little wrong tonight and yet certain posters are still looking to blame him for every goal conceded.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(10-23-2019, 02:35 AM)Everything Zin Wrote: So not blame attaches’ tonight, yet your post insinuates quite the opposite. If Johnstone had conceded the goals Collins did tonight, you would have slaughtered him.
Johnstone did little wrong tonight and yet certain posters are still looking to blame him for every goal conceded.
I dont blame him at all.
If your agenda is to blame him and boo him then carry on. I supported him all game, and clapped the team off the pitch.
How about you?
Posts: 1,060
Threads: 13
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
Try reading my post.
You don’t blame him at all?
‘Let one in at the near post....clutching at air’
‘He was positioned too far to his left’’
‘His feet were in treacle’
‘Flapping like a seal’
‘We are stuck with him’
‘We should sign someone who is competent and reliable’.
Sounds like a lot of blame (by you) to me.
Please tell me where in my post I attached any blame to Johnstone. And no, I didn’t boo any players at any point during the match - I never have and it would be rather pointless from 5000 miles away.
Posts: 167
Threads: 7
Joined: Apr 2019
Reputation:
4
10-23-2019, 07:17 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-23-2019, 07:20 AM by OmarLittle.)
(10-23-2019, 01:52 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: He was great tonight.
Let one in on his near post, from an admittedly good header, when the defence should have protected him. Clawing at thin air.
Second one was a very good shot, but at a savable height, when he was positioned too far to his left. A full stretch save didn't cover his posts. I doubt a Chump keeper would have saved it, but a Prem Keeper would be closer at that height, and from that distance. It wasn't "top corner". A Chump goal. He had no right to save either, and no blame attaches, but his feet were in treacle. How about that mess when Barnsley hit the bar in the second half, when Woodrow should have completed his hat-trick? Was that good? Why was he flapping like a seal?
We played out from the back at times, and this was a good time to do it. Don't play out against a high press, do it when the opposition are sitting deep. I get it. Fuck me, he played the Centre Halves into trouble on more than one occasion, by giving them them the ball when they were facing him, with players on their back.
I fear if we don't get promoted then we are stuck with him. If we do get promoted, we should do like The Seals have done, and sign someone who is actually reliable and competent. Tom Heaton or Johnstone - who would you rather have? He is 27 in March, for FFS. Foster played for England when he was 24 last cap at 31. SJ isn't a young inexperienced keeper any more.
I don't blame him for the goals tonight, but as Clint Eastwood once said "A man has to know his limitations"; and Sam has plenty.
By contrast, Bradley Collins in the Barnsley goal is 22 years old. Yes he has limitations. He isn't a classy keeper, and didn't make any "worldies". He only conceded 2 goals tonight though, came through the Chelsea Academy, and cost Barnsley nothing.
Moronic post, yet again.
I won’t attempt to unpick all of it, but a couple of things stand out;
He wasn’t beaten at his near post for the first goal, Woodrow was relatively central and headed back the way it’d come from which is exactly what you’re supposed to do to make it harder for ‘keepers.
Secondly the Barnsley ‘keeper was quite clearly at fault for the equaliser, but you appear to have missed that as you were probably focussing on Johnstone being half a yard too advanced at the other end.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
10-23-2019, 07:28 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-23-2019, 07:37 AM by CA Baggie.)
(10-21-2019, 12:30 PM)billybassett Wrote: (10-21-2019, 07:49 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: (10-21-2019, 07:15 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(10-20-2019, 08:36 AM)HeathAyIt Wrote: He's a very decent keeper at this level and was a good buy at the age and price. That is basically that.
Can't agree with that. £8m for a championship keeper. That's a bloody expensive keeper especially when you've not got a striker. Is he worth £8m still? Doubt it and whilst Bilic's formation and style means he can concentrate on just doing his job rather than assisting goals he's got a long way to go in terms of consistency to be worth that price tag. The past 3 games have showed that he's knuckling down and earning his corn. Let's see where he is at the end of the season.
I thought it was £5m?
In the world of football that’s absolute peanuts - you can’t beat him with any other areas of the team we may or may not have improved upon. A ridiculous argument.
We also had JRod & Gayle upfront last season.
Seemed to me he’s at his best when it’s instinctive, less so when he has to think about it, but some of that will be experience. I don’t see a glut of keepers who are better at this level...
It's not a ridiculous argument at all. He's the 7th most expensive English goalkeeper ever. The most expensive Championship goalkeeper ever. £7.4m I think with more payments possibly due. So it's obviously not peanuts for a goalkeeper at our level. What is peanuts is £1.5m for Ajeti or 3 for Sawyers.
I'm not saying he won't be worth it but the last 12 months has been a tough one and he's made a number of mistakes - some of his own making some of the team's making. I hope he keeps the next 15 clean sheets and gets an England cap. But he's got a level to go before he pays that transfer fee back
Have you deliberately misconstrued my point to back track?
It’s a ridiculous argument in that:
1. He didn’t set the fee;
2. It isn’t £8m anyway; and the most ridiculous part
3. It’s not his fault we didn’t sign a striker!
He’s not Ben Foster, but he’s no Crichton either.
(10-23-2019, 01:52 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: He was great tonight.
Let one in on his near post, from an admittedly good header, when the defence should have protected him. Clawing at thin air.
Second one was a very good shot, but at a savable height, when he was positioned too far to his left. A full stretch save didn't cover his posts. I doubt a Chump keeper would have saved it, but a Prem Keeper would be closer at that height, and from that distance. It wasn't "top corner". A Chump goal. He had no right to save either, and no blame attaches, but his feet were in treacle. How about that mess when Barnsley hit the bar in the second half, when Woodrow should have completed his hat-trick? Was that good? Why was he flapping like a seal?
We played out from the back at times, and this was a good time to do it. Don't play out against a high press, do it when the opposition are sitting deep. I get it. Fuck me, he played the Centre Halves into trouble on more than one occasion, by giving them them the ball when they were facing him, with players on their back.
I fear if we don't get promoted then we are stuck with him. If we do get promoted, we should do like The Seals have done, and sign someone who is actually reliable and competent. Tom Heaton or Johnstone - who would you rather have? He is 27 in March, for FFS. Foster played for England when he was 24 last cap at 31. SJ isn't a young inexperienced keeper any more.
I don't blame him for the goals tonight, but as Clint Eastwood once said "A man has to know his limitations"; and Sam has plenty.
By contrast, Bradley Collins in the Barnsley goal is 22 years old. Yes he has limitations. He isn't a classy keeper, and didn't make any "worldies". He only conceded 2 goals tonight though, came through the Chelsea Academy, and cost Barnsley nothing. This post has no relevance to my point...
You do get all Minstrel, nay menstrual, over this. Not blaming him and then listing all the reasons why you thought he was at fault!
Maybe you need to go out and buy some tyres to calm yourself down a little.
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(10-23-2019, 01:52 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: He was great tonight.
Let one in on his near post, from an admittedly good header, when the defence should have protected him. Clawing at thin air.
Second one was a very good shot, but at a savable height, when he was positioned too far to his left. A full stretch save didn't cover his posts. I doubt a Chump keeper would have saved it, but a Prem Keeper would be closer at that height, and from that distance. It wasn't "top corner". A Chump goal. He had no right to save either, and no blame attaches, but his feet were in treacle. How about that mess when Barnsley hit the bar in the second half, when Woodrow should have completed his hat-trick? Was that good? Why was he flapping like a seal?
We played out from the back at times, and this was a good time to do it. Don't play out against a high press, do it when the opposition are sitting deep. I get it. Fuck me, he played the Centre Halves into trouble on more than one occasion, by giving them them the ball when they were facing him, with players on their back.
I fear if we don't get promoted then we are stuck with him. If we do get promoted, we should do like The Seals have done, and sign someone who is actually reliable and competent. Tom Heaton or Johnstone - who would you rather have? He is 27 in March, for FFS. Foster played for England when he was 24 last cap at 31. SJ isn't a young inexperienced keeper any more.
I don't blame him for the goals tonight, but as Clint Eastwood once said "A man has to know his limitations"; and Sam has plenty.
By contrast, Bradley Collins in the Barnsley goal is 22 years old. Yes he has limitations. He isn't a classy keeper, and didn't make any "worldies". He only conceded 2 goals tonight though, came through the Chelsea Academy, and cost Barnsley nothing.
Fuck’s sake minstrel.
Did he run over your hamster or something?
Posts: 1,906
Threads: 31
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(10-23-2019, 01:52 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: He was great tonight.
Let one in on his near post, from an admittedly good header, when the defence should have protected him. Clawing at thin air.
Second one was a very good shot, but at a savable height, when he was positioned too far to his left. A full stretch save didn't cover his posts. I doubt a Chump keeper would have saved it, but a Prem Keeper would be closer at that height, and from that distance. It wasn't "top corner". A Chump goal. He had no right to save either, and no blame attaches, but his feet were in treacle. How about that mess when Barnsley hit the bar in the second half, when Woodrow should have completed his hat-trick? Was that good? Why was he flapping like a seal?
We played out from the back at times, and this was a good time to do it. Don't play out against a high press, do it when the opposition are sitting deep. I get it. Fuck me, he played the Centre Halves into trouble on more than one occasion, by giving them them the ball when they were facing him, with players on their back.
I fear if we don't get promoted then we are stuck with him. If we do get promoted, we should do like The Seals have done, and sign someone who is actually reliable and competent. Tom Heaton or Johnstone - who would you rather have? He is 27 in March, for FFS. Foster played for England when he was 24 last cap at 31. SJ isn't a young inexperienced keeper any more.
I don't blame him for the goals tonight, but as Clint Eastwood once said "A man has to know his limitations"; and Sam has plenty.
By contrast, Bradley Collins in the Barnsley goal is 22 years old. Yes he has limitations. He isn't a classy keeper, and didn't make any "worldies". He only conceded 2 goals tonight though, came through the Chelsea Academy, and cost Barnsley nothing.
Drivel, from start to finish.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
10-23-2019, 08:58 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-23-2019, 09:00 AM by MassDebater.)
'Alex Mowatt then cut in from the left before playing a square pass across to Woodrow, who unleashed a well-struck low left-foot shot just inside Sam Johnstone's right upright from 25 yards.'
Is how the BBC describe their second. Sounds very much like one of those that sometimes keepers will get to, but mostly they won't. If they do they're amazing, if they don't everyone goes 'bugger', but doesn't blame the keeper unduly, except on here, obviously!
|