New deal
#11
(10-17-2019, 12:55 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 12:41 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 10:49 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: The ONLY was out of this impasse is with a confirmatory vote whether people like it or not.

Agreed.

It wouldn't be pretty, though.

Uglier than it's been?  Confused
Uglier than Arlene Foster?
Reply
#12
So, assuming my numbers are correct:

There are 288 Tories, so lets assume they all vote with the government (although a few have indicated they might be influenced by the DUP)

There are 244 Labour, and even if Corbyn whips them there's no guarantee a handful of them won't defy the whips.
Then 10 DUP who seem to be definitely in the 'No' camp
Plus 19 Lib Dems, probably solidly against; 35 SNP similarly disposed; 4 Plaid Cymru; 1 Green; 5 Independent Group for Change

That potentially makes 288 for/318 against, but with the likelihood that Corbyn will lose more from his total than the government will from theirs; so that gap will probably close. And the Independent Group for Change might vote for the deal this time.


Then there are 36 other 'independents', some of whom are Tories who have had their whip removed but might still vote with the government. The remaining 8 (to make up the 650) are the 7 non-voting absentees (Sinn Fein) plus The Speaker.

Looks like it's going to be a very close call.

Edit: I haven't even contemplated the possibility of abstentions


I really could do with getting a life
Reply
#13
Juncker has inadvertently just made passing the bill harder - he has said that there is no need for an extension now a deal is there. I'm not certain if that is a direct quote, the BBC is saying he is ruling out an extension, but if that is the case then the hardliners who want no-deal could see this as a way to ensure crashing out.

Again it's not clear on what happens if we ask for an extension with a referendum attached but it seems a bit of a killer statement.
Reply
#14
(10-17-2019, 01:33 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Juncker has inadvertently just made passing the bill harder - he has said that there is no need for an extension now a deal is there. I'm not certain if that is a direct quote, the BBC is saying he is ruling out an extension, but if that is the case then the hardliners who want no-deal could see this as a way to ensure crashing out.

Again it's not clear on what happens if we ask for an extension with a referendum attached but it seems a bit of a killer statement.

2 ways of looking at that. You are right that it could persuade the hard-liners who want a no deal to vote against, but it could also persuade some Labour MP's to vote for the deal if they think they are likely to be punished by the electorate for being seen to be a barrier to a deal.

Interesting conundrum for both.
Reply
#15
(10-17-2019, 01:56 PM)strawman Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 01:33 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Juncker has inadvertently just made passing the bill harder - he has said that there is no need for an extension now a deal is there. I'm not certain if that is a direct quote, the BBC is saying he is ruling out an extension, but if that is the case then the hardliners who want no-deal could see this as a way to ensure crashing out.

Again it's not clear on what happens if we ask for an extension with a referendum attached but it seems a bit of a killer statement.

2 ways of looking at that. You are right that it could persuade the hard-liners who want a no deal to vote against, but it could also persuade some Labour MP's to vote for the deal if they think they are likely to be punished by the electorate for being seen to be a barrier to a deal.

Interesting conundrum for both.

Agree - I thought that after I'd posted. Not certain how much of it is politicking and what the EU would do if a referendum was offered with an extension. I do think it means that the deal will get through a vote and he has basically thrown the public under the Boris bus.
Reply
#16
(10-17-2019, 01:59 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 01:56 PM)strawman Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 01:33 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Juncker has inadvertently just made passing the bill harder - he has said that there is no need for an extension now a deal is there. I'm not certain if that is a direct quote, the BBC is saying he is ruling out an extension, but if that is the case then the hardliners who want no-deal could see this as a way to ensure crashing out.

Again it's not clear on what happens if we ask for an extension with a referendum attached but it seems a bit of a killer statement.

2 ways of looking at that. You are right that it could persuade the hard-liners who want a no deal to vote against, but it could also persuade some Labour MP's to vote for the deal if they think they are likely to be punished by the electorate for being seen to be a barrier to a deal.

Interesting conundrum for both.

Agree - I thought that after I'd posted. Not certain how much of it is politicking and what the EU would do if a referendum was offered with an extension. I do think it means that the deal will get through a vote and he has basically thrown the public under the Boris bus.

The numbers aren’t currently there to see it over the line and frankly any Labour MP that backs the deal which gives no protection to workers etc is betraying (war ref ;Wink one if the fundamental pillars of Labours reason to exist. I suspect there will be a removal of the whip for any of them that do so at this critical time.
Reply
#17
At least we will certainly know that the deal shafts the Northern Irish into effectively being part of Eire for ever. Once the Scots have gone back to the EU we can focus on the important things in life as determined by the England and Wales Cricket board.

They are way behind with wanting to introduce 100 balls.  that sounds far too "metric".  They might now want to change it to 144 balls   12-a-side.  Lords a'bowling and a'batting with the peasants fielding.
Reply
#18
(10-17-2019, 05:26 PM)Baggybenny Wrote: At least we will certainly know that the deal shafts the Northern Irish into effectively being part of Eire for ever. Once the Scots have gone back to the EU we can focus on the important things in life as determined by the England and Wales Cricket board.

They are way behind with wanting to introduce 100 balls.  that sounds far too "metric".  They might now want to change it to 144 balls   12-a-side.  Lords a'bowling and a'batting with the peasants fielding.

Trouble in Ireland, Scottish independence and workers rights shafted. Hey but it’s worth it to be out of Europe!
Reply
#19
(10-17-2019, 12:41 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 10:49 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: The ONLY was out of this impasse is with a confirmatory vote whether people like it or not.

Agreed.

It wouldn't be pretty, though.

Remain already rejected in 2016. So assume the vote would be Boris Deal vs No Deal?
Reply
#20
(10-17-2019, 11:08 PM)Big Cyrille Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 12:41 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 10:49 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: The ONLY was out of this impasse is with a confirmatory vote whether people like it or not.

Agreed.

It wouldn't be pretty, though.

Remain already rejected in 2016. So assume the vote would be Boris Deal vs No Deal?

Er no. The amount of lies told during the run up to the referendum should in any normal circumstances made the result null and void. If you or anyone else can say they knew exactly what they were voting for in regards to leaving then I say to them they’re lying.

Here’s the latest poxy deal, a pig with lipstick on just like every deal apart from remain will / would be... £2000 worse off (applause)

When you have Johnson, Cummings, Mogg, Cleverly, Raab, Patel and the Cheese Woman in favour of a deal be afraid be very afraid.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)