The Backstop
#31
(10-17-2019, 10:41 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 08:59 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So basically what you are saying is that it has been pretty good for the UK as part of the EU
No. What Dekka claims is that Racial minorities are better treated and protected within other parts of the Union than in the U.K.  that is clearly and demonstrably not true.
He insisted that mentally and physically disabled within the U.K. are more disadvantaged and have worse provision than in the rest of Europe. Again, proven to be inaccurate.
He claims that the E.U. Is traditionally the embodiment of a caring and enlightened society. Proven to be false with just a few facts.
Again, if the E.U. Is doing so brilliantly at “protecting “ the rights of these groups how come he can slam the treatment of them in one of that Union’s member states, i.e. the U.K.?
The statement  That the EU. is a collection of “ much fairer and kinder societies “ than the U.K. is patently a false and disingenuous statement.

I was responding to your post and Dekka's came afterwards if I can see it right. I'm not saying for one second that the EU is everything to everyman and there are certain areas that really do need improving at a domestic level for the respective countries. 

In response to your list I just highlighted how many of those points had nothing to do with the EU, ironically apart from a couple of positive EU points you made. 

I get that we are obviously in opposite camps but basic logic dictates that the deal that is on the table is not as good as the status quo. If you can point out where we would be better off then I would appreciate it. And please don't go down the route of us being able to negotiate our own deals with other countries - have you been looking at our negotiating skills for the past three years.

I'm also not going to insult you or say you are not entitled to your view, however I would feel a lot more comfortable with the current deal being put to the nation in a referendum. We can then get the measure of how the majority of people see the options. The questions would be simple - 
1. Do you want to leave the EU or Remain as part of the EU? 
2. If you would like to leave the EU would you accept the deal on the table or leave without a deal.
Or something that someone more intelligent than me could articulate
Reply
#32
(10-17-2019, 10:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 10:41 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 08:59 AM)baggy1 Wrote: It sounds like a defence for keeping pulis.




So basically what you are saying is that it has been pretty good for the UK as part of the EU
No. What Dekka claims is that Racial minorities are better treated and protected within other parts of the Union than in the U.K.  that is clearly and demonstrably not true.
He insisted that mentally and physically disabled within the U.K. are more disadvantaged and have worse provision than in the rest of Europe. Again, proven to be inaccurate.
He claims that the E.U. Is traditionally the embodiment of a caring and enlightened society. Proven to be false with just a few facts.
Again, if the E.U. Is doing so brilliantly at “protecting “ the rights of these groups how come he can slam the treatment of them in one of that Union’s member states, i.e. the U.K.?
The statement  That the EU. is a collection of “ much fairer and kinder societies “ than the U.K. is patently a false and disingenuous statement.

I didn’t claim any of those things so don’t blatantly lie.

The argument for Brexit by many is to control our own laws, domestic policies and economic trade deals. However the list of random links you put up show that the UK is in control of many of those things Brexiteers pretend we have no control of (because the EU is an easy / lazy spacegoat) This point is seemingly lost on you and you’re going off half cocked saying I said this and that without a shred of evidence.

My problem with leaving the EU is that it was not hindering us as a country and it acted as a buffer financially and regulatory to the worst excesses of our domestic politics notably this hard right Tory Government who imo will look to low tax, small state, low welfare, low worker rights, broken up NHS, broken Union policies. A race to the bottom for the benefit of the rich few.

I’m not in love with the EU but I recognise that the deal we have with them offers us some economic and social protection from the shysters at home.

Sounds like a defence for keeping pulis in charge
Reply
#33
(10-17-2019, 01:36 PM)The liquidator Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 10:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 10:41 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 08:59 AM)baggy1 Wrote: It sounds like a defence for keeping pulis.




So basically what you are saying is that it has been pretty good for the UK as part of the EU
No. What Dekka claims is that Racial minorities are better treated and protected within other parts of the Union than in the U.K.  that is clearly and demonstrably not true.
He insisted that mentally and physically disabled within the U.K. are more disadvantaged and have worse provision than in the rest of Europe. Again, proven to be inaccurate.
He claims that the E.U. Is traditionally the embodiment of a caring and enlightened society. Proven to be false with just a few facts.
Again, if the E.U. Is doing so brilliantly at “protecting “ the rights of these groups how come he can slam the treatment of them in one of that Union’s member states, i.e. the U.K.?
The statement  That the EU. is a collection of “ much fairer and kinder societies “ than the U.K. is patently a false and disingenuous statement.

I didn’t claim any of those things so don’t blatantly lie.

The argument for Brexit by many is to control our own laws, domestic policies and economic trade deals. However the list of random links you put up show that the UK is in control of many of those things Brexiteers pretend we have no control of (because the EU is an easy / lazy spacegoat) This point is seemingly lost on you and you’re going off half cocked saying I said this and that without a shred of evidence.

My problem with leaving the EU is that it was not hindering us as a country and it acted as a buffer financially and regulatory to the worst excesses of our domestic politics notably this hard right Tory Government who imo will look to low tax, small state, low welfare, low worker rights, broken up NHS, broken Union policies. A race to the bottom for the benefit of the rich few.

I’m not in love with the EU but I recognise that the deal we have with them offers us some economic and social protection from the shysters at home.

Sounds like a defence for keeping pulis in charge


If you think leaving is a good idea I’m very confident that my opinion is the correct one. Wink
Reply
#34
Still waiting to see the terms of the workers rights In black and white that you seem to think that they will take off us ......show us in black and white please ........or should we follow Macron's look how that is working out .
Reply
#35
(10-17-2019, 02:58 PM)The liquidator Wrote: Still waiting to see the terms of the workers rights In black and white that you seem to think that they will take off us ......show us in black and white please ........or should we follow Macron's look how that is working out .

We can’t because there aren’t any the government has effectively said trust us. This is a government that has a proven habitual liar as it’s Prime Minister.

Still waiting for the benefits of leaving btw...
Reply
#36
(10-17-2019, 10:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 10:41 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote: No. What Dekka claims is that Racial minorities are better treated and protected within other parts of the Union than in the U.K.  that is clearly and demonstrably not true.
He insisted that mentally and physically disabled within the U.K. are more disadvantaged and have worse provision than in the rest of Europe. Again, proven to be inaccurate.
He claims that the E.U. Is traditionally the embodiment of a caring and enlightened society. Proven to be false with just a few facts.
Again, if the E.U. Is doing so brilliantly at “protecting “ the rights of these groups how come he can slam the treatment of them in one of that Union’s member states, i.e. the U.K.?
The statement  That the EU. is a collection of “ much fairer and kinder societies “ than the U.K. is patently a false and disingenuous statement.

I didn’t claim any of those things so don’t blatantly lie.
That’s a bit rich, from the person who, basically, libelled me twice in one post. Inventing a sentence I did not write and then expressing views which you claim are mine which in no way represent my opinions or allegiances. Something you have a history of.

So you didn’t say, “Funny how other EU member states manage to have a much fairer, more caring societies.“? When referring to Racism, the disabled and homosexuals? ergo; the U.K. treat those groups worse. I think you’ll find you did. So no “blatant lie” just bald facts.

(10-17-2019, 12:00 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 10:41 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 08:59 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So basically what you are saying is that it has been pretty good for the UK as part of the EU
No. What Dekka claims is that Racial minorities are better treated and protected within other parts of the Union than in the U.K.  that is clearly and demonstrably not true.
He insisted that mentally and physically disabled within the U.K. are more disadvantaged and have worse provision than in the rest of Europe. Again, proven to be inaccurate.
He claims that the E.U. Is traditionally the embodiment of a caring and enlightened society. Proven to be false with just a few facts.
Again, if the E.U. Is doing so brilliantly at “protecting “ the rights of these groups how come he can slam the treatment of them in one of that Union’s member states, i.e. the U.K.?
The statement  That the EU. is a collection of “ much fairer and kinder societies “ than the U.K. is patently a false and disingenuous statement.

I was responding to your post and Dekka's came afterwards if I can see it right. I'm not saying for one second that the EU is everything to everyman and there are certain areas that really do need improving at a domestic level for the respective countries. 

In response to your list I just highlighted how many of those points had nothing to do with the EU, ironically apart from a couple of positive EU points you made. 

I get that we are obviously in opposite camps but basic logic dictates that the deal that is on the table is not as good as the status quo. If you can point out where we would be better off then I would appreciate it. And please don't go down the route of us being able to negotiate our own deals with other countries - have you been looking at our negotiating skills for the past three years.

I'm also not going to insult you or say you are not entitled to your view, however I would feel a lot more comfortable with the current deal being put to the nation in a referendum. We can then get the measure of how the majority of people see the options. The questions would be simple - 
1. Do you want to leave the EU or Remain as part of the EU? 
2. If you would like to leave the EU would you accept the deal on the table or leave without a deal.
Or something that someone more intelligent than me could articulate
I appreciate some things on the list are not totally within the compass of the E.U. I was responding to Dekka’s claim that they will be worse in the U.K. IF we leave. So which is it, does the EU ‘maintain’ rights in those areas and if not, what difference does being in the make and how would the EU prevent their diminution?

The argument for a second referendum is one thing. If I read your questions correctly that may be acceptable but some suggest three questions: Leave with a deal, Leave without, or remain. Which would, in effect, split the leave camp.
Reply
#37
(10-17-2019, 03:55 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 10:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 10:41 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote: No. What Dekka claims is that Racial minorities are better treated and protected within other parts of the Union than in the U.K.  that is clearly and demonstrably not true.
He insisted that mentally and physically disabled within the U.K. are more disadvantaged and have worse provision than in the rest of Europe. Again, proven to be inaccurate.
He claims that the E.U. Is traditionally the embodiment of a caring and enlightened society. Proven to be false with just a few facts.
Again, if the E.U. Is doing so brilliantly at “protecting “ the rights of these groups how come he can slam the treatment of them in one of that Union’s member states, i.e. the U.K.?
The statement  That the EU. is a collection of “ much fairer and kinder societies “ than the U.K. is patently a false and disingenuous statement.

I didn’t claim any of those things so don’t blatantly lie.
That’s a bit rich, from the person who, basically, libelled me twice in one post. Inventing a sentence I did not write and then expressing views which you claim are mine which in no way represent my opinions or allegiances. Something you have a history of.

So you didn’t say, “Funny how other EU member states manage to have a much fairer, more caring societies.“? When referring to Racism, the disabled and homosexuals? ergo; the U.K. treat those groups worse. I think you’ll find you did. So no “blatant lie” just bald facts.

(10-17-2019, 12:00 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 10:41 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 08:59 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So basically what you are saying is that it has been pretty good for the UK as part of the EU
No. What Dekka claims is that Racial minorities are better treated and protected within other parts of the Union than in the U.K.  that is clearly and demonstrably not true.
He insisted that mentally and physically disabled within the U.K. are more disadvantaged and have worse provision than in the rest of Europe. Again, proven to be inaccurate.
He claims that the E.U. Is traditionally the embodiment of a caring and enlightened society. Proven to be false with just a few facts.
Again, if the E.U. Is doing so brilliantly at “protecting “ the rights of these groups how come he can slam the treatment of them in one of that Union’s member states, i.e. the U.K.?
The statement  That the EU. is a collection of “ much fairer and kinder societies “ than the U.K. is patently a false and disingenuous statement.

I was responding to your post and Dekka's came afterwards if I can see it right. I'm not saying for one second that the EU is everything to everyman and there are certain areas that really do need improving at a domestic level for the respective countries. 

In response to your list I just highlighted how many of those points had nothing to do with the EU, ironically apart from a couple of positive EU points you made. 

I get that we are obviously in opposite camps but basic logic dictates that the deal that is on the table is not as good as the status quo. If you can point out where we would be better off then I would appreciate it. And please don't go down the route of us being able to negotiate our own deals with other countries - have you been looking at our negotiating skills for the past three years.

I'm also not going to insult you or say you are not entitled to your view, however I would feel a lot more comfortable with the current deal being put to the nation in a referendum. We can then get the measure of how the majority of people see the options. The questions would be simple - 
1. Do you want to leave the EU or Remain as part of the EU? 
2. If you would like to leave the EU would you accept the deal on the table or leave without a deal.
Or something that someone more intelligent than me could articulate
I appreciate some things on the list are not totally within the compass of the E.U. I was responding to Dekka’s claim that they will be worse in the U.K. IF we leave. So which is it, does the EU ‘maintain’ rights in those areas and if not, what difference does being in the make and how would the EU prevent their diminution?

The argument for a second referendum is one thing. If I read your questions correctly that may be acceptable but some suggest three questions: Leave with a deal, Leave without, or remain. Which would, in effect, split the leave camp.

To clarify...

Europe One

Europe Two

If you believe that this awful, grasping, conniving, power hungry, uncaring, ideologically driven Tory government will adhere to the E.U. standards of protection for its citizens then you’re a far more trusting person than I.
Reply
#38
(10-17-2019, 06:43 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If you believe that this awful, grasping, conniving, power hungry, uncaring, ideologically driven Tory government will adhere to the E.U. standards of protection for its citizens then you’re a far more trusting person than I.

Well, when a grasping, conniving, power hungry, ideologically driven Labour government gets in they can reinstate all protections or even make them even stronger. 

Trouble is you are just distrusting of one set of politicians.
Reply
#39
(10-17-2019, 07:11 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 06:43 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If you believe that this awful, grasping, conniving, power hungry, uncaring, ideologically driven Tory government will adhere to the E.U. standards of protection for its citizens then you’re a far more trusting person than I.

Well, when a grasping, conniving, power hungry, ideologically driven Labour government gets in they can reinstate all protections or even make them even stronger. 

Trouble is you are just distrusting of one set of politicians.

So rights that are consistent and give a minimum of protection to people can be scrapped every five years then reinstated again. Hmm I can’t really see the merit in that... don’t tell me it’s some load of old bollocks about the ever flexible sovereignty.

I’m distrusting an awful government that done immeasurable harm to the country, I’m not the BBC I don’t have to say but Labour and the Lib Dema are bad too, or exhume Farage for a hypocritical rant.
Reply
#40
(10-17-2019, 07:11 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote: Well, when a grasping, conniving, power hungry, ideologically driven Labour government gets in they can reinstate all protections or even make them even stronger. 

Trouble is you are just distrusting of one set of politicians.
John, I don't know whether it was your intention, but you've just described British politics for just about as long as I can remember: two alternating sides of a coin, repeatedly taking it in turns to inflict a different kind of damage; much of it down to the ideological short-termism of their approaches.

The Tories infatuated with their low tax/even lower investment philosophy; Labour then too impatient to rectify the perceived underfunding within a single term. Then they get to shout at each other across the commons: "You fucked up the public finances by overspending", "We had no choice - you'd fucked up everything else by the time you'd left office", "Well we had no choice either - there was no money left from the time before..." 

And so it goes on; and will again. Health, education, transport, energy policy - all (to mangle a quote from Field of Dreams) erased like a blackboard, rebuilt and erased again. But never quite properly finished and allowed to settle before the next ideologue comes along with a new master plan.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)