The Backstop
#21
(10-16-2019, 08:41 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-16-2019, 07:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-16-2019, 02:38 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-16-2019, 09:49 AM)Ossian Wrote:
(10-16-2019, 09:00 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Hampered by MP'S with their own ulterior motives and desire to disrupt any deal possible, the remoaning remoaning twats.

I could comment on "remoaning remoaning twats", but it's probably best just captured for posterity, as a reminder of the ill-informed ignorance of some on the leave side.
Not quite as bad as Dekka’s all leave supporters ”are as thick as pig sh*t” comment!

People who want Brexit to be complete because they are ‘tired / bored’ of it are thick as pig shit. A decision should be made in facts, benefits and rationality not fatigue. 

If you’re so confident that the outcome will be the same now we know the facts then why the reticence towards a second referendum?

Can you tell me the benefits of Boris’s deal for the average person in the street? Will it ensure workers rights, protections for the environment, safety net for the most vulnerable, securing a better NHS? Will it keep the UK together, will it keep peace in Northern Ireland?
As we do not know what the final deal will be and I am not clairvoyant, no I can’t.  Has the EU secured a better present day NHS? We are in the EU at present, hasn’t stopped the government from sweeping away the Green Belt, allowing Fracking and turning the Rivers Authority into a toothless, cash poor charity. It’s only your assumption that workers and civil rights will be worse. As I’ve pointed out before, Britain was a world leader, let alone Europe, in many advances in civil liberties. Are the most vulnerable exceptionally  well cared for today?  After 40 years of us being in the EU. The EU don’t seem to be improving the lot of minorities in other parts of the Empire, particular the new Eastern acquisitions. It may have escaped your notice but Scotland has been manoeuvring to leave the Union for years. (Mind, they don’t seem to want to honour that referendum either.). Is there peace in NI now. 
As usual, you are painting predictions, possibles and scaremongering crystal ball gazing as facts, which they are not.

Arf you’ve just completely defeated your own argument for Brexit. Bemoaning our national governments records on all the points I’ve made. I thought we had no control of these things? Funny how other EU member states manage to have a much fairer, more caring societies. 

You say we looked after the vulnerable before the EU, like throwing the disabled into awful residential homes, shaming and treating gay people appallingly and rampant racism? Hmm

I await the better deal and sunlit uplands you cling to because there is nothing left of Brexit but to believe. If you want to trust this government and prime minister good for you.
Reply
#22
(10-16-2019, 09:23 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-16-2019, 08:41 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote: As we do not know what the final deal will be and I am not clairvoyant, no I can’t.  Has the EU secured a better present day NHS? We are in the EU at present, hasn’t stopped the government from sweeping away the Green Belt, allowing Fracking and turning the Rivers Authority into a toothless, cash poor charity. It’s only your assumption that workers and civil rights will be worse. As I’ve pointed out before, Britain was a world leader, let alone Europe, in many advances in civil liberties. Are the most vulnerable exceptionally  well cared for today?  After 40 years of us being in the EU. The EU don’t seem to be improving the lot of minorities in other parts of the Empire, particular the new Eastern acquisitions. It may have escaped your notice but Scotland has been manoeuvring to leave the Union for years. (Mind, they don’t seem to want to honour that referendum either.). Is there peace in NI now. 
As usual, you are painting predictions, possibles and scaremongering crystal ball gazing as facts, which they are not.

Arf you’ve just completely defeated your own argument for Brexit. Bemoaning our national governments records on all the points I’ve made. I thought we had no control of these things? Funny how other EU member states manage to have a much fairer, more caring societies. 

You say we looked after the vulnerable before the EU, like throwing the disabled into awful residential homes, shaming and treating gay people appallingly and rampant racism? Hmm

I await the better deal and sunlit uplands you cling to because there is nothing left of Brexit but to believe. If you want to trust this government and prime minister good for you.
How am I arguing against myself? When I have simply pointed out the error in your argument that the EU protects these groups when it plainly doesn’t have any effect. You are negating your own argument. You regularly berate the government for its record on these areas yet then insist the EU makes things better.

Re. “Shaming and treating gay people appallingly”, 
Homosexuality was decriminalised in England and Wales in 1967, 
Austria 1971
Spain. 1978
France. 1982
Germany. 1994
Same sex marriages are recognised in only 14 of the 28 states (inc the uk)
Perhaps the EU isn’t as progressive with its inclusivity as you wet dream over.
Poland still has ‘Homosexual Conversion therapy’ The ruling Law and Justice party says the advancement of gay rights is a “grave danger” to family life. When the coalition that ruled for eight years up till 2015 ignored reforms to LGBT rights it was led by Donald Tusk. Remember him? Romania actively discriminates against its native Roma population.

When were women given universal suffrage in the U.K.? Oh, that’s correct, 1928 with some 8 million plus obtaining the vote in 1918. Portugal not until 1968 Belgium in 1948 and the great democracy of France in 1945. The first Equal Pay Act was passed in the U.K. in 1970! Before at least 14 of the other 27 member states.
Abortion has been legal up to 90 days of pregnancy in Italy and later in cases of ‘severe ‘ abnormalities since 1979 but it is almost impossible to get one. Trainee doctors aren’t even given any tutoring on terminations and GPs are also not educated in contraception. Let’s not forget the recent scandal of the poor women, often victims of rape or familial abuse having to secretly travel to England for treatment from Ireland.

Following more Brexit scare predictions (couldn’t be lies because, as we know, only leave supporters resorted to falsehoods) by Dame Grey-Thompson and others about how the U.Ks. Disabled would loose out following Brexit the Papworth Trust, a leading disability charity, says the UK is one of the more progressive of the 28 EU member states when it comes to the treatment of the disabled.
In 1970, the UK passed the Chronically Sick and Disabled Persons Ac, the first legislation in the world to award rights to disabled people.
From the, E.U. biased, BBCs ‘Fact Checker’ site “E.U. law governs workers' rights, but other areas of social policy are left to the governments of nation states, meaning UK law on disability is by nature more comprehensive than the EU's.”

EUs richest country also has Food Banks! 
https://edition.cnn.com/interactive/2017...cnnphotos/

https://www.irishtimes.com/news/world/eu...-1.3209052
France opened its first Food bank in 1984. In fact they are Europe wide.
https://www.eurofoodbank.org/

Actual EU funded schools do not adhere to The EU’s own standards when it comes to disabled children’s education.

https://www.theparliamentmagazine.eu/art...d-children
Oh look, Belgium condemned for its lack of support for the disabled.

https://enil.eu/news/europe-condemns-bel...ed-people/
The W.H.O. Claim Mental Health Care institutions across Europe fall well below standard. 
http://www.euro.who.int/en/media-centre/...assessment

You even ridiculously infer that only Britain had asylums. 

I know you are severely blinkered when it comes to comparing Britain with your beloved European Soviet Union but can you seriously believe that the attitudes towards the sections of society you mention was any different on mainland Europe to here? Have you studied how the French, Spanish, Italians and Germans treated their empires? I think you will find, as heinous as ours was, it compares favourably with those with regards to racism. 
Spain still does not have an independent body to tackle racism. Going on for 50% of Roma and non E.U. migrant children do not complete compulsory education in Spain. Croatia, Hungry, Poland, Serbia and even France do not even have a definition of discrimination in their equality legislation as required by the E.Us. Racial Equality Directive.”/Funny how other EU member states manage to have a much fairer, more caring societies. ” Big Arf.
[color=#000000]Again you are inventing words not written by a poster, a regular trick of yours to try and win a loosing argument. Where, in my post, did I say “We looked after the vulnerable before the EU”? I did not say that! I stated a fact which, with little research, can be verified, that Britain was often at the forefront of advances in liberalism. They may not have always been big steps but they were often bigger and years before many of your ‘more enlightened’ European states. Where also did I state I trust this government or Prime Minister?


We aught or remember too the environmental damage done in the name of the CAP., the loss of habitats, soil erosion and the rape of water courses which left flows to a trickle further downstream. Only now are they thinking of putting in some sort of environmental ‘green’ component into the farmers, no questions asked, Direct Payment to make them act in a little more eco friendly way.

I have said before, to suggest or infer that The European Union has led the way in enlightenment and that all other Nation Sates were the epitome of liberalism and all sweetness and light in previous eras and this, compared to Britain, is a more than a little spurious to say the least. In fact, it is down right incorrect. Of coarse you are at liberty to ignore history, facts and balance and you will and do, constantly.
Reply
#23
This is ridiculous. In a negotiation in an entity involving 500 million people a medieval party supported by 200,000 people are blocking agreement. We should be rid of the north of Ireland. 

What the world sees.
Reply
#24
(10-16-2019, 11:59 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-16-2019, 09:23 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-16-2019, 08:41 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote: As we do not know what the final deal will be and I am not clairvoyant, no I can’t.  Has the EU secured a better present day NHS? We are in the EU at present, hasn’t stopped the government from sweeping away the Green Belt, allowing Fracking and turning the Rivers Authority into a toothless, cash poor charity. It’s only your assumption that workers and civil rights will be worse. As I’ve pointed out before, Britain was a world leader, let alone Europe, in many advances in civil liberties. Are the most vulnerable exceptionally  well cared for today?  After 40 years of us being in the EU. The EU don’t seem to be improving the lot of minorities in other parts of the Empire, particular the new Eastern acquisitions. It may have escaped your notice but Scotland has been manoeuvring to leave the Union for years. (Mind, they don’t seem to want to honour that referendum either.). Is there peace in NI now. 
As usual, you are painting predictions, possibles and scaremongering crystal ball gazing as facts, which they are not.

Arf you’ve just completely defeated your own argument for Brexit. Bemoaning our national governments records on all the points I’ve made. I thought we had no control of these things? Funny how other EU member states manage to have a much fairer, more caring societies. 

You say we looked after the vulnerable before the EU, like throwing the disabled into awful residential homes, shaming and treating gay people appallingly and rampant racism? Hmm

I await the better deal and sunlit uplands you cling to because there is nothing left of Brexit but to believe. If you want to trust this government and prime minister good for you.
How am I arguing against myself? When I have simply pointed out the error in your argument that the EU protects these groups when it plainly doesn’t have any effect. You are negating your own argument. You regularly berate the government for its record on these areas yet then insist the EU makes things better.

Re. “Shaming and treating gay people appallingly”, 
Homosexuality was decriminalised in England and Wales in 1967, 
Austria 1971
Spain. 1978
France. 1982
Germany. 1994
Same sex marriages are recognised in only 14 of the 28 states (inc the uk)
Perhaps the EU isn’t as progressive with its inclusivity as you wet dream over.
Poland still has ‘Homosexual Conversion therapy’ The ruling Law and Justice party says the advancement of gay rights is a “grave danger” to family life. When the coalition that ruled for eight years up till 2015 ignored reforms to LGBT rights it was led by Donald Tusk. Remember him? Romania actively discriminates against its native Roma population.

When were women given universal suffrage in the U.K.? Oh, that’s correct, 1928 with some 8 million plus obtaining the vote in 1918. Portugal not until 1968 Belgium in 1948 and the great democracy of France in 1945. The first Equal Pay Act was passed in the U.K. in 1970! Before at least 14 of the other 27 member states.
Abortion has been legal up to 90 days of pregnancy in Italy and later in cases of ‘severe ‘ abnormalities since 1979 but it is almost impossible to get one. Trainee doctors aren’t even given any tutoring on terminations and GPs are also not educated in contraception. Let’s not forget the recent scandal of the poor women, often victims of rape or familial abuse having to secretly travel to England for treatment from Ireland.

Following more Brexit scare predictions (couldn’t be lies because, as we know, only leave supporters resorted to falsehoods) by Dame Grey-Thompson and others about how the U.Ks. Disabled would loose out following Brexit the Papworth Trust, a leading disability charity, says the UK is one of the more progressive of the 28 EU member states when it comes to the treatment of the disabled.
In 1970, the UK passed the Chronically Sick and Disabled Persons Ac, the first legislation in the world to award rights to disabled people.
From the, E.U. biased, BBCs ‘Fact Checker’ site “E.U. law governs workers' rights, but other areas of social policy are left to the governments of nation states, meaning UK law on disability is by nature more comprehensive than the EU's.”

EUs richest country also has Food Banks! 
https://edition.cnn.com/interactive/2017...cnnphotos/

https://www.irishtimes.com/news/world/eu...-1.3209052
France opened its first Food bank in 1984. In fact they are Europe wide.
https://www.eurofoodbank.org/

Actual EU funded schools do not adhere to The EU’s own standards when it comes to disabled children’s education.

https://www.theparliamentmagazine.eu/art...d-children
Oh look, Belgium condemned for its lack of support for the disabled.

https://enil.eu/news/europe-condemns-bel...ed-people/
The W.H.O. Claim Mental Health Care institutions across Europe fall well below standard. 
http://www.euro.who.int/en/media-centre/...assessment

You even ridiculously infer that only Britain had asylums. 

I know you are severely blinkered when it comes to comparing Britain with your beloved European Soviet Union but can you seriously believe that the attitudes towards the sections of society you mention was any different on mainland Europe to here? Have you studied how the French, Spanish, Italians and Germans treated their empires? I think you will find, as heinous as ours was, it compares favourably with those with regards to racism. 
Spain still does not have an independent body to tackle racism. Going on for 50% of Roma and non E.U. migrant children do not complete compulsory education in Spain. Croatia, Hungry, Poland, Serbia and even France do not even have a definition of discrimination in their equality legislation as required by the E.Us. Racial Equality Directive.”/Funny how other EU member states manage to have a much fairer, more caring societies. ” Big Arf.
Again you are inventing words not written by a poster, a regular trick of yours to try and win a loosing argument. Where, in my post, did I say “We looked after the vulnerable before the EU”? I did not say that! I stated a fact which, with little research, can be verified, that Britain was often at the forefront of advances in liberalism. They may not have always been big steps but they were often bigger and years before many of your ‘more enlightened’ European states. Where also did I state I trust this government or Prime Minister?

We aught or remember too the environmental damage done in the name of the CAP., the loss of habitats, soil erosion and the rape of water courses which left flows to a trickle further downstream. Only now are they thinking of putting in some sort of environmental ‘green’ component into the farmers, no questions asked, Direct Payment to make them act in a little more eco friendly way.

I have said before, to suggest or infer that The European Union has led the way in enlightenment and that all other Nation Sates were the epitome of liberalism and all sweetness and light in previous eras and this, compared to Britain, is a more than a little spurious to say the least. In fact, it is down right incorrect. Of coarse you are at liberty to ignore history, facts and balance and you will and do, constantly.

That’s a lot of words (some incorrectly spelt) to prove your own argument for Brexit is completely flawed. Wink

Also as an observation it seems that the country is now being held to ransom AGAIN by the ERG and DUP both right wing fruitloops... but let’s blame the EU and those awful remainers it’s easier eh!?’
Reply
#25
(10-16-2019, 08:41 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-16-2019, 07:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-16-2019, 02:38 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-16-2019, 09:49 AM)Ossian Wrote:
(10-16-2019, 09:00 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Hampered by MP'S with their own ulterior motives and desire to disrupt any deal possible, the remoaning remoaning twats.

I could comment on "remoaning remoaning twats", but it's probably best just captured for posterity, as a reminder of the ill-informed ignorance of some on the leave side.
Not quite as bad as Dekka’s all leave supporters ”are as thick as pig sh*t” comment!

People who want Brexit to be complete because they are ‘tired / bored’ of it are thick as pig shit. A decision should be made in facts, benefits and rationality not fatigue. 

If you’re so confident that the outcome will be the same now we know the facts then why the reticence towards a second referendum?

Can you tell me the benefits of Boris’s deal for the average person in the street? Will it ensure workers rights, protections for the environment, safety net for the most vulnerable, securing a better NHS? Will it keep the UK together, will it keep peace in Northern Ireland?
As we do not know what the final deal will be and I am not clairvoyant, no I can’t.  

Has the EU secured a better present day NHS? - Domestic UK Issue

We are in the EU at present, hasn’t stopped the government from sweeping away the Green Belt - Domestic UK Issue
allowing Fracking and turning the Rivers Authority into a toothless, cash poor charity. - Domestic UK Issue

It’s only your assumption that workers and civil rights will be worse. - As part of the EU they will definitely be protected

As I’ve pointed out before, Britain was a world leader, let alone Europe, in many advances in civil liberties. - Which are the basis of EU law, we can still lead the way apparently in building a better world from inside the EU.

Are the most vulnerable exceptionally  well cared for today?  Domestic UK Issue

After 40 years of us being in the EU. -  Nothing was broken, we are prosperous and have a seat at the top table already, why change for change sake?

The EU don’t seem to be improving the lot of minorities in other parts of the Empire, particular the new Eastern acquisitions. - I think the key word there is 'new', give them chance ffs. Greece was bailed out from bankruptcy by the EU. 

It may have escaped your notice but Scotland has been manoeuvring to leave the Union for years. (Mind, they don’t seem to want to honour that referendum either.). - As with this referendum people are allowed to change their mind, and if Scotland voted to remain that would probably tip the balance.

Is there peace in NI now - As part of the EU there is definitely peace currently

As usual, you are painting predictions, possibles and scaremongering crystal ball gazing as facts, which they are not. - One Thing is certain from your points in that where the EU has the authority things are good.

So basically what you are saying is that it has been pretty good for the UK as part of the EU
Reply
#26
(10-17-2019, 08:59 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-16-2019, 08:41 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-16-2019, 07:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-16-2019, 02:38 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-16-2019, 09:49 AM)Ossian Wrote: I could comment on "remoaning remoaning twats", but it's probably best just captured for posterity, as a reminder of the ill-informed ignorance of some on the leave side.
Not quite as bad as Dekka’s all leave supporters ”are as thick as pig sh*t” comment!

People who want Brexit to be complete because they are ‘tired / bored’ of it are thick as pig shit. A decision should be made in facts, benefits and rationality not fatigue. 

If you’re so confident that the outcome will be the same now we know the facts then why the reticence towards a second referendum?

Can you tell me the benefits of Boris’s deal for the average person in the street? Will it ensure workers rights, protections for the environment, safety net for the most vulnerable, securing a better NHS? Will it keep the UK together, will it keep peace in Northern Ireland?
As we do not know what the final deal will be and I am not clairvoyant, no I can’t.  

Has the EU secured a better present day NHS? - Domestic UK Issue

We are in the EU at present, hasn’t stopped the government from sweeping away the Green Belt - Domestic UK Issue
allowing Fracking and turning the Rivers Authority into a toothless, cash poor charity. - Domestic UK Issue

It’s only your assumption that workers and civil rights will be worse. - As part of the EU they will definitely be protected

As I’ve pointed out before, Britain was a world leader, let alone Europe, in many advances in civil liberties. - Which are the basis of EU law, we can still lead the way apparently in building a better world from inside the EU.

Are the most vulnerable exceptionally  well cared for today?  Domestic UK Issue

After 40 years of us being in the EU. -  Nothing was broken, we are prosperous and have a seat at the top table already, why change for change sake?

The EU don’t seem to be improving the lot of minorities in other parts of the Empire, particular the new Eastern acquisitions. - I think the key word there is 'new', give them chance ffs. Greece was bailed out from bankruptcy by the EU. 

It may have escaped your notice but Scotland has been manoeuvring to leave the Union for years. (Mind, they don’t seem to want to honour that referendum either.). - As with this referendum people are allowed to change their mind, and if Scotland voted to remain that would probably tip the balance.

Is there peace in NI now - As part of the EU there is definitely peace currently

As usual, you are painting predictions, possibles and scaremongering crystal ball gazing as facts, which they are not. - One Thing is certain from your points in that where the EU has the authority things are good.

So basically what you are saying is that it has been pretty good for the UK as part of the EU

Yep the longest reply I’ve ever seen that completely defeats its own argument.
Reply
#27
(10-17-2019, 08:59 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So basically what you are saying is that it has been pretty good for the UK as part of the EU
No. What Dekka claims is that Racial minorities are better treated and protected within other parts of the Union than in the U.K.  that is clearly and demonstrably not true.
He insisted that mentally and physically disabled within the U.K. are more disadvantaged and have worse provision than in the rest of Europe. Again, proven to be inaccurate.
He claims that the E.U. Is traditionally the embodiment of a caring and enlightened society. Proven to be false with just a few facts.
Again, if the E.U. Is doing so brilliantly at “protecting “ the rights of these groups how come he can slam the treatment of them in one of that Union’s member states, i.e. the U.K.?
The statement  That the EU. is a collection of “ much fairer and kinder societies “ than the U.K. is patently a false and disingenuous statement.
Reply
#28
(10-17-2019, 10:41 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 08:59 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So basically what you are saying is that it has been pretty good for the UK as part of the EU
No. What Dekka claims is that Racial minorities are better treated and protected within other parts of the Union than in the U.K.  that is clearly and demonstrably not true.
He insisted that mentally and physically disabled within the U.K. are more disadvantaged and have worse provision than in the rest of Europe. Again, proven to be inaccurate.
He claims that the E.U. Is traditionally the embodiment of a caring and enlightened society. Proven to be false with just a few facts.
Again, if the E.U. Is doing so brilliantly at “protecting “ the rights of these groups how come he can slam the treatment of them in one of that Union’s member states, i.e. the U.K.?
The statement  That the EU. is a collection of “ much fairer and kinder societies “ than the U.K. is patently a false and disingenuous statement.

I didn’t claim any of those things so don’t blatantly lie.

The argument for Brexit by many is to control our own laws, domestic policies and economic trade deals. However the list of random links you put up show that the UK is in control of many of those things Brexiteers pretend we have no control of (because the EU is an easy / lazy spacegoat) This point is seemingly lost on you and you’re going off half cocked saying I said this and that without a shred of evidence.

My problem with leaving the EU is that it was not hindering us as a country and it acted as a buffer financially and regulatory to the worst excesses of our domestic politics notably this hard right Tory Government who imo will look to low tax, small state, low welfare, low worker rights, broken up NHS, broken Union policies. A race to the bottom for the benefit of the rich few.

I’m not in love with the EU but I recognise that the deal we have with them offers us some economic and social protection from the shysters at home.
Reply
#29
(10-17-2019, 07:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: 1, That’s a lot of words (some incorrectly spelt) to prove your own argument for Brexit is completely flawed. Wink

2, Also as an observation it seems that the country is now being held to ransom AGAIN by the ERG and DUP both right wing fruitloops... but let’s blame the EU and those awful remainers it’s easier eh!?’

1, Do please point out all those misspelled words. (You May have set a dangerous precedent there)

2, irrelevant!
Reply
#30
(10-17-2019, 10:46 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 07:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: 1, That’s a lot of words (some incorrectly spelt) to prove your own argument for Brexit is completely flawed. Wink

2, Also as an observation it seems that the country is now being held to ransom AGAIN by the ERG and DUP both right wing fruitloops... but let’s blame the EU and those awful remainers it’s easier eh!?’

1, Do please point out all those misspelled words. (You May have set a dangerous precedent there)

2, irrelevant!

Ought of course. When you’re losing not loosing the argument.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: