Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
Where was he travelling to on the plane?
Posts: 2,270
Threads: 51
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(09-30-2019, 06:18 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: (09-30-2019, 05:04 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (09-30-2019, 04:55 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: (09-30-2019, 04:50 PM)Peachy Wrote: Cardiff bought him. He held the shirt and signed the deal. They made a commitment.
After the tragic incident for some reason they didn't want to pay for him.
My argument in court would be if he played and scored a few goals in his first two weeks would you have paid for him? Of course they would.
The transaction took place. Cardiff looked for a technicality after his death. Pretty disgusting if you ask me. Just my onions.....
I think the issue was that the Premier League had refused to register the player for some technical reason, so Cardiff's argument is that he wasn't technically their player, and despite the presentation in front of the fans, he could actually have signed for another club before the transfer window shut if he'd chosen to.
On this basis, I'm also assuming Cardiff's insurance company wouldn't have settled any claim. A very sad and unfortunate mess.
I think you're correct DK.
Most other transfers would have been paid up by the relevant insurers by now, but it looks like Cardiff's are refusing on a technicality and having been relegated Cardiff aren't in a place where they can hand £15m to Nantes out of good will and what's morally right.
Imagine this could rumble on yet.
Cardiff would automatically be insured as soon as the transfer was officially complete. Unfortunately it didn’t complete due to defective paperwork and of course Sala then died before the defective paperwork was complete. He would have ceased to be covered by Nantes because as far as they were aware the transfer was complete, so there was a vacuum when neither club was insured, instead of the cover passing instantaneously from one club to the other.
Cardiff made a minor admin error, but an error nonetheless. It was their responsibility to make sure that he signed in the correct replace. Somebody ballsed up.
Cardiff could countersue to recoup their loss, but that seems pointless. Willie McKay the agent is bankrupt, the pilot who was supposed to fly the plane is unlikely to be liable, and the pilot who flew the plane was not insured and apparently was penniless.
It’s hard to blame the insurers as they aren’t going to pay out when they aren’t liable. Cardiff made an admin error which is costing them massively. A very sorry tale all round.
Wouldn't he have had to remain insured with Nantes until the deal was ratified. Maybe someone there jumped the gun and cancelled the insurance before it should have been, in which case, the fault is at their end. A Cardiff admin error meant he wasn't really a Cardiff player. Maybe a Nantes admin error left them uninsured.
I get why morally people are pointing the finger at Cardiff, but from their point of view they've been told "You cocked it up. He's not your player." Then when the plane goes down they're being told that it would be a poor show if they didn't cough up the money.
Maybe the most equitable way to settle it without it dragging on in an unseemly way, possibly for years, would be for the two clubs and two insurance companies to pay a quarter each, but I'm probably being a tad naive there.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(09-30-2019, 07:32 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: (09-30-2019, 06:18 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: (09-30-2019, 05:04 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (09-30-2019, 04:55 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: (09-30-2019, 04:50 PM)Peachy Wrote: Cardiff bought him. He held the shirt and signed the deal. They made a commitment.
After the tragic incident for some reason they didn't want to pay for him.
My argument in court would be if he played and scored a few goals in his first two weeks would you have paid for him? Of course they would.
The transaction took place. Cardiff looked for a technicality after his death. Pretty disgusting if you ask me. Just my onions.....
I think the issue was that the Premier League had refused to register the player for some technical reason, so Cardiff's argument is that he wasn't technically their player, and despite the presentation in front of the fans, he could actually have signed for another club before the transfer window shut if he'd chosen to.
On this basis, I'm also assuming Cardiff's insurance company wouldn't have settled any claim. A very sad and unfortunate mess.
I think you're correct DK.
Most other transfers would have been paid up by the relevant insurers by now, but it looks like Cardiff's are refusing on a technicality and having been relegated Cardiff aren't in a place where they can hand £15m to Nantes out of good will and what's morally right.
Imagine this could rumble on yet.
Cardiff would automatically be insured as soon as the transfer was officially complete. Unfortunately it didn’t complete due to defective paperwork and of course Sala then died before the defective paperwork was complete. He would have ceased to be covered by Nantes because as far as they were aware the transfer was complete, so there was a vacuum when neither club was insured, instead of the cover passing instantaneously from one club to the other.
Cardiff made a minor admin error, but an error nonetheless. It was their responsibility to make sure that he signed in the correct replace. Somebody ballsed up.
Cardiff could countersue to recoup their loss, but that seems pointless. Willie McKay the agent is bankrupt, the pilot who was supposed to fly the plane is unlikely to be liable, and the pilot who flew the plane was not insured and apparently was penniless.
It’s hard to blame the insurers as they aren’t going to pay out when they aren’t liable. Cardiff made an admin error which is costing them massively. A very sorry tale all round.
Wouldn't he have had to remain insured with Nantes until the deal was ratified. Maybe someone there jumped the gun and cancelled the insurance before it should have been, in which case, the fault is at their end. A Cardiff admin error meant he wasn't really a Cardiff player. Maybe a Nantes admin error left them uninsured.
I get why morally people are pointing the finger at Cardiff, but from their point of view they've been told "You cocked it up. He's not your player." Then when the plane goes down they're being told that it would be a poor show if they didn't cough up the money.
Maybe the most equitable way to settle it without it dragging on in an unseemly way, possibly for years, would be for the two clubs and two insurance companies to pay a quarter each, but I'm probably being a tad naive there.
Good post DK. Yeah, way too much common sense, there'll be a solicitors bunfight instead and everyone will be way poorer.
Posts: 2,270
Threads: 51
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Except for the solicitors.
Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
So let me get this right.
1) Cardiff signed him on a contract and agreed to pay the money.
2) The player leaves after signing the contract in good faith and flies home to collect belongings.
3) on the return journey the player loses his life.
4) Cardiff realise that they screwed up the paperwork that incredibly means Sala was never actually theirs and then use that administrative error to then welch on paying as the aforementioned administrative error meant he was never leagally their player.
I'm sorry but everything about it says Cardiff should pay. Why should they be let off because they made an error.
Like I said before all parties had agreed to the signing in good faith.
If the courts have said Cardiff have to pay then I think they are spot on.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
09-30-2019, 08:04 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-30-2019, 10:44 PM by Kit Kat Chunky.)
The insurers will just say it wasn't on risk, because the underwriting criteria wasn't met.
Posts: 3,161
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
09-30-2019, 08:29 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-30-2019, 08:33 PM by Pragmatist.)
(09-30-2019, 08:04 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The insurers will just say it wasnt on risk, because the u underwriting criteria wasnt met.
Correct. Cover is automatic as soon as the transfer is fully confirmed by the FA
(09-30-2019, 07:32 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: (09-30-2019, 06:18 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: (09-30-2019, 05:04 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (09-30-2019, 04:55 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: (09-30-2019, 04:50 PM)Peachy Wrote: Cardiff bought him. He held the shirt and signed the deal. They made a commitment.
After the tragic incident for some reason they didn't want to pay for him.
My argument in court would be if he played and scored a few goals in his first two weeks would you have paid for him? Of course they would.
The transaction took place. Cardiff looked for a technicality after his death. Pretty disgusting if you ask me. Just my onions.....
I think the issue was that the Premier League had refused to register the player for some technical reason, so Cardiff's argument is that he wasn't technically their player, and despite the presentation in front of the fans, he could actually have signed for another club before the transfer window shut if he'd chosen to.
On this basis, I'm also assuming Cardiff's insurance company wouldn't have settled any claim. A very sad and unfortunate mess.
I think you're correct DK.
Most other transfers would have been paid up by the relevant insurers by now, but it looks like Cardiff's are refusing on a technicality and having been relegated Cardiff aren't in a place where they can hand £15m to Nantes out of good will and what's morally right.
Imagine this could rumble on yet.
Cardiff would automatically be insured as soon as the transfer was officially complete. Unfortunately it didn’t complete due to defective paperwork and of course Sala then died before the defective paperwork was complete. He would have ceased to be covered by Nantes because as far as they were aware the transfer was complete, so there was a vacuum when neither club was insured, instead of the cover passing instantaneously from one club to the other.
Cardiff made a minor admin error, but an error nonetheless. It was their responsibility to make sure that he signed in the correct replace. Somebody ballsed up.
Cardiff could countersue to recoup their loss, but that seems pointless. Willie McKay the agent is bankrupt, the pilot who was supposed to fly the plane is unlikely to be liable, and the pilot who flew the plane was not insured and apparently was penniless.
It’s hard to blame the insurers as they aren’t going to pay out when they aren’t liable. Cardiff made an admin error which is costing them massively. A very sorry tale all round.
Wouldn't he have had to remain insured with Nantes until the deal was ratified. Maybe someone there jumped the gun and cancelled the insurance before it should have been, in which case, the fault is at their end. A Cardiff admin error meant he wasn't really a Cardiff player. Maybe a Nantes admin error left them uninsured.
I get why morally people are pointing the finger at Cardiff, but from their point of view they've been told "You cocked it up. He's not your player." Then when the plane goes down they're being told that it would be a poor show if they didn't cough up the money.
Maybe the most equitable way to settle it without it dragging on in an unseemly way, possibly for years, would be for the two clubs and two insurance companies to pay a quarter each, but I'm probably being a tad naive there.
No. As soon as Nantes registered the transfer with the French FA then their cover automatically ceases as he is no longer their player. This is supposed to work simultaneously with the acceptance of risk cover for the buying club. It is quite probable that Nantes and the French FA weren’t even made aware of the paperwork deficiency. So cover at one end stops, but cover at the other end doesn’t yet start. A disastrous gap in cover results.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
It’s a colossal financial mistake that is a 1 in a million outside bet. A truly horrendous story and Cardiff are having their name further tarnished by this.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(09-30-2019, 08:54 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: It’s a colossal financial mistake that is a 1 in a million outside bet. A truly horrendous story and Cardiff are having their name further tarnished by this.
Yep. I get that every penny counts, but it wouldn't sit well with me if Albion were doing this. Some things are more important than money.
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
They're appealing the decision.....
|