Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(09-27-2019, 10:04 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote: (09-27-2019, 07:57 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (09-27-2019, 07:21 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote: Had it been about a Conservative front bencher I can think of one person who would have been posting on here sharpish, with his usual vitriolic sarcasm and bile. 
Tell me in the grand scheme of things currently why disliking Diane Abbott (an odd obsession of middle aged men I’ve noticed) is important to what is happening in government?
You’re going to have outline the positive merits of the Conservative Front bench to me. Is the list as long as the merits of Brexit?
Btw I’m not the BBC I don’t have a remit to be neutral or report equally sensible, rational arguments and idiotic ones used by people such as Farage etc. If you or other wish to defend the current government you are free to do so. You will have to point me in the direction of where I have “defended” the current government.
Can’t say I have noticed the derision of Abbott is restricted to “middle aged men”. Many of the young left leaning comedians, who’s continual lambasting of Brexit, I assume, you approve of wholeheartedly, knock her.
No, you don’t have to be neutral. I just like to point out your hypocrisy and total blinkered bias. And no, I do not have to point out the merits of any politician but I will redress your bias. If that means defending someone else’s perfect right to post negativity about one of your favourite babes, incompetent, racist, hypocritical and innumerate though she is, I am free to do that.
My babe? Erm I was asking the relevance of the thread currently. It seems utterly pointless to me. I think from your steadfast refusal to admit Brexiteers are using wartime vernacular is a good barometer of your awareness of who and what is happening and who is doing / saying what.
There is no hypocrisy to my posts on Brexit I haven’t said I was neutral, I haven’t defended the indefensible and if you can point me to a thread where I have please do. I’ve asked you this regarding several points you make against me and you haven’t supplied one link.
Who are you going to vote for at the next election? I can’t see who it can be other that Johnson or Farage...
Posts: 3,032
Threads: 78
Joined: Jun 2019
Reputation:
22
There are things which need addressing when it comes to the charitable status of private schools; things which should have been addressed long ago by successive governments and The Charity Commission. Here's an example of why...
Some years ago I worked for a very successful privately-owned company. Some of the owners (not all) sent their kids to pretty expensive private schools, paid the fees through the business, rounded up the amount and called it a donation. The charitable status of the schools allowed them to receive donated income free of tax; the business offset the expenditure against its corporation tax liability; the owners (also directors) did not declare the payments as a benefit in kind; tax was either avoided or exempted by all three of the parties; the auditors - much though they didn't want to - knew all about it. And I know they did because I told them. In the scheme of things, this anecdote is just one tiny flake in a whole blizzard of under-the-counter patronage and avoidance.
These are the kind of issues that do need addressing, but preferably rationally, not emotively, and by someone with a bit more credibility than Diane Abbott. Personally I have no issues at all with people sending their children to private schools; I do have a problem with certain schools being an automatic conduit to power and influence, but that's a different argument. Unfortunately we don't have the climate for forensic, rational scrutiny and debate; not in politics, not in the media.
Posts: 230
Threads: 11
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
0
(09-27-2019, 10:58 AM)Ossian Wrote: There are things which need addressing when it comes to the charitable status of private schools; things which should have been addressed long ago by successive governments and The Charity Commission. Here's an example of why...
Some years ago I worked for a very successful privately-owned company. Some of the owners (not all) sent their kids to pretty expensive private schools, paid the fees through the business, rounded up the amount and called it a donation. The charitable status of the schools allowed them to receive donated income free of tax; the business offset the expenditure against its corporation tax liability; the owners (also directors) did not declare the payments as a benefit in kind; tax was either avoided or exempted by all three of the parties; the auditors - much though they didn't want to - knew all about it. And I know they did because I told them. In the scheme of things, this anecdote is just one tiny flake in a whole blizzard of under-the-counter patronage and avoidance.
These are the kind of issues that do need addressing, but preferably rationally, not emotively, and by someone with a bit more credibility than Diane Abbott. Personally I have no issues at all with people sending their children to private schools; I do have a problem with certain schools being an automatic conduit to power and influence, but that's a different argument. Unfortunately we don't have the climate for forensic, rational scrutiny and debate; not in politics, not in the media.
I have never understood why public schools have charitable status unless they give bursaries to gifted children and somehow I can’t imagine Eaton or Harrow accepting children from sink estates.
You are correct, the ‘Old School Tie’ shame is a different topic. I know it’s not PC to think it now but I still believe that the abolishment of the majority of Grammar schools, which did accept kids from poorer backgrounds if the were cleaver enough, has hindered social mobility. Grand and noble idea that comprehensive schooling is, I believe that they round down to the mean rather than lift up the capable.
Posts: 2,431
Threads: 137
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
Most private schools exist to minimize downward social mobility.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(09-27-2019, 12:22 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote: (09-27-2019, 10:58 AM)Ossian Wrote: There are things which need addressing when it comes to the charitable status of private schools; things which should have been addressed long ago by successive governments and The Charity Commission. Here's an example of why...
Some years ago I worked for a very successful privately-owned company. Some of the owners (not all) sent their kids to pretty expensive private schools, paid the fees through the business, rounded up the amount and called it a donation. The charitable status of the schools allowed them to receive donated income free of tax; the business offset the expenditure against its corporation tax liability; the owners (also directors) did not declare the payments as a benefit in kind; tax was either avoided or exempted by all three of the parties; the auditors - much though they didn't want to - knew all about it. And I know they did because I told them. In the scheme of things, this anecdote is just one tiny flake in a whole blizzard of under-the-counter patronage and avoidance.
These are the kind of issues that do need addressing, but preferably rationally, not emotively, and by someone with a bit more credibility than Diane Abbott. Personally I have no issues at all with people sending their children to private schools; I do have a problem with certain schools being an automatic conduit to power and influence, but that's a different argument. Unfortunately we don't have the climate for forensic, rational scrutiny and debate; not in politics, not in the media.
I have never understood why public schools have charitable status unless they give bursaries to gifted children and somehow I can’t imagine Eaton or Harrow accepting children from sink estates.
You are correct, the ‘Old School Tie’ shame is a different topic. I know it’s not PC to think it now but I still believe that the abolishment of the majority of Grammar schools, which did accept kids from poorer backgrounds if the were cleaver enough, has hindered social mobility. Grand and noble idea that comprehensive schooling is, I believe that they round down to the mean rather than lift up the capable.
I feel that's a fair assesment of grammar schools but to play devils advocate, they weren't without problems. If we were to reintroduce them, how do you guarantee that a two-tier state education system doesn't arise again which was one of the main issues with grammars. On top of that, grammar schools do have issues with social mobility as well. Wealthier parents are able to pay for private tuition to give their children an advantage with regards to getting into grammar schools. Whether that's as bad as the postcode lotteries of comprehensive schools, I'm not sure.
Ultimately I feel as though the reforms needed in the education system aren't as easily addressed by just bringing back grammar schools. The biggest focus being a mentality change for me is to focus on teaching and understand the content instead of teaching to pass exams, though how you do that I'm not sure.
Posts: 230
Threads: 11
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
0
(09-27-2019, 12:45 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: (09-27-2019, 12:22 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote: (09-27-2019, 10:58 AM)Ossian Wrote: There are things which need addressing when it comes to the charitable status of private schools; things which should have been addressed long ago by successive governments and The Charity Commission. Here's an example of why...
Some years ago I worked for a very successful privately-owned company. Some of the owners (not all) sent their kids to pretty expensive private schools, paid the fees through the business, rounded up the amount and called it a donation. The charitable status of the schools allowed them to receive donated income free of tax; the business offset the expenditure against its corporation tax liability; the owners (also directors) did not declare the payments as a benefit in kind; tax was either avoided or exempted by all three of the parties; the auditors - much though they didn't want to - knew all about it. And I know they did because I told them. In the scheme of things, this anecdote is just one tiny flake in a whole blizzard of under-the-counter patronage and avoidance.
These are the kind of issues that do need addressing, but preferably rationally, not emotively, and by someone with a bit more credibility than Diane Abbott. Personally I have no issues at all with people sending their children to private schools; I do have a problem with certain schools being an automatic conduit to power and influence, but that's a different argument. Unfortunately we don't have the climate for forensic, rational scrutiny and debate; not in politics, not in the media.
I have never understood why public schools have charitable status unless they give bursaries to gifted children and somehow I can’t imagine Eaton or Harrow accepting children from sink estates.
You are correct, the ‘Old School Tie’ shame is a different topic. I know it’s not PC to think it now but I still believe that the abolishment of the majority of Grammar schools, which did accept kids from poorer backgrounds if the were cleaver enough, has hindered social mobility. Grand and noble idea that comprehensive schooling is, I believe that they round down to the mean rather than lift up the capable.
I feel that's a fair assesment of grammar schools but to play devils advocate, they weren't without problems. If we were to reintroduce them, how do you guarantee that a two-tier state education system doesn't arise again which was one of the main issues with grammars. On top of that, grammar schools do have issues with social mobility as well. Wealthier parents are able to pay for private tuition to give their children an advantage with regards to getting into grammar schools. Whether that's as bad as the postcode lotteries of comprehensive schools, I'm not sure.
Ultimately I feel as though the reforms needed in the education system aren't as easily addressed by just bringing back grammar schools. The biggest focus being a mentality change for me is to focus on teaching and understand the content instead of teaching to pass exams, though how you do that I'm not sure. Of coarse you are correct, the Grammar school system wasn’t without faults. Cost for uniforms and extra curricular activities, which pupils were expected to do was a burden for lower working class parents was one.
We still have a two tier system really, even within individual MATs. I know, first hand, of one MAT where a disproportionate amount of budget is creamed off to the two Grammars at the expense of the three other Academies and two ‘ladder’ schools. Fund or lack of isn’t helping. One academy doesn’t give its SEN and Dyslexia dept.s the whole of the money it receives from the local authority which is specifically allocated for their work.
The biggest mind shift we need to make is with parents who need to understand the role they have in helping the school and backing the teachers in helping their children to improve their lot and lift them out of the cycle of the “factory fodder” mentally.
Proper training for teachers is vital. PGCEs isn’t it really. Keeping the talented, Inspirational and experienced teachers in situ and motivated should be the first thing addressed.
Posts: 540
Threads: 32
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
0
(09-27-2019, 12:22 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote: (09-27-2019, 10:58 AM)Ossian Wrote: There are things which need addressing when it comes to the charitable status of private schools; things which should have been addressed long ago by successive governments and The Charity Commission. Here's an example of why...
Some years ago I worked for a very successful privately-owned company. Some of the owners (not all) sent their kids to pretty expensive private schools, paid the fees through the business, rounded up the amount and called it a donation. The charitable status of the schools allowed them to receive donated income free of tax; the business offset the expenditure against its corporation tax liability; the owners (also directors) did not declare the payments as a benefit in kind; tax was either avoided or exempted by all three of the parties; the auditors - much though they didn't want to - knew all about it. And I know they did because I told them. In the scheme of things, this anecdote is just one tiny flake in a whole blizzard of under-the-counter patronage and avoidance.
These are the kind of issues that do need addressing, but preferably rationally, not emotively, and by someone with a bit more credibility than Diane Abbott. Personally I have no issues at all with people sending their children to private schools; I do have a problem with certain schools being an automatic conduit to power and influence, but that's a different argument. Unfortunately we don't have the climate for forensic, rational scrutiny and debate; not in politics, not in the media.
I have never understood why public schools have charitable status unless they give bursaries to gifted children and somehow I can’t imagine Eaton or Harrow accepting children from sink estates.
You are correct, the ‘Old School Tie’ shame is a different topic. I know it’s not PC to think it now but I still believe that the abolishment of the majority of Grammar schools, which did accept kids from poorer backgrounds if the were cleaver enough, has hindered social mobility. Grand and noble idea that comprehensive schooling is, I believe that they round down to the mean rather than lift up the capable.
The number of kids on full bursaries at Eton was quoted as being 80 on the Beeb last week - they didn't give any more details about where they were from though.
Posts: 230
Threads: 11
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
0
(09-27-2019, 10:50 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (09-27-2019, 10:04 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote: (09-27-2019, 07:57 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (09-27-2019, 07:21 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote: Had it been about a Conservative front bencher I can think of one person who would have been posting on here sharpish, with his usual vitriolic sarcasm and bile. 
Tell me in the grand scheme of things currently why disliking Diane Abbott (an odd obsession of middle aged men I’ve noticed) is important to what is happening in government?
You’re going to have outline the positive merits of the Conservative Front bench to me. Is the list as long as the merits of Brexit?
Btw I’m not the BBC I don’t have a remit to be neutral or report equally sensible, rational arguments and idiotic ones used by people such as Farage etc. If you or other wish to defend the current government you are free to do so. You will have to point me in the direction of where I have “defended” the current government.
Can’t say I have noticed the derision of Abbott is restricted to “middle aged men”. Many of the young left leaning comedians, who’s continual lambasting of Brexit, I assume, you approve of wholeheartedly, knock her.
No, you don’t have to be neutral. I just like to point out your hypocrisy and total blinkered bias. And no, I do not have to point out the merits of any politician but I will redress your bias. If that means defending someone else’s perfect right to post negativity about one of your favourite babes, incompetent, racist, hypocritical and innumerate though she is, I am free to do that.
My babe? Erm I was asking the relevance of the thread currently. It seems utterly pointless to me. I think from your steadfast refusal to admit Brexiteers are using wartime vernacular is a good barometer of your awareness of who and what is happening and who is doing / saying what.
There is no hypocrisy to my posts on Brexit I haven’t said I was neutral, I haven’t defended the indefensible and if you can point me to a thread where I have please do. I’ve asked you this regarding several points you make against me and you haven’t supplied one link.
Who are you going to vote for at the next election? I can’t see who it can be other that Johnson or Farage...
There you go again. You are totally fixated with bleedin Brexit. The OP and my response was about a politician only. Europe was not mentioned.
As regards linking; there was a request for you to do the same in my very last post. And not for the first time. No such link. Pot, kettle , black.
There are scores of threads on here which have little relevance to anything. It’s just down to individual poster’s whims. You didn’t “ask the relevance “ of the thread. Questions start with the five masters and are punctuated with a question mark. You made a snidey comment just because the post wasn’t attacking Brexit or your reviled Conservatives. Anyway, surely the relative absence of a major shadow cabinet member from the front line (sorry, War reference again. Strange how we don’t have figures of speech from any other activity.) is of deep relevance.
Your touchiness on the subject can be seen as I made no indication of who I meant but you immediately jumped in on the ,aggressive, defensive as usual.
So, you can’t see any other alternative to who you KNOW who I am going to vote for. Perhaps that’s an indication to you that you are not as insightful as you like to think.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(09-27-2019, 06:58 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote: (09-27-2019, 10:50 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (09-27-2019, 10:04 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote: (09-27-2019, 07:57 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (09-27-2019, 07:21 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote: Had it been about a Conservative front bencher I can think of one person who would have been posting on here sharpish, with his usual vitriolic sarcasm and bile. 
Tell me in the grand scheme of things currently why disliking Diane Abbott (an odd obsession of middle aged men I’ve noticed) is important to what is happening in government?
You’re going to have outline the positive merits of the Conservative Front bench to me. Is the list as long as the merits of Brexit?
Btw I’m not the BBC I don’t have a remit to be neutral or report equally sensible, rational arguments and idiotic ones used by people such as Farage etc. If you or other wish to defend the current government you are free to do so. You will have to point me in the direction of where I have “defended” the current government.
Can’t say I have noticed the derision of Abbott is restricted to “middle aged men”. Many of the young left leaning comedians, who’s continual lambasting of Brexit, I assume, you approve of wholeheartedly, knock her.
No, you don’t have to be neutral. I just like to point out your hypocrisy and total blinkered bias. And no, I do not have to point out the merits of any politician but I will redress your bias. If that means defending someone else’s perfect right to post negativity about one of your favourite babes, incompetent, racist, hypocritical and innumerate though she is, I am free to do that.
My babe? Erm I was asking the relevance of the thread currently. It seems utterly pointless to me. I think from your steadfast refusal to admit Brexiteers are using wartime vernacular is a good barometer of your awareness of who and what is happening and who is doing / saying what.
There is no hypocrisy to my posts on Brexit I haven’t said I was neutral, I haven’t defended the indefensible and if you can point me to a thread where I have please do. I’ve asked you this regarding several points you make against me and you haven’t supplied one link.
Who are you going to vote for at the next election? I can’t see who it can be other that Johnson or Farage...
There you go again. You are totally fixated with bleedin Brexit. The OP and my response was about a politician only. Europe was not mentioned.
As regards linking; there was a request for you to do the same in my very last post. And not for the first time. No such link. Pot, kettle , black.
There are scores of threads on here which have little relevance to anything. It’s just down to individual poster’s whims. You didn’t “ask the relevance “ of the thread. Questions start with the five masters and are punctuated with a question mark. You made a snidey comment just because the post wasn’t attacking Brexit or your reviled Conservatives. Anyway, surely the relative absence of a major shadow cabinet member from the front line (sorry, War reference again. Strange how we don’t have figures of speech from any other activity.) is of deep relevance.
Your touchiness on the subject can be seen as I made no indication of who I meant but you immediately jumped in on the ,aggressive, defensive as usual.
So, you can’t see any other alternative to who you KNOW who I am going to vote for. Perhaps that’s an indication to you that you are not as insightful as you like to think.
Gobbledygook
Posts: 230
Threads: 11
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
0
(09-27-2019, 07:02 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (09-27-2019, 06:58 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote: (09-27-2019, 10:50 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: My babe? Erm I was asking the relevance of the thread currently. It seems utterly pointless to me. I think from your steadfast refusal to admit Brexiteers are using wartime vernacular is a good barometer of your awareness of who and what is happening and who is doing / saying what.
There is no hypocrisy to my posts on Brexit I haven’t said I was neutral, I haven’t defended the indefensible and if you can point me to a thread where I have please do. I’ve asked you this regarding several points you make against me and you haven’t supplied one link.
Who are you going to vote for at the next election? I can’t see who it can be other that Johnson or Farage...
There you go again. You are totally fixated with bleedin Brexit. The OP and my response was about a politician only. Europe was not mentioned.
As regards linking; there was a request for you to do the same in my very last post. And not for the first time. No such link. Pot, kettle , black.
There are scores of threads on here which have little relevance to anything. It’s just down to individual poster’s whims. You didn’t “ask the relevance “ of the thread. Questions start with the five masters and are punctuated with a question mark. You made a snidey comment just because the post wasn’t attacking Brexit or your reviled Conservatives. Anyway, surely the relative absence of a major shadow cabinet member from the front line (sorry, War reference again. Strange how we don’t have figures of speech from any other activity.) is of deep relevance.
Your touchiness on the subject can be seen as I made no indication of who I meant but you immediately jumped in on the ,aggressive, defensive as usual.
So, you can’t see any other alternative to who you KNOW who I am going to vote for. Perhaps that’s an indication to you that you are not as insightful as you like to think.
Gobbledygook That’s a very constructive and mature response. Still, I should take it as a compliment. As you are enamoured of experts, to have you describe my post as specialist jargon shows appreciation on your part.
I await your next incisive response.
|