Bernado Silva "Racism"
#31
(09-24-2019, 12:13 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-24-2019, 10:28 AM)Statto Wrote: I used to know a lad through football whose nickname was and still is “soft/softy” because he looked like Mr Soft from the TV adverts in his teens.

As a white man, looking like an advert for sweets would not be be considered racist, but a black man looking like an advert for sweets apparently is.

The PC stupidity of the early 90’s was bad enough, but the faux outrage desperate to be offended culture of today’s social media age boils my fucking piss.

This world truly doesn’t have a fucking prayer.

The point is that throughout the last 100years or so, black people have been compared to cartoon characters unfavourably and as a method of ridicule, which always aims at making them look inferior - usually as stupid / lazy / devious / predatory - to white people, or as a child or childlike character. It’s the same with Asian characters in 1800s comics and times of the Raj, or even how Jews were represented in Nazi storybooks for children.

White people don’t get cast in the same way. The inferiority / superiority dynamic is key. It’s why it’s very difficult for a white person to claim racism. It’s not a case of everyone being equal, it’s a subtle difference of everyone being equal to white people.

I’m absolutely certain Bernardo Silva isn’t racist, and he was just messing about with his mate - after all Mendy is a multi-millionaire celebrity footballer who is very unlikely to experience racism outside of a few dickheads chanting in an Eastern European CL match, but there will be people who may feel the comparison of a black person to that kind of character is offensive - though the press and those reacting on social media are unlikely to be, or be remotely representative, of those people.

It was silly, a little careless, and probably doesn’t offend anyone but in this day and age, footballers need to be savvier.

Bang on

(09-24-2019, 01:18 PM)Ed Hopper Wrote: I wouldn’t agree that it’s hard for a white person to claim racism-when I’m being hassled for money at a bus stop in town being called a White Pussy Bitch it feels pretty racist to me!

Sorry about that chief. I was in a rush and the chippy was about to shut
Reply
#32
(09-24-2019, 01:18 PM)Ed Hopper Wrote: I wouldn’t agree that it’s hard for a white person to claim racism-when I’m being hassled for money at a bus stop in town being called a White Pussy Bitch it feels pretty racist to me!

Being called a white pussy bitch isn't racist, it's just offensive.

Calling someone a black pussy bitch wouldn't realistically be racist either, unless of course you attribute calling someone black as an inferiority term. 

But, again, people of all colours don't understand racism, and some will cry it more often than others... and the lack of understanding prevents debate and education.
Reply
#33
(09-24-2019, 12:13 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-24-2019, 10:28 AM)Statto Wrote: I used to know a lad through football whose nickname was and still is “soft/softy” because he looked like Mr Soft from the TV adverts in his teens.

As a white man, looking like an advert for sweets would not be be considered racist, but a black man looking like an advert for sweets apparently is.

The PC stupidity of the early 90’s was bad enough, but the faux outrage desperate to be offended culture of today’s social media age boils my fucking piss.

This world truly doesn’t have a fucking prayer.

The point is that throughout the last 100years or so, black people have been compared to cartoon characters unfavourably and as a method of ridicule, which always aims at making them look inferior - usually as stupid / lazy / devious / predatory - to white people, or as a child or childlike character. It’s the same with Asian characters in 1800s comics and times of the Raj, or even how Jews were represented in Nazi storybooks for children.

White people don’t get cast in the same way. The inferiority / superiority dynamic is key. It’s why it’s very difficult for a white person to claim racism. It’s not a case of everyone being equal, it’s a subtle difference of everyone being equal to white people.

I’m absolutely certain Bernardo Silva isn’t racist, and he was just messing about with his mate - after all Mendy is a multi-millionaire celebrity footballer who is very unlikely to experience racism outside of a few dickheads chanting in an Eastern European CL match, but there will be people who may feel the comparison of a black person to that kind of character is offensive - though the press and those reacting on social media are unlikely to be, or be remotely representative, of those people.

It was silly, a little careless, and probably doesn’t offend anyone but in this day and age, footballers need to be savvier.
What I was trying to say on the other racism thread. But better put!
It's a power relationship. And those of us (white) people who've never experienced it struggle to get it.
Reply
#34
Rowley’s Coconut loves it.
Reply
#35
Silva is a fool to go 'public'. Has he heard of private messaging? Although context is everything, I would never send anything like that to any person of colour, be they Black etc. When I saw that, I thought what the fuck is he doing. If he's ignorant, well he ought too educate himself.

(09-24-2019, 05:38 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(09-24-2019, 12:13 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-24-2019, 10:28 AM)Statto Wrote: I used to know a lad through football whose nickname was and still is “soft/softy” because he looked like Mr Soft from the TV adverts in his teens.

As a white man, looking like an advert for sweets would not be be considered racist, but a black man looking like an advert for sweets apparently is.

The PC stupidity of the early 90’s was bad enough, but the faux outrage desperate to be offended culture of today’s social media age boils my fucking piss.

This world truly doesn’t have a fucking prayer.

The point is that throughout the last 100years or so, black people have been compared to cartoon characters unfavourably and as a method of ridicule, which always aims at making them look inferior - usually as stupid / lazy / devious / predatory - to white people, or as a child or childlike character. It’s the same with Asian characters in 1800s comics and times of the Raj, or even how Jews were represented in Nazi storybooks for children.

White people don’t get cast in the same way. The inferiority / superiority dynamic is key. It’s why it’s very difficult for a white person to claim racism. It’s not a case of everyone being equal, it’s a subtle difference of everyone being equal to white people.

I’m absolutely certain Bernardo Silva isn’t racist, and he was just messing about with his mate - after all Mendy is a multi-millionaire celebrity footballer who is very unlikely to experience racism outside of a few dickheads chanting in an Eastern European CL match, but there will be people who may feel the comparison of a black person to that kind of character is offensive - though the press and those reacting on social media are unlikely to be, or be remotely representative, of those people.

It was silly, a little careless, and probably doesn’t offend anyone but in this day and age, footballers need to be savvier.
What I was trying to say on the other racism thread. But better put!
It's a power relationship. And those of us (white) people who've never experienced it struggle to get it.

Bang on the button, Johnnie Kaye.
Reply
#36
'Guardiola defends Silva over Mendy tweet '

http://www.skysports.com/share/11818876

Interesting stance from Pep
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#37
Well, I suppose he wants it swept under the carpet.
Reply
#38
(09-24-2019, 01:51 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-24-2019, 01:18 PM)Ed Hopper Wrote: I wouldn’t agree that it’s hard for a white person to claim racism-when I’m being hassled for money at a bus stop in town being called a White Pussy Bitch it feels pretty racist to me!

Being called a white pussy bitch isn't racist, it's just offensive.

Calling someone a black pussy bitch wouldn't realistically be racist either, unless of course you attribute calling someone black as an inferiority term. 

But, again, people of all colours don't understand racism, and some will cry it more often than others... and the lack of understanding prevents debate and education.

If the pussy bitch part isn't suggestive of superiority and the addition of colour before it, isn't racist then I don't know what is.

Is a white bloke walking through Small Heath at night and having a car load of men of Asian origin shouting at you 'no whites allowed, Get back to your own place', and other colourful language, along with suggestions of violence towards you, is that racist? I'd say it was.
Reply
#39
I remember after an England game, Gascoigne looking at Paul Ince with a white bandage on his head and saying he looked like a pint of Guinness. Ince, whose not noted for his affability, couldn't stop laughing.
We don't want to go back to the awful, 'Love thy Neighbour' days, but  we're in danger of over reacting at every possible opportunity.
Silva was wrong to post the message on social media but I'd bet that Mendy has had many a pop at his mate, some of which outsiders would be quick to find offensive.
Reply
#40
(09-23-2019, 04:09 PM)Ossian Wrote: We christened Darren Moore 'Big Dave' on a roughly equivalent basis; I doubt he was ever offended or suspicious of the motivation behind it.

According to those who know, context is supposed to be everything.

Not forgetting 'The 3 Degrees' too of course!!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: