Thomas Cook
#41
(09-23-2019, 02:07 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 01:24 PM)billybassett Wrote: Not once did I say Brexit hasn't had an impact a weakening pound will have had an affect. But that wasn't THE reason it went bust. Christ. You commented that it was just down to Brexit and I picked you up on it.

Now you cede those points that it wasn't just Brexit. Well done for keeping up. You then add that Brexit pushed them over the edge. Nowhere have analysts said that the weakened £ pushed them over the edge. Again it is a combination of factors the biggest being over 10 years accumulating so much debt, through a defunct operating model; that their revenue has been unable to service. 

I'm a remainer sunshine so put you're pipe back in it's box..

And what you'll find is that with the points made I'll step back and agree that a weak business model was the main reason for all of their woes and it is my error about blaming the weak pound because of Brexit, albeit contributing to their demise earlier than otherwise.

It is obvious that the weak pound put their costs up by 10 - 15% pa which will be about £150m, and it also is a fact that without Brexit the pound wouldn't have weakened so much. My original point was badly worded and knee jerk due to people completely dismissing Brexit as contributory.

In the meantime I don't need to grow any balls, keep up, put my pipe back in my box or learn the appropriate use of 'your'. The one weakness in your aggressive argument is that I stated it ae THE (capital letters as well) reason was Brexit, I didn't say that, I was commenting on people saying it's purely down to using an app whilst having a shit and nothing to do with Brexit.

Next time wind yer neck in with the insults, the keyboard warrior look is so 2005.

(09-23-2019, 01:47 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 11:13 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 09:55 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 09:47 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: This is what happens when you have high street overheads and people can package up their own holiday on an app whilst having a dump, more like.

Exactly, but eh ho many will claim it's Brexit's fault.... gotta spread the fear! Most experts have said similar, people can sort their own holidays out these days just as easy as going to a shop and paying extra for it to be sorted for you.

Yeah it's nothing to do with companies budgeting at €1.20 to the pound when and it dropping to €1.09 because of the fucking shambles that is Brexit, it's all to do with people booking holidays using an app.

It doesn't take a rocket scientist to work out that when your major market is Europe and £1.5bn of your turnover is from that market that you will take a hit if the £ drops 10%.

Head in the fucking sand

Why have they been posting 9 figure losses for the last 6 years, then?

For the hard of reading, cash flow is the reason they have gone under - higher costs because of a weak pound are the final straw. 

Losses over the last few years are a combination of Terrorism fears, Weak £ following Brexit, market changes (no trips to Egypt for instance) and a lot of other issues including bad management. The weak £ bit is completely self inflicted following Brexit and as I've shown, without that, they have had the £200m needed to stay afloat.

Would they have stayed afloat for much longer, who knows - what with terrorism fears receding, if the pound had been stronger, public confidence growing, they might have done. All travel firms work on very tight margins, any knocks will affect them, and IMO Brexit has pushed them over the edge.

They have had 3 years to plan and consider the impact of brexit , they appear to have had the equivalent of Boris running operations and Corbyn looking after credit control
Reply
#42
(09-23-2019, 12:25 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I think you need to get closer to the screen JOK

Let's be clear again on this one JOK - is this business model sustainable? No. Would it have gone under eventually? Probably unless they changed their approach given time.

Now as I can cede both of those points and also say that this is not all down to Brexit, can the Brexiteers on here cede that Brexit has definitely had an impact that has pushed them over the edge.
No B1, what I need is a decent iPad and this one is only 18 months old. I have to compose my posts on Notebook then email it to myself (‘cause if I copy and paste from NP onto here I get all that gobbledygook) then copy and paste from email. Dodgy And don’t mention images.

Anyway, back to the plot.
Is Brexit responsible for the massive write down of value Thomas Cook had to do due to the greatly overpriced purchase of My Travel a couple of years ago? TUI have the same situation with the pound (and fluctuations in currencies is an age old problem anyway) and with customers ‘panicking ‘ about Brexit but they are still operating. 
My post was a response to the, more or less, “Brexit is to blame”, or Thos. Cook’s demise is solely the fault of Brexit voters “ posts.  Can you cede one more point? There are some posters on here who are, not just blinkered, but blind when it comes to blaming everything negative on Brexit. Even though the vast majority of ‘predictions ‘ haven’t happened yet.
Reply
#43
(09-23-2019, 02:34 PM)Beano Wrote: They have had 3 years to plan and consider the impact of brexit , they appear to have had the equivalent of Boris running operations and Corbyn looking after credit control

If only it was that easy Beano, if something costs more then you can do one of three things:

Stop buying it - not really an option, they need to buy holidays to be able to sell them.

Pass the cost onto the customer - they tried this, holidays have gone up this last year or so, but unfortunately we're all struggling with a weak pound and can't afford to spend. They sold something like 60% of their holidays this year, putting the price up wouldn't have helped that figure

Take the hit - looks like this was the way they ended up with.

The problem is you cannot plan for things out of their control, the weakening pound is out of their control.

(09-23-2019, 02:39 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 12:25 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I think you need to get closer to the screen JOK

Let's be clear again on this one JOK - is this business model sustainable? No. Would it have gone under eventually? Probably unless they changed their approach given time.

Now as I can cede both of those points and also say that this is not all down to Brexit, can the Brexiteers on here cede that Brexit has definitely had an impact that has pushed them over the edge.
No B1, what I need is a decent iPad and this one is only 18 months old. I have to compose my posts on Notebook then email it to myself (‘cause if I copy and paste from NP onto here I get all that gobbledygook) then copy and paste from email. Dodgy And don’t mention images.

Anyway, back to the plot.
Is Brexit responsible for the massive write down of value Thomas Cook had to do due to the greatly overpriced purchase of My Travel a couple of years ago? TUI have the same situation with the pound (and fluctuations in currencies is an age old problem anyway) and with customers ‘panicking ‘ about Brexit but they are still operating. 
My post was a response to the, more or less, “Brexit is to blame”, or Thos. Cook’s demise is solely the fault of Brexit voters “ posts.  Can you cede one more point? There are some posters on here who are, not just blinkered, but blind when it comes to blaming everything negative on Brexit. Even though the vast majority of ‘predictions ‘ haven’t happened yet.

As said above their operating model is going to be the reason for them being a shit business, the weak pound has pushed them over the edge. TUI are insulated against this as they are not solely a UK operation, they are part German. 

And I'll agree that there are posters on here from both sides that are blinkered and that is why this country is fucked at the moment. Another reason why Brexit was a bad idea  Tongue
Reply
#44
(09-23-2019, 02:41 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 02:39 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 12:25 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
No B1, what I need is a decent iPad and this one is only 18 months old. I have to compose my posts on Notebook then email it to myself (‘cause if I copy and paste from NP onto here I get all that gobbledygook) then copy and paste from email. Dodgy And don’t mention images.

Anyway, back to the plot.
Is Brexit responsible for the massive write down of value Thomas Cook had to do due to the greatly overpriced purchase of My Travel a couple of years ago? TUI have the same situation with the pound (and fluctuations in currencies is an age old problem anyway) and with customers ‘panicking ‘ about Brexit but they are still operating. 
My post was a response to the, more or less, “Brexit is to blame”, or Thos. Cook’s demise is solely the fault of Brexit voters “ posts.  Can you cede one more point? There are some posters on here who are, not just blinkered, but blind when it comes to blaming everything negative on Brexit. Even though the vast majority of ‘predictions ‘ haven’t happened yet.

As said above their operating model is going to be the reason for them being a shit business, the weak pound has pushed them over the edge. TUI are insulated against this as they are not solely a UK operation, they are part German. 

And I'll agree that there are posters on here from both sides that are blinkered and that is why this country is fucked at the moment. Another reason why Brexit was a bad idea  Tongue
You can’t let it lie can you Tommy. Wink
Reply
#45
(09-23-2019, 02:41 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 02:34 PM)Beano Wrote: They have had 3 years to plan and consider the impact of brexit , they appear to have had the equivalent of Boris running operations and Corbyn looking after credit control

If only it was that easy Beano, if something costs more then you can do one of three things:

Stop buying it - not really an option, they need to buy holidays to be able to sell them.

Pass the cost onto the customer - they tried this, holidays have gone up this last year or so, but unfortunately we're all struggling with a weak pound and can't afford to spend. They sold something like 60% of their holidays this year, putting the price up wouldn't have helped that figure

Take the hit - looks like this was the way they ended up with.

The problem is you cannot plan for things out of their control, the weakening pound is out of their control.

(09-23-2019, 02:39 PM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 12:25 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I think you need to get closer to the screen JOK

Let's be clear again on this one JOK - is this business model sustainable? No. Would it have gone under eventually? Probably unless they changed their approach given time.

Now as I can cede both of those points and also say that this is not all down to Brexit, can the Brexiteers on here cede that Brexit has definitely had an impact that has pushed them over the edge.
No B1, what I need is a decent iPad and this one is only 18 months old. I have to compose my posts on Notebook then email it to myself (‘cause if I copy and paste from NP onto here I get all that gobbledygook) then copy and paste from email. Dodgy And don’t mention images.

Anyway, back to the plot.
Is Brexit responsible for the massive write down of value Thomas Cook had to do due to the greatly overpriced purchase of My Travel a couple of years ago? TUI have the same situation with the pound (and fluctuations in currencies is an age old problem anyway) and with customers ‘panicking ‘ about Brexit but they are still operating. 
My post was a response to the, more or less, “Brexit is to blame”, or Thos. Cook’s demise is solely the fault of Brexit voters “ posts.  Can you cede one more point? There are some posters on here who are, not just blinkered, but blind when it comes to blaming everything negative on Brexit. Even though the vast majority of ‘predictions ‘ haven’t happened yet.

As said above their operating model is going to be the reason for them being a shit business, the weak pound has pushed them over the edge. TUI are insulated against this as they are not solely a UK operation, they are part German. 

And I'll agree that there are posters on here from both sides that are blinkered and that is why this country is fucked at the moment. Another reason why Brexit was a bad idea  Tongue

I've read analyst articles suggesting Brexit was the only reason they got additional funding over the past 3 years and that without Brexit they'd have gone bump 2 years ago.
Reply
#46
I'd read that somewhere between both stories if the truth be known BB, because of Brexit it could be seen that with a stronger pound the cashflow would have been positive and that is the reason they got extra funding (because the funders could see it was potentially just a bump in the road), but with Brexit showing no end in sight the lenders decided enough was enough.

Whichever way - the additional funding was only in place to get through Brexit. Without Brexit, it wouldn't have been needed in the 1st place.
Reply
#47
Thomas Cook's issues stem with them taking on loads of debt during a merger 10 years ago. Other factors will have of course influenced that but that is the underlying reason and they were doomed the minute they agreed to take on the debt.
Reply
#48
(09-23-2019, 02:07 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 01:24 PM)billybassett Wrote: Not once did I say Brexit hasn't had an impact a weakening pound will have had an affect. But that wasn't THE reason it went bust. Christ. You commented that it was just down to Brexit and I picked you up on it.

Now you cede those points that it wasn't just Brexit. Well done for keeping up. You then add that Brexit pushed them over the edge. Nowhere have analysts said that the weakened £ pushed them over the edge. Again it is a combination of factors the biggest being over 10 years accumulating so much debt, through a defunct operating model; that their revenue has been unable to service. 

I'm a remainer sunshine so put you're pipe back in it's box..

And what you'll find is that with the points made I'll step back and agree that a weak business model was the main reason for all of their woes and it is my error about blaming the weak pound because of Brexit, albeit contributing to their demise earlier than otherwise.

It is obvious that the weak pound put their costs up by 10 - 15% pa which will be about £150m, and it also is a fact that without Brexit the pound wouldn't have weakened so much. My original point was badly worded and knee jerk due to people completely dismissing Brexit as contributory.

In the meantime I don't need to grow any balls, keep up, put my pipe back in my box or learn the appropriate use of 'your'. The one weakness in your aggressive argument is that I stated it ae THE (capital letters as well) reason was Brexit, I didn't say that, I was commenting on people saying it's purely down to using an app whilst having a shit and nothing to do with Brexit.

Next time wind yer neck in with the insults, the keyboard warrior look is so 2005.

(09-23-2019, 01:47 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 11:13 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 09:55 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(09-23-2019, 09:47 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: This is what happens when you have high street overheads and people can package up their own holiday on an app whilst having a dump, more like.

Exactly, but eh ho many will claim it's Brexit's fault.... gotta spread the fear! Most experts have said similar, people can sort their own holidays out these days just as easy as going to a shop and paying extra for it to be sorted for you.

Yeah it's nothing to do with companies budgeting at €1.20 to the pound when and it dropping to €1.09 because of the fucking shambles that is Brexit, it's all to do with people booking holidays using an app.

It doesn't take a rocket scientist to work out that when your major market is Europe and £1.5bn of your turnover is from that market that you will take a hit if the £ drops 10%.

Head in the fucking sand

Why have they been posting 9 figure losses for the last 6 years, then?

For the hard of reading, cash flow is the reason they have gone under - higher costs because of a weak pound are the final straw. 

Losses over the last few years are a combination of Terrorism fears, Weak £ following Brexit, market changes (no trips to Egypt for instance) and a lot of other issues including bad management. The weak £ bit is completely self inflicted following Brexit and as I've shown, without that, they have had the £200m needed to stay afloat.

Would they have stayed afloat for much longer, who knows - what with terrorism fears receding, if the pound had been stronger, public confidence growing, they might have done. All travel firms work on very tight margins, any knocks will affect them, and IMO Brexit has pushed them over the edge.

Not many firms £1.9bn in the hole have cash knocking about...

Their current assets/liabilities ratio has consistently been around 1:2 since 2015. They were insolvent and have been for ages, whilst their business model is outdated and obsolete, Brexit or no Brexit.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)