09-22-2019, 07:48 AM
The problem with XAR is that its primary result to date is to solve a problem that didn't exist.
Prior to VAR no one was complaining about goals like Son's being awarded, everyone would have accepted the decision to award the goal without any controversy. It appears to me that rather than reducing controversial decisions it is just increasing them.
VAR is always going to struggle to exist in a sport where so many of the incidents that a referee has to adjudicate on are subjective. VAR has just added for these decisions another layer of subjectivity - was it a clear and obvious error.
Prior to VAR no one was complaining about goals like Son's being awarded, everyone would have accepted the decision to award the goal without any controversy. It appears to me that rather than reducing controversial decisions it is just increasing them.
VAR is always going to struggle to exist in a sport where so many of the incidents that a referee has to adjudicate on are subjective. VAR has just added for these decisions another layer of subjectivity - was it a clear and obvious error.

