Love/Hate
#11
(09-09-2019, 10:56 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(09-09-2019, 08:07 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote:
(09-08-2019, 09:06 PM)B36baggie Wrote: Irish underworld tv drama. Made for Irish tv but accessible here. Anyone watched it? 

Best thing I have watched in god knows how long & haven’t heard a mumour over here. Pis*es all over your Peaky Blinders nonsense.

Am I the only one who thinks it's massively overrated?

Peaky Blinders?

Nope - not yet watched this series but having watched all the others I'd say it's a good TV series but not a great like GoT, Band Of Brothers or Breaking Bad.  The fact it's British probably cranks up the hyperbole around it.

I've heard there's a legal battle between the brewers and the BBC around the use of the name.  Repainting of the ground coming soon!
I believe it's a lost cause. Apparently a few companies got ahead with copyrights on variants of the name and there isn't anything can be done about it. Reckon it's success took the writers by surprise.
Reply
#12
(09-09-2019, 04:05 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-09-2019, 10:56 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(09-09-2019, 08:07 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote:
(09-08-2019, 09:06 PM)B36baggie Wrote: Irish underworld tv drama. Made for Irish tv but accessible here. Anyone watched it? 

Best thing I have watched in god knows how long & haven’t heard a mumour over here. Pis*es all over your Peaky Blinders nonsense.

Am I the only one who thinks it's massively overrated?

Peaky Blinders?

Nope - not yet watched this series but having watched all the others I'd say it's a good TV series but not a great like GoT, Band Of Brothers or Breaking Bad.  The fact it's British probably cranks up the hyperbole around it.

I've heard there's a legal battle between the brewers and the BBC around the use of the name.  Repainting of the ground coming soon!
I believe it's a lost cause. Apparently a few companies got ahead with copyrights on variants of the name and there isn't anything can be done about it. Reckon it's success took the writers by surprise.

Halewood having taken over Sadler's are having a battle with BBC but I'm told are reasonably confident in winning.  I believe Sadler's approached the BBC at the beginning and have agreement to use the name etc.  As you say the success has took them all by surprise.
Reply
#13
Wasn't peaky blinders an actual gang? I can't imagine the BBC can sue them for using a name that wasn't theirs in the first place. If they used the likeness, or more tenuously, the style/logo, they might have a problem, but for the name itself, unlikely. 

As it is, I would imagine the brewery would say they are drawing inspiration from the original gang - in exactly the same way as the BBC have!

I'm going with the consensus, if they had thought it was going to be a huge success they should have used a fictitious name. 

The 'Sopranos' did exactly this, getting inspiration from a real-life gang, but changing the name.

I know you can get copyright for 'popularising' a concept - Apple has done it - but it is very hard in practice and would cost a fortune to enforce. And you would still probably lose. It wouldn't even slightly be worth the taxpayers' money.

A lesson for all you budding scriptwriters out there!

(If there wasn't such a gang and I've got it wrong, I would imagine the brewery's screwed!)
Reply
#14
HOPEFULLY SOME1 AT THE EVENING MALE WILL RIGHT A STORY ON THE REAL PEAKY BLINDERS 1 DAY
Reply
#15
I think the 'evening male' will be very confused that you asked them to bring someone over to write about the peaky blinders. They might be able to do a bit of 'role play', though
Reply
#16
(09-09-2019, 04:55 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: Wasn't peaky blinders an actual gang? I can't imagine the BBC can sue them for using a name that wasn't theirs in the first place. If they used the likeness, or more tenuously, the style/logo, they might have a problem, but for the name itself, unlikely. 

As it is, I would imagine the brewery would say they are drawing inspiration from the original gang - in exactly the same way as the BBC have!

I'm going with the consensus, if they had thought it was going to be a huge success they would have used a fictitious name. 

The 'Sopranos' did exactly this, getting inspiration from a real-life gang, but changing the name.

I know you can get copyright for 'popularising' a concept - Apple has done it  - but it is very hard in practice and would cost a fortune to enforce. And you would still probably lose. It wouldn't even slightly be worth the taxpayers' money.

A lesson for all you budding scriptwriters out there!

(If there wasn't such a gang and I've got it wrong, I would imagine the brewery's screwed!)

Thought the same too.
Reply
#17
(09-09-2019, 05:31 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: It's all just a bit amateur. They've made a mistake, which frankly, they should have known about. I'm actually surprised nobody pointed this out to them - it's pretty standard. I can think of ten examples off the top of my head.

Anyway, to moan about it now is far too late  and just makes you look greedy

It's one of those times you have to be grateful for what you've got, not what you could have had. Otherwise, you will just go crazy and stop enjoying what you've done

They've still got a hit show, which is probably making them a fortune and securing a career for those involved. If they'd have been offered this at the start, they would have given their left nut.

Spot on Fuzzbox, although the writer says he is quite relaxed about things, I would think someone's solicitor has suggested the action, "You have a very strong case, here...." Copyright is first past the post and I believe there are at least 2 companies that have got ahead of the show.
Reply
#18
It's strange.

In my job, the majority of people I work with are far more financially successful than me. Most of them share one thing in common - a refusal to let go of what most people would see as lost causes. The flip side of this is that a lot are very bitter and suspicious and have a tendency to go 'all in' and lose everything - friends, money and respect. Pretty soon they've burnt all their bridges and can never get back. It can be very frustrating to watch when you see all the great things they did to get to where they were.
Reply
#19
(09-08-2019, 09:06 PM)B36baggie Wrote: Irish underworld tv drama. Made for Irish tv but accessible here. Anyone watched it? 

Best thing I have watched in god knows how long & haven’t heard much about it over here. Pis*es all over your Peaky Blinders nonsense.

Can I just thank you for what a great shout this was

Love box sets/series and have seen all the major ones, Sopranos, Wire, GOT, Breaking Bad, Fargo, Boardwalk, Walking Dead, Killing, Bridge etc etc etc and Love/Hate is definitely in the top 5 of all time, great show, brutal, violent, gripping and at times laugh out loud hilarious. I’ve literally watched all 5 series in about 3 weeks, absolute top class TV

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)