Right back.
#41
Hervé Jean-Pierre Villechaize was one of the best I’ve seen at centreback
Reply
#42
(09-02-2019, 07:19 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(09-02-2019, 02:39 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-02-2019, 12:10 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(09-02-2019, 08:08 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-02-2019, 07:05 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Looking at height issues - out of my top 10 ever players only Ronaldo is over 6 ft
Pele, Messi, Cruyff, Beckenbauer, Moore, Eusabio, Charlton,  all under 6 ft.
You could say according to statistics you were more unlikely to be a footballer if you were over 6 ft. that's how stupid the height issue is

Most of those players played 30+ years ago when the average height for a person was shorter than it currently is, and football was a completely different game.

Average height of a PL player is currently 6 feet... if a player has enough talent, they’ll get opportunities regardless of height, but playing as a CB you’re on to a loser when you’re about 5’7/5’8 like Ferguson appears to be

What has playing 30 years ago got to do with it ????? are you saying these players wouldn't walk into any team nowadays even with the fitness levels and flimsy ball they use today???
Of course your not or are you ???  
What I said is if you have the talent and determination height is not a major factor.

Football is a very different game to 30 years ago.... if we're playing that game, these players would probably be a couple of inches taller if they'd been born in time to play these days.

You've also mostly listed attacking players as examples of short players, players who play roles that require very different skills to a centreback... even Moore's reputation was one of a CB who struggled with the aerial side of the game, but his reading of the game made up for it.

I guess if you add your maths to Ferguson's height by being 5'8 he's actually capable to play like a 6'6 player...

You think Moore struggled with the aerial side of the game. Where did you dream that up.
He only captained England to win the World Cup. The greatest achievement by any England player and YOU think he struggled?
That must be the most stupid post on here ever.
I've only listed attacking players ? - that's because they were the best, but just to prove a point and how ridiculous your height theory is try these (all centre backs) Franz Beckenbauer was Germany's best CH and captained them to the winning world cup (5'11") What about Cannavaro 5'7" - Robert Ayala 5'8" - Carlos Puyol 5'7" - Gaetano Scirea 5'8" Danny McGrain 5'8" - Ronald Koeman 5'9" - Billy Wight 5'11" 
I think that's enough under 6 footers who would all walk into any side in any league in the world now.
When you refer to my counting skills it's a clear sign of how much you actually know about football and me.

I guess my counting skills unfortunately include counting back several decades....people 30 years ago were shorter, so comparing footballers from 30 years ago isn’t a fair test. I’m not sure what you find so difficult to grasp about this.

Moore was an excellent player - apparently - I’m too young to have seen him, but as per my previous post, it was generally commented that his reading of the game, positioning and ability on the ball made up for the fact that he was generally not considered to be excellent in the air. 

There is no reason why Ferguson can’t become a decent CB, there are as you rightly say a very limited number of examples where shorter players have managed to make very successful careers overseas and 30years ago as a centre half, but the odds are very much stacked against him, and given he’s being played - and very much excelling - as a full back, where his height won’t be as much of an issue, and where his ability on the ball, and his general pace and attacking instincts are well utilised, my personal opinion is, he will have a better chance of making a career there.
Reply
#43
(09-02-2019, 09:54 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-02-2019, 07:19 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(09-02-2019, 02:39 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-02-2019, 12:10 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(09-02-2019, 08:08 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Most of those players played 30+ years ago when the average height for a person was shorter than it currently is, and football was a completely different game.

Average height of a PL player is currently 6 feet... if a player has enough talent, they’ll get opportunities regardless of height, but playing as a CB you’re on to a loser when you’re about 5’7/5’8 like Ferguson appears to be

What has playing 30 years ago got to do with it ????? are you saying these players wouldn't walk into any team nowadays even with the fitness levels and flimsy ball they use today???
Of course your not or are you ???  
What I said is if you have the talent and determination height is not a major factor.

Football is a very different game to 30 years ago.... if we're playing that game, these players would probably be a couple of inches taller if they'd been born in time to play these days.

You've also mostly listed attacking players as examples of short players, players who play roles that require very different skills to a centreback... even Moore's reputation was one of a CB who struggled with the aerial side of the game, but his reading of the game made up for it.

I guess if you add your maths to Ferguson's height by being 5'8 he's actually capable to play like a 6'6 player...

You think Moore struggled with the aerial side of the game. Where did you dream that up.
He only captained England to win the World Cup. The greatest achievement by any England player and YOU think he struggled?
That must be the most stupid post on here ever.
I've only listed attacking players ? - that's because they were the best, but just to prove a point and how ridiculous your height theory is try these (all centre backs) Franz Beckenbauer was Germany's best CH and captained them to the winning world cup (5'11") What about Cannavaro 5'7" - Robert Ayala 5'8" - Carlos Puyol 5'7" - Gaetano Scirea 5'8" Danny McGrain 5'8" - Ronald Koeman 5'9" - Billy Wight 5'11" 
I think that's enough under 6 footers who would all walk into any side in any league in the world now.
When you refer to my counting skills it's a clear sign of how much you actually know about football and me.

I guess my counting skills unfortunately include counting back several decades....people 30 years ago were shorter, so comparing footballers from 30 years ago isn’t a fair test. I’m not sure what you find so difficult to grasp about this.

Moore was an excellent player - apparently - I’m too young to have seen him, but as per my previous post, it was generally commented that his reading of the game, positioning and ability on the ball made up for the fact that he was generally not considered to be excellent in the air. 

There is no reason why Ferguson can’t become a decent CB, there are as you rightly say a very limited number of examples where shorter players have managed to make very successful careers overseas and 30years ago as a centre half, but the odds are very much stacked against him, and given he’s being played - and very much excelling - as a full back, where his height won’t be as much of an issue, and where his ability on the ball, and his general pace and attacking instincts are well utilised, my personal opinion is, he will have a better chance of making a career there.

I agree with 95% of what your saying, Ferguson is better suited to being a FB  

The players I mentioned from over the last 50 years or so IMO would still walk into any team today and talent would be the over riding factor. If and it's a unknown if Ferguson continues to improve IMO he could play at FB or CH. 

What ever you thought of Moore his legacy will never be surpassed in my lifetime i'm sure of that.

Interestingly as for height, (I can remember Jeff heading goals for fun). It may just be in my imagination but I do feel the percentage of headed goals is far less then it used to be. Strikers even for England ? I can't remember who last scored a headed goal. Where are the wingers who would float balls into the box - they have disappeared. Height is maybe less of an issue then then we are led to believe in the modern game.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: