The best criticism of Johnstone I've heard so far...
#41
(09-01-2019, 05:25 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Two things are as plain as day,
1. Some people have to be whinging about someone, although the target does change.
2. Others don't like a player and continually criticise his performances no matter what.  
While I agree everyone is entitled to a opinion, to criticise your own players shows disrespect for our club.
Johnstone has improved no end this season, his distribution is excellent. He is coming off his line more.
His shop stopping ability has never been in question.
I got a feeling the whingers were starting to point out Gibbs issue, just before his injury.
The season we were relegated Phillips was the target "Heart of a pea" jibes, JRod only scored penalties, Dawson didn't care, Hegazi was rubbish, Bartley was a waste of money and is unreliable, Barry legs had gone, Evans wanted to leave, Rondon was useless, it just goes on and on. Mears was to old, Sako was unfit, HRK is a Donkey, Nyom is useless, Burke can only run fast, Townsend is not good enough for the EFL, Livermore cannot run,
Only Foster is the only good player we have had over the last 3 years? Even he had his critics on occasions.
I don't know why they support our wonderful club.

+1

(though point 2's sub points went on a bit....)
Reply
#42
The plain and simple fact is that if Foster had not left last season we would have gone up!!..and this season why we did not go out and get someone like Hart who was available beggars believe.Jonstone will cost us again how many times has he not conceded a goal??.
Reply
#43
(09-02-2019, 05:36 AM)pindgill Wrote: The plain and simple fact is that if Foster had not left last season we would have gone up!!..and this season why we did not go out and get someone like Hart who was available beggars believe.Jonstone will cost us again how many times has he not conceded a goal??.

Hart is another fine goal keeper, but IMO drops more clangers then SJ hence he was dropped from Citey and England. I still think he's a great keeper - I for one completely understand no goal keeper can save every shot and will make mistakes as he is human. First and foremost if teams defended correctly the goalkeeper has nothing to do.
Reply
#44
(09-02-2019, 05:36 AM)pindgill Wrote: The plain and simple fact is that if Foster had not left last season we would have gone up!!..and this season why we did not go out and get someone like Hart who was available beggars believe.Jonstone will cost us again how many times has he not conceded a goal??.

Plain and simple fact eh? How’s that work then?

Would Foster have stopped the pissing around at the back?
Would Foster have strengthened the midfield?
Would Foster have provided the creativity we were desperate for after Barnes left?
Could Foster take five penalties?
Reply
#45
(09-02-2019, 07:11 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-02-2019, 05:36 AM)pindgill Wrote: The plain and simple fact is that if Foster had not left last season we would have gone up!!..and this season why we did not go out and get someone like Hart who was available beggars believe.Jonstone will cost us again how many times has he not conceded a goal??.

Plain and simple fact eh? How’s that work then?

Would Foster have stopped the pissing around at the back?
Would Foster have strengthened the midfield?
Would Foster have provided the creativity we were desperate for after Barnes left?
Could Foster take five penalties?

If Foster had referee'd the play offs we would have gone up. Big Grin
Reply
#46
(09-02-2019, 07:21 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(09-02-2019, 07:11 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-02-2019, 05:36 AM)pindgill Wrote: The plain and simple fact is that if Foster had not left last season we would have gone up!!..and this season why we did not go out and get someone like Hart who was available beggars believe.Jonstone will cost us again how many times has he not conceded a goal??.

Plain and simple fact eh? How’s that work then?

Would Foster have stopped the pissing around at the back?
Would Foster have strengthened the midfield?
Would Foster have provided the creativity we were desperate for after Barnes left?
Could Foster take five penalties?

If Foster had referee'd the play offs we would have gone up. Big Grin


That probably is the only plain & simple fact.   Rolleyes
Reply
#47
Opinion being stated as fact is never more evident than talking about goalkeepers. The absolute drivel on this thread is laughable, but not surprising.

Last time we were talking about Bialkowski as one of the top keepers in the division. As well as chocolate wrists for our goal v Millwall, has anyone seen the Hull goal from saturday?

Sam Johnstone is comparable the best in this division. It may come as a shock to some when they realise we actually did get relegated, because the goalkeeper is seemingly still expected to be performing at top half prem standard.
Reply
#48
Very good shot stopper
Excellent distribution 

Wretched on crosses
Low on confidence 

The fact remains that SJ has cost us more points this season that he has gained. In judging him as a Championship goalkeeper, NOTHING else matters. I would stick with him for now but he is one more error away from a spell out of the firing line. There is a decent keeper in there but his confidence must be very low
Reply
#49
(09-02-2019, 07:52 AM)Cunningham1979 Wrote: Very good shot stopper
Excellent distribution 

Wretched on crosses
Low on confidence 

The fact remains that SJ has cost us more points this season that he has gained. In judging him as a Championship goalkeeper, NOTHING else matters. I would stick with him for now but he is one more error away from a spell out of the firing line. There is a decent keeper in there but his confidence must be very low

Not sure he has cost us any points actually...

You could question the Millwall goal, but there are plenty of others who need to be blamed in the build up to that goal. 

The only other games we’ve dropped points are at Derby and Reading and he arguably won us a point at Derby with the pen save.

For all the criticism, his errors to date haven’t cost us anything. If we’re looking to apportion blame for us not winning a game, then Zohore and Austin’s open goal misses against Reading and Millwall, and Livermore skying his late chance at Derby are probably more costly than anything SJ has done.
Reply
#50
(09-02-2019, 08:14 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-02-2019, 07:52 AM)Cunningham1979 Wrote: Very good shot stopper
Excellent distribution 

Wretched on crosses
Low on confidence 

The fact remains that SJ has cost us more points this season that he has gained. In judging him as a Championship goalkeeper, NOTHING else matters. I would stick with him for now but he is one more error away from a spell out of the firing line. There is a decent keeper in there but his confidence must be very low

Not sure he has cost us any points actually...

You could question the Millwall goal, but there are plenty of others who need to be blamed in the build up to that goal. 

The only other games we’ve dropped points are at Derby and Reading and he arguably won us a point at Derby with the pen save.

For all the criticism, his errors to date haven’t cost us anything. If we’re looking to apportion blame for us not winning a game, then Zohore and Austin’s open goal misses against Reading and Millwall, and Livermore skying his late chance at Derby are probably more costly than anything SJ has done.

To be fair to Livermore it was a great block by the defender.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)