Posts: 3,808
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
Personally, I feel that there are lots of issues that need looking at. FFP was supposed to make things fair but is easily manipulated, ( selling the stadium to the owner anyone? ). The fit and proper person test is obviously not worth the paper it`s written on, while `big clubs` poaching young players and only paying a small `development fee`is, to me, scandalous.
We went to watch a game in Germany, paid £15 for a ticket, apparently all clubs must have supporter representatives on the board, clubs must assist young players to learn a proffesion outside football, ( think Klinsmann was a qualified mechanic or something ), the downside to this, according to my lad, is that teams like Hamburg, big support etc, can`t compete with Watford for player wages.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(08-26-2019, 11:15 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: Personally, I feel that there are lots of issues that need looking at. FFP was supposed to make things fair but is easily manipulated, ( selling the stadium to the owner anyone? ). The fit and proper person test is obviously not worth the paper it`s written on, while `big clubs` poaching young players and only paying a small `development fee`is, to me, scandalous.
We went to watch a game in Germany, paid £15 for a ticket, apparently all clubs must have supporter representatives on the board, clubs must assist young players to learn a proffesion outside football, ( think Klinsmann was a qualified mechanic or something ), the downside to this, according to my lad, is that teams like Hamburg, big support etc, can`t compete with Watford for player wages.
Yup...
Outside investors into German clubs can only own 49% of a club, with the remainder having to be under fan control. There are a couple of exceptions, in that Wolfsburg are owned by VW for example, and recently the rules have been amended so that Leipzig and Hoffenheim can have benefactors, but they have had to prove long term associations and voting rights to their FA who are far sterner. The only way anyone can take financial control of a club is to demonstrate long term best interests, not just show up promising millions of pounds of oil money or with a short term mandate from a corrupt peoples' president.
Other than the monopoly Bayern have over the Bundesliga, it's probably the most open and exciting league in Europe. It's very much like the Championship where any team can potentially throw a massive surprise, and clubs are dependent on savviness of Sporting Directors, Youth Development and Coaching to be successful.
Compared to the PL, the average Bundesliga player is paid just shy of £1m/yr, 14/18 clubs made a profit last season and most clubs see a wage to turnover ratio of 50% or less...
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(08-26-2019, 11:59 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-26-2019, 11:15 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: Personally, I feel that there are lots of issues that need looking at. FFP was supposed to make things fair but is easily manipulated, ( selling the stadium to the owner anyone? ). The fit and proper person test is obviously not worth the paper it`s written on, while `big clubs` poaching young players and only paying a small `development fee`is, to me, scandalous.
We went to watch a game in Germany, paid £15 for a ticket, apparently all clubs must have supporter representatives on the board, clubs must assist young players to learn a proffesion outside football, ( think Klinsmann was a qualified mechanic or something ), the downside to this, according to my lad, is that teams like Hamburg, big support etc, can`t compete with Watford for player wages.
Yup...
Outside investors into German clubs can only own 49% of a club, with the remainder having to be under fan control. There are a couple of exceptions, in that Wolfsburg are owned by VW for example, and recently the rules have been amended so that Leipzig and Hoffenheim can have benefactors, but they have had to prove long term associations and voting rights to their FA who are far sterner. The only way anyone can take financial control of a club is to demonstrate long term best interests, not just show up promising millions of pounds of oil money or with a short term mandate from a corrupt peoples' president.
Other than the monopoly Bayern have over the Bundesliga, it's probably the most open and exciting league in Europe. It's very much like the Championship where any team can potentially throw a massive surprise, and clubs are dependent on savviness of Sporting Directors, Youth Development and Coaching to be successful.
Compared to the PL, the average Bundesliga player is paid just shy of £1m/yr, 14/18 clubs made a profit last season and most clubs see a wage to turnover ratio of 50% or less...
All sounds great, BUT it's far too sensible for the FA / Premier cabal to try to emulate it.
Also, Sky would probably would stop throwing billions at the Prem if they did it...they don't want an unpredictable and competitive league, they want to know which 5 or 6 clubs to keep showing as they will be the ones up top at the end.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(08-26-2019, 12:06 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (08-26-2019, 11:59 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-26-2019, 11:15 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: Personally, I feel that there are lots of issues that need looking at. FFP was supposed to make things fair but is easily manipulated, ( selling the stadium to the owner anyone? ). The fit and proper person test is obviously not worth the paper it`s written on, while `big clubs` poaching young players and only paying a small `development fee`is, to me, scandalous.
We went to watch a game in Germany, paid £15 for a ticket, apparently all clubs must have supporter representatives on the board, clubs must assist young players to learn a proffesion outside football, ( think Klinsmann was a qualified mechanic or something ), the downside to this, according to my lad, is that teams like Hamburg, big support etc, can`t compete with Watford for player wages.
Yup...
Outside investors into German clubs can only own 49% of a club, with the remainder having to be under fan control. There are a couple of exceptions, in that Wolfsburg are owned by VW for example, and recently the rules have been amended so that Leipzig and Hoffenheim can have benefactors, but they have had to prove long term associations and voting rights to their FA who are far sterner. The only way anyone can take financial control of a club is to demonstrate long term best interests, not just show up promising millions of pounds of oil money or with a short term mandate from a corrupt peoples' president.
Other than the monopoly Bayern have over the Bundesliga, it's probably the most open and exciting league in Europe. It's very much like the Championship where any team can potentially throw a massive surprise, and clubs are dependent on savviness of Sporting Directors, Youth Development and Coaching to be successful.
Compared to the PL, the average Bundesliga player is paid just shy of £1m/yr, 14/18 clubs made a profit last season and most clubs see a wage to turnover ratio of 50% or less...
All sounds great, BUT it's far too sensible for the FA / Premier cabal to try to emulate it.
Also, Sky would probably would stop throwing billions at the Prem if they did it...they don't want an unpredictable and competitive league, they want to know which 5 or 6 clubs to keep showing as they will be the ones up top at the end.
Oh we'll never emulate it, but they get a lot more right than we do.
Unfortunately it's more likely the Bundesliga will loosen regulations and move towards the PL model... There's already a movement in Germany hell bent on opening up ownership as the Bundesliga is rapidly falling behind in terms of commercial revenues, and even Ligue Un will soon overtake it... there's only so long clubs will continue to put fans first when serious money can be made by not...
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(08-26-2019, 12:09 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Oh we'll never emulate it, but they get a lot more right than we do.
Unfortunately it's more likely the Bundesliga will loosen regulations and move towards the PL model... There's already a movement in Germany hell bent on opening up ownership as the Bundesliga is rapidly falling behind in terms of commercial revenues, and even Ligue Un will soon overtake it... there's only so long clubs will continue to put fans first when serious money can be made by not...
It's a shame indeed, sign of the times.
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(08-26-2019, 09:59 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Not looking good for them.
How can a club with a long and rich history be allowed to fold.
Football has well and truly lost the plot. Sad.
Bolton's demise can be traced way back when they were signing players they couldn't afford like Pimpey.
Posts: 117
Threads: 2
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
(08-26-2019, 02:11 PM)Hopalong Wrote: (08-26-2019, 09:59 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Not looking good for them.
How can a club with a long and rich history be allowed to fold.
Football has well and truly lost the plot. Sad.
Bolton's demise can be traced way back when they were signing players they couldn't afford like Pimpey. They bought a Sex trafficker? They deserve to go out of business then
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
This is the epitome of modern football is shit. A cartel of plastic clubs, which have become international brands, rule the roost and the rest of us feasting on crumbs with the yearning to be at the top table.
Meanwhile kids from Oldbury wear Liverpool shirts as we battle to be relevant.
Bolton, if they go, will come back. It's desperately sad though as they're a proper old club with a decent support- recall well us pipping them in 76 to promotion and a 2-0 win for us late in the season at home.
Posts: 335
Threads: 5
Joined: Jan 2019
Anyone who smirks at the demise of a tradition like Bolton Wanderers Football club is a douchebag of the highest order. We have allowed our game to be hijacked and corrupted by greed. I suppose it just reflects the horrible, celebrity ridden, narcissistic and selfish times we are in. In a world of six packs, botox, boob jobs and Kardashians, football as we know it never had a chance.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(08-26-2019, 04:08 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: This is the epitome of modern football is shit. A cartel of plastic clubs, which have become international brands, rule the roost and the rest of us feasting on crumbs with the yearning to be at the top table.
Meanwhile kids from Oldbury wear Liverpool shirts as we battle to be relevant.
Bolton, if they go, will come back. It's desperately sad though as they're a proper old club with a decent support- recall well us pipping them in 76 to promotion and a 2-0 win for us late in the season at home.
True. Proper club and a decent away day at Burnden Park. Even more galling these clubs are crumbling while Derby played Villa for the ultimate prize and both cheated their finances to get there.
|