Ratings...
#11
(08-21-2019, 09:36 PM)MGalea Wrote: If that was Sawyers having an off night he maybe the best midfielder i’ll ever see play for Albion. Class act. Reminds me of Pirlo at Juve. Not taking those words in vain either I mean it. Krovinovic ian excellent too. Once the movement ahead of them sorts itself out there’s a massive massive pasting on the cards for someone.

Agreed - I thought most of our best work came through Sawyers and whilst he may have had an off night compared to his usual standards he was still head and shoulders above Livermore who just seemed leggy and off the pace.

(08-21-2019, 09:51 PM)Lightnin Wrote: I think we’re very good apart from in either box! It took us ages to actually trouble there keeper with anything as we try to set up the perfect goal and walk it in. Our passing is quick and direct with plenty of zip about it all but we do sometimes turn back on the counter and let the opposition get back in. Also, tonight, why so many crosses against 3 centre backs with only Austin in the middle? When teams put 3 at the back, put 2 in the middle and play in the gaps.

We’ve got plenty of creativity in Edwards, Diangana, Phillips, Krovinovic and Pereira it seems. A couple of those Pereira passes were a different league and too clever maybe but it’ll come good when the players recognise his game better.

Wish we’d have signed Morrison on a free from Blues, thought he was very good for Reading.

Miazga the pick for me, his head seemed to be on everything.

Our best spells came from getting behind their back 3 which lacked any pace but we didn’t do it enough. 

Very excited to see Periera at full fitness, like you say some of those balls late on were simply on another level.
Reply
#12
Some of you posters were at a different match to me Sawyers well of the boil ,where as Livermore one of our better players and we duly deserved at least a point for our decent second half disp7.
Reply
#13
Disappointed with Phillips effort to prevent the shit for their goal, seemed to just watch him hoping someone else would do it
Reply
#14
(08-21-2019, 09:18 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Think we need to get used to games like this at home. Lots of possession but that cutting edge still deserts us... we probably did enough to win the game, and a decent official would have given at least 1 of the other 2 penalty shouts, but Reading were organised and defended heroically.

For all our control of games, we still don’t quite get the ball into dangerous areas, and against sides that play a little defensively we need to sacrifice one of Krov, Livermore and Sawyers as there just aren’t enough goals in them. 

With Sawyers and Krov  we probably  have enough energy to go 4-4-2, especially as Phillips can tuck in and shift us into 433 if we’re getting overrun. 

As has been said, we’ll probably do a lot better away than at home playing this way, but we need to be a little more clinical.

Johnstone - 7 - no chance with the goal, nice distribution and came off his line!!

Furlong - 7 - I thought he did ok. Created probably our best chance in open play and balanced attacking and defending well. A few sloppy passes but did ok.
Ajayi - 7 composed and kept a tricky attacker quiet 
Bartley - 7 - one sloppy moment thatcould have put us in trouble but otherwise solid.
Gibbs - 6 - Bit of the Dawson from LY about him recently. Looks a little disinterested and looked wound up again after a silly booking.    

Sawyers - 8 - keeps everything ticking over - gave the ball away 4-5 times though! 
Livermore - 6 - game passed him by for spells and was definitely not as fast as the other two in MC. Ejeria gave him a tough day!

Phillips - first half 4/ second half 7 - came to life after a very poor first half.
Krovinovic - 8 - if he can add goals to his game we have a player. Fouled a lot and should have had a couple pens.
Diangana - 7 - tricky and pacy but better as an impact sub at the moment Austin - 6.5 - linkup play isn’t his strong point... we look more dangerous with Zohore. Would have liked to see them have 15 together 


Periera - 6 - frustrating and brilliant. Created 2 greatchances and then missed 2. Entertaining cameo.
Zohore - 7 - the ball sticks up top far better with him. Tidy pen too under pressure. 
Edwards - no time 

Bilic - 6 - thought Diangana went off too soon, Phillips should have gone for me... also would have preferred Livermore for Zohore instead of Austin.

Shame that the ref probably cost us 3 points, but 8 from 4 is a solid start.

Great effort as always SW4. Have to stop from coming home from a game and reading the match thread. Some absolute bollocks on there, again. 
Been said elsewhere on this thread about controlling the game which, by and large, we did. Key to tonight's result was not staring Zohore. I know Austin can only get match fit by playing but surely he's better off the bench with some intense work and behind-closed-door type friendlies during the international break. Zohore's link up play and movement key for us at the moment.

Think you have Sawyer's mark spot on. Presumably looked better at the game rather than through the tv. Yes he had that little spell but thought he did well. My only gripe would be on Livermore. Accept I see little wrong in him but thought played very well again and interesting that all posters who would sacrifice a midfielder (for whatever attacking reason) would pick Livermore. He's absolutely the one i'd keep. That said I wouldn't change from 4.2.3.1 at the minute.

A decent return from 4 games but feel there could/would/should have been a point or two more from somewhere.
Going to be an interesting wait to see who plays on Saturday.
Reply
#15
In fairness I had a fella next to me slating Livermore for 90 mins so that probably affected my judgment. He also took an instant dislike to Furlong, so was wondering if it was just me who thought he was very promising tonight.

Agree on the rest.

Johnstone, Townsend, Ajayi, Bartley, Furlong, Sawyers, Livermore, Periera, Krov, Phillips, Zohore

For Derby IMO... Diangana. Austin and Edwards off the bench can create chaos!
Reply
#16
Soap 4- one smart save, made the free kick save look better than it was, stood and watched the goal!
Furgs 6 - good going forward, caught out on occasions. Could of had a pen?
Barts 7 - looks 100% better than last season
Semi 7- looked composed at times, shakey at others.
Gibbo 6- is it me or has he lost a yard since last season?
Jake 7- kept it simple, put a shift in
Matty 6- looked ok, match fitness an issue, corners shite.
Sawyers 7- gave the ball away more than he ever has in the stripes, but still looked v good.
Krovo 7- always wants the ball, tries to make things happen
Gravy 6- tried to hard at times, reminded me of Tony Daley!
Austin 3- looked like a maestro, unfortunately the 1 built at Longbridge!!

Pezza 5- he may look like Sane but doesn't play like him!
Zahore 7-did enough, scored.
Eddo 6 - not enough time shine
Reply
#17
(08-21-2019, 10:13 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: In fairness I had a fella next to me slating Livermore for 90 mins so that probably affected my judgment. He also took an instant dislike to Furlong, so was wondering if it was just me who thought he was very promising tonight.

Agree on the rest.

Johnstone, Townsend, Ajayi, Bartley, Furlong, Sawyers, Livermore, Periera, Krov, Phillips, Zohore

For Derby IMO... Diangana. Austin and Edwards off the bench can create chaos!

Johnstone
Ferguson Ajai Bartley Gibbs
Sawyers Livermore 
Phillips Krovinovic Edwards
Zohore
Reply
#18
James
Fergie Semi Bartman Gibbo
Le Fleur Jake
Matty Krovo Grady
Zahore
Reply
#19
Zahore. made a real difference. Plenty of balls too, no one else was ever getting that penalty kick.
Livermore, a solid 7
Austin. Looked a little rusty, although if I was defending him I'd have to say he had little service.
Romaine. Just after my mate said how brilliant he was, he promptly gave every ball away for the next 25 minutes. Never hid though and had a very decent 2nd half.
Krov. I'd like to see him shoot more.
Edwards. Not on long but he caused them havoc. Good lad, not overawed in the slightest.
A steady show from the 2 centre backs.
All in all, an entertaining game. They sat deep but countered dangerously 1st half. Maybe they ran out of legs 2nd half because we were getting properly on top when they scored with their only shot. I thought we were the only team that deserved to win it but a draw wasn't totally unfair. Reading are a very decent outfit.
Have to see those penalty shouts again though.
Reply
#20
Zohore for Austin would be the only change to starting 11 vs Derby
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)