To be an Albion legend
#1
It's a word that gets chucked about too much, especially on Radio WM, when they have someone who played for a club in an inauspicious time. However, to be a legend I think you must have done something memorable and played for a long time for a club in good times.
Otherwise you're just a loyal servant.
For this reason guys like Sneekes, despite being a shining light in crap times is not quite a legend. Andy Hunt isn't either, despite scoring a vital goal at Wembley.
As someone who recalls the 78-81 team, I would say the legends since are only a crop of guys from the past decade plus Super Bob.
He was a great striker, but also spearheaded our return to the top flight.
Guys like Brunt, Morrisson and Ollsen and I'd also add Gera are modern legends. However, they will only get the recognition in 20 years when their memories fade and the youngsters of now look back on them as the heroes of yesteryear.
To my mind of the 79 team are all legends because we were so brilliant, despite maybe a couple of them having had better players appear in the stripes since. Godden and Ally Brown stand out as possible the least deserving of legend status, but I do feel almost bad saying that. 
Incidentally 12 years for Brunty today. Proper modern legend who has been impeccable.
Reply
#2
After the thread the other day, and seeing a bit of that Ultimate Worrier show (where one of the worries was meeting your heroes)...

Is it just because we're all so much older now? Do the younger fans (no idea how old the youngest on here are!?) still revere Sneekes and Ollsen and Gera? And we older types think a little less of them, because of the legends from yesteryear that are in our minds?

I used to sit with my dad and go through his (even then) very old program collections, asking about such and such, and his eyes would glaze over and he would wax lyrical about The Tank, Jeff, Barlow, Allen, the likes of which seem to rarely get mentioned by posters (except Jeff obvs) on here discussing the legends... So is it really just a case of one generation's legends simply won't resonate with the next and subsequent ones?

I know for a fact that if I asked my nephew (a sad Man U fan, who I used to bring to games for about 3 or 4 seasons) who he sees as an Albion legend, he'd say Sneekes without thinking. Heck, he used to have this idea that I should take him to Sneekes restaurant in Sutton Coldfield...(closed a few years back). He just loves Sneekes and classes him as a legend.

I never started going until mid / late 1982 and then more regularly in 1983, but I knew that Jeff, Laurie, Cyrille were legends, even though I only saw Cyrille for a short time in Albion colours.

So a young person these days, who only started going say 5 or 6 years ago, would likely consider Brunteh and Mozza to be legends... Whereas maybe because of my age, I don't, even though they have played so many games that they probably should be.

I think legends/heroes should be left to the individual as there is no real criteria for deciding what makes a player such. I'll never forget Igor's penalty, but I can't really remember much else about him, and for that he'll always be a hero and a legend in my mind.
Reply
#3
And to be fair, the dictionary defines legend as: an extremely famous or notorious person, especially in a particular field.

By that definition Mozza and Brunt are definitely legends.
Reply
#4
Sneekes = cult hero
Reply
#5
I'd say Brunt is a legend, Bob Taylor definitely. I think there's a case for SuperKev too - I don't think length of service comes into it as much with some players, it's how good they are while they're here.

Gera, Sneekes, etc are cult heroes imo.
"I'm not a nerd Bart. Nerds are smart"
Reply
#6
Igor Balis, cult hero, scorer of legendary penalty...
Reply
#7
(08-16-2019, 11:45 AM)UCEbaggie Wrote: Sneekes = cult hero

Judging by his usual negative views of all things Albion on WM, I think you spelt "cult" wrong.  Wink
Reply
#8
I find this an interesting debate. I'm not sure if people will agree here, but...

I see the likes of Laurie Cunningham and Cyrille Regis as true Albion legends, whereas someone like Chris Brunt - I don't. Maybe it's because he is still actively playing for us? Maybe it's because I've grew up watching him play, and it's the norm for me? Maybe it's because I never saw Laurie and Cyrille play?

I rate Brunt highly, I think he's a fantastic player and has taken part in some iconic moments for us, down the years. But Cyrille and Laurie are part of our proud history in much more than a football sense.

When you compare Brunt's stats, they stack up well enough against pretty much any legend, cult hero or fans favourite you can name. 368 games and 44 goals. Between Laurie and Regis they managed less games (a combined 327), probably un surprisingly, they out scored a Brunt with combined 102 goals.

It shows how brilliant Brunt has been, statistically, for us. But it doesn't feel right to call him a legend.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#9
In the modern game anyone who does 10 years at a club earns the "Legend" status.
It really depends on the fans, they decide.
CB & JM can earn the "Legend" title if they continue to work with the club / Academy when the boots are hung up IMO.
Remember LEGEND status is just an opinion.
Reply
#10
(08-16-2019, 12:46 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: In the modern game anyone who does 10 years at a club earns the "Legend" status.
It really depends on the fans, they decide.
CB & JM can earn the "Legend" title if they continue to work with the club / Academy when the boots are hung up IMO.
Remember LEGEND status is just an opinion.
It is an opinion and only hindsight affords legends of any kind in any theatre.
For instance I saw on VH1, about a year ago, a documentary made about Queen in the 80s. At the time, about 88, Phil Collins said they were pioneers, but being current no one realises how important they are and only in 20 or so years will people realise that they are musical legends. 
Around that time, in July 86, I saw Queen at Wembley. When I tell young uns that now it is like a Woodtstock moment in my eyes. Very few times can you be in the moment and realise what it mesns in history, and I was unaware at that time.
However, even as a guy in my mid 30s in 2002, I knew what that day would mean and continue to mean when Super Bob pounced on the slippery handed Palace keeper's mistake.
Super Bob became a legend then whether you were 6 or 36.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)