Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
10-02-2026, 04:48 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-02-2026, 04:56 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(10-02-2026, 04:09 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Staggered by the belief that the ‘state’ could control a load of doctors to coerce people into dying so the state could save some money… the agents must have better skills than I ever did
You must have missed several high profile disabled people and organisations being against assisted dying for the fear of coercion amongst other related concerns. it’s not a binary argument of one side being right or wrong it’s a balancing act, where you sit on the scales is down to in many cases you’re own circumstances or those of others you know.
Last year, the commission's chair Baroness Falkner said: "While the bill provides safeguards against a person being coerced or pressured to end their own life by another individual, we know that disabled people, older people and especially older disabled people, may feel pressured to prematurely end their lives by societal attitudes and a lack of the support and services they need."
Comedian Rosie Jones, and actors Liz Carr and Ruth Madeley are among dozens of prominent disabled people in the arts, media and academia who have signed the open letter to MPs.
The letter says: "At the moment, sick and disabled people, including terminally ill people, are denied choice over the most basic of things: our ability to get out of bed, wash, eat, leave our houses or manage our pain.
"This creates a coercive environment where people will choose an earlier death simply because they are being failed by society.
"Put simply, introducing assisted dying in these circumstances will put sick and disabled people's lives at risk.
"No one wants any terminally ill person to suffer unnecessarily at death. But we must protect the lives and rights of disabled and terminally ill people in life."
I’m not falling into the boards narrative again am I… pfft
Posts: 11,928
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
(10-02-2026, 04:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-02-2026, 04:09 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Staggered by the belief that the ‘state’ could control a load of doctors to coerce people into dying so the state could save some money… the agents must have better skills than I ever did
You must have missed several high profile disabled people and organisations being against assisted dying for the fear of coercion amongst other related concerns. it’s not a binary argument of one side being right or wrong it’s a balancing act, where you sit on the scales is down to in many cases you’re own circumstances or those of others you know.
That’s not the same thing though is it Dekka? Those activists have rightly been voicing concerns, you are intimating that the state would promote (and deliver!) mass euthanasia to save a few quid. Don’t be like the ‘everyone who hates genocide must hate Jews’ lot on the other board - it devalues a very important argument.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
10-02-2026, 04:59 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-02-2026, 05:00 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(10-02-2026, 04:54 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (10-02-2026, 04:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-02-2026, 04:09 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Staggered by the belief that the ‘state’ could control a load of doctors to coerce people into dying so the state could save some money… the agents must have better skills than I ever did
You must have missed several high profile disabled people and organisations being against assisted dying for the fear of coercion amongst other related concerns. it’s not a binary argument of one side being right or wrong it’s a balancing act, where you sit on the scales is down to in many cases you’re own circumstances or those of others you know.
That’s not the same thing though is it Dekka? Those activists have rightly been voicing concerns, you are intimating that the state would promote (and deliver!) mass euthanasia to save a few quid. Don’t be like the ‘everyone who hates genocide must hate Jews’ lot on the other board - it devalues a very important argument.
I’m pointing out that there isn’t a right or wrong answer to assisted dying but sadly humans and particularly in these hard hearted times can’t be trusted with a needle in the U.K. given the propensity to boil life down to binary money making or losing widgets.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(10-02-2026, 04:27 PM)Jacko Wrote: CC It's not difficult, the coercion comes from bad actors, usually family members. The medical fallibility from the doctors. They are the actual equivalent to the corrupt cops or misinformed jurors/judiciary.
Derek's hypothesis of state controlled means-tested euthanasia is of course, extremely far-fetched.
CA, I am extremely sorry to hear you have had that experience. As I stated, I'm not making a false equivalence because I'm not comparing the morality of the two, mercy vs punishment, I'm comparing the fallibility of the systems that will administer them. Due to the finality of death, there is a clear systemic risk baked into both.
Firstly, thank you. A difficult time, especially for his parents. We certainly have a half-way house at the moment whereby people are left to die by the doctors and family when it's seen as in the best interest of the patient. In fact those were the very words by the doctor "we haver to do what's right for him now". The only missing piece is bringing that end in with mercy, peace and dignity rather than dragging in out to literally watch and wait for them to take their last breath.
I don't accept that your argument is merely a morality one that can be compared. Is it morally right to allow people to suffer? Is it morally right for the state to revenge kill someone in a eye-for-an-eye (the often used quote) manner?
I will accept there's an inherent risk attached to both elements of this, but frm oppiste angles. I do believe it's possible to put enough controls in place for someone to state their wishes upon reaching a certain point in their illness. I don't believe you can have protection against a false convction in the same way or an understanding of the mental health of someone who goes on a killing spree. It always amazes me when they're declared mentally fit, they're clearly not otherwise they wouldn't have killed people!
I can't get behind the state acting in a way to murder people for their wrong-doing but i can get behind the state allowing people to decide their own destiny at the point of end-of-life care. They're not a mirror image but fundamentally different, once is actively taking life, the other allowing someone to choose to end theirs in very pre-determined circumstances Dekka would have us believe we'll be throwing the elderly and diabaled on the fire to keep us all warm and reduce our dependency on oil. I can't imagine it's environmentally friendly!
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
Anyone who has been following the introduction of MAID in Canada will understand that assisted dying is more morally complex than one might initially assume and that the Right to Die swiftly becomes the Duty to Die. People with Learning disabilities already live on average 20 years less than the rest of the population, much of that is due to poor healthcare.
Posts: 3,821
Threads: 250
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
Will she be acquitted now - if she survives obviously?
Thought it was the law (over here anyway) that if somebody survived an execution they were pardoned?
John Babbacombe Lee - Wikipedia
Posts: 11,928
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
(10-02-2026, 05:24 PM)Squid Wrote: Anyone who has been following the introduction of MAID in Canada will understand that assisted dying is more morally complex than one might initially assume and that the Right to Die swiftly becomes the Duty to Die. People with Learning disabilities already live on average 20 years less than the rest of the population, much of that is due to poor healthcare.
I’m glad you said ‘much of that’ because it’s really fucking important - especially in a thread where concerns of state sponsored euthanasia is being worried about - to disaggregate healthcare PROVISION from factors that affect longevity.
Firstly COVID created a massive blip in deaths for people with LD. At present the causes are not proven but are multifactoral. Healthcare provision is felt by many to be a factor in the early days of the pandemic where beds were felt to be prioritised based upon other health factors. LD people were felt to have been disadvantaged due to a scoring system that factored cognition (as a proxy for dementia etc but NOT intended for LD). I say ‘felt’ not because I want to devalue the evidence but because the evidence is currently anecdotal rather than of a higher quality. My gut feel is to believe it.
However, when you look at large scale studies, meta-analysis and a vast wealth of trial and experiential evidence the causes for early mortality are multifactoral and ALWAYS extend beyond provision of healthcare. Employment, community, wealth, genetics and diet are all, 100% evidence based, contributors to lower life expectancy. We know people with LD have poorer outcomes in all of these domains.
As ever, nuance is important - balance is more important though, even if you dismiss the ‘balance’ later on in your deliberations.
Simplistic answers to complex questions only further the cause of charlatans and ne’erdowells
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(10-02-2026, 04:54 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (10-02-2026, 04:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-02-2026, 04:09 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Staggered by the belief that the ‘state’ could control a load of doctors to coerce people into dying so the state could save some money… the agents must have better skills than I ever did
You must have missed several high profile disabled people and organisations being against assisted dying for the fear of coercion amongst other related concerns. it’s not a binary argument of one side being right or wrong it’s a balancing act, where you sit on the scales is down to in many cases you’re own circumstances or those of others you know.
That’s not the same thing though is it Dekka? Those activists have rightly been voicing concerns, you are intimating that the state would promote (and deliver!) mass euthanasia to save a few quid. Don’t be like the ‘everyone who hates genocide must hate Jews’ lot on the other board - it devalues a very important argument.
I never said anything about state sponsored euthanasia, I said there was a danger all be it in a facetious way that vulnerable disabled people or their families could be coerced into premature death for reasons beyond pain or morality. Squid is correct, this is far from a black and white argument as is why many disabled groups are against it.
Posts: 11,928
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
(10-02-2026, 07:28 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-02-2026, 04:54 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (10-02-2026, 04:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-02-2026, 04:09 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Staggered by the belief that the ‘state’ could control a load of doctors to coerce people into dying so the state could save some money… the agents must have better skills than I ever did
You must have missed several high profile disabled people and organisations being against assisted dying for the fear of coercion amongst other related concerns. it’s not a binary argument of one side being right or wrong it’s a balancing act, where you sit on the scales is down to in many cases you’re own circumstances or those of others you know.
That’s not the same thing though is it Dekka? Those activists have rightly been voicing concerns, you are intimating that the state would promote (and deliver!) mass euthanasia to save a few quid. Don’t be like the ‘everyone who hates genocide must hate Jews’ lot on the other board - it devalues a very important argument.
I never said anything about state sponsored euthanasia, I said there was a danger all be it in a facetious way that vulnerable disabled people or their families could be coerced into premature death for reasons beyond pain or morality. Squid is correct, this is far from a black and white argument as is why many disabled groups are against it.
To quote “ Particularly as this country is getting more and more hard hearted, binary and ableist… ‘you cost the state too much money to support, it’s probably better you do the honourable thing and not be here any longer. It’s nothing personal we just don’t think you add anything to the public purse.’”
If you didn’t mean that then why did you say it?
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(10-02-2026, 07:33 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (10-02-2026, 07:28 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-02-2026, 04:54 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (10-02-2026, 04:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-02-2026, 04:09 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Staggered by the belief that the ‘state’ could control a load of doctors to coerce people into dying so the state could save some money… the agents must have better skills than I ever did
You must have missed several high profile disabled people and organisations being against assisted dying for the fear of coercion amongst other related concerns. it’s not a binary argument of one side being right or wrong it’s a balancing act, where you sit on the scales is down to in many cases you’re own circumstances or those of others you know.
That’s not the same thing though is it Dekka? Those activists have rightly been voicing concerns, you are intimating that the state would promote (and deliver!) mass euthanasia to save a few quid. Don’t be like the ‘everyone who hates genocide must hate Jews’ lot on the other board - it devalues a very important argument.
I never said anything about state sponsored euthanasia, I said there was a danger all be it in a facetious way that vulnerable disabled people or their families could be coerced into premature death for reasons beyond pain or morality. Squid is correct, this is far from a black and white argument as is why many disabled groups are against it.
To quote “Particularly as this country is getting more and more hard hearted, binary and ableist… ‘you cost the state too much money to support, it’s probably better you do the honourable thing and not be here any longer. It’s nothing personal we just don’t think you add anything to the public purse.’”
If you didn’t mean that then why did you say it?
Where did I say I was quoting the state? The point I was making is this type of insidious message is not overtly said, but implied, whether it’s via debates on welfare, Covid or even distinguishing between ‘working people’ and others. It’s not a state message it’s a social message encouraged and in some cases initiated by the media, some politicians and members of society.
|