Posts: 1,963
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
11-26-2025, 10:15 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-26-2025, 10:18 AM by richbaggie.)
(11-26-2025, 10:03 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (11-26-2025, 10:00 AM)richbaggie. Wrote: It's not a narrative, it's always been the case with football fans that once they make their mind up about someone, it's rare that they have a balanced view after that. I can be guilty as much as anyone. It's human nature.
As for Mason, saying "zero management ability" is the case in point about how unbalanced a view can get once a mind is made up.
Bruce and Tomo did not have good relationships with players by the way. Not 2nd time around in Moggas case.
Not sure it is an unbalanced view, Rich. I can't think of many if any games this year where he has out thought, out manoeuvred or out smarted the opposition manager.
Pretty much every decision he make makes me scratch my head.
Does this mean I don't want him to turn it around? No. I would like nothing more to see him making good decisions which positively impact games. But I just don't see any evidence of it.
Also I wasn't aware that ToMo wasnt well received? I thought he was loved by the players.
Thats where i think conscious or unconscious bias comes in. We've played well in games this season, most in the 6 or 7 games granted. Yet he hasn't had any impact on those wins in your view. I think the Oxford win is an example of bias. I thought he made some good changes in that game 2nd half which had a positive impact. However, he received little credit from those that clearly want him out and said we won simply because they were crap.
I am 100% not saying he's doing a good job, certainly not with in game management. However, i do try and find positives where I can and it's simply wrong that he's shown zero management ability this season.
(11-26-2025, 10:13 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Is it bias to point out the things you think Mason has got wrong in a thread about his managerial ability? Or are they just someone's observations?
Tough to disagree with what Lurker says but also I'm with Dekka in so much that it's early days, in a season where I don't think we can finish about about 8th. For once we're in a position to actually give a manager time.
Of course its not bias to point out weaknesses. Where has anyone said that. For me its bias when everything is deemed as negative and positives ignored.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
We are currently 17th in the table. So it's not surprising that the negatives outweigh the positives.
If we are talking about fans with agendas, quite a few didn't want Darren Moore as our permanent manager since day one and wanted Dean Smith instead. The comments after we lost to Bolton on the opening day were atrocious (including on here) and far worse than anything anyone has said about Mason thus far. To this day, people will openly say (including on here) that Darren Moore is not suited for football management.
That's an agenda.
What I'm seeing with Mason is fans losing faith after some consistently poor performances and results. That isn't an agenda, it's people responding to the evidence in front of them.
Posts: 9,633
Threads: 518
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(11-26-2025, 10:15 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Thats where i think conscious or unconscious bias comes in. We've played well in games this season, most in the 6 or 7 games granted. Yet he hasn't had any impact on those wins in your view. I think the Oxford win is an example of bias. I thought he made some good changes in that game 2nd half which had a positive impact. However, he received little credit from those that clearly want him out and said we won simply because they were crap.
I am 100% not saying he's doing a good job, certainly not with in game management. However, i do try and find positives where I can and it's simply wrong that he's shown zero management ability this season.
I would only say we've played well in 3 games this year to be honest. I think for the large part it's been aimless and unorganised, especially offensively. We have seen little in the way of repeated patterns of play and I struggle to see what we are trying to do. And I would expect the bunch of players we havez without a manager to show up and show some ability occasionally.
With regards to the Oxford game. I said in the match Fred, I don't think his subs were great. Yes the player who came on scored. But in terms of changing the dynamic of the game or the balance of the team. It was non existent. I replied to a post of Josh's earlier where I said that a manager can make the 'right' decisions and still fail to get a result, they can also make poor choices and the team win. They dont always align. Of course whether the changes are right or wrong is an opinion, and mine is that he rarely makes the correct calls.
Fwiw. I really hope it changes and he improves. Regardless of what results we manage to get.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
I'm in the Mason out camp, and to be honest Saturday for me was a final nail in the coffin.
Red cards happen, we were leading at the time, would CC, Roy, Pulis just stand there looking scared and doing nothing? Absolutely not, get organising, shouting, sit deep, all behind the ball, defend like lives depend on it, no forward play, just get rid, do that for 10 minutes, stop them scoring, take the sting out, then start to ease back into a game. Instead within 10 minutes they were winning.
Even RDM reacted better losing two men in the Prem, sat us in deep with a rigid shape and made the game an absolute bore.
Mason did nothing, and that scares me. And that's after the moronic, non sensical substitution of Johnston for SiJ.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(11-26-2025, 12:03 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (11-26-2025, 10:15 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Thats where i think conscious or unconscious bias comes in. We've played well in games this season, most in the 6 or 7 games granted. Yet he hasn't had any impact on those wins in your view. I think the Oxford win is an example of bias. I thought he made some good changes in that game 2nd half which had a positive impact. However, he received little credit from those that clearly want him out and said we won simply because they were crap.
I am 100% not saying he's doing a good job, certainly not with in game management. However, i do try and find positives where I can and it's simply wrong that he's shown zero management ability this season.
I would only say we've played well in 3 games this year to be honest. I think for the large part it's been aimless and unorganised, especially offensively. We have seen little in the way of repeated patterns of play and I struggle to see what we are trying to do. And I would expect the bunch of players we havez without a manager to show up and show some ability occasionally.
With regards to the Oxford game. I said in the match Fred, I don't think his subs were great. Yes the player who came on scored. But in terms of changing the dynamic of the game or the balance of the team. It was non existent. I replied to a post of Josh's earlier where I said that a manager can make the 'right' decisions and still fail to get a result, they can also make poor choices and the team win. They dont always align. Of course whether the changes are right or wrong is an opinion, and mine is that he rarely makes the correct calls.
Fwiw. I really hope it changes and he improves. Regardless of what results we manage to get.
Absolutely this.
I would love, in a few months time, for someone to be showing me my posts about Mason and saying how I called it wrong, but for every accusation of bias, I am yet to have anyone give me a convincing argument as to why we should give him time other than "he's inexperienced and needs to learn" which is fine, if as Lurker says, he shows signs of doing so, but they are non existent.
We did well to turn around the game and beat Oxford, but again, we'd failed to beat Sheff Wed at home, we lost away at Charlton, and then found ourselves 1-down at home to Oxford in a game we absolutely had to win, and in which we'd done very little of note for an hour.
There are huge, valid questions to be asked about Mason, and my (biased or not) belief is that I've seen nothing to suggest he has the ability to learn... but I guess we will know in about 10 or so hours. Anything other than a win, or that the VERY, VERY least, a strong performance in which he shows he can react and adapt to a game, and it will get toxic, and rightly there will be calls for him to go.
Posts: 9,649
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
I hope most of you are wrong, as that'll mean a successful Albion, but I wouldn't be so petty as to drag old posts up! You're entitled to an opinion.
I get the criticisms, I really do, what I struggle to get my head around, and this is probably on me, is the fact a lot of fans aren't showing any patience.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
11-26-2025, 01:54 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-26-2025, 01:54 PM by Birdman1811.)
(11-26-2025, 01:17 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I hope most of you are wrong, as that'll mean a successful Albion, but I wouldn't be so petty as to drag old posts up! You're entitled to an opinion.
I get the criticisms, I really do, what I struggle to get my head around, and this is probably on me, is the fact a lot of fans aren't showing any patience.
I'd love to be wrong Josh, and I'll support and cheer the team whatever, you'll never find me hoping we lose to sack the manager or anything. I just don't see anything to be optimistic about.
Irvine was an excellent coach.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(11-26-2025, 01:17 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I hope most of you are wrong, as that'll mean a successful Albion, but I wouldn't be so petty as to drag old posts up! You're entitled to an opinion.
I get the criticisms, I really do, what I struggle to get my head around, and this is probably on me, is the fact a lot of fans aren't showing any patience.
I will let you into a secret, fans talk a great game about patience, building slowly over several transfer windows and giving players and coaches time… this goes out the window as soon as the novelty wears off and a manager loses a few games or a player is out of form. In short it’s a load of old oss shit! It always was and always will be.
Posts: 9,649
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
11-26-2025, 02:41 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-26-2025, 02:42 PM by Josh1873.)
Maybe it's due to the fact that I've fallen out of love with football, and I find the whole thing boring, from the closed-door competitions where the same few elite sides only win them (save the odd exception), the corruption that isn't even hidden anymore, to the fact that most games are boring to watch as every team tries to copy Pep's City and Barca sides.
However, I'm willing to be patient. Winning isn't the be-all and end-all for me. Neither is promotion, given how the Premier League is, although I accept we need to get back to the gravy train sooner or later.
I get annoyed and pissed off if we lose, but it doesn't really bother me a great deal, especially when my expectations are already low. I'm willing to accept our financial position and that we're in a period of rebuilding - clearing out the older players on big wages and replacing them with younger players with reduced wages. I accept this tactic will result in us sliding down the table in the short term.
I like the idea of giving the gig to a rookie. It's a hell of a gamble, but it's one worth taking if you allow him time and give him a chance to settle into the role. I'm much happier with this gamble than appointing the same old faces on the management merry-go-round.
Posts: 3,108
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
11-26-2025, 02:55 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-26-2025, 02:57 PM by Tom Joad 25.)
I've criticised where I thought it was due. Two things are obvious. We look good at the start of most games and conversely our game management is poor.
I have an unsentimental approach to managers, patient but inevitably they are only around for a short while. Even SGM was always on the verge of leaving at quite a few times. I am more critical of the club normally and their scattergun appointments. Bruce, I knew would be a disaster. As did the clubs that sacked him over the latter years, it was hardly a secret. Irvine was Peace's cheap option. Robson, well. ...The Val appointment and length of contract was bold but then he wasn't provided with what his style needed, a battering ram centre forward. (OK, he got one in the very end, too late).
The posts above suggest we might again be falling into the trap of hiring the guy but not the tools required. Or rather the experience needed. I mean a Burrows for SGM, a Burkey for Ossie, Hunter for Giles. I have no idea what Gibbs does on matchdays but it's clear if we want to go with an option like Mason, he's going to need some decent advice. This must be obvious to Nestor, it's up to him to back his man and his judgement.
I don't want RM out. I want to see some definite improvements though and less mystifying selections.
|