Avoiding the jab
#71
(10-05-2021, 12:07 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 12:00 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Indeed. And when negative tests are a reasonable alternative (being accepted by Wales but not Scotland), it stinks that people won’t be allowed into places like football grounds. It’s divisive and creates a two tier society.

The fact is, when these come in, a vaccinated person with covid can go to an event. A non vaccinated person who hasn’t got covid can’t attend. That is ridiculous. Literally not about health. It’s ludicrous.

Correct, it's absolutely insane.

It is insane. Utterly bonkers and makes me wonder if the “passports” are not what they are supposed to be for.

Many say they’re to increase vaccine take up. I hope that’s the reason. Because I do wonder if it’s the other way round.
Reply
#72
(10-05-2021, 12:14 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 12:07 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 12:00 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Indeed. And when negative tests are a reasonable alternative (being accepted by Wales but not Scotland), it stinks that people won’t be allowed into places like football grounds. It’s divisive and creates a two tier society.

The fact is, when these come in, a vaccinated person with covid can go to an event. A non vaccinated person who hasn’t got covid can’t attend. That is ridiculous. Literally not about health. It’s ludicrous.

Correct, it's absolutely insane.

It is insane. Utterly bonkers and makes me wonder if the “passports” are not what they are supposed to be for.

Many say they’re to increase vaccine take up. I hope that’s the reason. Because I do wonder if it’s the other way round.

They may well be to increase vaccine take up. However in Israel they have a similar Green Pass and it seems that if you don't get the booster then your pass expires. That doesn't indicate that the passes are a short term measure to me
Reply
#73
(10-05-2021, 12:18 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 12:14 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 12:07 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 12:00 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Indeed. And when negative tests are a reasonable alternative (being accepted by Wales but not Scotland), it stinks that people won’t be allowed into places like football grounds. It’s divisive and creates a two tier society.

The fact is, when these come in, a vaccinated person with covid can go to an event. A non vaccinated person who hasn’t got covid can’t attend. That is ridiculous. Literally not about health. It’s ludicrous.

Correct, it's absolutely insane.

It is insane. Utterly bonkers and makes me wonder if the “passports” are not what they are supposed to be for.

Many say they’re to increase vaccine take up. I hope that’s the reason. Because I do wonder if it’s the other way round.

They may well be to increase vaccine take up. However in Israel they have a similar Green Pass and it seems that if you don't get the booster then your pass expires. That doesn't indicate that the passes are a short term measure to me

Indeed. I think they’re a long term measure too. They’ll morph into a digital ID IMO. And I don’t trust the government to decide what we need to do (for the greater good!!!!) to be in “Tier 1” of society. Tiered societies… yuk. It actually turns my stomach writing that.

Plenty of folk do though, as they think it’s all about ending the pandemic. We need to do it for the greater good…. Let’s see where that ends….
Reply
#74
(10-05-2021, 11:02 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 10:16 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 09:46 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: I think the problem within the scenario of those who choose not to be vaccinated comes down to something that has been argued on this bored for well over a year : rights versus responsibilities.  No one has a sacrosanct right within a society to exercise a "right" without also acknowledging responsibilities to the wider society.  Those who choose not to be vaccinated can exercise that right but the problem arises when they may as a consequence infect other individuals as a result of becoming infected.  Of course it is possible to become infected and go on to infect others, even though one may be double vaccinated, but clearly the risk of both is greatly reduced.  How do we weigh the risks of infection by a non-vaccinated person against the right of the individual in society at large?

I see that in New York the state authority has fired some 1400 employees working in health care who refused to be vaccinated.  At the same time there was a last minute huge rush to get vaccinated when the deadline approached so that thousands more did get the jab.  I think there is definitely a case for the compulsory vaccination of individuals who work closely in health care with the sick or the vulnerable as the onus of care is on those protecting persons at greater risk.  In most other respects the argument is less compelling.

I often see people make the argument that there are fundamental rights, and indeed the UN has a human rights charter, but within a nation state the only real rights one has are those the society allows you to have.  Thus in times of great crisis, be it war, climate catastrophe or pandemic, rights once thought to be inalienable are not quite so universal as they may have been in normal times.  The government has a right to curtail the rights of the individual for what it sees as the greater good - it has done so in the past and it almost certainly will do so in the future.  This may be seen as a slippery slope by some, or simply the exercise of good governance by others.  Tricky job running a country.

Very eloquently put Brentbaggie and something I have argued for at least a year. There are a few on here who are incapable of even admitting that people have responsibilities. It's the politics of the playground.

No one has said there’s not a case for care workers or nhs being vaccinated for their job. But it’s not as simple as all that. And you still cannot explain what happens if it causes a shortage.

And remember, it was these care workers who 18 months ago went to work and risked their life with no proper PPE while many of us sat on our arses working from home saying his great it was not to have a commute. Care workers on minimum wage putting themselves at the forefront of risk and never complained. They got on with it while lots of us sat on our computers safe as houses. They were heroes. Now many of those people sat on their computers are happy to see these people sacked for making a different decision on a vaccine. That doesn’t sit right with me. In fact I think it’s gross. Clap for carers to sack for carers in 18 months.

And you may call it politics of the playground DH, but you’re more guilty of that than most on here. Still waiting for an answer of what happens if there’s a care worker shortage (it’ll be nhs next)

As always in these situations there are some hypothetical causes and effects and some more concrete ones.  I don't argue that Care workers should be sacked and no one could deny the risks they have taken in the past.  However those risks are now more quantifiable and the situation is very different to what it was a year or so ago.  As Churchill famously said, "When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do?" To argue that a care workers' right to continue to work without being vaccinated transcends someone vulnerable's right to be protected is to say the least a 'fine' conundrum, but it is the essence of my reasoning.  

Now it may be that unvaccinated Careworkers can continue to be tested for Covid every two or three days, as happens with almost all hospital staff as I understand it, and so fulfill their responsibility to their co-workers and more importantly those in their care.  How long this can go on will be I think be the practical heart of this question. New York has reasoned in favour of taking what might be called the "unsentimental" approach. I don't think it will happen here. I hope it doesn't have to.  But I hope at the same time that some of the reticent care workers' fears re. the vaccine are becoming assuaged with the passage of time and they get the jab. Thems my onions.
Reply
#75
(10-05-2021, 11:38 AM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 08:52 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 08:46 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 06:41 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The key word is 'reduced'. The vaccine will reduce the likelihood of transmission, it won't remove transmission, so people who get transmitted covid will possibly transmit the virus, but that is reduced because 1stly they may be immune to it from the vaccine and therefore not transmit it at all, or 2ndly they may not have as many symptoms that mean it will be transmitted. For instance they may not cough as much and therefore don't expel as much of the virus as someone who coughs, which logically means they won't transmit it as much (reduced transmission).

And they tweak the flu vaccine, they don't replace it each year and start again.

Yes that is correct- to be a better match for the most likely strain they expect to be prevalent. Have they tweaked the Covid booster or is it still aimed at the Alpha?

I take it that your non-comment on how transmission works and what reduced transmission means now indicates that you agree that the vaccine has reduced transmission.

And your continued comparison of treatment for flu and covid is madness - the vaccine may or may not be as effective at treating the delta variant as it was the alpha variant but it is all we have got to reduce the transmission and it may not be 100% as effective but by being 75% effective it is still effective.

Just as an example why flu jabs and covid jabs aren't comparable is in the requirement for treating covid compared with flu. Annually on a global basis flu kills between quarter and half a million whereas covid has, in conservative estimates, killed 3M whilst the global excess death figure is nearer 5M (although due to timescales and different country reporting methods that is difficult to measure) but we are looking at 4M deaths more than normal in 2020.

I never said it didn't reduce transmission at all. I said that the actual percentage was debatable. According to SkyNews today the effectiveness of reducing transmission for Pfizer is 47% after 6 months having reduced from 88% at the outset. It is reasonable to expect it to drop even lower after another few months so boosters seem likely for everyone. It remains to be seen how the effectiveness against transmission will hold up after the boosters of course.

Good, so we agree that having the jab reduces transmission, and as it obviously is waning given time then we therefore agree that having one jab is good, a second is better as it brings the reduction of transmission back up, and until a better method is identified then any further boosters are also a good idea as it has been shown that the second jab brings improved protection and reduces transmission therefore the likelihood is the booster will do the same.

And to another point you raise, it isn't the government deciding on what is for the greater good, it is bleeding obvious that having the jab is for the greater good of society.
Reply
#76
(10-05-2021, 12:35 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 11:02 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 10:16 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 09:46 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: I think the problem within the scenario of those who choose not to be vaccinated comes down to something that has been argued on this bored for well over a year : rights versus responsibilities.  No one has a sacrosanct right within a society to exercise a "right" without also acknowledging responsibilities to the wider society.  Those who choose not to be vaccinated can exercise that right but the problem arises when they may as a consequence infect other individuals as a result of becoming infected.  Of course it is possible to become infected and go on to infect others, even though one may be double vaccinated, but clearly the risk of both is greatly reduced.  How do we weigh the risks of infection by a non-vaccinated person against the right of the individual in society at large?

I see that in New York the state authority has fired some 1400 employees working in health care who refused to be vaccinated.  At the same time there was a last minute huge rush to get vaccinated when the deadline approached so that thousands more did get the jab.  I think there is definitely a case for the compulsory vaccination of individuals who work closely in health care with the sick or the vulnerable as the onus of care is on those protecting persons at greater risk.  In most other respects the argument is less compelling.

I often see people make the argument that there are fundamental rights, and indeed the UN has a human rights charter, but within a nation state the only real rights one has are those the society allows you to have.  Thus in times of great crisis, be it war, climate catastrophe or pandemic, rights once thought to be inalienable are not quite so universal as they may have been in normal times.  The government has a right to curtail the rights of the individual for what it sees as the greater good - it has done so in the past and it almost certainly will do so in the future.  This may be seen as a slippery slope by some, or simply the exercise of good governance by others.  Tricky job running a country.

Very eloquently put Brentbaggie and something I have argued for at least a year. There are a few on here who are incapable of even admitting that people have responsibilities. It's the politics of the playground.

No one has said there’s not a case for care workers or nhs being vaccinated for their job. But it’s not as simple as all that. And you still cannot explain what happens if it causes a shortage.

And remember, it was these care workers who 18 months ago went to work and risked their life with no proper PPE while many of us sat on our arses working from home saying his great it was not to have a commute. Care workers on minimum wage putting themselves at the forefront of risk and never complained. They got on with it while lots of us sat on our computers safe as houses. They were heroes. Now many of those people sat on their computers are happy to see these people sacked for making a different decision on a vaccine. That doesn’t sit right with me. In fact I think it’s gross. Clap for carers to sack for carers in 18 months.

And you may call it politics of the playground DH, but you’re more guilty of that than most on here. Still waiting for an answer of what happens if there’s a care worker shortage (it’ll be nhs next)

As always in these situations there are some hypothetical causes and effects and some more concrete ones.  I don't argue that Care workers should be sacked and no one could deny the risks they have taken in the past.  However those risks are now more quantifiable and the situation is very different to what it was a year or so ago.  As Churchill famously said, "When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do?" To argue that a care workers' right to continue to work without being vaccinated transcends someone vulnerable's right to be protected is to say the least a 'fine' conundrum, but it is the essence of my reasoning.  

Now it may be that unvaccinated Careworkers can continue to be tested for Covid every two or three days, as happens with almost all hospital staff as I understand it, and so fulfill their responsibility to their co-workers and more importantly those in their care.  How long this can go on will be I think be the practical heart of this question. New York has reasoned in favour of taking what might be called the "unsentimental" approach. I don't think it will happen here. I hope it doesn't have to.  But I hope at the same time that some of the reticent care workers' fears re. the vaccine are becoming assuaged with the passage of time and they get the jab. Thems my onions.

I think the unvaccinated care workers are leaving and simply getting other minimum wage jobs. There’ll be a shortage once this happens. 

I think it’ll be nhs staff next, then other jobs too… offices, shops etc. Australia has I think mandated it for construction workers I think. And the scenes from Melbourne protests are not pretty. We’ve got all this to come IMO. Many think the worst of covid is over. I don’t think the real chaos has even started yet (socially as we’re discussing, and economically).

(10-05-2021, 12:43 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 11:38 AM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 08:52 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 08:46 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 06:41 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The key word is 'reduced'. The vaccine will reduce the likelihood of transmission, it won't remove transmission, so people who get transmitted covid will possibly transmit the virus, but that is reduced because 1stly they may be immune to it from the vaccine and therefore not transmit it at all, or 2ndly they may not have as many symptoms that mean it will be transmitted. For instance they may not cough as much and therefore don't expel as much of the virus as someone who coughs, which logically means they won't transmit it as much (reduced transmission).

And they tweak the flu vaccine, they don't replace it each year and start again.

Yes that is correct- to be a better match for the most likely strain they expect to be prevalent. Have they tweaked the Covid booster or is it still aimed at the Alpha?

I take it that your non-comment on how transmission works and what reduced transmission means now indicates that you agree that the vaccine has reduced transmission.

And your continued comparison of treatment for flu and covid is madness - the vaccine may or may not be as effective at treating the delta variant as it was the alpha variant but it is all we have got to reduce the transmission and it may not be 100% as effective but by being 75% effective it is still effective.

Just as an example why flu jabs and covid jabs aren't comparable is in the requirement for treating covid compared with flu. Annually on a global basis flu kills between quarter and half a million whereas covid has, in conservative estimates, killed 3M whilst the global excess death figure is nearer 5M (although due to timescales and different country reporting methods that is difficult to measure) but we are looking at 4M deaths more than normal in 2020.

I never said it didn't reduce transmission at all. I said that the actual percentage was debatable. According to SkyNews today the effectiveness of reducing transmission for Pfizer is 47% after 6 months having reduced from 88% at the outset. It is reasonable to expect it to drop even lower after another few months so boosters seem likely for everyone. It remains to be seen how the effectiveness against transmission will hold up after the boosters of course.

Good, so we agree that having the jab reduces transmission, and as it obviously is waning given time then we therefore agree that having one jab is good, a second is better as it brings the reduction of transmission back up, and until a better method is identified then any further boosters are also a good idea as it has been shown that the second jab brings improved protection and reduces transmission therefore the likelihood is the booster will do the same.

And to another point you raise, it isn't the government deciding on what is for the greater good, it is bleeding obvious that having the jab is for the greater good of society.

That’s totally missing the point. There’s an infinite number of things that could be seen as “for the greater good”, but personal freedoms come first for many of these things in society. Always has done. It’s for the greater good if alcohol was banned. But it’s not. It’s not about the government deciding whether it’s for the greater good, it’s about them deciding to create a two tier society and banning people from places if they don’t do what they’re asked.

Are you comfortable letting the government decide what can be coerced as “for the greater good” and those who don’t go along are excluded from some aspects of society? I’m not. It’s disgusting IMO.

They’ll argue it’s about health. See my point about people with covid being allowed to an event if they’ve had the vax. But not allowed if they haven’t got covid but are unvaccinated. How’s that for the greater good (in this case health)? It’s a nonsense. Utter nonsense.

This division being created is going to get messy. Really really messy.
Reply
#77
(10-05-2021, 12:45 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 12:35 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 11:02 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 10:16 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 09:46 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: I think the problem within the scenario of those who choose not to be vaccinated comes down to something that has been argued on this bored for well over a year : rights versus responsibilities.  No one has a sacrosanct right within a society to exercise a "right" without also acknowledging responsibilities to the wider society.  Those who choose not to be vaccinated can exercise that right but the problem arises when they may as a consequence infect other individuals as a result of becoming infected.  Of course it is possible to become infected and go on to infect others, even though one may be double vaccinated, but clearly the risk of both is greatly reduced.  How do we weigh the risks of infection by a non-vaccinated person against the right of the individual in society at large?

I see that in New York the state authority has fired some 1400 employees working in health care who refused to be vaccinated.  At the same time there was a last minute huge rush to get vaccinated when the deadline approached so that thousands more did get the jab.  I think there is definitely a case for the compulsory vaccination of individuals who work closely in health care with the sick or the vulnerable as the onus of care is on those protecting persons at greater risk.  In most other respects the argument is less compelling.

I often see people make the argument that there are fundamental rights, and indeed the UN has a human rights charter, but within a nation state the only real rights one has are those the society allows you to have.  Thus in times of great crisis, be it war, climate catastrophe or pandemic, rights once thought to be inalienable are not quite so universal as they may have been in normal times.  The government has a right to curtail the rights of the individual for what it sees as the greater good - it has done so in the past and it almost certainly will do so in the future.  This may be seen as a slippery slope by some, or simply the exercise of good governance by others.  Tricky job running a country.

Very eloquently put Brentbaggie and something I have argued for at least a year. There are a few on here who are incapable of even admitting that people have responsibilities. It's the politics of the playground.

No one has said there’s not a case for care workers or nhs being vaccinated for their job. But it’s not as simple as all that. And you still cannot explain what happens if it causes a shortage.

And remember, it was these care workers who 18 months ago went to work and risked their life with no proper PPE while many of us sat on our arses working from home saying his great it was not to have a commute. Care workers on minimum wage putting themselves at the forefront of risk and never complained. They got on with it while lots of us sat on our computers safe as houses. They were heroes. Now many of those people sat on their computers are happy to see these people sacked for making a different decision on a vaccine. That doesn’t sit right with me. In fact I think it’s gross. Clap for carers to sack for carers in 18 months.

And you may call it politics of the playground DH, but you’re more guilty of that than most on here. Still waiting for an answer of what happens if there’s a care worker shortage (it’ll be nhs next)

As always in these situations there are some hypothetical causes and effects and some more concrete ones.  I don't argue that Care workers should be sacked and no one could deny the risks they have taken in the past.  However those risks are now more quantifiable and the situation is very different to what it was a year or so ago.  As Churchill famously said, "When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do?" To argue that a care workers' right to continue to work without being vaccinated transcends someone vulnerable's right to be protected is to say the least a 'fine' conundrum, but it is the essence of my reasoning.  

Now it may be that unvaccinated Careworkers can continue to be tested for Covid every two or three days, as happens with almost all hospital staff as I understand it, and so fulfill their responsibility to their co-workers and more importantly those in their care.  How long this can go on will be I think be the practical heart of this question. New York has reasoned in favour of taking what might be called the "unsentimental" approach. I don't think it will happen here. I hope it doesn't have to.  But I hope at the same time that some of the reticent care workers' fears re. the vaccine are becoming assuaged with the passage of time and they get the jab. Thems my onions.

I think the unvaccinated care workers are leaving and simply getting other minimum wage jobs. There’ll be a shortage once this happens. 

I think it’ll be nhs staff next, then other jobs too… offices, shops etc. Australia has I think mandated it for construction workers I think. And the scenes from Melbourne protests are not pretty. We’ve got all this to come IMO. Many think the worst of covid is over. I don’t think the real chaos has even started yet (socially as we’re discussing, and economically).

(10-05-2021, 12:43 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 11:38 AM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 08:52 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 08:46 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: Yes that is correct- to be a better match for the most likely strain they expect to be prevalent. Have they tweaked the Covid booster or is it still aimed at the Alpha?

I take it that your non-comment on how transmission works and what reduced transmission means now indicates that you agree that the vaccine has reduced transmission.

And your continued comparison of treatment for flu and covid is madness - the vaccine may or may not be as effective at treating the delta variant as it was the alpha variant but it is all we have got to reduce the transmission and it may not be 100% as effective but by being 75% effective it is still effective.

Just as an example why flu jabs and covid jabs aren't comparable is in the requirement for treating covid compared with flu. Annually on a global basis flu kills between quarter and half a million whereas covid has, in conservative estimates, killed 3M whilst the global excess death figure is nearer 5M (although due to timescales and different country reporting methods that is difficult to measure) but we are looking at 4M deaths more than normal in 2020.

I never said it didn't reduce transmission at all. I said that the actual percentage was debatable. According to SkyNews today the effectiveness of reducing transmission for Pfizer is 47% after 6 months having reduced from 88% at the outset. It is reasonable to expect it to drop even lower after another few months so boosters seem likely for everyone. It remains to be seen how the effectiveness against transmission will hold up after the boosters of course.

Good, so we agree that having the jab reduces transmission, and as it obviously is waning given time then we therefore agree that having one jab is good, a second is better as it brings the reduction of transmission back up, and until a better method is identified then any further boosters are also a good idea as it has been shown that the second jab brings improved protection and reduces transmission therefore the likelihood is the booster will do the same.

And to another point you raise, it isn't the government deciding on what is for the greater good, it is bleeding obvious that having the jab is for the greater good of society.

That’s totally missing the point. There’s an infinite number of things that could be seen as “for the greater good”, but personal freedoms come first for many of these things in society. Always has done. It’s for the greater good if alcohol was banned. But it’s not. It’s not about the government deciding whether it’s for the greater good, it’s about them deciding to create a two tier society and banning people from places if they don’t do what they’re asked.

Are you comfortable letting the government decide what can be coerced as “for the greater good” and those who don’t go along are excluded from some aspects of society? I’m not. It’s disgusting IMO.

They’ll argue it’s about health. See my point about people with covid being allowed to an event if they’ve had the vax. But not allowed if they haven’t got covid but are unvaccinated. How’s that for the greater good (in this case health)? It’s a nonsense. Utter nonsense.

This division being created is going to get messy. Really really messy.

So where is the personal freedom of the most vulnerable protected in your argument?
Reply
#78
(10-05-2021, 12:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 12:45 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 12:35 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 11:02 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 10:16 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Very eloquently put Brentbaggie and something I have argued for at least a year. There are a few on here who are incapable of even admitting that people have responsibilities. It's the politics of the playground.

No one has said there’s not a case for care workers or nhs being vaccinated for their job. But it’s not as simple as all that. And you still cannot explain what happens if it causes a shortage.

And remember, it was these care workers who 18 months ago went to work and risked their life with no proper PPE while many of us sat on our arses working from home saying his great it was not to have a commute. Care workers on minimum wage putting themselves at the forefront of risk and never complained. They got on with it while lots of us sat on our computers safe as houses. They were heroes. Now many of those people sat on their computers are happy to see these people sacked for making a different decision on a vaccine. That doesn’t sit right with me. In fact I think it’s gross. Clap for carers to sack for carers in 18 months.

And you may call it politics of the playground DH, but you’re more guilty of that than most on here. Still waiting for an answer of what happens if there’s a care worker shortage (it’ll be nhs next)

As always in these situations there are some hypothetical causes and effects and some more concrete ones.  I don't argue that Care workers should be sacked and no one could deny the risks they have taken in the past.  However those risks are now more quantifiable and the situation is very different to what it was a year or so ago.  As Churchill famously said, "When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do?" To argue that a care workers' right to continue to work without being vaccinated transcends someone vulnerable's right to be protected is to say the least a 'fine' conundrum, but it is the essence of my reasoning.  

Now it may be that unvaccinated Careworkers can continue to be tested for Covid every two or three days, as happens with almost all hospital staff as I understand it, and so fulfill their responsibility to their co-workers and more importantly those in their care.  How long this can go on will be I think be the practical heart of this question. New York has reasoned in favour of taking what might be called the "unsentimental" approach. I don't think it will happen here. I hope it doesn't have to.  But I hope at the same time that some of the reticent care workers' fears re. the vaccine are becoming assuaged with the passage of time and they get the jab. Thems my onions.

I think the unvaccinated care workers are leaving and simply getting other minimum wage jobs. There’ll be a shortage once this happens. 

I think it’ll be nhs staff next, then other jobs too… offices, shops etc. Australia has I think mandated it for construction workers I think. And the scenes from Melbourne protests are not pretty. We’ve got all this to come IMO. Many think the worst of covid is over. I don’t think the real chaos has even started yet (socially as we’re discussing, and economically).

(10-05-2021, 12:43 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 11:38 AM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 08:52 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I take it that your non-comment on how transmission works and what reduced transmission means now indicates that you agree that the vaccine has reduced transmission.

And your continued comparison of treatment for flu and covid is madness - the vaccine may or may not be as effective at treating the delta variant as it was the alpha variant but it is all we have got to reduce the transmission and it may not be 100% as effective but by being 75% effective it is still effective.

Just as an example why flu jabs and covid jabs aren't comparable is in the requirement for treating covid compared with flu. Annually on a global basis flu kills between quarter and half a million whereas covid has, in conservative estimates, killed 3M whilst the global excess death figure is nearer 5M (although due to timescales and different country reporting methods that is difficult to measure) but we are looking at 4M deaths more than normal in 2020.

I never said it didn't reduce transmission at all. I said that the actual percentage was debatable. According to SkyNews today the effectiveness of reducing transmission for Pfizer is 47% after 6 months having reduced from 88% at the outset. It is reasonable to expect it to drop even lower after another few months so boosters seem likely for everyone. It remains to be seen how the effectiveness against transmission will hold up after the boosters of course.

Good, so we agree that having the jab reduces transmission, and as it obviously is waning given time then we therefore agree that having one jab is good, a second is better as it brings the reduction of transmission back up, and until a better method is identified then any further boosters are also a good idea as it has been shown that the second jab brings improved protection and reduces transmission therefore the likelihood is the booster will do the same.

And to another point you raise, it isn't the government deciding on what is for the greater good, it is bleeding obvious that having the jab is for the greater good of society.

That’s totally missing the point. There’s an infinite number of things that could be seen as “for the greater good”, but personal freedoms come first for many of these things in society. Always has done. It’s for the greater good if alcohol was banned. But it’s not. It’s not about the government deciding whether it’s for the greater good, it’s about them deciding to create a two tier society and banning people from places if they don’t do what they’re asked.

Are you comfortable letting the government decide what can be coerced as “for the greater good” and those who don’t go along are excluded from some aspects of society? I’m not. It’s disgusting IMO.

They’ll argue it’s about health. See my point about people with covid being allowed to an event if they’ve had the vax. But not allowed if they haven’t got covid but are unvaccinated. How’s that for the greater good (in this case health)? It’s a nonsense. Utter nonsense.

This division being created is going to get messy. Really really messy.

So where is the personal freedom of the most vulnerable protected in your argument?

There’s no perfect way of protecting the most vulnerable DH. 

Where’s the personal medical freedom in your argument?

Where’s the protection for the vulnerable given vaccinated can still get covid and are half as likely to pass it on? (Still a darn good chance). Had there been significant outbreaks in care homes over the last 8-9 months when many staff remain unvaccinated? I don’t think there has? Testing seems to have worked well has it not?

Where’s the fact testing is a reasonable alternative?

Where’s the answer to a staff dshortage crisis in care and nhs should a percentage be sacked?

I think these people are being treated like shit, and I’m glad there’s a number of minimum wage vacancies for them to apply elsewhere at present. Let’s see how well the vulnerable are cared for if there’s a staff shortage.
Reply
#79
(10-05-2021, 01:07 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 12:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 12:45 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 12:35 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 11:02 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: No one has said there’s not a case for care workers or nhs being vaccinated for their job. But it’s not as simple as all that. And you still cannot explain what happens if it causes a shortage.

And remember, it was these care workers who 18 months ago went to work and risked their life with no proper PPE while many of us sat on our arses working from home saying his great it was not to have a commute. Care workers on minimum wage putting themselves at the forefront of risk and never complained. They got on with it while lots of us sat on our computers safe as houses. They were heroes. Now many of those people sat on their computers are happy to see these people sacked for making a different decision on a vaccine. That doesn’t sit right with me. In fact I think it’s gross. Clap for carers to sack for carers in 18 months.

And you may call it politics of the playground DH, but you’re more guilty of that than most on here. Still waiting for an answer of what happens if there’s a care worker shortage (it’ll be nhs next)

As always in these situations there are some hypothetical causes and effects and some more concrete ones.  I don't argue that Care workers should be sacked and no one could deny the risks they have taken in the past.  However those risks are now more quantifiable and the situation is very different to what it was a year or so ago.  As Churchill famously said, "When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do?" To argue that a care workers' right to continue to work without being vaccinated transcends someone vulnerable's right to be protected is to say the least a 'fine' conundrum, but it is the essence of my reasoning.  

Now it may be that unvaccinated Careworkers can continue to be tested for Covid every two or three days, as happens with almost all hospital staff as I understand it, and so fulfill their responsibility to their co-workers and more importantly those in their care.  How long this can go on will be I think be the practical heart of this question. New York has reasoned in favour of taking what might be called the "unsentimental" approach. I don't think it will happen here. I hope it doesn't have to.  But I hope at the same time that some of the reticent care workers' fears re. the vaccine are becoming assuaged with the passage of time and they get the jab. Thems my onions.

I think the unvaccinated care workers are leaving and simply getting other minimum wage jobs. There’ll be a shortage once this happens. 

I think it’ll be nhs staff next, then other jobs too… offices, shops etc. Australia has I think mandated it for construction workers I think. And the scenes from Melbourne protests are not pretty. We’ve got all this to come IMO. Many think the worst of covid is over. I don’t think the real chaos has even started yet (socially as we’re discussing, and economically).

(10-05-2021, 12:43 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 11:38 AM)baggiebuckster Wrote: I never said it didn't reduce transmission at all. I said that the actual percentage was debatable. According to SkyNews today the effectiveness of reducing transmission for Pfizer is 47% after 6 months having reduced from 88% at the outset. It is reasonable to expect it to drop even lower after another few months so boosters seem likely for everyone. It remains to be seen how the effectiveness against transmission will hold up after the boosters of course.

Good, so we agree that having the jab reduces transmission, and as it obviously is waning given time then we therefore agree that having one jab is good, a second is better as it brings the reduction of transmission back up, and until a better method is identified then any further boosters are also a good idea as it has been shown that the second jab brings improved protection and reduces transmission therefore the likelihood is the booster will do the same.

And to another point you raise, it isn't the government deciding on what is for the greater good, it is bleeding obvious that having the jab is for the greater good of society.

That’s totally missing the point. There’s an infinite number of things that could be seen as “for the greater good”, but personal freedoms come first for many of these things in society. Always has done. It’s for the greater good if alcohol was banned. But it’s not. It’s not about the government deciding whether it’s for the greater good, it’s about them deciding to create a two tier society and banning people from places if they don’t do what they’re asked.

Are you comfortable letting the government decide what can be coerced as “for the greater good” and those who don’t go along are excluded from some aspects of society? I’m not. It’s disgusting IMO.

They’ll argue it’s about health. See my point about people with covid being allowed to an event if they’ve had the vax. But not allowed if they haven’t got covid but are unvaccinated. How’s that for the greater good (in this case health)? It’s a nonsense. Utter nonsense.

This division being created is going to get messy. Really really messy.

So where is the personal freedom of the most vulnerable protected in your argument?

There’s no perfect way of protecting the most vulnerable DH. 

Where’s the personal medical freedom in your argument?

Where’s the protection for the vulnerable given vaccinated can still get covid and are half as likely to pass it on? (Still a darn good chance). Had there been significant outbreaks in care homes over the last 8-9 months when many staff remain unvaccinated? I don’t think there has? Testing seems to have worked well has it not?

Where’s the fact testing is a reasonable alternative?

Where’s the answer to a staff dshortage crisis in care and nhs should a percentage be sacked?

I think these people are being treated like shit, and I’m glad there’s a number of minimum wage vacancies for them to apply elsewhere at present. Let’s see how well the vulnerable are cared for if there’s a staff shortage.

Still no answer
Reply
#80
(10-05-2021, 01:24 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 01:07 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 12:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 12:45 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 12:35 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote: As always in these situations there are some hypothetical causes and effects and some more concrete ones.  I don't argue that Care workers should be sacked and no one could deny the risks they have taken in the past.  However those risks are now more quantifiable and the situation is very different to what it was a year or so ago.  As Churchill famously said, "When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do?" To argue that a care workers' right to continue to work without being vaccinated transcends someone vulnerable's right to be protected is to say the least a 'fine' conundrum, but it is the essence of my reasoning.  

Now it may be that unvaccinated Careworkers can continue to be tested for Covid every two or three days, as happens with almost all hospital staff as I understand it, and so fulfill their responsibility to their co-workers and more importantly those in their care.  How long this can go on will be I think be the practical heart of this question. New York has reasoned in favour of taking what might be called the "unsentimental" approach. I don't think it will happen here. I hope it doesn't have to.  But I hope at the same time that some of the reticent care workers' fears re. the vaccine are becoming assuaged with the passage of time and they get the jab. Thems my onions.

I think the unvaccinated care workers are leaving and simply getting other minimum wage jobs. There’ll be a shortage once this happens. 

I think it’ll be nhs staff next, then other jobs too… offices, shops etc. Australia has I think mandated it for construction workers I think. And the scenes from Melbourne protests are not pretty. We’ve got all this to come IMO. Many think the worst of covid is over. I don’t think the real chaos has even started yet (socially as we’re discussing, and economically).

(10-05-2021, 12:43 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Good, so we agree that having the jab reduces transmission, and as it obviously is waning given time then we therefore agree that having one jab is good, a second is better as it brings the reduction of transmission back up, and until a better method is identified then any further boosters are also a good idea as it has been shown that the second jab brings improved protection and reduces transmission therefore the likelihood is the booster will do the same.

And to another point you raise, it isn't the government deciding on what is for the greater good, it is bleeding obvious that having the jab is for the greater good of society.

That’s totally missing the point. There’s an infinite number of things that could be seen as “for the greater good”, but personal freedoms come first for many of these things in society. Always has done. It’s for the greater good if alcohol was banned. But it’s not. It’s not about the government deciding whether it’s for the greater good, it’s about them deciding to create a two tier society and banning people from places if they don’t do what they’re asked.

Are you comfortable letting the government decide what can be coerced as “for the greater good” and those who don’t go along are excluded from some aspects of society? I’m not. It’s disgusting IMO.

They’ll argue it’s about health. See my point about people with covid being allowed to an event if they’ve had the vax. But not allowed if they haven’t got covid but are unvaccinated. How’s that for the greater good (in this case health)? It’s a nonsense. Utter nonsense.

This division being created is going to get messy. Really really messy.

So where is the personal freedom of the most vulnerable protected in your argument?

There’s no perfect way of protecting the most vulnerable DH. 

Where’s the personal medical freedom in your argument?

Where’s the protection for the vulnerable given vaccinated can still get covid and are half as likely to pass it on? (Still a darn good chance). Had there been significant outbreaks in care homes over the last 8-9 months when many staff remain unvaccinated? I don’t think there has? Testing seems to have worked well has it not?

Where’s the fact testing is a reasonable alternative?

Where’s the answer to a staff dshortage crisis in care and nhs should a percentage be sacked?

I think these people are being treated like shit, and I’m glad there’s a number of minimum wage vacancies for them to apply elsewhere at present. Let’s see how well the vulnerable are cared for if there’s a staff shortage.

Still no answer

Lol! Coming from you who literally has been unable to answer my question about staff shortages over many threads for the last 6 months.

I repeat, there is no perfect way of protecting the vulnerable. That’s literally why they’re vulnerable! Reasonable testing will protect them as much as possible (for vaccinated and non vaccinated staff). Staff having the vaccine doesn’t protect the vulnerable fully.

Sacking care and nhs staff in a health crisis is beyond dumb! So let’s see how well the vulnerable are protected when there’s staff shortages - a point you have not been able to answer in months!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 4 Guest(s)