Erling Haaland
#61
Superb athlete and player.
I think he would make any team in any era!
Reply
#62
(05-04-2023, 09:04 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 08:55 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 08:53 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 08:42 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 08:38 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Ok, 20 years ago he was 2. I don't even think he would have got one goal.

Point is it's all about questioning the achievement of this record, whilst acknowledging the talent. We as Albion fans have seen the Prem boat sail off and we couldn't even hope to be competitive against Man City's reserves. So fawning over Haaland whilst not doing a shade more critical thinking about the environment that has had created this seems to be a shade simplistic.

As I've said further up though City have had elite players before and the environment you mention has existed for a while. Yet nobody in that environment has achieved what Haaland has this season.

It's not "fawning" to acknowledge that he's simply a different class to what has come before him.

And I have. Look at the very start of the thread- I think he is going to be one of the greatest of all time. He is phenomenal, but he is also in a team that has world stars galore around him. 
His record though surely isn't as impressive as Dixie Dean's on for want of a better term was in a time when those muddy pitches saw teams on a level playing field.

This is a pointless comparison though. Physical ability was way lower back in the day, goalkeeping and defending likely wasn't of the standard it is today. That isn't meant to denegrate the achievement of Dean, it just serves no purpose. It's effectively a different sport.

Yes. 

It's not a pointless comparison though is it otherwise we just all become lemmings and buy into the Prem jizzfest. 

Everton won the league with the equivalent of 78 points in todays's maths, from 42 games. With 9 games less City have overtaken that figure last night.

Dean did it in a league that was competitive, playing against teams of a similar quality.

I am paying homage to how great Haaland is whilst saying, steady on, lets not get carried away in a way Sky and the  corrupt oil rich Arabs who own City want us to.

Honestly, the sooner they are feck off to their intergalactic league the better.

Yes. Forget about 'muddy and rock hard pitches' and the other myriad of differences between the game 30, 50, 60 years ago. All were playing in the same conditions and to a certain degree can only be judged in times in which they were playing.

The real, crucial difference is that due to the money involved in the modern game the true, elite players - with the odd outlier here or there - are now all sucked up by a tiny handful of mega-rich clubs and it has created a field so uneven it's a miracle players can even stand upright when they play one of the 'big boys'.

The average points total of the title winners over 6 year periods are:

'68-'73: 80
'80-'85: 76
'88-'93: 81
'94-'99: 82
'00-'05: 87
'10-'15: 87
'17-'22: 95

Is it any wonder that with the beginning of the Premier League the winning points average gradually edged up, then took off following Chelsea's influx of cash, before shooting up again with Man City, who with the combined threat of a virtual bottomless pit of money and under the tutelage of Pep, have taken things to a whole different level over the last 5 years?

The league for Man City is currently more or less 30+ games of theatre with 6-8 games of sport sandwiched in-between.

(05-04-2023, 08:52 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 08:42 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 08:38 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 08:31 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: But that isn't your argument spandau, you said stick him in a team 20 years ago.

Ok, 20 years ago he was 2. I don't even think he would have got one goal.

Point is it's all about questioning the achievement of this record, whilst acknowledging the talent. We as Albion fans have seen the Prem boat sail off and we couldn't even hope to be competitive against Man City's reserves. So fawning over Haaland whilst not doing a shade more critical thinking about the environment that has had created this seems to be a shade simplistic.

As I've said further up though City have had elite players before and the environment you mention has existed for a while. Yet nobody in that environment has achieved what Haaland has this season.

It's not "fawning" to acknowledge that he's simply a different class to what has come before him.

Let's take a look at City's top goal scorers for the last 6 seasons, when you can easily say they're the cream of the crop.

21/22 - De Bruyne (15)
20/21 - Gundogan (13)
19/20 - Sterling (20)
18/19 - Aguero (21)
17/18 - Aguero (21)
16/17 - Aguero (20)

The most Aguero managed for City was 24. Haaland currently has 35 goals in 31 appearances. And they've still got 5 games left. It's definitely a cut above.

Aguero's most was 26. The season he reached 24 was in just 30 games. The crucial point is that both these were before Pep arrived and it is Pep who is the real star at Man City. City have only really dominated over the last 5 years  -Aguero was almost 30 by the start of that dominance and his game had already been affected by a number of injuries.

Before this season, City had scored 485 league goals over 5 season. The goals were more spread around though and City are playing a slightly different game this year.

(05-04-2023, 09:14 AM)Duffers Wrote: 29 goals in 27 games for RB Salzburg
86 goals in 89 games for Dortmund
51 goals in 45 games for City
21 goals in 23 games for Norway

He was incredible well before he signed for City.


'Incredible' is a bit much. Maradona and Messi were incredible at their peaks. He's a superb centre forward but he's not going to be an 'all time great' type player.

Patrick Schlick has 36 in 70 for Leverkusen over the same period and 18 in 35 for Czech Republic in his career.

Timo Werner had 78 in 127 for Leipzig before going to Chelsea.

If having close to a goal a game for Dortmund makes Haaland 'incredible' then how would you describe Schlick and Werner? 'Absolutely superb'?
Reply
#63
Not sure why this is up for debate. He is quite simply the best forward the Premier League has ever seen and would obviously be better than the old guard when football was a different game etc etc.

It's great to watch him and his movement and yes, he has quality around him but he'd do it for anyone. It's great to watch good players.

Only thing that will hold him back is that, unlike the likes of Ronaldo and Messi, he won't ever achieve anything on the world stage Aplaying for Norway.

I wish the lad well. Great to watch.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: