Erling Haaland
#11
(05-04-2023, 07:01 AM)Logic1 Wrote: Why is everyone going on about this record. Dixie Dean scored 60 goals in a top flight season (he played 39 games). Haaland isn't even close to that record. It would become a remarkable achievement if he gets 50+ goals as no one other than Dean has done that. There are a few players (Jimmy Greaves being one) who banged in between 40-49.

Honestly, this bullshit about the Premier League is fucking ridiculous. It's like football never existed before 1992.

I’m sure he’ll get near that record once he’s had a season to adapt and get used to the league.
Reply
#12
(05-03-2023, 09:41 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: You beat me to a post on him Saus and I’m going to piss on the parade somewhat whilst accepting that he is a truly astonishing player.
His record is in a great deal due to the cumulative effects of having a billion pounds of talent around him. How many goals less would he have even playing for Arsenal? I would guess several.
I would love to put him in say Shearers position in a Time Machine in a more equal league.
He’s another tool in the unequal money machine for a bunch of sport washing Arabs.
It’s a bittersweet thing as I truly think he is going to be a legend. The bloke has it all, but having De Bruyne able to line up chances is worth something.

Given how much faster and complex the game now is, I imagine Haaland would score double if you sent him back 20 years. Two wingers getting to the byline and swinging the ball in and him playing as a poacher supreme, he’d be in his element. 

Haaland is a machine and if you give him chances, he will bury them. As Birdie says, Man City don’t really play to his strengths, they create chances but not the sort he tends to favour. If they released the ball to him sooner, played more direct through balls or crossed a little sooner you could probably add 10 to his tally this year.

City have scored almost 140 goals in all comps this year, and that’s with a Haaland probably at 7/10…
Reply
#13
I find all modern day records a bit cringe. It's a bit like that Olympic sprinter winning the mom's race at her kid's school sports day, but taking it seriously. Winning a fixed / unfair race is no great achievement.

If any of these super star players or managers want to really prove their worth, then come to a club like ours.

I know these days Le Tiss is a bit of a bellend, but, pound for pound, he's still the best the greed league has ever seen IMO. Mainly because much of what he did, he did while surrounded by a bunch of cloggers and journeymen.
Reply
#14
(05-04-2023, 07:23 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-03-2023, 09:41 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: You beat me to a post on him Saus and I’m going to piss on the parade somewhat whilst accepting that he is a truly astonishing player.
His record is in a great deal due to the cumulative effects of having a billion pounds of talent around him. How many goals less would he have even playing for Arsenal? I would guess several.
I would love to put him in say Shearers position in a Time Machine in a more equal league.
He’s another tool in the unequal money machine for a bunch of sport washing Arabs.
It’s a bittersweet thing as I truly think he is going to be a legend. The bloke has it all, but having De Bruyne able to line up chances is worth something.

Given how much faster and complex the game now is, I imagine Haaland would score double if you sent him back 20 years. Two wingers getting to the byline and swinging the ball in and him playing as a poacher supreme, he’d be in his element. 

Haaland is a machine and if you give him chances, he will bury them. As Birdie says, Man City don’t really play to his strengths, they create chances but not the sort he tends to favour. If they released the ball to him sooner, played more direct through balls or crossed a little sooner you could probably add 10 to his tally this year.

City have scored almost 140 goals in all comps this year, and that’s with a Haaland probably at 7/10…

Spot on, he's probably twice as fit and healthy as players were 20 years ago as well.
In the form of his life.
Reply
#15
(05-04-2023, 08:06 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 07:23 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-03-2023, 09:41 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: You beat me to a post on him Saus and I’m going to piss on the parade somewhat whilst accepting that he is a truly astonishing player.
His record is in a great deal due to the cumulative effects of having a billion pounds of talent around him. How many goals less would he have even playing for Arsenal? I would guess several.
I would love to put him in say Shearers position in a Time Machine in a more equal league.
He’s another tool in the unequal money machine for a bunch of sport washing Arabs.
It’s a bittersweet thing as I truly think he is going to be a legend. The bloke has it all, but having De Bruyne able to line up chances is worth something.

Given how much faster and complex the game now is, I imagine Haaland would score double if you sent him back 20 years. Two wingers getting to the byline and swinging the ball in and him playing as a poacher supreme, he’d be in his element. 

Haaland is a machine and if you give him chances, he will bury them. As Birdie says, Man City don’t really play to his strengths, they create chances but not the sort he tends to favour. If they released the ball to him sooner, played more direct through balls or crossed a little sooner you could probably add 10 to his tally this year.

City have scored almost 140 goals in all comps this year, and that’s with a Haaland probably at 7/10…

Spot on, he's probably twice as fit and healthy as players were 20 years ago as well.

And don't you think the players of 20 years ago would be fitter and healthier if they had been born in this era? Of course they would.

You can only be the best of your time and Haaland is phenomenal, of that I've no doubt- I think he will probably go onto be one of the top players in history. However, as one or two on here have said let's not get carried away as at the top tier football is now so incredibly unequal. 

Anyone wishing to look at the Guardian article I linked earlier will see that the top teams score more goals, accumulate more points than they did 30 years ago whilst the bottom few get less points and less goals. 

There's a chasm, getting wider, and buying one player that costs more than the whole of the squad of 20 for a team 15 places below you in the league makes a mockery of the competitiveness.

So whilst acknowledging Haaland's greatness let's have some perspective.

(05-04-2023, 08:05 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: I find all modern day records a bit cringe. It's a bit like that Olympic sprinter winning the mom's race at her kid's school sports day, but taking it seriously. Winning a fixed / unfair race is no great achievement.

If any of these super star players or managers want to really prove their worth, then come to a club like ours.

I know these days Le Tiss is a bit of a bellend, but, pound for pound, he's still the best the greed league has ever seen IMO. Mainly because much of what he did, he did while surrounded by a bunch of cloggers and journeymen.

This in spades Bob. At City he gets more chances made by better players. The inequality of now is something far too easily brushed over and a failure to point it out does a disservice to clubs like ours.

The Haaland arguments does not stop at fawning over him. Let us look at what else has created this record, which we are.

It isn't anywhere near as pure a sporting achievement as say what Federer, Nadal and Djokovic have done.

(05-04-2023, 07:01 AM)Logic1 Wrote: Why is everyone going on about this record. Dixie Dean scored 60 goals in a top flight season (he played 39 games). Haaland isn't even close to that record. It would become a remarkable achievement if he gets 50+ goals as no one other than Dean has done that. There are a few players (Jimmy Greaves being one) who banged in between 40-49.

Honestly, this bullshit about the Premier League is fucking ridiculous. It's like football never existed before 1992.

x 2.

Don't believe the Prem hype. Look how fed up most clubs fans are with the pointlessness of it.
Reply
#16
Whilst I can see the "Yeah but he's in a billion pound team creating chances for him" argument it's worth remembering that City have been an elite side for years now and have never seen a single player score this many goals.

Even Sergio Aguero, for my money of the greatest strikers of the PL era, couldn't get near Haaland's numbers.
Reply
#17
But that isn't your argument spandau, you said stick him in a team 20 years ago.
In the form of his life.
Reply
#18
(05-04-2023, 08:31 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: But that isn't your argument spandau, you said stick him in a team 20 years ago.

Ok, 20 years ago he was 2. I don't even think he would have got one goal.

Point is it's all about questioning the achievement of this record, whilst acknowledging the talent. We as Albion fans have seen the Prem boat sail off and we couldn't even hope to be competitive against Man City's reserves. So fawning over Haaland whilst not doing a shade more critical thinking about the environment that has created this seems to be a shade simplistic.
Reply
#19
(05-04-2023, 08:38 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 08:31 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: But that isn't your argument spandau, you said stick him in a team 20 years ago.

Ok, 20 years ago he was 2. I don't even think he would have got one goal.

Point is it's all about questioning the achievement of this record, whilst acknowledging the talent. We as Albion fans have seen the Prem boat sail off and we couldn't even hope to be competitive against Man City's reserves. So fawning over Haaland whilst not doing a shade more critical thinking about the environment that has had created this seems to be a shade simplistic.

As I've said further up though City have had elite players before and the environment you mention has existed for a while. Yet nobody in that environment has achieved what Haaland has this season.

It's not "fawning" to acknowledge that he's simply a different class to what has come before him.
Reply
#20
(05-04-2023, 08:42 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 08:38 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 08:31 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: But that isn't your argument spandau, you said stick him in a team 20 years ago.

Ok, 20 years ago he was 2. I don't even think he would have got one goal.

Point is it's all about questioning the achievement of this record, whilst acknowledging the talent. We as Albion fans have seen the Prem boat sail off and we couldn't even hope to be competitive against Man City's reserves. So fawning over Haaland whilst not doing a shade more critical thinking about the environment that has had created this seems to be a shade simplistic.

As I've said further up though City have had elite players before and the environment you mention has existed for a while. Yet nobody in that environment has achieved what Haaland has this season.

It's not "fawning" to acknowledge that he's simply a different class to what has come before him.

Let's take a look at City's top goal scorers for the last 6 seasons, when you can easily say they're the cream of the crop.

21/22 - De Bruyne (15)
20/21 - Gundogan (13)
19/20 - Sterling (20)
18/19 - Aguero (21)
17/18 - Aguero (21)
16/17 - Aguero (20)

The most Aguero managed for City was 24. Haaland currently has 35 goals in 31 appearances. And they've still got 5 games left. It's definitely a cut above.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: