My final word on Val's tenure
#61
Be interesting to see who has the actual final word on this subject and when :-)

Just in case it's me.
He was crap, but the players are worse.
Reply
#62
(03-03-2022, 11:38 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(03-03-2022, 08:38 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(03-03-2022, 08:07 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(03-03-2022, 12:20 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(03-02-2022, 03:04 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: Although some are clamouring for him to come back into the side as soon as he's fit, I can still remember Phillips bottling out of 50-50 challenges during our promotion season with Bilic.

We've stupidly given them long contracts with no reasonable justification, but it's the old guard that we need to see the back of most, so that we can try to build with younger, hungrier players. It's hard to imagine who else would take them off our hands though who they'd be willing to go to.

Snods signed by Luton. 

We'll have to cut our losses no doubt on some of them  but if we cut them adrift and they want to play?   That's if they do!  

We've only really invested big money on Diang and Grant.  Both are still young and will come good with the right manager but if not move them on.

There is an argument to be had that Robinson cost us 15m.

Or are we just writing the Burke transfer fee off.

There is but it’s a crappy argument. Burke wasn’t worth a fifth of that when we swapped him. It’s not like we could’ve swapped Burke for Diangana or chose a 15m pound player we wanted and paid with Burke instead of cash. The only reason we managed to get Robinson is because Sheff United really didn’t want him

Still 15m paid .

Add that to the fees paid for Diangana and Grant that's 45m plus.

That's a lot of money with very little prospect of ever realising more than a third of that sum, as things stand.

Well that's true but I don't think you can count Robinson as a big money signing, we swapped him for a player that wasn't even getting on our bench. It was a lot of money wasted on Burke, not Robinson.
Reply
#63
Val turned out to be crap. Ferenc was the first one to point it out eloquently, that he was wrong for us. I'm honest enough to say I dissed Ferenc for this, but I was proven wrong.

I have always had patience with managers, but my patience ran out when we lost to Preston. It was clear the game was up. 99 per cent of fans thought this too.

The final word on Val is there appears 3 posters with some fixation on him still and are trying to rewrite history. He was appalling- a disaster and Bruce has been given a sow's ear, made from Val's paperweight midfield. However, so far he's not doing anything.

I really hope this ends it.
Reply
#64
(03-03-2022, 03:00 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: The final word on Val is there appears 3 posters with some fixation on him still and are trying to rewrite history.

You missed the point of my OP then (or are choosing to ignore it), which was to try to evidentially show that it's people like yourself who are rewriting history when it actually wasn't as awful as you're making out.
Reply
#65
(03-03-2022, 03:11 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(03-03-2022, 03:00 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: The final word on Val is there appears 3 posters with some fixation on him still and are trying to rewrite history.

You missed the point of my OP then (or are choosing to ignore it), which was to try to evidentially show that it's people like yourself who are rewriting history when it actually wasn't as awful as you're making out.

Sorry Worcs, as I said I gave him the benefit of the doubt far more than most. I cringed when I heard fans in the Smethwick turning on him when we were struggling to beat Peterborough.

I desperately wanted him to succeed. However, after that the Preston game sealed his fate and the no show v Millwall added to it.

He'd lost the plot. Awful football and no goals.

The hideous start to Bruce's era does make me wonder would we have done any worse if we'd kept him. I suspect we wouldn't have.

However, there's some serious crap at the club at the minute that has come from the top.

You fight your corner well chap, but I doubt you'll change anyone's mind. Onwards we go.
Reply
#66
(03-03-2022, 03:24 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: However, there's some serious crap at the club at the minute that has come from the top.

I agree entirely about that and can't see there's going to be an end to it anytime soon.
Reply
#67
(03-03-2022, 03:00 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: The final word on Val is there appears 3 posters with some fixation on him still and are trying to rewrite history.

'Appears' is the key word. I was happy with Val until Preston also, which is around the same time as you. After then I said he needs to go but whichever poor sod comes in next is going to struggle with the group of players we had, which is exactly what has happened.

No history rewriting from me, but hindsight has shown that we actually made a better start than people realised at the time for the quality we have.
Reply
#68
(03-03-2022, 03:24 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(03-03-2022, 03:11 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(03-03-2022, 03:00 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: The final word on Val is there appears 3 posters with some fixation on him still and are trying to rewrite history.

You missed the point of my OP then (or are choosing to ignore it), which was to try to evidentially show that it's people like yourself who are rewriting history when it actually wasn't as awful as you're making out.

Sorry Worcs, as I said I gave him the benefit of the doubt far more than most. I cringed when I heard fans in the Smethwick turning on him when we were struggling to beat Peterborough.

I desperately wanted him to succeed. However, after that the Preston game sealed his fate and the no show v Millwall added to it.

He'd lost the plot. Awful football and no goals.

The hideous start to Bruce's era does make me wonder would we have done any worse if we'd kept him. I suspect we wouldn't have.

However, there's some serious crap at the club at the minute that has come from the top.

You fight your corner well chap, but I doubt you'll change anyone's mind. Onwards we go.

But Preston was apparently due to Johnstone having a hissy fit at not being selected and the players downing tools.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: