Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
I'd be very happy with Duffy.
I'm amazed at how many quite sensible posters on here though still go on about transfer budgets as though they are a set number, they arent, there's one massive playing budget, as wages go up, transfer budget comes down, if Duffy takes a lower wage than say, Gibbs who gets moved on, we may pay 8 million in a fee, but that saving in wages also goes onto that budget.
Trust the team, they've earned it in my mind.
Posts: 27,980
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(08-11-2020, 06:32 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'd be very happy with Duffy.
I'm amazed at how many quite sensible posters on here though still go on about transfer budgets as though they are a set number, they arent, there's one massive playing budget, as wages go up, transfer budget comes down, if Duffy takes a lower wage than say, Gibbs who gets moved on, we may pay 8 million in a fee, but that saving in wages also goes onto that budget.
Trust the team, they've earned it in my mind.
Spot on.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(08-11-2020, 06:25 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: This (Duffy) is a sticky plaster over a huge crack which is our totally incompetent goalkeeper.
Spend the money on a decent keeper who has communication skills and, well, talent. The one we have is nowhere near good enough. I'd be delighted with Duffy but also a new keeper and then I think defensively we'd be competitive around where we need to compete. To sign Duffy for a whopping chunk and keep our Keeper would be daft. I don't think it would work. And we also need to think about improving on Laurel and Hardy up front!
Much to do. I don't think an 8m centre back is the answer.
Saying Johnstone has no talent is once again showing your total lack of knowledge Nick.
He's an excellent shot stopper, and his reactions are superb, amount of penalty saves he makes shows that. Everyone would say he doesn't command the box enough, and certainly isn't good at coming for crosses, but as has been mentioned a lot, almost all 'keepers under 30 suffer from that, since modern day coaching is more about reflexes and saving the ball when it goes at goal, rather than stopping it coming in at all, leaving that to the defenders.
I'd ideally like an experienced head to be his cover/replacement for a season or two, and see if he has developed as a player at all, if not, well we have Griffiths coming through, and if he hasn't improved, by then I like to think Palmer would have staked his claim for the no.1 jersey too.
'Keeper is always a difficult position to sort, cover is a player happy to not play, if you have young, highly talented 'keepers, you have to allow for the fact they will make mistakes, and sadly, 'Keepers mistakes cost, Foster was diabolical at Man Utd remember, many comparing him to Taibi.
Posts: 27,980
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(08-11-2020, 06:40 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (08-11-2020, 06:25 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: This (Duffy) is a sticky plaster over a huge crack which is our totally incompetent goalkeeper.
Spend the money on a decent keeper who has communication skills and, well, talent. The one we have is nowhere near good enough. I'd be delighted with Duffy but also a new keeper and then I think defensively we'd be competitive around where we need to compete. To sign Duffy for a whopping chunk and keep our Keeper would be daft. I don't think it would work. And we also need to think about improving on Laurel and Hardy up front!
Much to do. I don't think an 8m centre back is the answer.
Saying Johnstone has no talent is once again showing your total lack of knowledge Nick.
Come on Birdy - you know better than to bite...
Posts: 3,775
Threads: 73
Joined: May 2020
(08-11-2020, 06:40 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (08-11-2020, 06:25 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: This (Duffy) is a sticky plaster over a huge crack which is our totally incompetent goalkeeper.
Spend the money on a decent keeper who has communication skills and, well, talent. The one we have is nowhere near good enough. I'd be delighted with Duffy but also a new keeper and then I think defensively we'd be competitive around where we need to compete. To sign Duffy for a whopping chunk and keep our Keeper would be daft. I don't think it would work. And we also need to think about improving on Laurel and Hardy up front!
Much to do. I don't think an 8m centre back is the answer.
Saying Johnstone has no talent is once again showing your total lack of knowledge Nick.
He's an excellent shot stopper, and his reactions are superb, amount of penalty saves he makes shows that. Everyone would say he doesn't command the box enough, and certainly isn't good at coming for crosses, but as has been mentioned a lot, almost all 'keepers under 30 suffer from that, since modern day coaching is more about reflexes and saving the ball when it goes at goal, rather than stopping it coming in at all, leaving that to the defenders.
I'd ideally like an experienced head to be his cover/replacement for a season or two, and see if he has developed as a player at all, if not, well we have Griffiths coming through, and if he hasn't improved, by then I like to think Palmer would have staked his claim for the no.1 jersey too.
'Keeper is always a difficult position to sort, cover is a player happy to not play, if you have young, highly talented 'keepers, you have to allow for the fact they will make mistakes, and sadly, 'Keepers mistakes cost, Foster was diabolical at Man Utd remember, many comparing him to Taibi.
No need to be nasty...
He's not good enough. If he makes mistakes next season then the whole defence will be under pressure and that is not what we need. Mistake after mistake last season.
At the very least we need a quality addition to push him hard next season.
We'll see...
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(08-11-2020, 06:41 PM)Duffers Wrote: (08-11-2020, 06:40 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (08-11-2020, 06:25 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: This (Duffy) is a sticky plaster over a huge crack which is our totally incompetent goalkeeper.
Spend the money on a decent keeper who has communication skills and, well, talent. The one we have is nowhere near good enough. I'd be delighted with Duffy but also a new keeper and then I think defensively we'd be competitive around where we need to compete. To sign Duffy for a whopping chunk and keep our Keeper would be daft. I don't think it would work. And we also need to think about improving on Laurel and Hardy up front!
Much to do. I don't think an 8m centre back is the answer.
Saying Johnstone has no talent is once again showing your total lack of knowledge Nick.
Come on Birdy - you know better than to bite...
I can't help it.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(08-11-2020, 06:42 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (08-11-2020, 06:40 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (08-11-2020, 06:25 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: This (Duffy) is a sticky plaster over a huge crack which is our totally incompetent goalkeeper.
Spend the money on a decent keeper who has communication skills and, well, talent. The one we have is nowhere near good enough. I'd be delighted with Duffy but also a new keeper and then I think defensively we'd be competitive around where we need to compete. To sign Duffy for a whopping chunk and keep our Keeper would be daft. I don't think it would work. And we also need to think about improving on Laurel and Hardy up front!
Much to do. I don't think an 8m centre back is the answer.
Saying Johnstone has no talent is once again showing your total lack of knowledge Nick.
He's an excellent shot stopper, and his reactions are superb, amount of penalty saves he makes shows that. Everyone would say he doesn't command the box enough, and certainly isn't good at coming for crosses, but as has been mentioned a lot, almost all 'keepers under 30 suffer from that, since modern day coaching is more about reflexes and saving the ball when it goes at goal, rather than stopping it coming in at all, leaving that to the defenders.
I'd ideally like an experienced head to be his cover/replacement for a season or two, and see if he has developed as a player at all, if not, well we have Griffiths coming through, and if he hasn't improved, by then I like to think Palmer would have staked his claim for the no.1 jersey too.
'Keeper is always a difficult position to sort, cover is a player happy to not play, if you have young, highly talented 'keepers, you have to allow for the fact they will make mistakes, and sadly, 'Keepers mistakes cost, Foster was diabolical at Man Utd remember, many comparing him to Taibi.
No need to be nasty...
He's not good enough. If he makes mistakes next season then the whole defence will be under pressure and that is not what we need. Mistake after mistake last season.
At the very least we need a quality addition to push him hard next season.
We'll see...
He didn't make as many mistakes as many on here like to attribute to him. He is considered to have had a strong season by many, including Bilic.
Posts: 27,980
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
I’m pretty confident Johnstone won us more points than he cost us last season.
Posts: 3,775
Threads: 73
Joined: May 2020
(08-11-2020, 06:43 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (08-11-2020, 06:41 PM)Duffers Wrote: (08-11-2020, 06:40 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (08-11-2020, 06:25 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: This (Duffy) is a sticky plaster over a huge crack which is our totally incompetent goalkeeper.
Spend the money on a decent keeper who has communication skills and, well, talent. The one we have is nowhere near good enough. I'd be delighted with Duffy but also a new keeper and then I think defensively we'd be competitive around where we need to compete. To sign Duffy for a whopping chunk and keep our Keeper would be daft. I don't think it would work. And we also need to think about improving on Laurel and Hardy up front!
Much to do. I don't think an 8m centre back is the answer.
Saying Johnstone has no talent is once again showing your total lack of knowledge Nick.
Come on Birdy - you know better than to bite...
I can't help it.
I know.
Deep down you know I'm right.
If he plays a Blider next season then great but I can't see it. And to go into next season with an exponential rise in quality of opposition it would be criminal not to address. An Irish centre half from Brighton is papering over those cracks - particularly at 8m. For 3-4m it's a no-brainer - in addition to a new keeper.
Posts: 2,414
Threads: 94
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
19
I watched most games on iFollow and I'd consider him in credit in terms of saves made vs mistakes costing us a goal. I'm hoping Palmer/Griffiths will come good but I haven't got a problem with Johnstone as Number 1 next season. My main gripe with him is his lack of lip to his defenders.
|