Shane Duffy strong links
#1
Seen a lot of talk from various media sources saying we’re looking to sign Shane Duffy off Brighton. Apparently they are happy to let him go. 
6 4 and still only 28. 
We’ve a thing for big Irish centre halves with G Mac and Evans both recent memories. If he’s on par with either of them then sounds like a match made in heaven.
Reply
#2
Depending on price.. I'm in.
Reply
#3
Wasn't he in Westlife?
Reply
#4
Very happy with this. Some much needed Prem experience and a commanding presence.
Reply
#5
He loves the Albion.
Reply
#6
Would depend entirely on price.

I don’t think Duffy is good enough, and the fact a side that narrowly avoided relegation were actively trying to replace him last year, and are happy to move him on speaks volumes.

He’s a good player if we go down, but we shouldn’t be paying more than a couple million. Fees and big wages for players at his age got us into trouble last time.
Reply
#7
(08-09-2020, 09:29 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Would depend entirely on price.

I don’t think Duffy is good enough, and the fact a side that narrowly avoided relegation were actively trying to replace him last year, and are happy to move him on speaks volumes.

He’s a good player if we go down, but we shouldn’t be paying more than a couple million. Fees and big wages for players at his age got us into trouble last time.

+1
Reply
#8
It’s catch 20/20. We need Prem experience as Johnstone, O’Shea and Ajayi have never played at the level we are going to be come September.

Joe Rodon May seem the better choice (age, profile etc), but considering we will be replacing Gibbs with a player no PL experience. Is it really advisable to have not one player in the back 5 with PL experience?
Reply
#9
(08-09-2020, 10:03 PM)Super_Slav Wrote: It’s catch 20/20. We need Prem experience as Johnstone, O’Shea and Ajayi have never played at the level we are going to be come September.

Joe Rodon May seem the better choice (age, profile etc), but considering we will be replacing Gibbs with a player no PL experience. Is it really advisable to have not one player in the back 5 with PL experience?

Catch what?!?
Reply
#10
(08-09-2020, 10:03 PM)Super_Slav Wrote: It’s catch 20/20. We need Prem experience as Johnstone, O’Shea and Ajayi have never played at the level we are going to be come September.

Joe Rodon May seem the better choice (age, profile etc), but considering we will be replacing Gibbs with a player no PL experience. Is it really advisable to have not one player in the back 5 with PL experience?

Sheff United’s back 5 didn’t have any prem experience, other than Basham having a handful of games a decade ago... Bartley has 5 years in the PL with Swansea, Hegazi has had a year with us... I doubt we’ll find a buyer for Gibbs and he has plenty.

Experience may have it’s use, but the players being good enough is far more important IMO, and Duffy is no better than Hegazi or Bartley IMO.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)