Madge in Monday
#51
(01-08-2026, 03:37 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(01-08-2026, 03:11 PM)AlsoKeithCurlesToePoke Wrote: Speaking as a Loughborough alumni bellend, if this comes off, Nestor is a genius.

Filled with apprehension at another punt, although I suppose at least he's showing consistency in selection criteria now.

Trust the plan? Not worked so far - 3rd time lucky or we're screwed.

At least the expectation level is now back at pre-Megson settings.

I also have doubts about this appointment, because it suggests that Nestor wants to stay involved in the football side by going for inexperienced coaches who might be more compliant than established coaches.

I deplore the OP's abuse of Loughborough alumni. There's a great many of us out there. I've found in my engineering career that you're never more than 6 feet away from a Loughborough graduate - - -

6 feet?
You should get out more!
Reply
#52
(01-08-2026, 02:20 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Lepko just shared on X an interview that Ramsey did with American media and he comes across v well, but then again so did Mason in that high performance pod-cast interview he did.  I feel more confident in this appointment than I did in the Mason one because Ramsey has had two years actual managerial experience and against his peers has done well and improved a team and a football club.  Having said that I still think this is a bit of a punt with no more than a 50:50 chance of success, where success is getting us into the play-offs over the next couple of seasons.
What I am willing to accept is that Ramsey is the best candidate available given where we are ( 18th in the second tier of English football with no money to spend ) as I've said before we're now in the realms of calling the tallest dwarf the winner.

Just read that its an interesting read. He seems to like 3/5 at the back which, eirh a right sided wingback could suit us, though not good news for Mikey J.
Reply
#53
(01-08-2026, 03:56 PM)Cornflake Wrote:
(01-08-2026, 02:20 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Lepko just shared on X an interview that Ramsey did with American media and he comes across v well, but then again so did Mason in that high performance pod-cast interview he did.  I feel more confident in this appointment than I did in the Mason one because Ramsey has had two years actual managerial experience and against his peers has done well and improved a team and a football club.  Having said that I still think this is a bit of a punt with no more than a 50:50 chance of success, where success is getting us into the play-offs over the next couple of seasons.
What I am willing to accept is that Ramsey is the best candidate available given where we are ( 18th in the second tier of English football with no money to spend ) as I've said before we're now in the realms of calling the tallest dwarf the winner.

Just read that its an interesting read. He seems to like 3/5 at the back which, eirh a right sided wingback could suit us, though not good news for Mikey J.

A fkin disaster if the right wing back is SFIFJ
Reply
#54
(01-08-2026, 02:10 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We bought Mason in for the future and gave him a three year deal he lasted what five months? With fans demanding he was sacked in November. The average tenure of a manager is 18mths so I don’t see how a club can allow a manager time to develop over 2 or 3 seasons.

Just so you know, Derek, the chances of there being no escape clause in the contract is minuscule. There usually is anyway, but for a coach with no real experience it would be negligent to not include one. (There was also one for Mowbray by the way. I believe it was the end of the season. I suspect that Mason's is the same.)
Reply
#55
(01-08-2026, 01:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-08-2026, 01:46 PM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: We have to think outside the box a bit, nobody wants the usual suspects. It is another gamble though.

Why do we? Why can’t we find a manager who has some experience of the EFL and has or is having some success? The same ‘it’s a gamble’ arguments were used when we brought in Mason ffs. 

Megson had, had limited but success non the less at both Stoke and Stockport before he joined us, and had played for years in the EFL for comparison. RDM had managed MK Dons and his playing career was excellent. 

This is a pivotal appointment and yet we are arguing it’s worth a go, it’s exciting etc. I am not advocating going for Bruce type managers but I am arguing that we should be looking for managers that have managed in the EFL or abroad in a decent league with some success. This all feels a bit tech bro’s playing at sport’ and wanting a hassle free coach for my liking. IF the speculation is true, of course.

Btw what I’ve read about Ramsay makes me think he may be a good fit but only IF he had proven himself in decent league in Europe or the EFL.

Not saying this to be antagonistic, but who? You've made this point several times, but haven't given us a name that fits your criteria.

I've just done a cursory glance of the EFL, and who stands out that's attainable? From the Championship, Alex Neil is doing a good job at Millwall as is Heckingbottom at PNE and to a degree Nathan Jones at Charlton, and I imagine all 3 may be tempted, but they all have some black spots on their CVs with no guarantee of success. I like Mousinho at Portsmouth, but would our fans be happy taking a bloke who is struggling near the relegation zone? The other managers overachieving are Stephen at QPR, Jakirovic at Hull, Gracia at Watford, and Struber at Bristol - none of those came from the Championship into their roles, and again, they all came with chequered backgrounds - would we have been blown away with any of those being linked in the summer pre-Mason?

Dropping into Leagues One and Two, Barry-Murphy and Skubala are the outright options, one has a similar background to Mason in u21 coaching at a big club and a relegation from League One on his CV and the other never played professional football and has a couple seasons' management at Lincoln, along with a decent reputation as futsal coach. After that, you're in the world of long ball merchants and blokes who fire up the lads, like Challinor at Stockport, Alexander at Bradford and Revell at Stevenage. Like Schumacher who did very well at Plymouth and Bolton, but had a 'mare at Stoke, and Wellens deserves a chance at a bigger club than Orient, but would we be happy taking a manager from a club in a relegation battle in League One? 

League Two then has Ian Holloway and Andy Woodman (who learned his trade coaching under Pardew) before spending several years in non-league. After that you have the likes of Karl Robinson and Paul Warne...

I've even looked at out of work options that fit the bill and we have Liam Manning, who was highly regarded at Oxford, got Bristol into the POs but massively messed up at Norwich, Hoff Throrupp who did well in Scandinavia but couldn't get a tune out of a talented Norwich side last year, Thomasson who did well with Blackburn, but played awful percentage football and struggled with Sweden, or the roundly disliked Russell Martin...

So who should it be Derek? Which of the managers above offer us a more stable hand than the idea or Ramsay? FWIW I think Ramsay is a big gamble, but I'm encouraged by what I've read. I don't think Mason would have relegated us as the squad has shown it has enough to effectively manage itself out of danger, so the next 6 months is a bit of a free hit for whoever comes in. Provided we approach games with a plan, we try and use a couple of the younger players, we don't force SIJ into the team, and we don't sub Mikey off at HT, whoever is in charge will get support.
Reply
#56
(01-08-2026, 03:37 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(01-08-2026, 03:11 PM)AlsoKeithCurlesToePoke Wrote: Speaking as a Loughborough alumni bellend, if this comes off, Nestor is a genius.

Filled with apprehension at another punt, although I suppose at least he's showing consistency in selection criteria now.

Trust the plan? Not worked so far - 3rd time lucky or we're screwed.

At least the expectation level is now back at pre-Megson settings.

I also have doubts about this appointment, because it suggests that Nestor wants to stay involved in the football side by going for inexperienced coaches who might be more compliant than established coaches.

I deplore the OP's abuse of Loughborough alumni. There's a great many of us out there. I've found in my engineering career that you're never more than 6 feet away from a Loughborough graduate - - -

Isn't that uncomfortable?
Reply
#57
Minnesota United coach Eric Ramsay to take West Brom job

(from twincities.com in the US, which covers Minnesota)
Reply
#58
Apprehensive about this, seems to have the same flaw as Mason in being tactically inflexible and stubborn with how he sets teams up.
Reply
#59
In fairness no one can be as shit as Mason so roll on Madge. Bring Harold with you as well as first team coach and we golden, home and away.
Reply
#60
I am not enthused but if it stops Russell Martin getting the job that's a good start.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)