Madge in Monday
#31
(01-08-2026, 02:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-08-2026, 02:16 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(01-08-2026, 02:10 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-08-2026, 02:05 PM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote:
(01-08-2026, 01:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Why do we? Why can’t we find a manager who has some experience of the EFL and has or is having some success? The same ‘it’s a gamble’ arguments were used when we brought in Mason ffs. 

Megson had, had limited but success non the less at both Stoke and Stockport before he joined us, and had played for years in the EFL for comparison. RDM had managed MK Dons and his playing career was excellent. 

This is a pivotal appointment and yet we are arguing it’s worth a go, it’s exciting etc. I am not advocating going for Bruce type managers but I am arguing that we should be looking for managers that have managed in the EFL or abroad in a decent league with some success. This all feels a bit tech bro’s playing at sport’ for my liking. 

Btw what I’ve read about Ramsay makes me think he may be a good fit but only IF he had proven himself in decent league in Europe or the EFL.

Megason and RDM were well over a decade ago, times have changed. Just maybe, the club are thinking about an appointment for the long term future of the club. Not someone who is currently having success, and could just be right timing at the right club? There are far too many unknowns for any of us to be right about this until we find out. But we both know you'll argue with anyone about anything so, I'll leave it at that.

We bought Mason in for the future and gave him a three year deal he lasted what five months? With fans demanding he was sacked in November. The average tenure of a manager is 18mths so I don’t see how a club can allow a manager time to develop over 2 or 3 seasons.

I doubt they are. I imagine the conversation goes something along the lines of "Get us out of the shit this season and we'll have another conversation at the end of May."

In which case if I was Ramsay I’d say no thanks, give me a two or three year contract or I’m not interested.

Exactly right.
Reply
#32
Lepko just shared on X an interview that Ramsey did with American media and he comes across v well, but then again so did Mason in that high performance pod-cast interview he did. I feel more confident in this appointment than I did in the Mason one because Ramsey has had two years actual managerial experience and against his peers has done well and improved a team and a football club. Having said that I still think this is a bit of a punt with no more than a 50:50 chance of success, where success is getting us into the play-offs over the next couple of seasons.
What I am willing to accept is that Ramsey is the best candidate available given where we are ( 18th in the second tier of English football with no money to spend ) as I've said before we're now in the realms of calling the tallest dwarf the winner.
Reply
#33
(01-08-2026, 02:17 PM)CIM Wrote: Maybe, just maybe we should give the new guy a chance before any meltdown

You new here?
Reply
#34
(01-08-2026, 02:17 PM)CIM Wrote: Maybe, just maybe we should give the new guy a chance before any meltdown

Arf the same posters less than a week ago were clamouring for a young inexperienced manager to be sacked after half a season at best, at worst in November! Every defeat was a ‘meltdown’.
Reply
#35
(01-08-2026, 02:21 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-08-2026, 02:17 PM)CIM Wrote: Maybe, just maybe we should give the new guy a chance before any meltdown

Arf the same posters less than a week ago were clamouring for a young inexperienced manager to be sacked after half a season at best, at worst in November! Every defeat was a ‘meltdown’.

I think many gave him a few months before making judgement. Which is fair.
Reply
#36
(01-08-2026, 02:21 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-08-2026, 02:17 PM)CIM Wrote: Maybe, just maybe we should give the new guy a chance before any meltdown

Arf the same posters less than a week ago were clamouring for a young inexperienced manager to be sacked after half a season at best, at worst in November! Every defeat was a ‘meltdown’.

You say it like he was doing a great job and the posts were irrational. Again, that's not reality, doesn't matter how many times you say it.
The posts were in response to his overall performance, in which he was failing on pretty much every level. He wasn't wanted out because he was young or inexperienced he was wanted out because he wasn't very good and showed no sign of improvement. Those that said it in November proved to be very astute, didn't they?

If the same happens here then it is Nestor who's at fault, not other posters.
Reply
#37
(01-08-2026, 02:29 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-08-2026, 02:21 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-08-2026, 02:17 PM)CIM Wrote: Maybe, just maybe we should give the new guy a chance before any meltdown

Arf the same posters less than a week ago were clamouring for a young inexperienced manager to be sacked after half a season at best, at worst in November! Every defeat was a ‘meltdown’.

You say it like he was doing a great job and the posts were irrational. Again, that's not reality, doesn't matter how many times you say it.
The posts were in response to his overall performance, in which he was failing on pretty much every level. He wasn't wanted out because he was young or inexperienced he was wanted out because he wasn't very good and showed no sign of improvement. Those that said it in November proved to be very astute, didn't they?

If the same happens here then it is Nestor who's at fault, not other posters.

Great post that I couldn't be arsed writing myself.
Reply
#38
(01-08-2026, 12:54 PM)Albion AI Wrote: So - from what I hear Eric 'Madge' Ramsay will be appointed Monday morning.

Whilst I welcome we didn't return to an old school type manager that have blighted the club in recent years - I can't help thinking it's one hell of a gamble.

Ramsay has an excellent coaching pedigree (we've heard that somewhere before) but has only managed for 18 months in a mediocre league and as a result has really only ever managed 'average' 'soccer' players. Every current Albion player would walk into the Minnesota team (bar Wildsmith) - add in Ramsay's lack of playing pedigree and I fear he will struggle to gain respect and buy-in from what look like a group of Albion players with a poor attitude.

Let's see what happens - and he will have my full backing, but I can see Mozza & Brunty back in charge at some point if it goes tits up...

Also Loughborough Alumni are by and large massive dickheads.

Still 6/5 on skybet if you’re confident it’s him

(01-08-2026, 02:29 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-08-2026, 02:21 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-08-2026, 02:17 PM)CIM Wrote: Maybe, just maybe we should give the new guy a chance before any meltdown

Arf the same posters less than a week ago were clamouring for a young inexperienced manager to be sacked after half a season at best, at worst in November! Every defeat was a ‘meltdown’.

You say it like he was doing a great job and the posts were irrational. Again, that's not reality, doesn't matter how many times you say it.
The posts were in response to his overall performance, in which he was failing on pretty much every level. He wasn't wanted out because he was young or inexperienced he was wanted out because he wasn't very good and showed no sign of improvement. Those that said it in November proved to be very astute, didn't they?

If the same happens here then it is Nestor who's at fault, not other posters.

Plus one Bob

In relation to how poor he was he got a lot of patience if anything
Raw Sausage
Reply
#39
(01-08-2026, 02:29 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-08-2026, 02:21 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-08-2026, 02:17 PM)CIM Wrote: Maybe, just maybe we should give the new guy a chance before any meltdown

Arf the same posters less than a week ago were clamouring for a young inexperienced manager to be sacked after half a season at best, at worst in November! Every defeat was a ‘meltdown’.

You say it like he was doing a great job and the posts were irrational. Again, that's not reality, doesn't matter how many times you say it.
The posts were in response to his overall performance, in which he was failing on pretty much every level. He wasn't wanted out because he was young or inexperienced he was wanted out because he wasn't very good and showed no sign of improvement. Those that said it in November proved to be very astute, didn't they?

If the same happens here then it is Nestor who's at fault, not other posters.

But the point is no one is melting down over the potential of Ramsay becoming manager, just because I’m saying I don’t think it’s the right time to take a punt on a manager with no experience of the EFL at senior level doesn’t mean my argument is irrational either. 

I thought Mason was a mistake but personally I saved my criticism for the person who made the decision to hire him. I did however feel some fans only want long term plans when they go well from the start and continue to do so and that doesn’t always happen. Many of those advocating for this approach won’t care a jot about long term plans if the wheels fall off for the next half of the season. The most telling part of your reply was when you say ‘fans gave the manger a few months patience’ but then argue we are rebuilding over two or three seasons!
Reply
#40
Ramsey has been linked with Strasbourg and Chelsea. If I remember correctly he was also at Loughborough with McKenna.

He was also first team coach at United when they won something. I’m happy to give him a go.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)