MORE VAR BOLLOCKS
#41
(02-18-2020, 02:31 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 02:22 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 01:18 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: VAR is in its first season. I hope and expect that in the summer they'll look at the issues it has raised and hopefully iron out some of the problems. Might take 3-4 seasons to sort but variations of VAR used in other sports now with less controversy. I still think it 's important to get the correct decision, especially given the prizes nowadays.

I agree with the meaning behind the post - yes things need some time but....it aint rocket science

The trouble is many decisions with VAR are still plain wrong. Last night there were definitely 2.

The offside one does need a variation. As people start having to draw lines on a computer when they can't even tell if the ball has left the foot of the crosser/passer etc.. then you might as well leave it as it is. If you can see with the naked eye across the line (i.e. big errors) an offside then overrule.

If ever there was more likelihood of bias in refereeing it is has come with VAR. 5 additional blokes locked in a box without sound or vision on them.
Maguire's dismissal should have been the same as Min's dismissal a few weeks back - difference was a different set of blokes and no matter how you cut it everyone has sub conscious bias and that's why these subjective ones will never be consistent.

I haven't seen last night's decisions but from what I gather, they were outrageous. VAR isn't helped by some of the guidelines set out and also some the rules of the game need clarifying. If these were more clear cut, then VAR would probably be less controversial.

As for the people making the decisions, I'd like to think that they are on some sort of performance management. If they make mistakes, then fugg 'em off.

I'm fed up of some pundits giving VAR a kicking. Shearer springs to mind in particular. Before this season, they'd lay into refs for making mistakes, usually with the help of seeing replays of incidents. Now they bleat about VAR. They can't have it both ways.

And just look at some of the attacks on referees that we see on here - Graham Scott has his own thread! Keith Stroud has a petition against him on change.org.

All fair comments. 

The issue is clear though. For the extra 2% in correct calls - the collateral damage just isn’t worth it
Reply
#42
(02-18-2020, 04:29 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 02:31 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 02:22 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 01:18 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: VAR is in its first season. I hope and expect that in the summer they'll look at the issues it has raised and hopefully iron out some of the problems. Might take 3-4 seasons to sort but variations of VAR used in other sports now with less controversy. I still think it 's important to get the correct decision, especially given the prizes nowadays.

I agree with the meaning behind the post - yes things need some time but....it aint rocket science

The trouble is many decisions with VAR are still plain wrong. Last night there were definitely 2.

The offside one does need a variation. As people start having to draw lines on a computer when they can't even tell if the ball has left the foot of the crosser/passer etc.. then you might as well leave it as it is. If you can see with the naked eye across the line (i.e. big errors) an offside then overrule.

If ever there was more likelihood of bias in refereeing it is has come with VAR. 5 additional blokes locked in a box without sound or vision on them.
Maguire's dismissal should have been the same as Min's dismissal a few weeks back - difference was a different set of blokes and no matter how you cut it everyone has sub conscious bias and that's why these subjective ones will never be consistent.

I haven't seen last night's decisions but from what I gather, they were outrageous. VAR isn't helped by some of the guidelines set out and also some the rules of the game need clarifying. If these were more clear cut, then VAR would probably be less controversial.

As for the people making the decisions, I'd like to think that they are on some sort of performance management. If they make mistakes, then fugg 'em off.

I'm fed up of some pundits giving VAR a kicking. Shearer springs to mind in particular. Before this season, they'd lay into refs for making mistakes, usually with the help of seeing replays of incidents. Now they bleat about VAR. They can't have it both ways.
Keith Stroud has a petition against him on change.org.
And just look at some of the attacks on referees that we see on here - Graham Scott has his own thread!
Too right he does! The man cheated, plain and simple. Booking a player for not running to take a throw? Never seen it before, nor since.
This is exactly why we have VAR. Because people claim that refs cheat.
They don't.
Scott was incompetent, had no feel for the game, reffed like a robot...all those things are true.
But he didn't cheat.
The day refs cheat in any sport is when sport is finished.
I don't like VAR and I'd get rid. Some very good reasons above.
Because ultimately some decisions come down to personal judgement.
Where do we want that judgement made? On the pitch for me. By a flawed- but honest- ref.
Reply
#43
(02-23-2020, 10:18 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 04:29 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 02:31 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 02:22 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 01:18 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: VAR is in its first season. I hope and expect that in the summer they'll look at the issues it has raised and hopefully iron out some of the problems. Might take 3-4 seasons to sort but variations of VAR used in other sports now with less controversy. I still think it 's important to get the correct decision, especially given the prizes nowadays.

I agree with the meaning behind the post - yes things need some time but....it aint rocket science

The trouble is many decisions with VAR are still plain wrong. Last night there were definitely 2.

The offside one does need a variation. As people start having to draw lines on a computer when they can't even tell if the ball has left the foot of the crosser/passer etc.. then you might as well leave it as it is. If you can see with the naked eye across the line (i.e. big errors) an offside then overrule.

If ever there was more likelihood of bias in refereeing it is has come with VAR. 5 additional blokes locked in a box without sound or vision on them.
Maguire's dismissal should have been the same as Min's dismissal a few weeks back - difference was a different set of blokes and no matter how you cut it everyone has sub conscious bias and that's why these subjective ones will never be consistent.

I haven't seen last night's decisions but from what I gather, they were outrageous. VAR isn't helped by some of the guidelines set out and also some the rules of the game need clarifying. If these were more clear cut, then VAR would probably be less controversial.

As for the people making the decisions, I'd like to think that they are on some sort of performance management. If they make mistakes, then fugg 'em off.

I'm fed up of some pundits giving VAR a kicking. Shearer springs to mind in particular. Before this season, they'd lay into refs for making mistakes, usually with the help of seeing replays of incidents. Now they bleat about VAR. They can't have it both ways.
Keith Stroud has a petition against him on change.org.
And just look at some of the attacks on referees that we see on here - Graham Scott has his own thread!
Too right he does! The man cheated, plain and simple. Booking a player for not running to take a throw? Never seen it before, nor since.
This is exactly why we have VAR. Because people claim that refs cheat.
They don't.
Scott was incompetent, had no feel for the game, reffed like a robot...all those things are true.
But he didn't cheat.
The day refs cheat in any sport is when sport is finished.
I don't like VAR and I'd get rid. Some very good reasons above.
Because ultimately some decisions come down to personal judgement.
Where do we want that judgement made? On the pitch for me. By a flawed- but honest- ref.

Agree with that, totally.

Decisions made on the pitch. In a matter of seconds.

Fuck VAR. It is total crap. And wholly un-necessary.
Reply
#44
(02-23-2020, 10:05 AM)Mancbaggies Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 02:31 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 02:22 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 01:18 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: VAR is in its first season. I hope and expect that in the summer they'll look at the issues it has raised and hopefully iron out some of the problems. Might take 3-4 seasons to sort but variations of VAR used in other sports now with less controversy. I still think it 's important to get the correct decision, especially given the prizes nowadays.

I agree with the meaning behind the post - yes things need some time but....it aint rocket science

The trouble is many decisions with VAR are still plain wrong. Last night there were definitely 2.

The offside one does need a variation. As people start having to draw lines on a computer when they can't even tell if the ball has left the foot of the crosser/passer etc.. then you might as well leave it as it is. If you can see with the naked eye across the line (i.e. big errors) an offside then overrule.

If ever there was more likelihood of bias in refereeing it is has come with VAR. 5 additional blokes locked in a box without sound or vision on them.
Maguire's dismissal should have been the same as Min's dismissal a few weeks back - difference was a different set of blokes and no matter how you cut it everyone has sub conscious bias and that's why these subjective ones will never be consistent.

I haven't seen last night's decisions but from what I gather, they were outrageous. VAR isn't helped by some of the guidelines set out and also some the rules of the game need clarifying. If these were more clear cut, then VAR would probably be less controversial.

As for the people making the decisions, I'd like to think that they are on some sort of performance management. If they make mistakes, then fugg 'em off.

I'm fed up of some pundits giving VAR a kicking. Shearer springs to mind in particular. Before this season, they'd lay into refs for making mistakes, usually with the help of seeing replays of incidents. Now they bleat about VAR. They can't have it both ways.

And just look at some of the attacks on referees that we see on here - Graham Scott has his own thread! Keith Stroud has a petition against him on change.org.

All fair comments. 

The issue is clear though. For the extra 2% in correct calls - the collateral damage just isn’t worth it


But what about the collateral damage when the ref's on the field get it wrong? The prizes are too big at the top level to allow for human error to affect results. VAR is far from perfect at the moment and, given the nature of the game, it will probably never will be - but I think they should give it 3 seasons to refine the system, guidelines and the rules.

Incidentally, my point about performance management - I really do hope there is some. I felt sorry for Bournemouth yesterday having seen 2 decisions go against them despite the ball clearly hitting player's shoulders. The VAR referee in that game was Chris Kavanagh - the same bloke who disallowed Chelsea's goal against Man U last Monday. He'd be on very shakey ground if I was in charge.
Reply
#45
There should be a more extensive system for analysing refereeing performance. Supposedly the best referees are in the Premier league, but it's the same referees season upon season regardless of performance.

If you're found to be consistently getting relatively obvious calls wrong then you should be relegated to the next league and replaced with the best performing ref from the league below.. Not just for a game or two, but until you yourself reach the top of that refereeing leaderboard for your league. That way the best referees rise to the top, but also there's some reaction and incentives to improve yourselves. The arrogance of some of these prem refs is unbelievable, with little to back it up.

VAR is more trouble than it's worth and the refs are still incompetent with it, therefore the emphasis should be on refereeing performance. Scrap VAR and have a more fluid refereeing hierarchy
Reply
#46
(02-23-2020, 01:36 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(02-23-2020, 10:05 AM)Mancbaggies Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 02:31 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 02:22 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 01:18 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: VAR is in its first season. I hope and expect that in the summer they'll look at the issues it has raised and hopefully iron out some of the problems. Might take 3-4 seasons to sort but variations of VAR used in other sports now with less controversy. I still think it 's important to get the correct decision, especially given the prizes nowadays.

I agree with the meaning behind the post - yes things need some time but....it aint rocket science

The trouble is many decisions with VAR are still plain wrong. Last night there were definitely 2.

The offside one does need a variation. As people start having to draw lines on a computer when they can't even tell if the ball has left the foot of the crosser/passer etc.. then you might as well leave it as it is. If you can see with the naked eye across the line (i.e. big errors) an offside then overrule.

If ever there was more likelihood of bias in refereeing it is has come with VAR. 5 additional blokes locked in a box without sound or vision on them.
Maguire's dismissal should have been the same as Min's dismissal a few weeks back - difference was a different set of blokes and no matter how you cut it everyone has sub conscious bias and that's why these subjective ones will never be consistent.

I haven't seen last night's decisions but from what I gather, they were outrageous. VAR isn't helped by some of the guidelines set out and also some the rules of the game need clarifying. If these were more clear cut, then VAR would probably be less controversial.

As for the people making the decisions, I'd like to think that they are on some sort of performance management. If they make mistakes, then fugg 'em off.

I'm fed up of some pundits giving VAR a kicking. Shearer springs to mind in particular. Before this season, they'd lay into refs for making mistakes, usually with the help of seeing replays of incidents. Now they bleat about VAR. They can't have it both ways.

And just look at some of the attacks on referees that we see on here - Graham Scott has his own thread! Keith Stroud has a petition against him on change.org.

All fair comments. 

The issue is clear though. For the extra 2% in correct calls - the collateral damage just isn’t worth it


But what about the collateral damage when the ref's on the field get it wrong? The prizes are too big at the top level to allow for human error to affect results. VAR is far from perfect at the moment and, given the nature of the game, it will probably never will be - but I think they should give it 3 seasons to refine the system, guidelines and the rules.

Incidentally, my point about performance management - I really do hope there is some. I felt sorry for Bournemouth yesterday having seen 2 decisions go against them despite the ball clearly hitting player's shoulders. The VAR referee in that game was Chris Kavanagh - the same bloke who disallowed Chelsea's goal against Man U last Monday. He'd be on very shakey ground if I was in charge.

All that appears to be happening is that the human error is just consigned to a different human watching a screen. Meanwhile taking all the instant joy out of the game
Reply
#47
(02-23-2020, 01:50 PM)strawman Wrote:
(02-23-2020, 01:36 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(02-23-2020, 10:05 AM)Mancbaggies Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 02:31 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 02:22 PM)billybassett Wrote: I agree with the meaning behind the post - yes things need some time but....it aint rocket science

The trouble is many decisions with VAR are still plain wrong. Last night there were definitely 2.

The offside one does need a variation. As people start having to draw lines on a computer when they can't even tell if the ball has left the foot of the crosser/passer etc.. then you might as well leave it as it is. If you can see with the naked eye across the line (i.e. big errors) an offside then overrule.

If ever there was more likelihood of bias in refereeing it is has come with VAR. 5 additional blokes locked in a box without sound or vision on them.
Maguire's dismissal should have been the same as Min's dismissal a few weeks back - difference was a different set of blokes and no matter how you cut it everyone has sub conscious bias and that's why these subjective ones will never be consistent.

I haven't seen last night's decisions but from what I gather, they were outrageous. VAR isn't helped by some of the guidelines set out and also some the rules of the game need clarifying. If these were more clear cut, then VAR would probably be less controversial.

As for the people making the decisions, I'd like to think that they are on some sort of performance management. If they make mistakes, then fugg 'em off.

I'm fed up of some pundits giving VAR a kicking. Shearer springs to mind in particular. Before this season, they'd lay into refs for making mistakes, usually with the help of seeing replays of incidents. Now they bleat about VAR. They can't have it both ways.

And just look at some of the attacks on referees that we see on here - Graham Scott has his own thread! Keith Stroud has a petition against him on change.org.

All fair comments. 

The issue is clear though. For the extra 2% in correct calls - the collateral damage just isn’t worth it


But what about the collateral damage when the ref's on the field get it wrong? The prizes are too big at the top level to allow for human error to affect results. VAR is far from perfect at the moment and, given the nature of the game, it will probably never will be - but I think they should give it 3 seasons to refine the system, guidelines and the rules.

Incidentally, my point about performance management - I really do hope there is some. I felt sorry for Bournemouth yesterday having seen 2 decisions go against them despite the ball clearly hitting player's shoulders. The VAR referee in that game was Chris Kavanagh - the same bloke who disallowed Chelsea's goal against Man U last Monday. He'd be on very shakey ground if I was in charge.

All that appears to be happening is that the human error is just consigned to a different human watching a screen. Meanwhile taking all the instant joy out of the game

The ones watching the screen don't always get it wrong.
Reply
#48
(02-23-2020, 01:53 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(02-23-2020, 01:50 PM)strawman Wrote:
(02-23-2020, 01:36 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(02-23-2020, 10:05 AM)Mancbaggies Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 02:31 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: I haven't seen last night's decisions but from what I gather, they were outrageous. VAR isn't helped by some of the guidelines set out and also some the rules of the game need clarifying. If these were more clear cut, then VAR would probably be less controversial.

As for the people making the decisions, I'd like to think that they are on some sort of performance management. If they make mistakes, then fugg 'em off.

I'm fed up of some pundits giving VAR a kicking. Shearer springs to mind in particular. Before this season, they'd lay into refs for making mistakes, usually with the help of seeing replays of incidents. Now they bleat about VAR. They can't have it both ways.

And just look at some of the attacks on referees that we see on here - Graham Scott has his own thread! Keith Stroud has a petition against him on change.org.

All fair comments. 

The issue is clear though. For the extra 2% in correct calls - the collateral damage just isn’t worth it


But what about the collateral damage when the ref's on the field get it wrong? The prizes are too big at the top level to allow for human error to affect results. VAR is far from perfect at the moment and, given the nature of the game, it will probably never will be - but I think they should give it 3 seasons to refine the system, guidelines and the rules.

Incidentally, my point about performance management - I really do hope there is some. I felt sorry for Bournemouth yesterday having seen 2 decisions go against them despite the ball clearly hitting player's shoulders. The VAR referee in that game was Chris Kavanagh - the same bloke who disallowed Chelsea's goal against Man U last Monday. He'd be on very shakey ground if I was in charge.

All that appears to be happening is that the human error is just consigned to a different human watching a screen. Meanwhile taking all the instant joy out of the game

The ones watching the screen don't always get it wrong.

Neither do the ones on the pitch. They get it wrong a fair amount of the time or it wouldn't keep being discussed. Some of the offside decisions based on a cm or so have supposedly improved the correct rate by 2%, but I don't believe that the technology can distinguish when the ball is actually played. We will be fitting the players with sensors next so we can tell if the ball hit shoulder or arm and when the ball was actually kicked  Big Grin Big Grin
Reply
#49
The thing is sounds like just 3 of us off this bored could have got all those decisions right yesterday and in the blink of an eye.

This is what I can't get my head round. Maguire's on Monday, le Celso, the Burnley shoulders etc etc took me 20 seconds to decide. They're making the easy look v difficult. If you can't decide on the first Replay, providing the right view, then it's a no...
Reply
#50
(02-23-2020, 10:18 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 04:29 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(02-18-2020, 02:31 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: I haven't seen last night's decisions but from what I gather, they were outrageous. VAR isn't helped by some of the guidelines set out and also some the rules of the game need clarifying. If these were more clear cut, then VAR would probably be less controversial.

As for the people making the decisions, I'd like to think that they are on some sort of performance management. If they make mistakes, then fugg 'em off.

I'm fed up of some pundits giving VAR a kicking. Shearer springs to mind in particular. Before this season, they'd lay into refs for making mistakes, usually with the help of seeing replays of incidents. Now they bleat about VAR. They can't have it both ways.
Keith Stroud has a petition against him on change.org.
And just look at some of the attacks on referees that we see on here - Graham Scott has his own thread!
Too right he does! The man cheated, plain and simple. Booking a player for not running to take a throw? Never seen it before, nor since.
This is exactly why we have VAR. Because people claim that refs cheat.
They don't.
Scott was incompetent, had no feel for the game, reffed like a robot...all those things are true.
But he didn't cheat.

The day refs cheat in any sport is when sport is finished.
I don't like VAR and I'd get rid. Some very good reasons above.
Because ultimately some decisions come down to personal judgement.
Where do we want that judgement made? On the pitch for me. By a flawed- but honest- ref.
OK, JKE, I May be wrong to call him a cheat but it is absolutely clear he favoured one team. (In that game). There were just too many incidents going in villa's favour to be coincidence. Even ignoring the numerous free kicks given that weren't, even ignoring the blatant penalty, ignoring villa's outrageous gamesmanship, there were still enough inconsistencies to question the guy. The Gayle booking for walking over to take a throw in is still the only time I have ever seen that, plus him turning a blind eye to the other sides timewasting at the end?
FWIW, once when I played and was held down in the box on the ref's blindside, I called the ref a cheat. He made a point of finding me after the game and explaining, "I may get things wrong, young man, but I do not cheat". I couldn't apologise enough and it was a valuable lesson learned. Smile
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: