![]() |
|
MORE VAR BOLLOCKS - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: MORE VAR BOLLOCKS (/showthread.php?tid=7591) |
MORE VAR BOLLOCKS - Ampadu's Left Boot - 12-01-2019 Penalty awarded to Leicester, looked stonewall. It goes to VAR, which takes a couple of minutes to check it from about god knows how many angles to see if there was any contact or not, after which the decision gets overruled. It's meant to be only overruled if it's clear and obvious, if it's clear and obvious their was no contact why did it take VAR so long, and from so many different angles, and by taking multiple slow-motion replays to try and ascertain whether or not the challenge by the Everton player made any contact? Also, the none of the angles VAR had would likely be worse than what the ref had in this case, as he was in a great position to see the tackle, yet VAR can overrule it? Despite all the angles I still couldn't tell if there was any contact or not, and the contact only had to be minimal for it to be a foul, and the way the player fell looked like there had been contact. Also, the offending player (Holgate) made no appeal and just his head in acceptance at the decision, so he clearly thought he had made contact. An absolute joke. I'm done with the fucking thing, it's more of a disgrace every passing weekend. RE: MORE VAR BOLLOCKS - Duffers - 12-01-2019 Looked a dive to me. RE: MORE VAR BOLLOCKS - Sliced - 12-01-2019 There was a blatant penalty on Perez earlier in the half which nothing was done about. However I thought the VAR penalty was one of the most blatant dives I've ever seen RE: MORE VAR BOLLOCKS - Ampadu's Left Boot - 12-01-2019 (12-01-2019, 05:21 PM)Duffers Wrote: Looked a dive to me. Not to me. Got clipped on the side of his ankle. Sky just shown an extreme close up and you STILL can't say for sure either way, it's simply not clear and shouldn't have been overruled. (12-01-2019, 05:25 PM)Sliced Wrote: There was a blatant penalty on Perez earlier in the half which nothing was done about. However I thought the VAR penalty was one of the most blatant dives I've ever seen Not watched much football then? He got clipped on the side of his ankle, very minimal contact but contact nonetheless, and that's all it took to take his feet away. The way he fell looked perfectly natural considering the momentum he had. Holgate knew what he did as well, and Chilwell was still protesting to the ref at half time. If there was no contact how would Chilwell know that replays hadn't highlighted there was a good 6 inches between his trailing foot and boot tackle, rather than an inconclusive close-up? RE: MORE VAR BOLLOCKS - Johnnykayeengland - 12-01-2019 Maybe it's a game of opinions? And the ref has one! I don't like VAR,and I'd be happy to revert to last season. I don't think it'll happen, though, as some people want what they call"consistency"! RE: MORE VAR BOLLOCKS - Sliced - 12-01-2019 (12-01-2019, 05:31 PM)Ampadu\s Left Boot Wrote:(12-01-2019, 05:21 PM)Duffers Wrote: Looked a dive to me. There's really no need for that. We have a difference of opinion about an obviously debatable decision. Chilwell went down like he'd been shot in the back, that doesn't come from "minimal contact" to his ankle. You think there was contact, I don't, which VAR agreed with. No need to get personal. Also your last sentence makes no logical sense? Is the logic that players only protest when they're right? Not to mention that the clip was briefly shown on the screen after the decision was overturned. Footballers protest about absolutely everything regardless of the truth of what happened. RE: MORE VAR BOLLOCKS - SW4Baggie - 12-01-2019 I think the principle of VAR is brilliant, and I thought at the WC it worked really well, bar a couple of lengthy decisions. I was optimistic that as refs got more used to the system a lot of the slow decisions and controversial inconsistencies would even themselves out, but it’s fast spiralling out of control. The principle of “clear and obvious” has been completely lost in a quest for absolute accuracy and application of rules to letter of the law which football is far too fast a paced game to allow. I was a big fan of VAR and have defended it a lot, but seeing how the PL are applying it is farcical. There needs to be a set amount of time to decide decisions - 15s is plenty of time to see if something is clear and obvious, and a couple of camera angles from the ref’s view and assistant’s. If this can’t be sorted the whole thing needs scrapping as this quest for an impossible perfection is far worse than the odd bad decision . Giving teams set numbers of Reviews is far from the answer as this won’t change frustrations with decision times or goal checks as there will no doubt be tactical use of reviews or optimistic uses that will find something 4-5 passes ago that overrules goals. RE: MORE VAR BOLLOCKS - Mish - 12-01-2019 Loathe VAR for all the spontaneity it's taking out of the game. Turn over the big fuck ups, but if its close, just let it go. RE: MORE VAR BOLLOCKS - Bloke who lives abroad - 12-01-2019 Hate VAR. NO time for it at all. Who needs the game run by referees sitting in aa tV studio? It's just the Americanisation of sport. Football has been fine for 150 years without it and controversy is part of our game. Don't need computers and the like to take it over. Sod off VAR. RE: MORE VAR BOLLOCKS - 4-hero - 12-01-2019 (12-01-2019, 05:20 PM)Ampadu\s Left Boot Wrote: Penalty awarded to Leicester, looked stonewall. It goes to VAR, which takes a couple of minutes to check it from about god knows how many angles to see if there was any contact or not, after which the decision gets overruled. Absolute shite same with the retaken penalty at Naaarge, I honestly cannot be arsed with getting promoted, when that dull as dishwater Brummie Arsenal twat Alan Smith was bleating on about how much excitement it created I could have put my foot through the telly like a Johnny Metgod piledriver |