Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
I have minimal knowledge of this situation, so whilst this discussion was very interesting to read, it's quite obvious one person is discussing the facts and presenting their interpretation of it, and the other person is presenting their biased view without bothering to reply to points raised or questions asked. The rhetoric style of both posters is quite starkly different.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(09-04-2025, 08:31 AM)Jacko Wrote: (09-04-2025, 07:21 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (09-03-2025, 09:55 PM)Squid Wrote: (09-03-2025, 09:24 PM)Sliced Wrote: (09-03-2025, 09:06 PM)Squid Wrote: Argue with the World Bank:
https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/algeria/overview
The "World Bank Group" also classifies Iraq as an upper middle income country and Gaza was an upper middle income country until July of last year.
The salary and wealth figures I've laid out are correct, and I'm pretty sure Imane Khelif wouldn't have been that accepted in "Upper Middle Income" Iraq either, although monthly salary in Iraq is almost double that of Algeria so her family income would likely have been better.
None of that counters any of my points that Imane Khelif and the Algerian boxing authorities were not some wide-eyed innocents unaware of the existence of disorders of sexual development. Everyone in professional sport knows about these issues.
Pedant alert.
Olympic boxing is still very much an amateur sport.
I have no knowledge of Khelif's medical history, nor should I have.
I'm not particularly interested in boxing, there's a lot to dislike about professional boxing.
But I did have a look at her record.
49 wins, 9 defeats, that's good for an amateur boxer, but not infallible.
Of her 49 wins, 9 were by KO, the rest won on points. Not really the record of someone who is winning through brute strength alone. Most of her defeats came early in her 'career', implying that she has become a better skilled boxer through experience. If strength was her main asset she would have been winning those early contests.
There is nothing in her record that screams this is a man boxing against women.
It shows, amateur boxing is about skill. Early in Khelif's career their will have been boxers who could just dance around him lumbering his way round the ring windmilling away at them. As his skill improved his stength advantage obviously comes to the fore. He has never lost a fight by KO despite starting his career 1 and 5 and hasn't been beaten at all for 3 and a half years.
You clearly have the advantage on me, having watched her early contests....a niche way to spend your time.
Posts: 7,726
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(09-04-2025, 09:12 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (09-04-2025, 08:31 AM)Jacko Wrote: (09-04-2025, 07:21 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (09-03-2025, 09:55 PM)Squid Wrote: (09-03-2025, 09:24 PM)Sliced Wrote: The "World Bank Group" also classifies Iraq as an upper middle income country and Gaza was an upper middle income country until July of last year.
The salary and wealth figures I've laid out are correct, and I'm pretty sure Imane Khelif wouldn't have been that accepted in "Upper Middle Income" Iraq either, although monthly salary in Iraq is almost double that of Algeria so her family income would likely have been better.
None of that counters any of my points that Imane Khelif and the Algerian boxing authorities were not some wide-eyed innocents unaware of the existence of disorders of sexual development. Everyone in professional sport knows about these issues.
Pedant alert.
Olympic boxing is still very much an amateur sport.
I have no knowledge of Khelif's medical history, nor should I have.
I'm not particularly interested in boxing, there's a lot to dislike about professional boxing.
But I did have a look at her record.
49 wins, 9 defeats, that's good for an amateur boxer, but not infallible.
Of her 49 wins, 9 were by KO, the rest won on points. Not really the record of someone who is winning through brute strength alone. Most of her defeats came early in her 'career', implying that she has become a better skilled boxer through experience. If strength was her main asset she would have been winning those early contests.
There is nothing in her record that screams this is a man boxing against women.
It shows, amateur boxing is about skill. Early in Khelif's career their will have been boxers who could just dance around him lumbering his way round the ring windmilling away at them. As his skill improved his stength advantage obviously comes to the fore. He has never lost a fight by KO despite starting his career 1 and 5 and hasn't been beaten at all for 3 and a half years.
You clearly have the advantage on me, having watched her early contests....a niche way to spend your time.
There's this incredible resource called the internet mate.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(09-04-2025, 09:22 AM)Jacko Wrote: (09-04-2025, 09:12 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (09-04-2025, 08:31 AM)Jacko Wrote: (09-04-2025, 07:21 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (09-03-2025, 09:55 PM)Squid Wrote: None of that counters any of my points that Imane Khelif and the Algerian boxing authorities were not some wide-eyed innocents unaware of the existence of disorders of sexual development. Everyone in professional sport knows about these issues.
Pedant alert.
Olympic boxing is still very much an amateur sport.
I have no knowledge of Khelif's medical history, nor should I have.
I'm not particularly interested in boxing, there's a lot to dislike about professional boxing.
But I did have a look at her record.
49 wins, 9 defeats, that's good for an amateur boxer, but not infallible.
Of her 49 wins, 9 were by KO, the rest won on points. Not really the record of someone who is winning through brute strength alone. Most of her defeats came early in her 'career', implying that she has become a better skilled boxer through experience. If strength was her main asset she would have been winning those early contests.
There is nothing in her record that screams this is a man boxing against women.
It shows, amateur boxing is about skill. Early in Khelif's career their will have been boxers who could just dance around him lumbering his way round the ring windmilling away at them. As his skill improved his stength advantage obviously comes to the fore. He has never lost a fight by KO despite starting his career 1 and 5 and hasn't been beaten at all for 3 and a half years.
You clearly have the advantage on me, having watched her early contests....a niche way to spend your time.
There's this incredible resource called the internet mate.
Hard to believe but I am aware of it.
The existence of the Internet doesn't make watching the early contests if an Algerian boxer any less niche.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(09-04-2025, 08:39 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: I have minimal knowledge of this situation, so whilst this discussion was very interesting to read, it's quite obvious one person is discussing the facts and presenting their interpretation of it, and the other person is presenting their biased view without bothering to reply to points raised or questions asked. The rhetoric style of both posters is quite starkly different.
There's more than two people involved in this discussion, so I'm unsure as to what point you are trying to make here.
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
(09-04-2025, 10:16 AM)Squid Wrote: (09-04-2025, 08:39 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: I have minimal knowledge of this situation, so whilst this discussion was very interesting to read, it's quite obvious one person is discussing the facts and presenting their interpretation of it, and the other person is presenting their biased view without bothering to reply to points raised or questions asked. The rhetoric style of both posters is quite starkly different.
There's more than two people involved in this discussion, so I'm unsure as to what point you are trying to make here.
The fact you've felt the need to reply means my point has been made.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(09-04-2025, 10:29 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (09-04-2025, 10:16 AM)Squid Wrote: (09-04-2025, 08:39 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: I have minimal knowledge of this situation, so whilst this discussion was very interesting to read, it's quite obvious one person is discussing the facts and presenting their interpretation of it, and the other person is presenting their biased view without bothering to reply to points raised or questions asked. The rhetoric style of both posters is quite starkly different.
There's more than two people involved in this discussion, so I'm unsure as to what point you are trying to make here.
The fact you've felt the need to reply means my point has been made.
I think you are reading something into my posts which says more about your own internal biases.
Posts: 11,931
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
I think that any member of the general public who knows too much about these types of things should not be listened to. Not because their opinion is wrong or right, nor that the point they are trying to make isn't 'just' - in some way or another. But the very fact that Joe Public 'understands' (possibly in the Dunning Kruger context, admittedly) some of these terms means that they have been researching them to prove their own preconceived opinion on the matter. The likelihood of attaining agreement or even compromise is nil.
In my experience and opinion, which may be Dunning Kruger-like
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 9,633
Threads: 518
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
09-04-2025, 12:30 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-04-2025, 01:08 PM by Lurker#3.)
(09-04-2025, 11:54 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I think that any member of the general public who knows too much about these types of things should not be listened to. Not because their opinion is wrong or right, nor that the point they are trying to make isn't 'just' - in some way or another. But the very fact that Joe Public 'understands' (possibly in the Dunning Kruger context, admittedly) some of these terms means that they have been researching them to prove their own preconceived opinion on the matter. The likelihood of attaining agreement or even compromise is nil.
In my experience and opinion, which may be Dunning Kruger-like
I have researched the matter, mainly because, as explained, I am a sports scientist by trade I find anything like this really interesting. When I had my own PT/Lifestyle business after uni, circa 2009, there were not many coaches that specialised in womens health, male or female. So I did a years training on pre and post natal stuff as well general 'womens health' issues.
Fwiw.. this was the first article I read on the mattera year or so ago.
https://shro.org/imane-khelif-unfairly-a...20athletes.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(09-04-2025, 11:54 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I think that any member of the general public who knows too much about these types of things should not be listened to. Not because their opinion is wrong or right, nor that the point they are trying to make isn't 'just' - in some way or another. But the very fact that Joe Public 'understands' (possibly in the Dunning Kruger context, admittedly) some of these terms means that they have been researching them to prove their own preconceived opinion on the matter. The likelihood of attaining agreement or even compromise is nil.
In my experience and opinion, which may be Dunning Kruger-like
That's the most scenic route I've ever seen taken into calling someone a nerd.
|