Posts: 11,929
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
11-05-2025, 01:03 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-05-2025, 01:05 PM by CarlosCorbewrong.)
(11-05-2025, 12:07 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Some interesting, and frightening, reading here: https://www.gov.uk/government/publicatio...-discovery
I'd overstated the number of people working in my post above and it is actually 31.4M actively employed people in the UK paying taxes into a system that supports 68M people (Exhibit 3 point 24) and a benefits bill that has grown out of sync with comparative economies (point 29).
I'm sure the underlying causes are significantly more complex than a ham-fisted attempt to 'slash the bill' warrants (not that i expect any more from government). We have the longest waits in NHS memory, a post COVID (and Gen Z/A) societal drift which has devalued work, a growing cohort of people with caring responsibilities who aren't served by the NHS or Social Care. Soon, we'll have a generation of people who took best part of a year off school during a pandemic. Shortly after that we'll have the AI generation where huge swathes of jobs just will not be replaced. I think all of these factors exceed "able bodied people conning us" in volume.
Unfortunately the solutions to all of these things require ingenuity/cross-departmental work and money. The government has neither.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(11-05-2025, 01:03 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (11-05-2025, 12:07 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Some interesting, and frightening, reading here: https://www.gov.uk/government/publicatio...-discovery
I'd overstated the number of people working in my post above and it is actually 31.4M actively employed people in the UK paying taxes into a system that supports 68M people (Exhibit 3 point 24) and a benefits bill that has grown out of sync with comparative economies (point 29).
I'm sure the underlying causes are significantly more complex than a ham-fisted attempt to 'slash the bill' warrants (not that i expect any more from government). We have the longest waits in NHS memory, a post COVID (and Gen Z/A) societal drift which has devalued work, a growing cohort of people with caring responsibilities who aren't served by the NHS or Social Care. Soon, we'll have a generation of people who took best part of a year off school during a pandemic. Shortly after that we'll have the AI generation where huge swathes of jobs just will not be replaced. Unfortunately the solutions to all of these things require ingenuity/cross-departmental work and money. The government has neither.
The link paper does actually discuss this. For example, if people are not working due to awaiting medical treatment, then the longer they have to wait, the less likely it is that they will be able to return to work.
So it is a complex problem, requiring multi-factorial solutions. However, just saying "What about the 1%?" is not one of those solutions.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(11-05-2025, 01:03 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (11-05-2025, 12:07 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Some interesting, and frightening, reading here: https://www.gov.uk/government/publicatio...-discovery
I'd overstated the number of people working in my post above and it is actually 31.4M actively employed people in the UK paying taxes into a system that supports 68M people (Exhibit 3 point 24) and a benefits bill that has grown out of sync with comparative economies (point 29).
I'm sure the underlying causes are significantly more complex than a ham-fisted attempt to 'slash the bill' warrants (not that i expect any more from government). We have the longest waits in NHS memory, a post COVID (and Gen Z/A) societal drift which has devalued work, a growing cohort of people with caring responsibilities who aren't served by the NHS or Social Care. Soon, we'll have a generation of people who took best part of a year off school during a pandemic. Shortly after that we'll have the AI generation where huge swathes of jobs just will not be replaced. I think all of these factors exceed "able bodied people conning us" in volume.
Unfortunately the solutions to all of these things require ingenuity/cross-departmental work and money. The government has neither.
If you are including the 'complexity' of 'a post covid societal drift which has devalued work' as a reason for benefits increasing then you should be calling for tighter management of the benefits application process even if you want to label that as a 'slash the bill' approach. Surely your own example is a very good definition of 'able bodied people conning us'.
The carers grouping is 1.7M of the 9.3M economically inactive and probably a distraction from the overall problem as they will not be costing the state as much as they are saving it.
The future figures, which no doubt need to be planned for, do not change the current massive growth in benefit payments to people who, as you clearly state, have devalued work.
Posts: 11,929
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
(11-05-2025, 01:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (11-05-2025, 01:03 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (11-05-2025, 12:07 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Some interesting, and frightening, reading here: https://www.gov.uk/government/publicatio...-discovery
I'd overstated the number of people working in my post above and it is actually 31.4M actively employed people in the UK paying taxes into a system that supports 68M people (Exhibit 3 point 24) and a benefits bill that has grown out of sync with comparative economies (point 29).
I'm sure the underlying causes are significantly more complex than a ham-fisted attempt to 'slash the bill' warrants (not that i expect any more from government). We have the longest waits in NHS memory, a post COVID (and Gen Z/A) societal drift which has devalued work, a growing cohort of people with caring responsibilities who aren't served by the NHS or Social Care. Soon, we'll have a generation of people who took best part of a year off school during a pandemic. Shortly after that we'll have the AI generation where huge swathes of jobs just will not be replaced. I think all of these factors exceed "able bodied people conning us" in volume.
Unfortunately the solutions to all of these things require ingenuity/cross-departmental work and money. The government has neither.
If you are including the 'complexity' of 'a post covid societal drift which has devalued work' as a reason for benefits increasing then you should be calling for tighter management of the benefits application process even if you want to label that as a 'slash the bill' approach. Surely your own example is a very good definition of 'able bodied people conning us'.
The carers grouping is 1.7M of the 9.3M economically inactive and probably a distraction from the overall problem as they will not be costing the state as much as they are saving it.
The future figures, which no doubt need to be planned for, do not change the current massive growth in benefit payments to people who, as you clearly state, have devalued work.
You know full well that 'able bodied' refers to those who claim disability benefits, Proth.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
Ah the old ‘Proth’ insult when you can’t be bothered to face up to the points you make yourself. Your own words highlight an abuse of the benefits system by referencing those that have devalued work. That in itself should lead to stricter criteria.
Posts: 11,929
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
11-05-2025, 02:05 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-05-2025, 02:07 PM by CarlosCorbewrong.)
(11-05-2025, 01:39 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Ah the old ‘Proth’ insult when you can’t be bothered to face up to the points you make yourself. Your own words highlight an abuse of the benefits system by referencing those that have devalued work. That in itself should lead to stricter criteria.
Nibble
If you take your purple tinted glasses off for a second you'll see no criticism from me about stopping benefits for workshy people who are able to work. But an evidence based unintended consequence of cutting benefits for poor people is a rise in crime, homelessness, intergenerational unemployment, metal health crises etc and I think a government should be more obsessed with than "able bodied people conning us".
The impacts of worklessness is the same, generally, regardless of the root cause. But if you don't address the root causes then you just shunt the problem from the DWP to policing, housing and social care.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
Nibble?
Your suggestion is that instead of people getting jobs we should support them through benefits or they will resort to criminal behaviour. That's ridiculous. I can see one of your problems in looking at any debate is that someone who doesn't have your view must have a politically driven agenda based on their voting pattern. It's an easy way out of actually looking at the points. You've said that there are people who simply don't like work that are on benefits and if we take them off benefits they will rob. That really isn't a reason for not tightening the criteria.
Posts: 3,107
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
11-05-2025, 02:47 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-05-2025, 02:49 PM by Tom Joad 25.)
(11-05-2025, 02:11 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Nibble?
Your suggestion is that instead of people getting jobs we should support them through benefits or they will resort to criminal behaviour. That's ridiculous. I can see one of your problems in looking at any debate is that someone who doesn't have your view must have a politically driven agenda based on their voting pattern. It's an easy way out of actually looking at the points. You've said that there are people who simply don't like work that are on benefits and if we take them off benefits they will rob. That really isn't a reason for not tightening the criteria.
Agree. And if the policing wasn't broken there would be the threat of being arrested. And if the courts didn't have a 2 or more years backlog we could get them into court, as long as the CPS thought it was worth the prosecution and the jails weren't too full to put them in. The entire system is falling apart -as we knew -after years of austerity and giving away money. The culture of not working is out of hand and unsustainable, likewise the medicating of anxiety. Its not anxiety, it's simply being a teenager, it is a challenge to get past. Before anyone accuses me of forcing the lame into coalmines, no, this is my experience from a number of people I have met. (And not people with serious disabilities). Everyone knew whoever got in it was going to be an impossible job, I still think changing the government just over a year ago was absolutely necessary and unpopular decisions need to be made.
Posts: 11,929
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
(11-05-2025, 02:11 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Nibble?
Your suggestion is that instead of people getting jobs we should support them through benefits or they will resort to criminal behaviour. That's ridiculous. I can see one of your problems in looking at any debate is that someone who doesn't have your view must have a politically driven agenda based on their voting pattern. It's an easy way out of actually looking at the points. You've said that there are people who simply don't like work that are on benefits and if we take them off benefits they will rob. That really isn't a reason for not tightening the criteria.
It's not my suggestion at all - that's extrapolation and pretty much unfounded if you care to read my post. You're very angry today Jacko.
I'm saying that we should be removing the incentives to not work/barriers to work and that those incentives/barriers are far more complicated than sanctioning people's benefits like Ian Duncan Smith and SERCO celebrated doing/tightening the criteria that Rachel Reeves failed to do.
I'm saying, for the avoidance of doubt, that worklessness is complicated and that there doesn't appear to be a coordinated approach to resolving some of these underlying structural barriers to work. 3 examples I've thought of whilst I've been on a dull ass Teams call...
There's currently a 16 month wait for assessment for Access To Work - a Tory government scheme which provides genuinely practical support for people with disabilities to gain or maintain employment. Their reason for the delays - "we're understaffed" - that was a formal response to a Junior Minister btw, not just some poor call handler. Yet, even a low level genius like me can quickly work out that providing support services to people who are asking for them (!) would quickly break even if the government just thought a bit harder...
Just this week, the government decided not to fund a cross party recommendation to pay for young person's travel. To quote a Labour Lord:
" "Throughout our inquiry we heard about the consequences of poor connectivity," Labour MP Cadbury said.
"Young people unable to get their first jobs or taking exhausting journeys to reach school or college. Older and disabled people feeling isolated and depressed, and high streets starved of customers." ... that's 2...
Birmingham City Council have been allowed to cut disabled kids transport for 6th formers... directly targeting the most vulnerable and those with the most need whilst adding additional burden to carers. How realistic is it for someone to maintain employment when they have to drive 55 minutes to a Special School the other side of the City twice a day at 9am and 3pm...that's 3.
You'll say that this is all hard to do. It's certainly harder than cutting a number on a spreadsheet. I'll say that anything is possible with the right amount of will.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
I'm really not angry, I've linked a report that was commissioned by this government on the complexities of the subject, and then just highlighting your own comments after you've not bothered to look at the report by the sounds of it. I've also pointed out how unsustainable it is and we are just creating a problem for the future by not dealing with it. You're the one that has gone all precious on me referencing able bodied people and using emotive words such as 'targeting' when the reality is nearer they haven't got the funds for everyone and they have to make the least worst choice. You're whole argument is about the need for funding now whilst also saying there is no money, it makes no sense.
The reality is that the benefit system is being abused, even using your own examples, and we are at a point that it is unsustainable without cutting other services such as the ones you highlight. We do need to tighten up the criteria and as much as the ideal world would look after all conditions, some of them need to look after themselves more and that will take both a carrot and stick approach.
|