Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
10-16-2021, 02:53 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-16-2021, 02:57 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(10-16-2021, 02:45 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I didn't go last night and couldn't bring myself to watch it. My dad phoned me at the end, and he was annoyed with the pile of crap he'd watched. I said, let me guess; we lumped it forward, rushed at it, and there was no end product and it was boring. He said exactly. I replied, it's like bad parks football, hoof and chase, and that the fact i didn't watch it and described it pretty accurately shows how crap it is.
He actually said he thought it was the worst he'd ever seen, I said come on we had Pulis, which he agreed was worse. He's been a fan since the 1950s, he thinks it's an utter shambles and utterly boring to watch. We both agreed that getting promoted with this side, manager and 'way of playing' could see us doing worse than Derby did.
Some of us need more than just winning, which I know is an unpopular view on here. Six has his work cut out and needs to provide more than flukey wins.
They aren’t flukey wins and what were you and your Dad doing in the 90s? It couldn’t have been watching us getting thrashed by the likes of Stockport and Crewe or embarrassing ourselves against Bristol Rover, Halifax and Woking etc. I respect the fact you don’t like the style of play but not the hyperbole.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
10-16-2021, 02:59 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-16-2021, 02:59 PM by MassDebater.)
(10-16-2021, 02:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-16-2021, 02:45 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I didn't go last night and couldn't bring myself to watch it. My dad phoned me at the end, and he was annoyed with the pile of crap he'd watched. I said, let me guess; we lumped it forward, rushed at it, and there was no end product and it was boring. He said exactly. I replied, it's like bad parks football, hoof and chase, and that the fact i didn't watch it and described it pretty accurately shows how crap it is.
He actually said he thought it was the worst he'd ever seen, I said come on we had Pulis, which he agreed was worse. He's been a fan since the 1950s, he thinks it's an utter shambles and utterly boring to watch. We both agreed that getting promoted with this side, manager and 'way of playing' could see us doing worse than Derby did.
Some of us need more than just winning, which I know is an unpopular view on here. Six has his work cut out and needs to provide more than flukey wins.
They aren’t flukey wins and what were you and your Dad doing in the 90s? It couldn’t have been watching us getting thrashed by the likes of Stockport and Crewe or embarrassing ourselves against Halifax and Woking etc.
We were there. Whilst it was shyte back then, it never ever felt boring. Most of the stuff served up by Six has been boring, interspersed with a few bits of excitement. I'd say there's been about 30% of games this season that I've enjoyed. Football was a different beast back in the 90s, and I always enjoyed going even when we were utter shyte, maybe it's an age thing and the realisation that promotion is only good for the club's finances. I'm long past the winning is all that counts mentality, as what will that actually get us?
I've not felt this disconnected from enjoying the games since Pulis, who completely stopped me going for a good while. Last night I cheered when I heard we'd scored, but since it was 75 minutes in and I'd checked the stats at half time, I just knew it was another load of turgid crap. When you don't even need to watch it to know it's bad, then something is not right.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(10-16-2021, 02:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-16-2021, 02:45 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I didn't go last night and couldn't bring myself to watch it. My dad phoned me at the end, and he was annoyed with the pile of crap he'd watched. I said, let me guess; we lumped it forward, rushed at it, and there was no end product and it was boring. He said exactly. I replied, it's like bad parks football, hoof and chase, and that the fact i didn't watch it and described it pretty accurately shows how crap it is.
He actually said he thought it was the worst he'd ever seen, I said come on we had Pulis, which he agreed was worse. He's been a fan since the 1950s, he thinks it's an utter shambles and utterly boring to watch. We both agreed that getting promoted with this side, manager and 'way of playing' could see us doing worse than Derby did.
Some of us need more than just winning, which I know is an unpopular view on here. Six has his work cut out and needs to provide more than flukey wins.
They aren’t flukey wins and what were you and your Dad doing in the 90s? It couldn’t have been watching us getting thrashed by the likes of Stockport and Crewe or embarrassing ourselves against Halifax and Woking etc. I respect the fact you don’t like the style of play but not the hyperbole.
Indeed.
I get as I said, that football purists are not going to like it, those that love possession, delicate passing and creative flair throughout the midfield are not going to like this at all. And that's fine, so long as they accept that so long as we're getting results the manager is doing the job he is paid to do. It's a results based business, if you need entertainment, may I suggest wrestling or the cinema?
I see no evidence to say why we'd fail in the prem because of how we play. With current personnel, yes, but until I see who we sign I won't make any predictions on that count, in fact, considering most prem teams prefer to hold possession and play out from the back, would suit us more than the Champ where teams want rid of it far more quickly. So as said, I'll make predictions and worry / get excited about that when and if we get there!
But anyone saying this is worse than under Buckley, Little, Pardew... I'm sorry, football isn't the sport for you or you're just whining because it's not the style you like, and that is sad. I didn't whine about Bilic's teams holding on to the ball too long while results were good, which I hated as much as some hate this. Because, results were good.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(10-16-2021, 02:59 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (10-16-2021, 02:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-16-2021, 02:45 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I didn't go last night and couldn't bring myself to watch it. My dad phoned me at the end, and he was annoyed with the pile of crap he'd watched. I said, let me guess; we lumped it forward, rushed at it, and there was no end product and it was boring. He said exactly. I replied, it's like bad parks football, hoof and chase, and that the fact i didn't watch it and described it pretty accurately shows how crap it is.
He actually said he thought it was the worst he'd ever seen, I said come on we had Pulis, which he agreed was worse. He's been a fan since the 1950s, he thinks it's an utter shambles and utterly boring to watch. We both agreed that getting promoted with this side, manager and 'way of playing' could see us doing worse than Derby did.
Some of us need more than just winning, which I know is an unpopular view on here. Six has his work cut out and needs to provide more than flukey wins.
They aren’t flukey wins and what were you and your Dad doing in the 90s? It couldn’t have been watching us getting thrashed by the likes of Stockport and Crewe or embarrassing ourselves against Halifax and Woking etc.
We were there. Whilst it was shyte back then, it never ever felt boring. Most of the stuff served up by Six has been boring, interspersed with a few bits of excitement. I'd say there's been about 30% of games this season that I've enjoyed. Football was a different beast back in the 90s, and I always enjoyed going even when we were utter shyte, maybe it's an age thing and the realisation that promotion is only good for the club's finances. I'm long past the winning is all that counts mentality, as what will that actually get us?
I've not felt this disconnected from enjoying the games since Pulis, who completely stopped me going for a good while. Last night I cheered when I heard we'd scored, but since it was 75 minutes in and I'd checked the stats at half time, I just knew it was another load of turgid crap. When you don't even need to watch it to know it's bad, then something is not right.
The 90s were embarrassing and our gates for run of the mill games back this up. My old school struggled to give tickets away for free. The 90s ingeneral were great fun though
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(10-16-2021, 02:45 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I didn't go last night and couldn't bring myself to watch it. My dad phoned me at the end, and he was annoyed with the pile of crap he'd watched. I said, let me guess; we lumped it forward, rushed at it, and there was no end product and it was boring. He said exactly. I replied, it's like bad parks football, hoof and chase, and that the fact i didn't watch it and described it pretty accurately shows how crap it is.
He actually said he thought it was the worst he'd ever seen, I said come on we had Pulis, which he agreed was worse. He's been a fan since the 1950s, he thinks it's an utter shambles and utterly boring to watch. We both agreed that getting promoted with this side, manager and 'way of playing' could see us doing worse than Derby did.
Some of us need more than just winning, which I know is an unpopular view on here. Six has his work cut out and needs to provide more than flukey wins.
(10-16-2021, 01:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-16-2021, 01:43 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Derek Hardballs Wrote:Squid Wrote:Yes. I fail to see the Pulis comparison either. The ball was constantly going in the box yesterday, there just wasn't anyone on the end of it.
The comparison is with the entertainment value. There have been a number of matches this season that are just as dull as many TP games against much lower opposition. I really don’t care how we play but I can see the point that those who prefer a more sophisticated style of play are making. Lumping the ball in the box isn’t particularly great to watch and neither is turning the ball around the corner and into the channels from midfield aimlessly and frenetically. I'm not buying this Pulis comparison either, DH. The football under TP was always turgid and most games he didn't even attempt to win, (including annoyingly, the home game against worst villa side in memory). Val has us straining to win every game. I will agree it isn't pretty although it does have it's moments, Sheff Utd, Luton, Bournemouth were all very entertaining.
I also was bought up with the free flowing football of the 60s and witnessed the excitement of the late 70's. I was told by my grandad, Albion always had this reputation, Albion being the entertainers and Wolves were the powerhouses. Times have changed now and with the normal tenure of a manager being less than 2 years, I don't see anyone putting anything but their own methods first.
We won a number of games, playing decent football under Pulis it’s a myth that always played with no attacking intent.
Pulis won less than 30% of the matches he was manager for. He drew exactly the same percentage of games as he won, that kind of backs up the lack of intent to win.
It wasn't a flukey win. Blues huffed and puffed, but only had one shot on target. As soon as we scored it was all over.
Posts: 1,036
Threads: 23
Joined: Jan 2019
(10-16-2021, 02:45 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I didn't go last night and couldn't bring myself to watch it. My dad phoned me at the end, and he was annoyed with the pile of crap he'd watched. I said, let me guess; we lumped it forward, rushed at it, and there was no end product and it was boring. He said exactly. I replied, it's like bad parks football, hoof and chase, and that the fact i didn't watch it and described it pretty accurately shows how crap it is.
He actually said he thought it was the worst he'd ever seen, I said come on we had Pulis, which he agreed was worse. He's been a fan since the 1950s, he thinks it's an utter shambles and utterly boring to watch. We both agreed that getting promoted with this side, manager and 'way of playing' could see us doing worse than Derby did.
Some of us need more than just winning, which I know is an unpopular view on here. Six has his work cut out and needs to provide more than flukey wins.
(10-16-2021, 01:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-16-2021, 01:43 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Derek Hardballs Wrote:Squid Wrote:Yes. I fail to see the Pulis comparison either. The ball was constantly going in the box yesterday, there just wasn't anyone on the end of it.
The comparison is with the entertainment value. There have been a number of matches this season that are just as dull as many TP games against much lower opposition. I really don’t care how we play but I can see the point that those who prefer a more sophisticated style of play are making. Lumping the ball in the box isn’t particularly great to watch and neither is turning the ball around the corner and into the channels from midfield aimlessly and frenetically. I'm not buying this Pulis comparison either, DH. The football under TP was always turgid and most games he didn't even attempt to win, (including annoyingly, the home game against worst villa side in memory). Val has us straining to win every game. I will agree it isn't pretty although it does have it's moments, Sheff Utd, Luton, Bournemouth were all very entertaining.
I also was bought up with the free flowing football of the 60s and witnessed the excitement of the late 70's. I was told by my grandad, Albion always had this reputation, Albion being the entertainers and Wolves were the powerhouses. Times have changed now and with the normal tenure of a manager being less than 2 years, I don't see anyone putting anything but their own methods first.
We won a number of games, playing decent football under Pulis it’s a myth that always played with no attacking intent.
Pulis won less than 30% of the matches he was manager for. He drew exactly the same percentage of games as he won, that kind of backs up the lack of intent to win. All of those matches were in the Prem though.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(10-16-2021, 03:08 PM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: (10-16-2021, 02:45 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I didn't go last night and couldn't bring myself to watch it. My dad phoned me at the end, and he was annoyed with the pile of crap he'd watched. I said, let me guess; we lumped it forward, rushed at it, and there was no end product and it was boring. He said exactly. I replied, it's like bad parks football, hoof and chase, and that the fact i didn't watch it and described it pretty accurately shows how crap it is.
He actually said he thought it was the worst he'd ever seen, I said come on we had Pulis, which he agreed was worse. He's been a fan since the 1950s, he thinks it's an utter shambles and utterly boring to watch. We both agreed that getting promoted with this side, manager and 'way of playing' could see us doing worse than Derby did.
Some of us need more than just winning, which I know is an unpopular view on here. Six has his work cut out and needs to provide more than flukey wins.
(10-16-2021, 01:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-16-2021, 01:43 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Derek Hardballs Wrote:The comparison is with the entertainment value. There have been a number of matches this season that are just as dull as many TP games against much lower opposition. I really don’t care how we play but I can see the point that those who prefer a more sophisticated style of play are making. Lumping the ball in the box isn’t particularly great to watch and neither is turning the ball around the corner and into the channels from midfield aimlessly and frenetically. I'm not buying this Pulis comparison either, DH. The football under TP was always turgid and most games he didn't even attempt to win, (including annoyingly, the home game against worst villa side in memory). Val has us straining to win every game. I will agree it isn't pretty although it does have it's moments, Sheff Utd, Luton, Bournemouth were all very entertaining.
I also was bought up with the free flowing football of the 60s and witnessed the excitement of the late 70's. I was told by my grandad, Albion always had this reputation, Albion being the entertainers and Wolves were the powerhouses. Times have changed now and with the normal tenure of a manager being less than 2 years, I don't see anyone putting anything but their own methods first.
We won a number of games, playing decent football under Pulis it’s a myth that always played with no attacking intent.
Pulis won less than 30% of the matches he was manager for. He drew exactly the same percentage of games as he won, that kind of backs up the lack of intent to win. All of those matches were in the Prem though.
Exactly against far better opposition and it wasn’t a fluke that we finished comfortably safe for two seasons.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
10-16-2021, 03:13 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-16-2021, 03:16 PM by MassDebater.)
(10-16-2021, 03:03 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (10-16-2021, 02:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-16-2021, 02:45 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I didn't go last night and couldn't bring myself to watch it. My dad phoned me at the end, and he was annoyed with the pile of crap he'd watched. I said, let me guess; we lumped it forward, rushed at it, and there was no end product and it was boring. He said exactly. I replied, it's like bad parks football, hoof and chase, and that the fact i didn't watch it and described it pretty accurately shows how crap it is.
He actually said he thought it was the worst he'd ever seen, I said come on we had Pulis, which he agreed was worse. He's been a fan since the 1950s, he thinks it's an utter shambles and utterly boring to watch. We both agreed that getting promoted with this side, manager and 'way of playing' could see us doing worse than Derby did.
Some of us need more than just winning, which I know is an unpopular view on here. Six has his work cut out and needs to provide more than flukey wins.
They aren’t flukey wins and what were you and your Dad doing in the 90s? It couldn’t have been watching us getting thrashed by the likes of Stockport and Crewe or embarrassing ourselves against Halifax and Woking etc. I respect the fact you don’t like the style of play but not the hyperbole.
Indeed.
I get as I said, that football purists are not going to like it, those that love possession, delicate passing and creative flair throughout the midfield are not going to like this at all. And that's fine, so long as they accept that so long as we're getting results the manager is doing the job he is paid to do. It's a results based business, if you need entertainment, may I suggest wrestling or the cinema?
I see no evidence to say why we'd fail in the prem because of how we play. With current personnel, yes, but until I see who we sign I won't make any predictions on that count, in fact, considering most prem teams prefer to hold possession and play out from the back, would suit us more than the Champ where teams want rid of it far more quickly. So as said, I'll make predictions and worry / get excited about that when and if we get there!
But anyone saying this is worse than under Buckley, Little, Pardew... I'm sorry, football isn't the sport for you or you're just whining because it's not the style you like, and that is sad. I didn't whine about Bilic's teams holding on to the ball too long while results were good, which I hated as much as some hate this. Because, results were good.
As I've stated many times, maybe it's age (could be similar with Ferenc and others too?), we just want more from the match, but obviously only you and the win is all that matters brigade are the only ones who are allowed to watch the game, because obviously only your opinion counts.
I'm all for giving credit where it is due and did so when we played Sheff Utd and Cardiff off the park (and 70 minutes v Luton), but that also means when we play shyte then I'll say that too. If you recall I said against Bournemouth that this style is easily countered, by just not holding onto the ball, I wish I had been wrong, but that'll be me watching something else that gave me that obvious knowledge.
Moore and Bilic showed that you can play decent / entertaining football and get results. Fulham and Bournemouth also seem to be having no issues doing it either.
For me, Six is a few bad results away from being lumped in with Pulis and that would be sad and unfair on him. I see what he is trying to do, and it can work and provide some excitement, sadly he just seems to not be aware that the opposition are allowed to change how they usually play to counter it. Which is a kind of compliment to Six and the team, but it's getting very boring and getting even more boring saying exactly the same things even when we eke out a win.
I've not felt like I missed out on not going to a match since Pulis was here, when I could just check the results and know I'd not missed anything, Six is currently heading in that direction for me. At the moment it's purely results football, i.e. just check and hope we won after its over without needing to watch it to annoy yourself. I've seen glimpses to know we can play better, but we just seem to fall into the same no ideas so hoof it trap when the opposition set up to counter us.
(10-16-2021, 03:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-16-2021, 02:59 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (10-16-2021, 02:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-16-2021, 02:45 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I didn't go last night and couldn't bring myself to watch it. My dad phoned me at the end, and he was annoyed with the pile of crap he'd watched. I said, let me guess; we lumped it forward, rushed at it, and there was no end product and it was boring. He said exactly. I replied, it's like bad parks football, hoof and chase, and that the fact i didn't watch it and described it pretty accurately shows how crap it is.
He actually said he thought it was the worst he'd ever seen, I said come on we had Pulis, which he agreed was worse. He's been a fan since the 1950s, he thinks it's an utter shambles and utterly boring to watch. We both agreed that getting promoted with this side, manager and 'way of playing' could see us doing worse than Derby did.
Some of us need more than just winning, which I know is an unpopular view on here. Six has his work cut out and needs to provide more than flukey wins.
They aren’t flukey wins and what were you and your Dad doing in the 90s? It couldn’t have been watching us getting thrashed by the likes of Stockport and Crewe or embarrassing ourselves against Halifax and Woking etc.
We were there. Whilst it was shyte back then, it never ever felt boring. Most of the stuff served up by Six has been boring, interspersed with a few bits of excitement. I'd say there's been about 30% of games this season that I've enjoyed. Football was a different beast back in the 90s, and I always enjoyed going even when we were utter shyte, maybe it's an age thing and the realisation that promotion is only good for the club's finances. I'm long past the winning is all that counts mentality, as what will that actually get us?
I've not felt this disconnected from enjoying the games since Pulis, who completely stopped me going for a good while. Last night I cheered when I heard we'd scored, but since it was 75 minutes in and I'd checked the stats at half time, I just knew it was another load of turgid crap. When you don't even need to watch it to know it's bad, then something is not right.
The 90s were embarrassing and our gates for run of the mill games back this up. My old school struggled to give tickets away for free. The 90s ingeneral were great fun though 
See it's weird, I only ever felt embarrassed vs Woking, the rest I was always proud. Our gates were low, but my dad and I virtually never missed a single game. These days I'm more likely to not bust a gut to go, god knows how Cornish does it.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
I ahve no issue with you sharing your opinion at all MD, as said, I disagree but see whaere you're coming from, but hyperbole like it being worse than the 90's is inexcusable. Honestly, it's a good thing I really loved football because fuck it was shit back then. There were times I thought my school team played better than West Brom, and several times I thought we could give them a game, we were dire, literally relying on one or two players who we were lucky to have to get us something, Taylor/Hunt/Sneekes/Hughes...
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
But I said NEED entertainment for a reason, it's absolutely fine to want it, and I get that totally. But needing it for you to like the manager when he's getting results, is to me, non sensical.
|