The death row case of Christa Pike
#21
(10-01-2026, 09:53 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Having seen how the legal system works, and how money basically goes a VERY long way, I wouldn’t ever want to see it implemented here. There have been too many miscarriages of justice recently to warrant it. Despite the fact that - I agree - there are some out there who need removal from society altogether.

I suppose until you’ve been the family member/friend (or indeed victim) of such heinous a crime meriting it, it’s hard to say.

I echo every word of that. Chuck 'em in a miserable hell hole with few privileges and time to think.
Reply
#22
Remember this is my opinion. Someone walks down the road looks at someone who doesn’t like how the person looked at him so uses a weapon he should not be carrying to kill that person. Is caught straight away by whatever means some don’t think he/ she deserves to die. Someone pulls out a rifle or knife and shoots or stabs children and staff and kills them all caught on CCTV and arrested at the scene don’t deserve to die. Why would anyone want these pathetic low lives kept alive is beyond me.
There is enough shit going on in the world with these low lives making things worse.

As you can tell I’m a big advocate for the death penalty in the right circumstances.

I will now leave this subject as it stresses me to much.
Reply
#23
(10-01-2026, 07:06 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 06:48 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: She was a really fucked-up kid and that was never properly taken into account. Not excusing her actions one bit, but everyone was baying for blood so ferociously her childhood was never properly considered.

A fucked up country with fucked up laws fucks up. It’s hardly a surprise!

Yeah, I thought that bit was particularly sad that a) the defence failed to present that info b) it wasn’t sufficient to prevent the death penalty c) she got the death penalty but her boyfriend, 17 at the time, escapes it. 

You can’t excuse people because of the abuse they suffered as kids - but if ever there was a legitimate mitigation for the death penalty this must be it, surely?
The Truman Capote film/ book way back made essentially the same point. It's the barbarity of the death sentence laid bare 
It's natural to want revenge I guess. But should the state -us- descend to the lowest level?
Fwiw my opinion of the USA is that it's descending into barbarism.
Reply
#24
The state should never be involved in killing it's own citizens. If it sets itself up as justifying killing individuals then it's a slippery slope to members of the public doing the same when they feel they have not been given justice
The points regarding money influencing outcomes within the system are also very salient.
In short the death penalty drags our collective consciousness back to a more uncivilised way of thinking.
The current case seems to be one of a person who should have been protected by the system now being killed by the system due to actions she took which she most likely wouldn't have if that system hadn't failed so abysmaly in the first place
Reply
#25
(10-01-2026, 11:50 AM)wba13 Wrote: Remember this is my opinion. Someone walks down the road looks at someone who doesn’t like how the person looked at him so uses a weapon he should not be carrying to kill that person. Is caught straight away by whatever means some don’t think he/ she deserves to die. Someone pulls out a rifle or knife and shoots or stabs children and staff and kills them all caught on CCTV and arrested at the scene don’t deserve to die. Why would anyone want these pathetic low lives kept alive is beyond me.
There is enough shit going on in the world with these low lives making things worse.

As you can tell I’m a big advocate for the death penalty in the right circumstances.

I will now leave this subject as it stresses me to much.

As ever, 13, you see things completely black and white with no wriggle room for nuance or wider context.

I completely echo Birdie's thoughts. Giving the state the power to kill people will never stop at the situations your outline above. And it completely relies on the intent and morals of the people in charge.
Reply
#26
It'll all be fine when Judge and Jury are replaced with AI, there'll be no risk of injustice then.
Reply
#27
The Lucy Letby case has completely changed my view on the death penalty, in all honesty.

When she was convicted I was of the opinion that killing so many babies was worthy of the death penalty, and to some extent, I still hold that view. It takes a sick, evil individual to do that, and they would be beyond redemption, and would have nothing to offer society. That's probably an extreme and harsh view, but that's what I felt at the time.

However, there's some doubt as to her guilt now. We could have been in a situation where an innocent person was sentenced to death (in a hypothetical world where the death penalty was an option when sentencing). That has made me rethink my views, even in the most deplorable and sickening cases.

It's so tough. Life is ultimately precious, and we shouldn't be so quick to end it, even if it seems morally the right thing to do.
Reply
#28
(10-01-2026, 02:01 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: The Lucy Letby case has completely changed my view on the death penalty, in all honesty.

When she was convicted I was of the opinion that killing so many babies was worthy of the death penalty, and to some extent, I still hold that view. It takes a sick, evil individual to do that, and they would be beyond redemption, and would have nothing to offer society. That's probably an extreme and harsh view, but that's what I felt at the time.

However, there's some doubt as to her guilt now. We could have been in a situation where an innocent person was sentenced to death (in a hypothetical world where the death penalty was an option when sentencing). That has made me rethink my views, even in the most deplorable and sickening cases.

It's so tough. Life is ultimately precious, and we shouldn't be so quick to end it, even if it seems morally the right thing to do.

Exactly this.

Mistaken convictions, state overreach, corrupt/biased Police (eg racism, coerced confessions etc), availability of a good enough lawyer due to not having enough money, a biased/ignorant/stupid jury.

I'm sure there's more reasons. You just can't have the death penalty when there's so many factors that go into someone being found guilty.
Reply
#29
This is why it can't be judged purely on the seriousness of the crime, it has to be judged on the level of ambiguity.
If there is absolutely no doubt whatsoever, then the miscarriage of justice argument is moot and it becomes a purely moral dilemma and I would be more inclined to consider it..
If, however, there is even the slightest doubt, it can simply never be an option.
Reply
#30
(10-01-2026, 02:33 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: This is why it can't be judged purely on the seriousness of the crime, it has to be judged on the level of ambiguity.
If there is absolutely no doubt whatsoever, then the miscarriage of justice argument is moot and it becomes a purely moral dilemma and I would be more inclined to consider it..
If, however, there is even the slightest doubt, it can simply never be an option.

I think this would always be the case though. The criminal standard for guilty is "beyond reasonable doubt". So there can still be some doubt for them to be found guilty.

Especially these days when video evidence can be doctored more easily than ever, and witness testimony is as always, flawed, you just won't be 100% certain almost ever.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)