Interest level in our FA Cup match?
#21
Given the attitude of most here, we might as well not enter either the FA Cup or the Leage Cup at all. The Club has a very proud FA Cup tradition, but many people would just throw all of that away because they regard it as meaningless, probably primarily because they're not old enough to remember it.

Only one club will win the FA Cip in the end, so to suggest not bothering to make an effort because we won't win the Cup makes no sense. If that attitude was applied to Formula 1, there would probably only be 8 cars in every race and tennis tournaments would have about 16 participants. Indeed, it could be applied to all sports.
Reply
#22
I'd like to see us win this one and get a good home draw next round against a top Prem team (not Villa). But if we lose, meh.
Reply
#23
(01-10-2026, 10:22 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: Given the attitude of most here, we might as well not enter either the FA Cup or the Leage Cup at all. The Club has a very proud FA Cup tradition, but many people would just throw all of that away because they regard it as meaningless, probably primarily because they're not old enough to remember it.

Only one club will win the FA Cip in the end, so to suggest not bothering to make an effort because we won't win the Cup makes no sense. If that attitude was applied to Formula 1, there would probably only be 8 cars in every race and tennis tournaments would have about 16 participants. Indeed, it could be applied to all sports.

The main problems with this argument are in reality it’ll be a Prem team that wins it and more likely than not a top six team. Plus given our unbalanced and small squad and potentially precarious position in the league I’m not sure it’s a priority of the clubs. This isn’t the 70 or early 80s where twenty/thirty clubs could win the competition. It’s not fans that have devalued the cup, it’s the owners and tv companies.
Reply
#24
Come on you Baggies always will and always have wanted us to win and yes I’m always interested.
Reply
#25
The intrigue for me today is all around the team and how they approach a game post-Mason, and hoping Morrison has the backing to give Whitwell and Bostock starts. Just for his own confidence it would be great to give Dike a start too.

I’m not fussed about the result as the FA Cup has lost so much of its magic, and losing to Palace’s reserves in the fifth round would just compound how far we’ve fallen, so today for me is more about the cathartic post-Mason optimism.
Reply
#26
(01-10-2026, 10:15 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Back in the day (late 60s, late 70s) relegation seemed less of a worry, so the Cup comps were an annual adventure. Two wins and a good many semi-finals before I hit 30 years old.

Since 1986 we've always been looking over our shoulder at the abyss. Cup runs have seemed a risk and a luxury.

Tomorrow is a bit different. Start of a new era, free of the baggage that Mason accumulated during his underwhelming tenure. No league points at risk. Quite enthusiastic myself.


Same here Chesh
Reply
#27
(01-10-2026, 10:15 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Back in the day (late 60s, late 70s) relegation seemed less of a worry, so the Cup comps were an annual adventure. Two wins and a good many semi-finals before I hit 30 years old.

Since 1986 we've always been looking over our shoulder at the abyss. Cup runs have seemed a risk and a luxury.

Tomorrow is a bit different. Start of a new era, free of the baggage that Mason accumulated during his underwhelming tenure. No league points at risk. Quite enthusiastic myself.

Where I am too.  We’re not going down or up, why not give it a go.  Think Swansea are in a similar position. Also I really hate it when we go out in the third round and there’s nothing to look forward when they’re drawing the 4th round.  I wouldn’t risk MJ or Griffiths but after that I’d pick the strongest team possible.
Reply
#28
Third Round day used to be one of the best days of the footballimg year. They have downgraded the FA cup so much that it means little to me anymore. The Premier League, Sky and BBC have done their utmost to emasculate the competition. It makes me laugh out loud when they try to whip up enthusiasm and harp on about the "magic of the Cup" which they they have done their damndest to ruin.
Reply
#29
(01-10-2026, 11:50 AM)col lard Wrote: Third Round day used to be one of the best days of the footballimg year. They have downgraded the FA cup so much that it means little to me anymore. The Premier League, Sky and BBC have done their utmost to emasculate the competition. It makes me laugh out loud when they try to whip up enthusiasm and harp on about the "magic of the Cup" which they they have done their damndest to ruin.

So true. The only games in the cup that have retained any authenticity are the qualifiers and early rounds involving clubs who can live the dream for a while and earn a bit of useful cash.
Reply
#30
(01-10-2026, 10:53 AM)wba13 Wrote: Come on you Baggies always will and always have wanted us to win and yes I’m always interested.

Exactly this
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)