Free broadband with labour
#11
(11-15-2019, 10:59 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(11-15-2019, 10:31 AM)strawman Wrote:
(11-15-2019, 10:19 AM)billybassett Wrote: 100bn on HS2 or 15bn on superfast broadband for everyone. I know what's better value.

Whether the market economics make sense and the knock on impact of part nationalising I'm not sure but what I do know is that it's obvious that fast broadband is as important as running water in households (like it or not). The fact that for £400 a year you can get all your water and sewerage dealt with and yet for the same price (and more in many places) you can't actually get a broadband speed above a 1mb is ridiculous. It's massively important for the future economy of our country, the education of young people in less privileged circumstances etc etc

BT say it will be nearer 100bn - and with the history of Government estimates v final costs I know who I believe.

That is of course without the knock on effects on jobs or costs of nationalising other broadband  broadband providers and their pension schemes.

And from experience and history never, never, ever let Government have anything to do with technology projects.

Various governments have tried to get BT to provide a minimum standard of broadband to the rural communities and balance out the inequalities of access that we currently have. An example for you - Fujitsu and Talk Talk (IIRC) went into partnership and proposed a business case to compete with BT to roll out fibre to the country. BT, who said it couldn't be done because it was too expensive realised that there was some competition here so cut all of their contracts with Fujitsu to destabilise the UK operations.

As much as there are many different providers BT still own the networks and make it very difficult for companies to provide real competition. They are effectively still a monopoly for a great part of the market. 

There are still many areas of the country that get next to no broadband access because it isn't profitable for companies to do. This is exactly what governments need to do to balance up the haves and have nots.

I agree the costs are probably out - the government one is under the final amount and the BT one will be overestimating (unsurprisingly they don't want this to happen)

Good points. Maybe the costs will be higher but nowhere near 100bn. The other point is why can;t we actually get a stable and valid mobile signal everywhere. I mean where I live it's chronic and that's not rural. Go anywhere into the sticks and you're knackered.
Reply
#12
I think I read somewhere I might be wrong but there is a black hole in their pension fund .
Reply
#13
(11-15-2019, 10:54 AM)The liquidator Wrote: And the government will have to pay for it ........still waiting for my router I wish they would hurry up I've got the darts to watch later all FREE

Not true: if the BT scheme fails and meets the eligibility criteria it might be picked up by the Pension Protection Fund, which isn't 'The Government'.

The alternative is... well, the alternative is the very thing which caused the PPF to be set up in the first place.
Reply
#14
(11-15-2019, 12:18 PM)The liquidator Wrote: I think I read somewhere I might be wrong but there is a black hole in their pension fund .

There is - it's been massively underfunded for years (In fairness they are throwing money at it now but it's 'ongoing'), but as Oss says that isn't the governments problem (directly). 

It's been based on a jam tomorrow mantra and as long as there are employees paying in they will be able to balance the books for the pensioners that are being paid out. 

There really isn't any downside to the government taking this to focus on the have nots who have been neglected because they are simply unprofitable. This is a good thing, there are many bad things about labour, this isn't one of them.
Reply
#15
In principle this is no different to - just as an example - the highland railway line north of Perth. Yes, it undoubtedly consumes some of Abellio's (Scotrail's) subsidy, but the alternative for all of those populations between Perth and Inverness is barely thinkable; some things just come with a cost which is worth paying purely for social reasons.

Tax and public expenditure aren't automatically bad things; historically badly managed at times, but that's a different argument. They are, for want of a better word, a couple of the various glues which hold a developed society together.
Reply
#16
I've got a feeling this proposal wont be happening the main one is that they are going to get spanked In the GE

I'm off up the german market going to get pissed and put it on JC tab as everything else is free by the looks of it
Reply
#17
(11-15-2019, 01:14 PM)The liquidator Wrote: I've got a feeling this proposal wont be happening the main one is that they are going to get spanked In the GE

I'm off up the german market going to get pissed and put it on JC tab as everything else is free by the looks of it

And if the Tories has proposed similar you’d have said differently.

What is the the incentive currently for BT to expand fibre optic broadband into areas that are expensive / non profit making? How have you been so conditioned that you want to pay shareholders money for what is becoming a necessity and are irritated by the thought of the state suppling a solution the current one supplier (discounting Virgin) is failing to do so?
Reply
#18
(11-15-2019, 01:24 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-15-2019, 01:14 PM)The liquidator Wrote: I've got a feeling this proposal wont be happening the main one is that they are going to get spanked In the GE

I'm off up the german market going to get pissed and put it on JC tab as everything else is free by the looks of it

And if the Tories has proposed similar you’d have said differently.

What is the the incentive currently for BT to expand fibre optic broadband into areas that are expensive / non profit making? How have you been so conditioned that you want to pay shareholders money for what is becoming a necessity and are irritated by the thought of the state suppling a solution the current one supplier (discounting Virgin) is failing to do so?

The Tory magic money tree seems to have been flourishing with cash in recent years.....
In the form of his life.
Reply
#19
(11-15-2019, 01:24 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-15-2019, 01:14 PM)The liquidator Wrote: I've got a feeling this proposal wont be happening the main one is that they are going to get spanked In the GE

I'm off up the german market going to get pissed and put it on JC tab as everything else is free by the looks of it

And if the Tories has proposed similar you’d have said differently.

What is the the incentive currently for BT to expand fibre optic broadband into areas that are expensive / non profit making? How have you been so conditioned that you want to pay shareholders money for what is becoming a necessity and are irritated by the thought of the state suppling a solution the current one supplier (discounting Virgin) is failing to do so?

Why are you so obsessed with having everything free ???
Reply
#20
(11-15-2019, 01:14 PM)The liquidator Wrote: I've got a feeling this proposal wont be happening the main one is that they are going to get spanked In the GE

I'm off up the german market going to get pissed and put it on JC tab as everything else is free by the looks of it

were you #ToryBoy on QT?

Seems like every Tory is able to put a hole into spending plans issued by the opposition but isn't bothered that their own Tory party hasn't managed to publish a valid spending report backing up their manifesto for many a year.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)