V.A.R
#11
(08-11-2019, 08:39 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: I agree with the fact these decisions are worth millions and can't afford to be got wrong, especially for clubs like us who don't have the "United", factor. It needs to be a different format though. There should be a panel in the ref's ear for important decisions who are watching from multiple angles who can tell them instantly whether the decision is right or not. It's not difficult.

Correct. We should also be able to see what they’re looking at on the big screens in the ground.
Reply
#12
should there not be two camera angles shown for tight offsides?

should we not see the exact moment the ball has left the passers foot?

who decides what frame to use for the offside call?

sterling would have been onside a fraction of a second earlier.
Reply
#13
For me, VAR is very close to killing the game I love.
That is all.
Reply
#14
(08-11-2019, 08:30 PM)Huggybear Wrote: So you would be happy to accept that goal that Wolves scored today and also the Man City so called offside goal yesterday ,if that happened to us in the FA Cup Final ?

What if it happened to go our way, would you not be happy......

Would you be happy if we lost n an incorrect referee decision, of course not.

Need to move with the times, look how cricket decisions have improved.
Reply
#15
(08-11-2019, 09:31 PM)foreveralbion Wrote: should there not be two camera angles shown for tight offsides?

should we not see the exact moment the ball has left the passers foot?

who decides what frame to use for the offside call?


sterling would have been onside a fraction of a second earlier.


This is something that bugs me. I haven't seen the Sterling goal that was disallowed, but the one that was checked for offside and allowed to stand looked offside to me as well. The frame shown on Sky was just before the player struck the ball through to Sterling. Was that the frame used by the VAR officials? If it was then they got it wrong.

I'm all for VAR, but their are issues with the way it's currently being implemented that certainly need ironing out.
Reply
#16
Football is nothing like cricket.It works in cricket but football is a totally different matter.Just wait until Mo Salah has a hand on his shoulder and goes down in the box and then VAR gives a penalty because there was contact.VAR doesn't consider the player involved or how big a push on a player is .The whole concept is flawed .
Reply
#17
I thought Wolves' goal should have stood. As said above it should be restricted to finals. Too much faff for my liking.
Reply
#18
Interesting one in the PSG game.

Handball from a corner.

VAR picked it up about 7 minutes after the corner and pen was given.
Reply
#19
(08-12-2019, 06:07 AM)HLS Wrote: I thought Wolves' goal should have stood. As said above it should be restricted to finals. Too much faff for my liking.

The Wolves one is more about the new law change, rather than VAR. 

Should probably be called “The J-Rod rule”.
Reply
#20
Dont forget, we had the only goal in the history of football chalked off for offside from a corner when the corner taker took it and the player headed it in. It has its place but unless the technology improves on offside to give instant, unarguable descisions on offsides then its an ass. So glad that we aint part of it
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)